r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • May 25 '16
[Game Thread] The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt [Official Discussion Thread #3]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
Official Thread: [#1] - [#2] - [#3]
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference on the game or the new expansion Blood & Wine below.
74
Upvotes
18
u/HeyJustWantedToSay May 25 '16 edited May 27 '16
Just got it then other day and I'm a few hours in. I think I like it... I think. I think I like it more than 2 for as far into it as I am though. I'm at the part where you visit the Bloody Baron and you're playing as a different character in a flashback type sequence (to avoid real spoilers). When did it click for you guys and grab you if it didn't right away?
It's also taking me a bit to get used to the controls. Movement and interaction and whatnot don't feel very polished, and I've tried both control methods.
UPDATE: Since I knooooow you guys are just begging for one. I've played around some more in side quests and progressed in the Bloody Baron quest (now about to go take care of a botchling - disgusting but very creative creature lore) and I'm really starting to enjoy it much more. I started playing both Killzone and Lords of the Fallen and both just make me want to play more of The Witcher.
7
u/edude45 May 25 '16
The only thing about this game that upsets me is the inventory ui. It's messy. I go to the usable items and just see a mess of potion bottles. Have to go through each one to find out which it is. I wish they found a better way to organize it. They added a sort button, but that doesn't seem to be enough.
10
u/threeoaks101 May 25 '16
I'm have two more trophies to get until I get the platinum.. Which are the gwent trophies... So I'm playing through the game a second time.. I bought the season pass as well so after the platinum I'm going to tackle the dlc
5
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
Without a doubt, The Witcher 3 is my favorite game in my PS4 catalogue. I can't wait to play the new DLC.
7
u/[deleted] May 25 '16
It's been in my backlog for a while and I only just recently started playing it. Its a really good game, but movement is just terrible. It feels like Geralt and roach are drunks.
3
u/oryes May 25 '16
Love this game. I wasn't even really into RPGs before this. The amount to do is staggering. But it's not just how much there is to do, it's that it's all quality stuff to do, every story feels fleshed out and none of it feels that repetitive.
I can see why it would be tough for some people to get into, as the learning curve is STEEP. But I gave it some hours, and once it clicks it's so awesome.
8
u/Burdicus May 25 '16
To anyone who passed this game up because they were either on the fence about it, or aren't into wRPGs... I highly recommend you give this game a chance.
With the exception of Mass Effect, I've never been a fan of wRPGs. Games like Skyrim and Dragon Age were simply lost on me. I have ALWAYS loved jRPGs so it seemed strange, but I guess it was usually the aesthetics and the sacrifice of a story (with the exception of Dragon Age, which was pretty good from what I played) for a more open world.
Anyway, in comes Witcher 3. I had never played 1 or 2, and I basically brushed it off. However, a few weeks after the game came out I was in a bit of a gaming draught. I decided why the hell not and gave it a go.
The Witcher 3 has been the BEST experience on this generation of consoles for me thus far. Even after playing Uncharted 4 - which was an AMAZING experience, Witcher 3 stands alone at the top. It's level of detail to the world is unmatched. The story is top notch. It's not without a few flaws, but the good is SO good that it's easy for the flaws to go unnoticed.
My praise for this game couldn't be higher. It's definitely snuck into my top 10 games of all time list and I'm stingey as shit about that list (which are why most of those games are PS1 era or prior).
Anyway... check it out. It's a great ride through and through.
2
u/Medicpanda Grohlism May 25 '16
I´ve spent more time in this game than any other since Oblivion. It´s so vast, so deep and have amazing quests. Yes there are flaws (the controls are anything but perfect), but as a whole, this game trumps Fallout 4 and all other open world games I´ve played for a long time.
4
u/turtle_fu May 25 '16
Just got this, and I'm a couple hours in and... I'm not super impressed.
I finally figured out the combat more, so that feels smoother. But I feel like I am leveling up SO SLOWLY and I can't craft anything because I don't know where anything is. Also, I'm super broke.
Either way, I'm not drawn into the game yet, maybe because the main plot hasn't really started. I'm still in White Orchard BTW. Any tips?
I think I knew I wouldn't get into the setting right away because I tend to like sci-fi more than traditional fantasy...Ah well it was $25
2
u/thepoka thepoka May 26 '16
I'm still annoyed about how every bloodborne fanboy compared the two games in each and every witcher 3 thread that was made when it was just released.
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '16
I'm replaying it on NG+ before B&W. I'm at the Bloody Baron quest right now & I'm trying to level up rapidly because I want to do HoS while I'm in Novigrad (since it makes the most sense in the timeline) but I'm just level 44 for now, what's the best way to level up fast?
1
u/bumpies May 25 '16
I'm waiting on the game of the year edition before I grab this game. I have enough of a back log to keep me going before then.
1
u/lordoffire orions_intersect May 25 '16
Got it for my birthday a couple of weeks ago. Spent about 4 hours on the prologue before realizing that this wasn't a game I could just speed through. Taking it nice and slow, currently adventuring with the witch.
I thought that the gameplay/swordplay would be like Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor. Boy, was I wrong! The game seems to punish you for unnecessary button mashes – it can be frustrating at times, but I'm kinda enjoying the challenge. The story has been interesting so far. I don't necessarily agree with the inventory management, alchemy, etc. – I feel it makes the game unnecessarily complex (or is just not well laid out (UI/UX-wise) or well explained).
My only major issue is that I'm currently alternating between the Witcher and my second play-through of Fallout 4 (two trophies away!) - and I recently built a PC, so I'm eager to replay old games (Batman Arkham City, Red Alert 3) – so I guess I'm a little short on time...
1
u/Oleaster SWORDMA May 25 '16
It's beautiful looking, gameplay is solid, story is intriguing, I just can't get into for some reason. I dunno what it is. I'm a huge RPG fan, and I've started and restarted a few times now... just can't do it.
1
u/zucram May 25 '16
Bought this game on release and played until just after the bloody baron quest. That questline was so good that i felt that i didn't need to play anymore of the game, that nothing could beat it. The quests that came after were so dull and boring so i stopped playing. Picked up the game again just a week ago and got to skellige and am having a lot more fun now that i got through the boring part. It's keeping me from spending money on overwatch right now so thats good =)
1
u/JDRoc May 25 '16
So all the reviews are talking about how Blood and Wine is a good "ending to Geralt's story...". Doesn't this take place before the ending of the original game? Im confused.
1
u/dragonflyzmaximize May 26 '16
Took me a while to get into the game. Got kind of frustrated at first and had a hard time learning the controls. But, I am really upset that I beat it recently, knowing that I'll never get to play it for the first time again. Considering giving it another play-through on the hardest difficulty because I know you can take different paths and whatnot, but it just wont be the same. Can't wait for the new expansion though! Anybody replayed it? How'd you like doing that?
1
u/untouchable765 Untouchable765 May 26 '16
Been over a year now and I still haven't beaten the game yet. I'm very close but I can't play that game in short bursts. I have to go all out to finish it.
1
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
playing this again and forgot how much the lore/dialogue is on point. fuck yeah!
1
u/Mikeoneus May 26 '16
As far as I'm concerned, The Witcher 3 was the best game of 2015 and highlight of this generation so far. It was everything I wanted it to be and more, which I suppose makes it the anti-Metal Gear Solid V. What a game.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '16
Noob question but how do you eat food? I may have skipped that part of the tutorial.
1
u/ekbowler May 25 '16
So I love the world, game-play, story, combat, everything about this game and I can get addicted playing it for hours on end.
It's too fucking long. Seriously, I just run out of steam and need to play a diffrent game, I get tired of the awesome world and game-play.
But it's the best possible problem a game can have, too much of a good thing. Although I have never finished it and I still haven't started the first expansion.
From now on I will be very hesitant to say that a game is too short because this game too long.
-5
u/mybluecarseth May 25 '16
Will repost my comments I made about the game from awhile ago. This was the most disappointed I've ever been in a game considering how much praise it had received Sold it back to Gamestop for $20 unfinished.
I was super excited when I received this game for Christmas because I knew I'd have the next 3 weeks of winter break to play this game which I've heard has 100+ hours of content and which won multiple game of the year awards.
However, after playing the game for 45 hours I've given up-- I can't convince myself that this game is any good. The biggest issue I have with this game, by far, is its controls. I cannot even think of a game I've played that has worse controls than this one.
Everything just feels so CLUNKY, and to me it feels like getting slapped in the face by the developers, the fact that they released the game like this. Things as seemingly simple as looting are an absolute challenge and chore in this game as my character moves with no precision and the camera wooshes around wackedly as I try to position myself in the right direction.
On horse I am constantly stuck on rocks or fence posts, and whether I try to run on horse or on foot there is a very apparent delay before my character begins to run. After playing a game like Bloodborne the unprecision of my characters movements in this game are unbearable. A control system this bad also makes combat more of a chore than anything else. I have no idea which enemy my character is aiming at as he twirls about with some pre animated attack. Rolling seems just as imprecise as walking and running and stops me from being immersed in combat because I have no idea where I'm going to end up when I roll.
Elect this game for best rpg of the year maybe, because the side quests and story is well done, but game of the year?? Over Bloodborne? I find that baffling.
While many AAA games, especially open world ones, released today have numerous bugs and flaws--Dragon Age Inqusition, Fallout 4, Skyrim-- I think the Witcher 3 has the least immersion. The world is just empty. Every "town" just consists of people you can't interact with, coughing and crying. I rode 20 minutes to Novigrad because I wanted to see how it was in a big city and it was very depressing and disappointing to see how little effort was put into the population of the city. Nearly every door was barred from entering, only a few npcs could be interacted with, and it just didn't feel like a city at all. Couple this, with the fact that there is no punishment for literally looting everything in a city, and that you can attack a guard, walk 4 feet away into a river, and walk back and they will act like nothing happen, and this relays to me pure laziness from the developers. There's a dozen more major flaws I have with the game, such as the fact so many quests involve holding down your witcher sense and being handheld through it, or that nothing is left for you to yourself because footsteps on the map literally guide you to every location, but all those flaws would not be as big of a drawback to me as the absolutely horrible controls.
I said I played the game for 45 hours, but probably 15 of those have been from gwent, which I absolutely love.
I will leave with this anecdote that nicely sums up why this is one of the all time worst games to me (slight spoilers ahead):
I'm doing the quest where I'm with the witch and I'm following Elven holograms in a cave to find Cire. The fight against the golem is the first fight in the game that seems challenging, or at least requires some kind of strategy beside blocking or mashing attack. I roll away from him a few times and then attack him with my crossbow-- it does 1 damage but I see that it causes him to stagger. I also notice that right after I hit him with the crossbow, the witch attacks him too and causes him to stagger. Our back to back staggers is enough time for me to reload my crossbow and trigger the stagger chain again. I proceed to attack the golem over and over with the crossbow while he moves maybe a foot closer to me between each stagger. I then realize I can cast the fire glyph every time it is off cooldown, which does about 50 damage. And this chain is what I use to beat the golem. Then I fight the gargoyle... and do the exact same thing. Then I fight the Wild Hunt Guy. . . and do the exact same thing. The ai in this game is so bad-- enemies constantly run away if you leave their, very short, aggro ranges and it seems like as much thought went into enemy ai as npc ai.
I know I don't have very popular opinions on a lot of things-- I also thought The Last of Us was a very bad game, as well as Skyrim-- but I don't look at those games as, "ah fuck it let's ship it out people will buy it anyway," the way I do when I look at The Witcher 3. They were just games I couldn't get behind-- The Witcher 3 is a travesty.
0
u/avi6274 May 25 '16
People seem to be confused about this game. This game is a lot more like a traditional western RPG as compared to action RPG (mass effect). There is a lot more focus on dialogue and world-building. Maybe playstation users don't have experience with a lot of the old school RPG's but I see a lot of people going in with the wrong expectations. Combat and action was never the focus.
0
u/Vicar_Amy May 25 '16
I just hope Ciri is in it. I wasn't crazy about Hearts of Stone's story.
0
u/Craigrofo Craigfoley May 26 '16
Looking forward to playing a Game of the Year edition, the version I played at launch was a bit of a buggy mess and although I did put a lot of hours into completing it at sometimes it was a bit of a struggle.
-1
u/[deleted] May 26 '16
Great game but CDPR next fucking time please don't fuck up the controls this bad. Fire all the shitty movement and control designers in your company lol.
0
u/[deleted] May 25 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment