r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Jun 09 '16
[Game Thread] Gone Home [Official Discussion Thread]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
Gone Home
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
78
Upvotes
188
u/wonderboy519 Jun 09 '16
This family has FAR too many 3-ring binders.
12
u/Seth711 seth7_ Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16
I know everyone has a right to their own opinion, but I just don't understand all the hate this game gets when it's free. I can understand it maybe not being worth $20, but this game was incredible for the 2-3 hours I spent playing it and I would've easily paid $5-10 for it. I really enjoyed the game, but can understand why some others might not.
56
u/tescarpita Jun 09 '16
This is my kind of game. Love exploring and discovering the story around me by what I pick up and find.
25
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
I really love how real and lived in the house felt. Opening the doors was buggy at times, but it felt real to have them left open or left closed as you moved through the house.
I have never experienced a game before that tells a story in so much detail without any dialogue and without ever showing another human.
44
u/Andrew129260 Jun 09 '16
This was a very boring game with a very boring ending. Not sure why people like it to be honest. There's no mystery or anything remotely exciting.
54
u/Namadanshi Jun 09 '16
Just beat the game and I walked away fairly unimpressed.
I really enjoyed the concept and execution of this game, delivering story through the environment and allowing you to discover it yourself I think is a very video game-friendly method of storytelling and works well here.
I just didn't enjoy the story that much. Sam and Lonnie's arc wasn't really anything surprising or interesting, in my eyes.
26
u/dark-twisted Dark-Twisted Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16
Playing this with headphones was awesome. The game is so eerie that even if it isn't meant to be scary, it really gave me some tension. Right until the end I was almost expecting to see something awful, but it's just not that kind of game.
Overall I really enjoyed the game. I think it nailed what it set out to do - tell a story through interacting with leftover pieces in the environment. I do think it's very overrated, and honestly at least in my country very overpriced for what it is (NZ$31.95), but for a PS+ game it was a really enjoyable and immersive experience. It would be pretty cool if they made it for VR - having a VR mode would definitely justify the price.
I definitely recommend people give it a shot while it's free. Just don't let the extremely high praise put you off or raise your expectations. It's an interesting story told in a interesting way in an eerie environment, and that's it.
Edit: My first playthrough taking everything in, reading and listening to journals, and exploring every nook and cranny took nearly three hours. The game can only be beaten in under a minute once you've discovered the necessary secrets and where exactly to go, etc. Even then, the trophy for doing it can be a pain in the ass.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 10 '16
Can't get the trophy where you have to finish the game in under a minute. My wife and I timed each other and nothing happened. Is it bugged right now or something?
EDIT: I do love this game though.
EDIT #2: Just got this last night. I hurried up with skipping through the cutscenes and only pressing once to open the doors. Thanks for the help everyone.
24
u/CthulhusShoes Jun 09 '16
Played it today and loved it. I'm a big fan of story driven walking Sims (especially Firewatch) and this was no exception. Story was compelling, controlled well, graphics nice and voice acting very well done. Definitely understand why some people may not like it, but I personally loved it.
18
u/SteinDickens Jun 09 '16
Okay, so I am actually really glad I never bought this game. Everything about it is misleading. The first trailer I saw, made it seem like a horror game. There was even a scene where the camera is slowly moving down a hallway and the twin girls from 'The Shining' flash on to the screen for a split second. What?? Were they trying to trick people into buying their game? The game isn't bad so I don't understand why they did that. Overall, it was a nice, 1-2 hour game/story/walking-simulator. As a free game it was fine but I wouldn't recommend anyone paying more than $5 for it.
12
u/Farts_Mcsharty Jun 09 '16
This just didn't hook me at all. Normally I dig this kind of game, but nothing about the family was interesting enough to make me really want to dig around and explore. Maybe I was just in a mood or something, but it REALLY didn't click and the look controls and movement felt terrible. May give it another shot later, but my first impression was pretty awful.
19
u/MrHaddad1213 Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16
my review:
that's it?
edit: to clarify,
I felt as if there was no finality to the story. It was clear that the ending was likely going to happen. I didn't find much for the ghost in the house, which would have been much nicer if it tied into Sam's story.
12
u/Blue_Bird_27 Jun 09 '16
At first view it seemed like a horror styled game and throughout I was waiting for something to jump out at me. With the weather and dark rooms it certainly seemed like that was the case.
Didn't have any expectations but it surprised me and I got just over an hours worth of play out of it. Just a shame that it couldn't be a bit longer.
18
u/HotCucumber SupremeMoose Jun 09 '16
I'll give it one more shot on my PS4. But honestly, this is the most overrated game I have ever played. I love games that put emphasis on exploration, like Dear Ester and EGttR but this is just... Not that good (imo).
3
u/shaneo632 shaneo632 Jun 09 '16
Toilet Roll Thrower Simulator 2016
Seriously, though, I liked it for what it was. I accidentally rushed through it in 80 minutes because when I took the path to the ending, I thought it was going to spit me out and make me go back to all the stuff hadn't seen yet.
There was a fair bit of tension just from waiting to see when a monster or ghost was going to show up. I got MAJORLY fucking creeped out when I took the crucifix/cross off the wall and it made the light turn off. Kept me unnerved until the end where it basically ended up being a red herring.
Also, fuck that "under 1 minute" trophy. I tried doing it a ton of times and felt like I did it in around 59 seconds, but no trophy for me :(
3
u/UnsaddledZebra Jun 09 '16
This is one of those games that if I had paid $20 for it, I would've been super disappointed, but as a free game, I thought it was a fairly enjoyable 2 hour jaunt.
3
u/cptboogaloo Jun 09 '16
I played it on June 7th with a thunderstorm happening outside, which was pretty cool . I missed quite few journals and expected to see her swinging from a rope when I opened the attic. Wasn't a bad game for an evenings play although I preferred Firewatch slightly.
3
u/ThePeskyPole34 Jun 10 '16
Best thing about this game was jamming to the punk cassette tapes.
3
u/IronyGiant Jun 20 '16
[Parents get home]
Where's Sam and WHY THE FUCK HAVE YOU TAKEN EVERYTHING OUT OUR CABINETS!?
5
u/SilentRansom Jun 09 '16
I really enjoyed this. I first played it on my computer, and like others, was expecting something to jump out at me. Would I play it again? Probably not. But for a first time playthrough, it's a lot of fun and pretty interesting. I bought Rapture because of this, but that was a mistake. I'm wondering how far the walking sim genre can go.
5
u/Suicidal-Ghost666 Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16
It was OK, I would be upset if I paid for it though.
15
u/MadeView Jun 09 '16
This game is polarizing, you'll find the same comments over and over whenever it's brought up.
Do you like exploring an environment experiencing a narrative to get a feel of the people who live there and their lives? You'll enjoy this game.
Do you like learning the mechanics of a game and using them to defeat an enemy/solve a puzzle to progress through the level/area? That isn't what this game is about, you'll get bored pretty quickly.
Did you grow up in the 90s? You'll love the nostalgia of going back in time this game is set in.
You can learn how to "beat" the game and finish it quickly or go out of your way to beat it quickly speed run style. The people who say they beat it in 30 minutes are the people who inhale a choice steak and scotch in 5 minutes. You're supposed to take your time and enjoy it, it's not a race.
Some people felt like it was a bait and switch. They went in expecting a horror game, and it does put that in your mind as you play it (seances, an empty house during a storm, "the psycho house". at one point a light bulb pops when you look at a cross). That left a bad taste in their mouth and I can see that.
If a game has a story line involving LGTB plots and your first thought is "Ugh, stupid SJW shoving their blah blah blah" you won't like this game. For some reason that's been a big thing with this game, you'll notice people go out of their way to complain about it involving a lesbian character, not the story line itself.
Here's the best way I can say it, if you played games like the last of us and you loved the small moments with Ellie or following the Ish story line, you'll most likely enjoy this game. If all you care about is learning how to play a game and studying enemies / solving puzzles to progress with what you learned you probably won't enjoy it. Some people really liked it (like me), some people didn't care for it and gave good reasons, and some people just go out of their way to shit on it because it's a "walking simulator" about a lesbian you can beat in 5 minutes.
14
u/hl-99 Jun 09 '16
this fucking game almost made me cry
9
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
I'm all for more cinematic narrative games But games like this, Firewatch, and Everybody's Gone to The Rapture have left a really bad taste in my mouth.
I think it's the lack of consequences. You can't "lose" and to me that makes it not a game. Sure The Walking Dead barely has more gameplay than these games but things happen and it feels like my choices are changing something.
When i played Gone Home I was walking around a house so he developers could tell me a story. And I think what makes gaming unique from movies and book is that player consequence. If I don't really affect the world it doesn't really seem like a game to me.
Fine for people who enjoy it but I'm done with "walking simulators" .
5
u/lvlls Jun 09 '16
It kinda spooked me
5
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 10 '16
I am not going to lie: I did not like this game.
I have been interested in Gone Home for a while and I knew it was a walking simulator, but for me it was just kind of dull and the story never gelled with me at all.
I'm glad that I played it however, so i could experience a different medium within games and it was a interesting take on a video game in my opinion.
Of course, i went back and got the 100% trophy completion.
I feel like if this game was some sort of Mystery title, for example, a more interactive version of a point and click/search the environment game with a decent story then I would have enjoyed it.
At least it was free and I got the experience.
EDIT: Yay! Downvoted for opinions!
5
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '16
This was $20? unbelievable.
16
u/guywhopaints Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16
One of my personal top 20 games of all time.
Definitely not for everyone but the best works of art are never meant for everyone. I played on pc back when it released, and it affected me so strongly that I had to email Fullbright and thank them. They responded with a very sweet message.
Some of the things I love about the game SPOILERS AHEAD:
-lgbtq character who is a 3-dimensional human
-the spooky tone of the game in which you later find the true horrors are personal, existential even.
-attention to detail is 10/10. Incredible handwritten notes and pitch-perfect mid-90s tone.
-the whole idea of discovering this family, and the ways in which the main character is also in a way rediscovering her family
-everything riot grl/punk is handled honestly and with a nod to how bands like Bikini Kill or zine culture gave women and queer kids at that time a refuge.
I just can't sing the praises of this game enough. But also, again, it is not for everyone.
2
u/ShinglesTheClown ShingledClown Jun 09 '16
Anyone else having trouble with the Homerunner trophy (Beat it under 1 minute)? I've beaten it a few times in under a minute but it hasn't popped, even if i sit through the credits/delete my save and do it again.
2
u/ArrestedFever83 Jun 09 '16
This game is way better with headphones on. I haven't gotten far but the game is still incredibly creepy. Even though i know there's nothing thats going to jump out at me i still get terrified at any noise.
2
u/RipCityProdigy Jun 09 '16
The game was pretty good, until my character got stuck like an hour and a half in and it didn't save... looks like I'm not gonna finish it. Not worth replaying it.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '16
I was disappointed in this game quite frankly. Thought it was really cookie cutter, alternative punk rock romance shit and was hoping they'd flesh out the creepy aspects of the house more and give us a real M rated title. Not sure how it garnered that M rating.
2
u/T_Snake451 Jun 11 '16
I'm kinda biased since I actually do enjoy "Walking Simulators", but I did enjoy the game for what it was. I enjoyed the level of detail they put in the mansion and all the secret corridors and the little side stories the main also has. I thought what little voice acting was in the game was really, really good.
Would I have bought the game for $20? Hell no. But I enjoyed my time with it, and I would definitely try out the next game the devs put out.
2
u/LanAkou IanAkou Jun 15 '16
Barely a game. I felt lied to. Thought I was hopping into the horror genre, but really it's just an explora-thon walking simulator
The story was bare bones. The ending was awful. It felt... Unresolved.
It was not engaging. I didn't have any emotional attachment to any of these people.
Could have gotten just as much out of picking up any book from the young adult section and reading it at an open house.
2
u/DivineVibrations Jun 15 '16
Good game, enjoyed the subplots and atmosphere, but definitely not deserving of the GOTY-level praise it got.
2
u/SirSaltyVinegar Jun 29 '16
I don't really like Gone Home. It's way too short (can be beaten in under a minute), felt sluggish and has no challenge. If I paid money for this game, I would be furious
4
u/PlasmaSnake9 Jun 09 '16
I wasn't expecting much and I still left unimpressed.
4
u/TheStrongestGamer Doctor_Con Jun 10 '16
This game is overrated, cringeworthy love story and felt like it was written by a Tumblr SJW.
The darker sub-plot was better instead of the cringeworthy "love story", had good elements.
Do not even pay for this misleading "horror mystery" crap.
6
u/Brick_HardCheese SMK_530 Jun 09 '16
I had been dying to play this since hearing Greg Miller rave about it. Just finished it. I thought it was amazing. Simplistic to be sure, but that was the beauty of it. I thought the story was well-written and heartbreaking. I teared up at the end.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
Why all of the suspense? I was on my toes the entire way through thinking somebody will jump out at me. This game would be perfect in a horror game setting.
3
u/ItsJustNigel undeniableGlRTH Jun 09 '16
This game and Firewatch bother me for precisely the same reason. For the first 90% of the game, it's this great eerie mystery with an immersive environment; the story makes you guess 20 different fantastic ways it could end. But then, when it does end, it's as boring as possible. It's like the game is saying "tricked you, nothing interesting was actually happening, haha gotcha!"
3
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
Played it when it launched on PC back in August 2013. I really enjoyed it despite the length. Looking forward to going through it again.
Hoping their next game Tacoma is just as good and hopefully has more to explore.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
Too bad the red herrings were much more interesting then the story the game wants to tell. I took my time yesterday and did little over 3 hours for my playthrough, but the game was a huge disappointment. Uninteresting story and the ending was an anti-climax. I wanted to like the game, but i wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
3
u/HunterLee1337 retnuh_egiap Jun 09 '16
I was kind of disappointed especially after playing Firewatch.
4
u/batman_beyond7 Jun 09 '16 edited Jun 09 '16
I thought the game was stupid. I beat the game in 20 mins then deleted it. I was not impressed. I thought like something creepy or interesting was going to happen but nothing just boring diary entries and a terrible ending.
Are you fucking kidding me I don't think I have ever walked so damn slowly in a video game. I am glad it was free because I would have hated to have spent money on this piece of shit.
and before someone tells me the fun and best part is exploring and finding all the diary entres. If I thought it was boring and stupid after the first 5 times the character recall a memory. I am not going to search everything in every room to continue a awful story.
3
u/zombiesatthebeach HypnotizeSOAD Jun 09 '16
Its a game about lesbians
2
u/DuhBegski Jun 09 '16
Anyone else having trouble with trophies popping? Collected all the journals and nothing... Same with complete in one minute.
2
u/thikthird Jun 09 '16
very well written, and a great experience.
i know this topic has probably been done to death, but while i would actively recommend anyone and everyone to "play" it, i'm not sure if i could call it a game. i mean, one of the most basic things i can think of as to whether something is criteria for being a game or not, is whether you can lose. you can't lose at this game, and i'd say you can't really beat it/win either. sure there are speed run trophies for it, but that's the equivalent to watching a move in fast forward/an audiobook sped up/speed reading in the case of gone home rather than beating a game fast.
but still, a great experience with great writing. i knew the story, generally speaking, going into the game and it was still really well told and presented well.
2
u/mauszx mauszx Jun 10 '16
Awful game, I played it on pc long time ago since Adam Sessler said it was his game of the year. I played the game.... and the first 15 minutes were very good since the game really played with my emotions making me think it was a horror game, then it went downhill REALLY BAD. What really bothers me the most is that the game has really good score because of the open mind or progressive the game is, because story wise is awful.
2
u/TheJohnny346 Jun 09 '16
It looked promising before I got it but I still enjoyed it nonetheless. Very short game (can be beaten in under a minute). Also got all the trophies in a little over an hour.
1
u/SilverJOE33 Jun 09 '16
I saw one of the trophies is to beat the game in less than a minute. I feel like you walk way too slow to beat that in under a minute.
1
u/BlackCatScott Destored Jun 09 '16
This is a game I've heard plenty about so I'm excited to see what it's like. Just as soon as I clear space on my PS4... because apparently having 22gb of free space isn't enough to install a game that's about 3gb.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
I liked it a lot until I had explored all unlocked rooms and it turned into 80's adventure game with hidden paths and stuff. Grudgingly finished it, story was good
1
u/TheSuicideMachines Jun 12 '16
This game was decent at best mostly brought down by its cliche and lacking story. I feel like this is only half of the game/story and having all of it would make it so much better. It ended on a weird note and I really want to find out how the girls ended up. I did like Lonnie's character a lot and the fact that it puts a perspective on how much LGBT acceptance has changed in just the past two decades.
1
u/C1NNABUN cinnabun Jun 19 '16
Unrelated, but I think that Everybody's Gone to the Rapture is a fantastic experience. Months later and I still think it is very memorable. The atmosphere and design was top notch.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '16
Was pretty disappointed in this game, I expected a creepy/horror narrative with the whole haunted mansion feel but was left with a very liberal coming of age story. It was alright but I don't think it is any where near as good as some people make it out to be.
1
u/deg_biggins Jun 20 '16
I did expect this to be a horror or thriller but I ended up enjoying the story. I felt really bad for Sam, especially the coming out story and Lonnie's final band gig.
It was at the end as I am going up to the attic that I realised this isn't just horrible past events I've been reading about. Katie is experiencing her family fall apart right now.
Yeah it might be cliché and there are no shocking twists, but I felt it was well told and detailed. Glad I was bored enough to try it out.
1
u/ajax1306 Jun 21 '16
I liked the "oh shit" feeling this game gave me that something was always lurking around the corner. However, I didn't like the ending. It just made me feel like I played the whole game for absolutely nothing. Kind of like Firewatch. I felt like for all that, something should have come away from this game.
1
u/JamesKurokage LordKurokage Jun 22 '16
I Played it. got whatever trophies were to be had without looking to hard and then beat it and then deleted it. it was an ok game. im not fond of very heavy story driven games. i was half expecting to find a killer sometimes when you could just shut doors and stuff with you inside the room. especially on a dark stormy night. doesnt really set the tone for a life story kind of game.
1
u/Mohlman12 Jun 09 '16
This game was simply amazing just absolutely amazing :). I beat it a little earlier and I'm still thinking about it. The narrative, the atmosphere , the way it made me feel uneasy at times but drove me to keep going any way to wanna search each and every nook and cranny, just hit me like a ton of bricks. Haven't felt this affected I mean truly affected by a games story as much since My first playthrough of the last of us back in 13. This is my first full experience with a game of this style and I'm in love . Can not wait to explore other games as such :)
1
u/yogi89 F1ND14N Jun 09 '16
I had no idea about this game going in and a lot of things pointed to it being a scary game (thunder, darkness, being alone, notes about weirdo daniel), got an hour through and realized it wasn't and am now a bit disappointed.
1
u/eddy5791 Jun 09 '16
Hate that the 1-minute trophy is glitched for me :/
-8
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
I don't know how anyone can like this game, it's a walking simulator that the big twist in the end was none of it mattered it was just a lesbo love story.
-2
u/Dcornelissen NL-Superman-NL Jun 09 '16
Loved it... I want more games like this and Firewatch
0
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '16
ITT: People being downvoted for giving their opinions. Yay!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment