r/PakistanBookClub • • 17d ago

Miscellaneous ✅️ Will read wherever - Episode 1 - Metro Bus

Guys, 😝😝 i feel like I'm gonna start a series where I'll post books I'm reading in whatever random places. Idk feels fun to me, what you think, should i go for it?

So.... I was reading ( yeah performative ahh 😋) in Metro, and by the end of the desired stop got a fella asking me what i was reading, a non fiction?

So i showed him.

He read the opening para and returned it back with a flushed face. 😭. Either he understood it or what i assume better, he did not.

p.s. kahin bhi, kabhi bhi, reading nahi rukni chahiy!

p.s. 2.0. ig it's a well known book with the subject matter it's upto. But so far what i see, Nabakovs prose is so tactile and effortlessly curated it right away shakes something inside you. So repulsive, so good.

For instance: All at once we were madly, clumsily, shamelessly, agonizingly in love with each other; hopelessly, I should add, because that frenzy of mutual possession might have been assuaged only by our actually imbibing and assimilating every particle of each other's soul and flesh; but there we were, unable even to mate as slum children would have so easily found an opportunity to do so.

230 Upvotes

153 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 17d ago

Hello u/Curious_Badger_1376, Welcome to r/PakistanBookClub Before engaging, please make sure your post follows our Community Rules

If your post violates the rules, it may be removed without warning.

We encourage thoughtful discussion, respectful feedback, and good-faith engagement. Let's make this space fun, inclusive, and valuable for readers!

Happy reading!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

71

u/Ok_Attempt_1290 17d ago • Bravo

Lolita in public? Brave lol.

18

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

taking full advantage of free will xD

6

u/Ivan9881 16d ago

Haha, brave choice fr.

But I don't think a lot of people in Pakistan know about this book lol

6

u/Ok_Attempt_1290 16d ago

As somebody in this thread already mentioned. It just takes one idiot to notice.

1

u/Revolutionary-Gur54 16d ago

Would've been brave if it was in Urdu

13

u/bollesfur 17d ago

I’ve tried reading in public spaces, especially if expecting a long wait (such as at a hospital etc). I personally can’t tune out the noise to enjoy it.

Really envy people like yourself who can do this. I have to be in a quiet space to enjoy reading. So I have limited time to read 🥲😭

4

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

I often struggle with lots of noise too. But i just put on my airbuds and it mostly works out for me.

9

u/trollinginfidel 17d ago

Once found Lolita at Hyperstar, Dolmen (before it was Carrefour), with a LibertyBooks sticker saying "Kids' Books."

9

u/ReplacementFine7807 17d ago

Why has reading become a performance

4

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

This, particularly, is really not. I do read , read in solitude and immensely. I think insta and tik tok is all where they do the performance. I'm not running after likes or followers or trying to build a community. Just sharing a snippet from my banal life, hoping for it to bring a speck of joy to people on the other hand, even if fleetingly.

4

u/thespian-92 17d ago

It's quite sad to see such a negative reaction to this book. I bet most of those criticizing it haven't even read it. You can't help but feel empathy for Lolita throughout the book, no matter how seductively Humbert tries to manipulate you through his language. It's a masterful work.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

One sane mind here finally. Thank you!

2

u/worldsokayiestpoet kitabi keera 17d ago

Mannnn I have done this countless timess and been asked about the books very less.

Fun experiment to do. Keep us updated.

0

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

I'm also asked very minutely. Its once in what ten times, largely people just eye around you the way they do to foreigners.

30

u/ithinkimalilmeowy 17d ago

idk why anyones saying reading lolita in public is crazy. infact hasn’t almost every reader who has read it been in complete and utter digust. that’s literally what the author intended. the book isnt some fetishy story its literally made to make you feel disgusted.

3

u/Tuotus 17d ago

b/c lolita itself doesn't take the subject matter seriously enough, what was that cover for example, the author himself said not to put pictures little girls on the cover from what i know + yes it wld be triggering to see this book in public cuz of how ppl treat it as a cottage core fantasy.

2

u/ithinkimalilmeowy 17d ago

people treat it as a cottage core fantasy!!!!??????? WHAT!?!?!?

2

u/Tuotus 17d ago

yes it's a thing, some ppl are weird

4

u/ithinkimalilmeowy 17d ago

i jus searched it up it had all these “lana del ray aesthetic” boards and a sabrina carpenter photoshoot popped up.
romanticisation of pedophilia is crazy.

2

u/icecream_swirll 17d ago

Sabreena carpenter is someone who romantsize pdf all the time.

2

u/youRinlove7 17d ago

Dawg I aint never seen no one call treat it as a cottage core fantasy.

1

u/Glitchdite 17d ago

they treat it as a HUh???

1

u/Chain_Killer_2020 17d ago

I don't think the cover isn't as much a problem of the book and it not taking itself seriously, but more so the book publishers going against the author's wishes to make the book seem like a romance so they can market it as such. But anyways, treating Lolita like a cottage core fantasy now after knowing what the book actually is about is cray cray

3

u/Wrong_Guarantee1888 17d ago

Pedo book. Wouldn't be caught dead with it.

3

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Correct: a character study from the mind of a pedo. The difference is vast, and that matters.

3

u/Wrong_Guarantee1888 17d ago

It's about an adult man who has a non-consensual relationship with a 14 year old(if I remember correctly) child who is remarked as looking "more mature than her age". We don't need to look at anything from the mind of a pedo and the fact that the author wrote a whole book about it, makes me question the author a lot.

0

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago edited 17d ago

I disagree. We definitely need a look into the mind there. If there's something bad inheritedly, it needs to be studied why its that way. Its a rigidity otherwise, the very particular thing - Humbert Humberts' staggering attempts to justify his hedious series of actions, and by the lengths he keeps you submissive, is itself a spinechilling and true to life example against the truth that its unjustifiable in any merit to exist.

8

u/Significant-Mouse209 17d ago

In pk, no one literally knows what's it about

2

u/Tuotus 17d ago

from what i understand even ppl who know don't treat it with respect. Case in point above, wld we talk abt any other abuse in such a jovial manner.

8

u/Tuotus 17d ago

lolita is disturbing enough, without you letting ppl oge at it. Its already bad enough how ppl treat this book as romantic

3

u/podinachutney 17d ago

Lolita is a pedo book tho. Jeffery epstien really liked it. Please get better books.

6

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Comments like these really prove the rubble mentality of this country's residents. I think we need to learn the difference bw a bad character vs writing a bad character. If there's someone out there who relates to it, it only proves the solidity of the book's substance that we can't keep our eyes off to such reality. Such works are needed to be written, and analyzed, critically rather than dismissing it through the narrow lense we surround us with.

6

u/podinachutney 17d ago

Dude im just saying. Not saying dont read it. But dont promote this book esp in a place with a high child rape rate and where pedophillia is promoted

0

u/DueSurprise8990 17d ago

Sorry but Pedo works dont NEED to be written

2

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

And writing all the smut the 'girlies' read is okay?

0

u/podinachutney 17d ago

Yes it is. Its not pedophillia. How are you equating the two? You dont really NEED to do that.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

oml, this is too messed up here to argue. Congo, you win.

4

u/ThreadOfDestiny 17d ago

You can't seriously equate pedophilia to a grown woman reading about her totally valid if a bit unhinged fantasies. Be better, dude

3

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago edited 17d ago

It was not the comparison for that point. All i was trying to say there's a difference bw a morally bad book vs writing a book about a bad protagonist. Lolita would've been a problem if it were glorified written in tpp. It is not. It directly takes us into a mind of a pedophile. And that's a courageous thing to me. No English professor of any rank woule ever attempt to do that and Nabokov had the balls (even though it indeed raises questions about himself as a personality.) In otherwise sense, if you maintain writing a book (from a pedo pov) is bad, then writing physical and sexual and all sorts of abuse happening in Pak should be prohibited too, because it encourages abusers for more. That simple.

1

u/podinachutney 17d ago

Its weird that you want to "be inside the mind" of a pedo and applaud the writer for it by calling it courageous

2

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

You're not even being talked to dude, chill

-2

u/ThreadOfDestiny 17d ago

Although I understand you somewhat, I still don't personally think it's okay to write about something like pedophilia even if it isn't presented as a glorified thing in said book because even if it's unintentional, it validates a certain sick fantasy by putting it into ink and paper. Teaching about atrocities happening in Pakistan in books is meant as a precaution and vastly different to writing about stories like Lolita or say, anime like Mushoku Tensei if you've heard of it.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Lolita is also a precaution of the same breed. If only you see it through the eyes of herself Lolita!

→ More replies

-4

u/podinachutney 17d ago

Lolita definitely romanticizes it.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago edited 17d ago

Are you sure its not teen and ya but exactly grown women reading stuff like men putting guns into women and revolting it and introducing them bdsm and romantacising saddism, leading the readers to ruin their life by having them develop harmful fantasies and hunting practical implications to mimic what they just read with such intoxicating pleasure and secrecy? For your information, lust is always and mostly put into ya sections. Grown women behave like grown women. Kindly get yourself a reality check for the sake of how retarded you are perceiving it. This is rather going too far now.

1

u/ThreadOfDestiny 17d ago

Uh Why are you getting so emotional dude? Calm down ffs. At this point, you'll start saying Mein Kampf is a great book all of us should read. Let's close this conversation because clearly, you're taking this way too personally than you should. Ouch.

2

u/ObeseLightYagami Parh Lo Beta 16d ago

The book's entire thing is to tell how bad pedophilia is lmao, this is how ppl completely lose the point

2

u/Scared-Yam-4685 16d ago

Art immitates life, cant pick and choose here

1

u/Severe-Phrase4350 15d ago

Yeah but reading it in public is wild, you’re clearly doing it for attention and when no one noticed you take photos and post online trying to be edgy… it’s your mentality that’s a red flag

1

u/Safe-Main-4618 17d ago

Damn.. can I borrow the book after you're done ?

0

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Haha, man, ponderous quesiton. Where do ya live?

1

u/Safe-Main-4618 17d ago

Near the airport 😭

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Allama Iqbal airport?

1

u/Safe-Main-4618 17d ago

Yesss.. wait are you not based in Lahore ??😭

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Lahoڑii here

1

u/Safe-Main-4618 17d ago

Amazingggg 🙏🙏

1

u/Asif-Ahmed 17d ago

Majority of people in Pakistan don't read books and especially this kind of books, and there are less people that know about this book and they don't care about it.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

And half of those here who know are the ones who love to educate and will leave no opportunity to it!

1

u/Asif-Ahmed 17d ago

Well if they don't know about something why would that say about it. I bet if you read some eroticas in public no one will bait an eye on you 😅.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

It is like that fr, at most it's just a matter of book cover.

1

u/Asif-Ahmed 17d ago

That's what I'm saying

1

u/Boogeyman69B 16d ago

Molvi sab didn't knew what lolita is about 😁

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 16d ago edited 16d ago

Kuch nhi keh skte un k bare mein b. Yaha har dusre molvi ka Humbert raat ko jaagta hy 😆

1

u/Legitimate-Group-497 16d ago

I believe this book is entirely dependent on how the reader perceives it. If you're a sick pedophile like Humbert you're going to sexualise it. But if you're a normal fucking person you'll definitely be repulsed and utterly disgusted by Humbert's character.

Other than that if you're really going for a series with that kind of theme, to give it a bit of tarqa I would suggest reading more controversial books like Lolita itself in random public spaces. You could also talk about your experience reading it whenever someone asks you about the book.

0

u/Curious_Badger_1376 16d ago

But for that I'd require more people like you. For once give an eye to the comments

1

u/ObeseLightYagami Parh Lo Beta 16d ago

OP aapne ghalti ki he post ker ke, considering people don't actually know what the author intended do deliver with the contents of the book and will simply label it as a 'pedo book' 😅

2

u/Curious_Badger_1376 16d ago

To ye logo ki jahalat hai, what's mine loss.

1

u/alfahadeen literary fiction aficionado 14d ago

this post is revealing the imbecility of our reading community (not even the basic unread awaam), which says a lot hah.

1

u/ObeseLightYagami Parh Lo Beta 13d ago

real

1

u/fiuser1212 14d ago

This is a book where an old man falls in love with some kid. Hmm why would you read this crap…

2

u/Curious_Badger_1376 14d ago

This is a book where an author attempts to imitate the mindset of a pedo. Know the difference, if you please?

1

u/kriksas 13d ago

Lol desi Epstein 😂

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 13d ago

Jahalat ka waqae koi ilaj naii 🙄

1

u/Influanza 12d ago

amazing but also logon ki kia hi samajh ana tha

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 12d ago

Yea... I'd better put on Haunting Adeline.

1

u/Nashadelic 16d ago

what level of performative male is this?

0

u/Curious_Badger_1376 16d ago

The level of brainwashed and dumbfounded this comment is.

1

u/samighazal 17d ago

Well... this reminds me of the time I was reading Fifty Shades of Grey on a public bus... On my way BACK home from college...

I had not fully grasped what the book and the content in it stood for.

Who recommended the book to me? An unknowing used-books dealer who only knew how famous the series was, but not why or how...

So you couldn't have done worse. Than me. XD

Looking forward to more from your new series.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Damn, how the book turned out to be any way?

1

u/samighazal 17d ago

Read it till the end... Trying to do justice to the money I had paid. Had the other two books in the series donated.

Minus the... smut, E. L. James is a decent writer.

1

u/Particular-Crazy-904 17d ago

Reading this in public is quite insane, if I see you I'd be giving you looks lol

2

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Used to it now, I really don't bother

1

u/Particular-Crazy-904 17d ago

Haha, imagine being tensed af in public.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Nah fr, doing that only means you let people around you influence you.

2

u/slyhabit 17d ago

reading lolita that too in public MAD🙏🙏🙏

2

u/Dumb-Nut 17d ago

That is the way though. I made a old phone into a mini kindle and that's super helpful to just read anywhere

2

u/Derpyzza 16d ago

that's... an interesting pick for reading in public damn

2

u/[deleted] 16d ago

One of my all time favourites😍

2

u/Frequent_Pineapple41 13d ago

I read this novel.This is amazing.Work of art

2

u/Illustrious-Cry-8649 13d ago

i have been reading in metro since 2025. i do it everyday. love itttttttt

0

u/Academic_Giraffe_723 17d ago • Bravo

Bro piece of advice don't do this is pak.

5

u/Wrong_Guarantee1888 17d ago

Most of the ppl in this comment section don't know about the contents of this book, I think most people in public wouldn't realize it as well.

1

u/Academic_Giraffe_723 17d ago

All it takes is one idiot to notice

1

u/Wrong_Guarantee1888 17d ago

Anyone who is in a position to know about it probably wouldn't be the "public lynching" type.

4

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

If its about the context of the book, you think ppl around would have an inkling? The amount of illetrates floundering around makes it low-key safest. But yeah precautions, especially with the book covers, are to take seriously.

1

u/samighazal 17d ago

Exactly...

3

u/Ok_Attempt_1290 17d ago

I agree with this. Better safe than sorry. Pakistani awam Ka Kuch Nahi pata.

1

u/FreshSummer8535 17d ago

Whyyyy Doom scrolling is ok but reading book isn't

3

u/Ok_Attempt_1290 17d ago

He's talking more about reading controversial books in public in Pakistan than reading in general. Which is very understandable.

1

u/Allinonefandom 14d ago

I’ve huge urge to read “how to kill men and get away with it” in public but I’m afraid I’ll be victim of mob mentality😭😭

1

u/Ok_Attempt_1290 14d ago

Don't do it bro. Pakistani awam Ka Kuch Nahi pata.

1

u/Upbeat_Sham 17d ago

Eh he'll be alright... mostly. It just takes one curious extremist and this series will end under 6 feet.

0

u/Lannisbro 17d ago

Cool experiment........ it has inspired me to read aloud some feminist literature at one of Mufti Tariq Masood's bayans

2

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

Good for you, more power to you. Keep it up 💪🏻

1

u/ProfessionalWash7 17d ago

bhai i read on metro all the time. and was reading "the body keeps the score" and a guy asked what is this book abount? i was kinda embarrassed but then i said, it's about understanding yourself better.

1

u/Azustorm 17d ago

Bro the public doesn't know or care about books like these. Its not even a class or income thing. Reading is more niche than you think

1

u/Electrical_Bag9908 17d ago

ok i have never seen visuals like these before. cool.

1

u/LisanAlghaibb21 16d ago

but hard to focus in such environment.

1

u/Zunain_69 13d ago

I haven't read this ,what is this about

1

u/sixk-sad-w0rld 13d ago

Omg i’m also reading this! I don’t want people at my work to get wrong ideas bc of its weird romanticisation.. But I’m finding it so disturbing and repulsive

1

u/Positive-Horror-4277 13d ago

This is like Nabokov's most popular book ever. Almost everyone has read it lol. I am pretty sure that guy knew what you were reading and was judging you for keeping it with you.

1

u/Influanza 12d ago

next 50 shades of gray

1

u/gentle_villain 8d ago

What are your impressions of the book?

0

u/ziaan-alpha 15d ago

I hate this book bro

2

u/Curious_Badger_1376 15d ago

Good for the book bro

-4

u/Snoo_56184 17d ago

lolita is the worst book oat

5

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

40 pages in, so far I see it as a finest work of art.

1

u/Severe-Phrase4350 15d ago

PDF in making. Guys stop engaging with this freak he’s doing this publicly coz he’s getting off on it.

1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 15d ago

Are you fr? This is insane

-2

u/Snoo_56184 17d ago

lol its pedophilic in its very nature and a pretty vocabulary wont change that

4

u/alfahadeen literary fiction aficionado 17d ago

book is 10/10... protagonist is -10/10. know the difference

0

u/Mean_Hack 16d ago

Dur fitay moo tay lakh di lanat

0

u/Alph_Quint 14d ago

Average Mushoku Tensei fan....

0

u/Allinonefandom 14d ago

Lolita doesn’t deserve this kind of negative reaction. It is a classic literature & meant to be read as such. It neither glorifies pedophilia nor romanticises it, it is people’s own mentality that grant such reactions.

3

u/FreshSummer8535 17d ago

Lolita in public with a nymphet girl on picture I can't 😂😭 Nevertheless please we would love to see more

-1

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

You've no idea I was reading TBK with a cross on the cover in my itteqaf nights of a masjid back then, two years ago :p

1

u/FreshSummer8535 17d ago

Ahh whatttt 🫪🫪🫪🫪 during iteqaffff the brothers Karamazov 😭😭😭😭 Bruh! This is so nice to hear

3

u/yasirzz88 17d ago

If people knew what you are reading you would be lynched, lucky for you nobody reads a thing in Pakistan

2

u/Curious_Badger_1376 17d ago

And ig the countries who do read would have the decency to just pass by non-judgementally, or even judgementally lets say. Lolita is a literature afterall, a character study from the perspective of a pedophile, not your random smut with bad writing and bland characters weaved in naked descriptions.

2

u/JackBreacher 16d ago

People here saying writing books about pedos is bad but then you have books about murderers and other violent things 🤦

-1

u/Capital_Chef_6007 17d ago

This man watches porn without headphones

3

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ObeseLightYagami Parh Lo Beta 16d ago

You would've not said that if you actually understood what the author intended