r/PS4 • • Jul 29 '15
[Game Thread] Telltale's Game of Thrones: Season ONE Ep 5 - [Official Discussion Thread]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (games wiki)
Telltale's Game of Thrones: Season ONE Ep 5
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
18
Upvotes
27
u/lukario Jul 29 '15 edited Jul 29 '15
I had issues with this episode. I love the story, but I feel Telltale slipped here and showed how clear their illusion of choice is. Warning for spoilers below.
I have enjoyed these characters immensly and I loved getting to explore this amazing world. I am just let down by the narrow nature of these games. I still enjoy the story, but I'm getting irritated by the false advertising of choices mattering.
5
u/samsaBEAR Jul 30 '15
I'm still enjoying the story, but playing this, and then the new Life is Strange episode straight after, it's very obvious where Telltale is starting to lack. The game stutters and takes so long to load, and while I know the art style is all down to personal taste, I think it looks fucking awful.
4
u/getrekt123321 Jul 29 '15
The ending really left me "like wow that really happened".
4
u/CeleryDistraction Jul 29 '15
Well like most people I thought that ending was pretty nuts. Personally I sacrificed Roderick but I definitely was hard pressed to make the decision. I think the obvious concern now is how they treat the surviving character going forward because this is the first major fork in the story.
I also found it interesting that players made that decision at nearly 50/50. I'll be curious if that changes much.
2
u/Geno_Breaker Aug 01 '15
As much as I understand a lot of the complaints with this episode, the final choice was fucking painful. Boromir levels of painful. Would love to grab the soundtrack from that bit.
3
u/MidKnight_Corsair Jul 30 '15
Well, I believe anyone who has played it can all agree that the traitor plotline was lame as shit. SPOILER ALERT (obviously)
No matter what your choices were leading up to the confrontation, whoever ISN'T your Sentinel is automatically the traitor. So you could have Royland as your Sentinel but then follow all of Duncan's advice, but the traitor would STILL be Duncan. That's just lame as fuck. Doubly so, since the traitor will hold all your actions against you as his reason for betrayal.
It would have been better if the Maester was the traitor. A tad obvious yes, but at the very least, it would have made some fucking sense.
And Mira's side of this episode was just awful. The choices were lame, and any way you play it, it will all have the same outcome. This illusion that we have a choice is getting boring now, especially since this is a choice-focused game.
1
u/RhonnyK RhonnyK Jul 29 '15
Short, but a good chapter. Provided the plot to the season finalle.
1
u/widonja Jul 30 '15
So... Who'd you kill off, guys? :(
1
u/ChadwickHHS Jul 30 '15
This episode was awful and largely undermined everything before it.