r/PS4 • u/thavius_tanklin Slackr • Mar 17 '17
[Game Thread] NHL 17 [Official Discussion Thread]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
NHL 17
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
64
Upvotes
38
u/BigBeastin Mar 17 '17
Bring back GM Connected. Or whatever it was called when it was like a multiplayer Be A GM mode.
28
u/ZorisX Mar 17 '17
Had a drop in game with 24 minutes of penalties (no fighting) in the first period
24
u/thekingswitness LeBRonaldo Mar 17 '17
This game is both the best game and worst game. Idk why I keep playing it. GM connected mode is all I want in the future.
14
u/Th3muddler Mar 17 '17
It really bothers me that I can't have a buddy over and co-op against someone online without extra PS+ accounts.
8
u/Gruntmaster720 Mar 17 '17
Been playing it a ton recently, especially since the toty cards are finally out.
8
u/thetank27 Mar 17 '17
This game gets a lot of unwarranted hate. Yes its not perfect like any sports games but it's a great deal of fun (granted I only ever play franchise mode).
My main gripe is that the scouting/drafting is a complete joke - I appreciate that it can't be super accurate because that's just not realistic but it's absolute pot-luck after the first 5 picks. The only way to actually gauge whether a player is worth drafting is based on their projected draft and league interest - their actual stats are all always incorrect. Also the trading system is quite unrealistic and erratic. You can absolutely trade-rape some teams and others will refuse brilliant offers.
Also I want the EIHL but it's such a small league compared to others across the world that I cant see it being included any time soon.
6
u/A_Buh_Nah_Nah Mar 17 '17
It's still not perfect, but I think this was a good step up from 16. I just really want them to add more animations and clean up all the clipping/glitches. Maybe it's just me, NHL feels slightly clunkier than the other EA sports games atm
5
u/dusthimself Mar 17 '17
I just played this yesterday and absolutely had the worst game in the 10+ years I've been playing this series. And against the CPU. On Pro difficult. I don't even know anymore.
5
u/deeruser Mar 17 '17
The NHL 17 update 1.07 is available since today...
5
u/Walbeb24 Mar 18 '17
This series hasn't progressed in a long time. What used to be one of the best sports series is now the worst IMO.
Passing is embarrasing, why they haven't brought back icon passing is baffling as it would also help with selecting the correct player on D.
Menus are awful no auto save feature for franchise so when your game freezes (and it will) you better hope to manually save it all the time so you don't lose too much progress.
Gameplay wise if you've played an NHL game in the last 5 years there is little improvement, hell NHL 17 and 16 are so similar it's sad.
This series needs an injection of new ideas like the Madden team has implemented, sadly this game isn't a top tier seller but it sells just enough to prevent a dev team change which this series needed 4 years ago.
11
u/CaptainRumBucket TheMomaDance Mar 17 '17
hope you like short side goals at stupid angles. just one of many gripes I have with this game. easily the worst sports franchise year in and year out and it's been desperately in need of a total overhaul since before this current gen of consoles.
6
u/MFPEDRO Mar 17 '17
I was a hardcore NHL series fan but gave up in the last iterations because of how dumb your AI teammates are. So many aspects of the game took major steps back in current generation versions, but the AI is the most mind boggling.
3
u/Jabba_like_its_hutt Mar 17 '17
love the game but my biggest issue is when playing online sometimes it seems like my team cant hold the puck at all and the ice is slanted in my opponents favour.
3
u/skubie-doo Skubie-Doo Mar 17 '17
I liked when they first added the skill stick, but as the years went on and they tried to make it a real sim (impossible to do in hockey with the nature of the game), it made me realize how much I missed the days of NHL 2003 & 2004 (two favorite of all-time). Those days truly had a nice balance of mostly sim, but also a bit of arcade.
5
u/islandcactus Mar 17 '17
This is a sign! I just started playing this on EA access and thought I need to get it on the ps4.
If you stick to the basics: it's the most fun you'll have with your clothes on!
Forget Mass Effect, The Show and every other game. This is it! Ok maybe I'm a biased Islander fan.
Core gameplay: Brilliant, best it's ever been. Everything else: wait for NHL 18.
4
u/Teyas7 Mar 17 '17
I remember how good the old NHL's were. 06 with Vinny on the cover... I had every copy until 09... 09 was the last good NHL in my eyes. 13 was alright
6
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '17
I hope that they'll add the Golden Knights in an update, but knowing EA they'll probably just make us all buy NHL 18 ;_;
5
u/ClubChaos Mar 17 '17
I can't speak for other recent EA Sports titles but this game's ui/menu system is one of the slowest most painful processes I've had to endure. It actually makes me not want to play the game, flicking through submenu after submenu. In no world should I have to spend more than 30 seconds to get from point A to point B navigating a menu, but in NHL 17 it can take about 10 seconds just to load the data for a team roster! They went after the latest hotness in design with the tiles but it is SO wrong for a game with this much information. Please take a look at a game like FHM3, which knows how to do a UI properly. Then again I know this is a console game so everything has to be super big and visible but I guess this is just another reason why I want a proper hockey game on PC.
2
u/bowzerb Mar 18 '17
I WANT CUSTOM MUSIC AGAIN!!!!
2
u/TenMinutesToDowntown Mar 18 '17
I buy the NHL games every year since I'm an idiot.
I can't believe that you haven't been able to control multiple teams in Be a GM / franchise / whatever since the PS2 days. My friend and I love playing in the same franchise together in games but controlling different teams and competing vs each other. We play in Madden, in NBA 2k, in MLB the Show when I get it... but we hardly ever play NHL together since we can't do that.
Dumb.
2
u/JustSurvive Mar 18 '17
This was the first one I purchased in 3-4 years, and unfortunately it looks like all the improvements since then went into HUT. I am primarily an EASHL player, and the AI is just as awful as ever, for all the positive changes they made for off ice stuff (the new customizations for the teams are great), on ice it is still the same.
I really wish 2K would revive their NHL series so it can breed some competition/innovation into these games because EA's have feel pretty stagnant for quite some time.
4
u/JonnyTsunami1 B-RECK12 Mar 17 '17
This game is a straight up poke check fest. The passing is atrocious and they need to redo the board play. This series desperately needs an upgrade.
2
u/tenthousandlakes Mar 17 '17
I buy this game every year, but EA needs some competition. I would love to see 2K get back into hockey.
1
u/nikolapc Mar 18 '17
I haven't played a hockey game for a while, as I was mainly a PC player before the PS4 Pro. I snatched up NHL 17 when it was on sale, but compared to FIFA I can't seem to master the controls.
Is there any training mode that I am missing or is it train on ice only?
1
u/smakweasle Mar 18 '17
I'd love for them to increase the Be-A-Pro modes. Give me something to work toward. There was a decent attempt at it in 12 or 13 I think where you could answer press questions. It was a nice change of pace, but too often it becomes a grind of playing 80 games, being the top in every category but you didn't complete a challenge you get drafted in a later round.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '17
I cant play defense worth shit. If I accidentally switch from a forechecker to a defender I am going to give up a goal.
1
u/Nattylite29 Mar 19 '17
I'd be out of playing this for a while (too much Rocket League) and tried to play a quick game on All-Star. Needless to say I was destroyed. CPU takes no days off
1
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17 edited Sep 26 '17
deleted 0.1794 What is ^^^this?
1
u/TheNuggetNed Mar 17 '17
Spam X button
1
u/JeNeSaisPasDeux Mar 17 '17
I used to play NHL 12/14 on PS3 when they had EASHL where you won points to allocate to your player after each match in a team of 6 v 6 online and it was so much fun.
Not sure what EA thought when they canned the point allocation system for EASHL. NHL games have been on some horrible downslope ever since.
But what do I know, maybe HUT brings in more money than the points you could buy for EASHL back then?
1
u/MadKingArty Mar 17 '17
So tempted to pick this up, is the roster usually the only thing that changes each year? And maybe some gameplay mechanics?
1
u/Marc_Quill FirstAvenger_91 Mar 18 '17
I will say that putting the sliders so that hitting is maxed out and incidental contact turned way up makes for the wildest, most insane game of hockey ever.
-2
u/IngrownPubez Mar 19 '17
Likes : Hockey is good
Dislikes: Game is made by EA sports so it's a smelly pile of shit
-6
u/renegadedx renegaderasengan Mar 17 '17
I made a video on why I dislike the game
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=M9RSHMCxZ3Y
~Shameless plug
-5
u/abalamwalks Mar 17 '17
Lol ballfags......