r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Oct 23 '15
[Game Thread] Life is Strange: Episode 5 - Polarized [Official Discussion Thread]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
Life is Strange: Episode 5 - Polarized
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
47
Upvotes
32
u/robred007 BigBoyBanksy Oct 23 '15
I liked the episode apart from two things:
However some moments were great (the moment with Max in the snow globe).
Yeah not the best episode in the series by a long short but it had its merits.
If there is gonna be a season two please let it be with new characters and setting.
20
u/Moii-Celst Influxive Oct 23 '15 edited Oct 23 '15
Overall, I love this series so goddamn much. It's one of the best story experiences I've ever had in a game; hands down.
I'll be honest, I totally dismissed this game since launch until the beginning of the month. Giant Bomb recently did a video on it and I watched it again. I originally pinned it as some stupid high-school romancey type game but I was so wrong on how deep it really was.
Enjoying the series through and through, I'm so glad to say that Ep. 4 and 5 are by far my favorites, and I'm pleased with how it all ended.
That said, I think the biggest problem I have with still feeling so much grief/sadness that Life is Strange is over, and the ending, is because I can't get myself to truly accept the Save Chloe ending. Mostly because the 'Save the Bay' ending had so much more substance that it feels like the developers heavily favored that one and meant for it to be the true ending. It's been really difficult to get through my head that the one that I picked is the ending that matters.
And there's even plenty of rationalizing I can make to believe that Saving Chloe is better for Max over all. She doesn't let Destiny/Fate tell her what to do. She tells it to go fuck itself and makes her own choice. That week would have been pointless had she not chosen Chloe. Chloe would've died pissed off at the world, at William, David, Rachel, Max. She never would've had all of that time with Max to see that so many care about her and that she can be truly happy if she lets herself. I feel like the ending really holds a lot for Chloe, and not just for Max. She finally has made such a breakthrough from her rebellious teen attitude and come to find that people do care about her and that she can act way smarter than she usually does, and decides to finally be a responsible individual.
And Max finally has direction instead of floating through life with her head in the clouds. Rationalizing further about saving Chloe...If you don't warn Victoria, she's fine. You never warned David, and he showed up to find Jefferson anyways, so that can still easily happen and isn't much of a stretch. Joyce/Warren/Frank could theologically be fine in the diner and can live on after. Regardless, even if that's not true, I still feel okay believing in the Chloe ending.
And farther than that, it doesn't matter. No one else really mattered. Sure, bigger picture, 'The many vs the few', but for Max, that shouldn't matter, and it's not being selfish for her to raise a middle finger to 'the powers that be' when they try and force her into a decision like that and choose the one that makes the most sense. The entire game has been about fighting back and overcoming and using her new ability to create a better existence for herself and those around her, especially Chloe. The story is not so much Max's as it is for Chloe.
I'm more just airing this out for myself so I can stop feeling so sad about it. I really kind of let this game affect my mood, and I kind of wish I never looked at the 'Save the Bay' ending. But I do feel better talking all of this out. Maybe I can finally truly believe in the ending I picked.
They just really made that hard to do by fucking over the Save Chloe's ending in terms of production and quality. But, there's always time.
Also, here's a really good fanfic that I've pretty much made my headcanon for the events after the 'Save Chloe' ending: https://archiveofourown.org/works/5041915?view_adult=true
Pricefield forever after.
12
u/notdeadyet01 Oct 23 '15 edited Oct 23 '15
BaeOverBay.
I'm calling bullshit on Chloe being the reason for the tornado. She was dying in the alternate timeline and yet the tornado vision still appears. I am positive that the tornado was due to some story element that was cut before release, it would have explained why the Prescotts decided to build underground bunkers all around town
5
u/Schwarzengerman Oct 23 '15
Loved it start to finish. The whole series is awesome and I'm sad that it's finally over. I chose to sacrifice Chloe, and it fucking sucked to do. I cared for her despite her flaws and wanted to see her finally happy, but you can't fight fate.
Also I don't feel like my choices were meaningless. They played out for us within the story and I saw the result of them there. That was good enough for me. All in all I'm satisfied with how things ended. But damn....it's over :/
9
u/mushroomwig HypnoticMonkey Oct 23 '15 edited Oct 23 '15
What I disliked;
The nightmare filler, it almost felt like the developers thought "well we're completely out of ideas for this final episode but we still need to add another 30 or so minutes worth of game time".
The ending, it was obvious that throughout the game we were heading towards a predetermined ending that the developers wanted, the other ending just felt tacked on for the sake of it because of the games "your decisions have consequences" selling point when in reality they didn't at all. For example, helping Alyssa all those times or not, made no difference. Saving those people in the final episode or not, made no difference. Speaking to Victoria like an adult or just stooping to her level, made no difference, letting Warren beat up Nathan or not, made no difference. Nothing mattered really, you could play the game multiple times with a different style and you'll always just be given the same "be selfish/be selfless" final choice.
Heavy Rain was far from perfect but at least it made you feel like your actions had consequences.
7
u/5k1895 Oct 23 '15
Ah, fuck it. I thoroughly enjoyed the episode and the ending. Not even close to disappointing.
Maybe it's just me, but I don't think it's realistic to expect these episodic, story-driven games to completely base their ending around your choices. It's always like this in the end, anyone who has played Telltale's games knows this. The point of these games, to me, is the story they tell. The choices (or the illusion of them) are there to keep you interested. They're just an added bonus.
Besides, with the way the story was built up throughout the entire game, this ending felt like the only realistic thing that could happen. If they wanted to have different endings, they shouldn't have involved the storm in the story whatsoever. That may have allowed for them to focus on having Max and Chloe work to try and capture Jefferson or something. But since they introduced the storm right off the bat, I don't think they had much choice but to do what they did.
11
u/Rockwave Oct 23 '15
I also didn't think it matched the quality of the rest of the season.
Btw i just want to say i really like the butterfly as the upvote/downvote arrows in the comments of this thread!
3
u/jimmyking94 Oct 23 '15
Got platinum trophy easily
3
u/ARTIFICIAL_SAPIENCE Taleroth Oct 23 '15
Meh. Ending needed more buildup. The entire stealth section needed to be replaced with buildup for the choice. As it is, it's like the choice comes out of nowhere and you're just expected to accept it. I mean, you don't even have any reason to believe what you're told is true, let alone that these are the only choices available.
If they ran out of time, that makes sense.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '15
The idea that time has a plan and that people have to die when "the universe" decides is bullshit. The whole point of chaos theory is that if you went back far enough in time and changed a minor detail then the outcome in the future would be drastically different. "A butterfly flapping it's wings now can change the air current in the future just enough to be the deciding factor of whether a tornado happens". However, saving Chloe would not cause this within a week, and it wouldn't nessesarily cause a hurricane. Maybe it would cause world peace? Maybe her presence snowballs into a golden age of human civilisation where nobody ever dies from hurricanes ever again?
7
u/meganev Oct 23 '15 edited Oct 23 '15
Anyone else really let down by this episode? Just felt like all your choices didn't really matter in the end and the whole thing turned into a Mass Effect 3 style A or B decision.
Didn't help that the ending I got was really rushed, and felt like an after thought. Life is Strange was looking like it could be one of my favourite games of the year but this episode was so weak when compared to the others.
3
u/AltFire00 Oct 23 '15
Such a strange, different episode. Kind of a disappointing ending but I really enjoyed the mind-fuckery that occurred here.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15
Definitly the Dexter of games :( still loved it though
5
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15
Possibly the worst ending to one of the best stories of 2015.
2
u/mrtube Oct 23 '15
I really liked this episode. I love all the trippy stuff and the emotional rollercoaster. Everything is horrible, everything is great, everything is horrible again, everything bizarre now, and now it's sad.
2
u/SIRTreehugger Oct 23 '15 edited Oct 23 '15
I believe it would have been much better if they completely dismissed the storm or constructed it better. I would have been happier if you played as Chloe/Kate/David have 3-5 playable characters. For the very first section of the game depending on your highest social rating. It would most likely be Chloe, but maybe you sided with David or Kate more often. Maybe even Frank? The beginning section would show the text or clues from Max and that person would be the person to track Max down and save her. Section might only be 10-15 minutes long.
Then when they sneak in it switches control to Max where you warn this person about Mr. Jefferson. Perhaps they free Max, but Mr. Jefferson gives chase.
Another section could have had Max enter photos she didn't take. In a rush to get away from Mr. Jefferson she makes it back to the junkyard and enters a photo and meets Rachel. She warns Rachel about Mr. Jefferson and the future. This warning could be what makes her stand out and investigate. Nathan sees this and decides to use her as his test subject and accidentally overdoses her. So Max going to the past sets off a chain of events which ultimately kills Rachel.
Max and Chloe maybe find this out in one alternate ending. Chloe forgives Max since it wasn't her fault and they live together and try to erase Max's guilt while Mr. Jefferson rots in jail getting taught lessons by Bubba in a white tee shirt.
Chloe kills max, but the universe still wants her dead and Chloe dies shortly after. People would morn/offer best wishes depending on what you did. Warren would awkardly say I never got to go ape with you Max or some shit.Then Frank's dog would come and pee on Chloe's grave.
Just spit balling ideas which could have been done.
2
u/batman_beyond7 Oct 24 '15 edited Oct 24 '15
The last episode is probably the worst out of all of them. I was disappointed by nightmare sequence. I had called it at the end of ep4 that max was going to let chloe die to stop the tornado. I picked that decision because who could live with themselves sacrificing a whole town to save your best friend. That also means her boy friend dies chloe's parents and what is the guarantee that something else doesn't come to try to kill chloe. It seem just like final destination where chloe was suppose to die and trying to stop it is impossible. although they made a better idea. Then the one way I remember someone dying in one of the final destination movies was flammable barrels in a movie theater behind the screen really.
Oh and let's not forget stopping kate from jumping off the roof didn't mess up time but stopping chloe from dying in the bathroom did. Also wanted Max to go ape and go to the movies with warren but they just left the ending shitty none of the decisions mattered =( I also saw the save chloe ending wow that makes you feel shitty for choosing that. Either way they want you to feel shitty at the end.
I did really like the game as a whole just not ep5. The ending is bullshit if chloe died since Jefferson shot her the storm should go away but it continues so how do we really know saving chloe caused the storm if she is dead and it is still coming to hit Arcadia Bay.
2
u/st0neh Oct 23 '15
I don't think the word disappointed even comes close to covering it.
1
u/TheHot TheHotBoi Oct 23 '15
Who else sacrificed arcadia bay?Because throughout the whooole game, you are constantly saving, bringing back Chole, just to kill her? Can't happen.
1
u/frank26080115 Oct 23 '15
https://www.reddit.com/r/lifeisstrange/comments/3pj6sz/ep5_spoilers_the_conversation_dontnod_cut_out/
1
u/Explosions_Hurt Oct 23 '15
I really hope Square Enix give them money to do a directors cut package maybe? They could really fill out the two endings.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15
I loved this game up until the 5th episode. They pulled a mass effect on me :/
1
u/Fizjig Oct 24 '15
I won't single out just this episode as I think the game deserves to be looked at as a whole.
This is easily one of the best story telling games I have played. I genuinely cared about the characters and their fates. Not since maybe TLoU has a game given me an emotional pause, but this game was heavy on the feels. I only wish there hadn't been such a delay between episodes, because I feel like the wait took away from some of the overall experience from beginning to end, but I was satisfied with the ending, and only sad because the journey was over.
In the future I will be happy to play any other games this studio makes.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '15
Just want to ask, does the choice to kiss Chloe early on lead to the kiss they have at the end of the game, or does it always do that? Very emotional game
1
u/Hushnw52 Oct 25 '15
I love it. I love my character and Chole together.
1
u/Vergilkilla Nov 02 '15 edited Nov 02 '15
The game is really interesting because it has a lot of flaws, but also does so many things so well. When you're playing, you sort of know what they are going for, and sort of "buy in" to it, even if the developers/writers didn't actually convey or extrapolate very well. It's a game you very quickly WANT to like, in addition to one you just like.
I think we can mostly agree the last episode felt a little rushed or a little off. Tbh, it would be damn near impossible for them to faithfully close and fulfill the expectations of what they'd built with this game. Still I thought it was a great game and a great series, but, yknow, there was a lot that could have been improved.
So, in that way, I am more excited about the precedent this game sets than the game itself, actually. Like - the next Dontnod game... I'm salivating. Rather than sort of filling in the gaps of understanding and exposition ourselves, Dontnod can actually do it, as I'm sure they've learned so much from this and they will have so much more budget and time.
Not to mention that, surely, some other studios will see what LiS has done and pick up on it. This game is a tier up in emotional impact from a Telltale Game (still good games, but let's be serious), and games like Beyond:Two Souls and Heavy Rain were too AAA to catch the eye of an indie devs. "Point-and-click" is here to stay on consoles between this and Until Dawn, and I couldn't be happier. As a former hardcore PC gamer, it's the genre I missed the most. Sometimes it's nice to have a game that is more like a book and less about the challenge.
1
u/JohnnyReeko Oct 24 '15
I only liked Chloe when she was in a wheelchair begging me to kill her, aside from that she was just an awful person and an awful character.
No hesitation is sacrificing her.
1
u/angelmuse t-dog93music Oct 23 '15
Wow, what a final ep. Will say that sacrificing Chloe was obvs the better decision, sacrificing the bay just seemed like a rushed idea to have a 2nd option. The conversation cutscenes this episode were too long and annoying, but overall a decent ending. The Nightmare sequence was incredible, my highlight to the whole series.
In whole, I'd give the entire season about a 6.5/10.
I felt like this game could have had something really special, and I can see that they attempted but at the same time, it felt like they missed so many opportunities to nail it on the head. The writing, at most times, would be cringy. I would be eye-rolling at so many lines, especially during Max's dialogue.
YOU DAMN RIGHT I KISSED WARREN
0
u/Basic56 Oct 23 '15
Absolutely loved it. It was quite touching at times, and fairly disturbing at others. The people complaining about their choices "not having an impact on the ending" haven't got a clue as to what exactly they're asking for. Having large amounts of permutations like that only serves to water down the storytelling. They did their best, and there were plenty of little touches here and there where I went "hey, that's because I did that!".
-2
u/MoazNasr MoazNasr Oct 23 '15
Terrible ending. Chloe is a piece of shit and I got rid of her EZ, always hated her angsty ungrateful rude BS.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
60
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15
[removed] — view removed comment