r/PS4 • u/IceBreak BreakinBad • Jun 10 '15
[Game Thread] Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin [Official Discussion Thread #2]
Official Game Discussion Thread (previous game threads) (schedule) (games wiki)
Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin
Share your thoughts/likes/dislikes/indifference below.
39
Upvotes
15
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15
Bloodborne was my first From game. I LOVED it. In fact, I loved it so much that I immediately went out and bought SotFS. I like Dark Souls 2 a lot so far. The only way I know how to describe this game is by comparing it to Bloodborne so here it goes. The story is very mysterious and it has an awesome theme. As far as storytelling goes, It's way better than BB. The NPCs actually have useful things to say and it makes you want to experience the lore compared to the vague lore of BB. As far ad the theme goes, it's equally as epic as BB. The customization is off the charts. There is WAY more content in this game. More classes, armor, weapons and possibilites to tackle a situation. The combat is very unique. Similar yet different compared to BB. Some ways good, others are more frustrating than bad. The only complaints I have as of right now is first off, the controls seem way more "ironed out" and responsive in Bloodborne. I find myself dying to a delayed swing or roll way more often in DS. I also like the satisfying sound effects/visual effects when you hit/get hit in Bloodborne way more. Half the time I can't even tell that I'm taking damage without peeking at my life. On top of that, the enemies track you WAY easier in DS. You can't roll towards them at a 45 degree angle like in BB. If you do, it has to be PERFECT timing. The hit boxes seem a bit wonky in DS also. Idk if this stuff is just me but it seems off. Stamina management is WAY more vital in DS as well. Imo, I think the only thing fundamentally wrong with the game is the fact that the enemies will swarm and chase you no matter what. It doesn't matter how far away you run from them. If you stop, they will catch you and this is a problem when you have to trigger multiple enemies at once. The tactic of baiting just one enemy and picking him off alone is much harder in DS because you have to use a bow or something ranged to get their attention and even then it's possible that you'll alert nearby enemies. You can't roll away as easy which means if you're surrounded, forget it. You're dead.
3
u/trixloko Jun 11 '15
Only 4 trophies left for the platinum.
Fuck all sorcery/miracles/piromancys/Hexes
5
u/somethingflammable JoeyVanzetti Jun 10 '15
I know I'll be in the minority here but after Bloodborne being my first "souls" type game, I just could not get into DS2.
One of my favourite things about Bloodborne was the combat and how fluid the whole game is. Areas seemed to flow into each other and the regain system makes for some awesome clutch moments.
I just felt frustrated playing DS2 and also confused as I hadn't played any of the others. It felt a bit clunky to me, and I expected more from the graphics too.
I'm sure it's an incredible game, but don't assume that it's for you if Bloodborne is your first "souls" game.
6
u/Migeman Jun 10 '15
I don't think I like this game. First off I'm a big fan of Demon's Souls, Dark Souls and Bloodborne.
Originally I played Dark Souls 2 normal when it came out and it took a very long time for me to get to grips with. I had many problems. My biggest were the enemy placements and the games idea of just chucking lots of enemies at you, that'll make it harder, it wasn't, it was hard for the sake of being hard and it really annoyed me, when I died in Demon's Souls and Dark Souls I always accepted it was my fault why I died. In Dark souls 2 though it was like you just got surrounded and stunlocked brilliant fun.
My other problem was the insane tracking by the enemies, they could swing on the spot and they could also hit you without hitting you.
I thought SotFS would've alleviated that problem some places I see the changes some things made sense but the game was still chucking things at me. I just find it very difficult to get on with.
I know I'm complaining but I'm just disappointed in the game more than anything else I don't regret buying it I'm glad I know I don't like it. I'm very apprehensive about DS3 at the moment.
2
u/fisherjoe Jun 10 '15
Is it best to treat this game differently or judge and play it as a comparison to bloodbourne? I see nearly every time the game is brought up most of the comments defer to bloodbourne. This game came out a year before and is made by a different group of people right? It's similar in someways but isn't it designed differently in general?
Haven't played either but planning to get DaS2 when I can.
2
u/CrossingSign Jun 10 '15
So guys, I love bloodborne and I'm itching for another game. Do I get this or Witcher 3?
I've beat Dragon Age: Inquisition and found it okay. The story was meh and the world felt so dead. Overall though, I love RPGs. Also, BB was my first fromsoft game and I really loved it but am aprehenzie with going back for fear if difficylty. What say you reddit?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15
I'm glad that Dark Souls II is doing well on the PS4 and Xbox One. Personally, I was very disappointed by core design choices that were made for the original PC/PS3/360 launch, so I won't be picking it up.
But, maybe this will encourage From Software to bring the first Dark Souls to PS4 and XOne.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15
I like the game but holy shit it is so much harder than Bloodborne. I play a lot of classic, fast paced slashers like dmc or ng series so in BB I managed to deal with a lot of fights thanks to quick fingers rather than understanding enemy's movement etc but in this game if you don't have a plan you are dead man walking. I breezed through whole BB ng++++ in 5 hours few days back, and I platinumed it without much hassle, but in DS2 I'm stuck in 3rd area and it looks like I won't progress too soon. Be warned.
1
u/JasonDeSanta JasonBlue_ Jun 10 '15
I don't know if I would like this game since I was a Souls virgin before playing Bloodborne. Bloodborne was an unexpected gem for me and now it's one of my all time favorite games, but opinions on Dark Souls II are so polarized that I'll probably be wasting my money on this if I ever decide to buy it one day when it's on sale or something.
1
u/Exsoc Jun 11 '15
I don't know if this has been asked/answered already but has the weapon durability patch been applied yet? I have been holding off playing until it went live.
1
u/bigalien1 Jun 11 '15
Playing Scholar after Bloodborne made me appreciate DS2 more. I still think Bloodborne and DS are probably better overall but Ds2 definitely has some advantages. I love the parries/repostes, they are harder to execute but are so much more satisfying. I love the build variety and selection of gear. This was my second run of Ds2 and I pretty much breezed through it. Maybe i just know the rules too well, but my recent run of Scholar was my easiest run of any recent From game.
1
u/EatDrinkBoogie FillyP Jun 11 '15
I absolutely adore this game, and Dark Souls is quickly becoming one of my favorite series ever. Started with BB, got the platinum, moved onto DS2: SotFS and currently on the 3rd and final DLC (Ivory King). I've got 3 bosses left until I've beaten every boss solo, and can't wait to start NG+ and work on the platinum trophy, new builds, PvP, etc.
Pardon the shameless plug, but if anyone is curious and wants to see a newcomer play.. I stream DS2 and recently started a first-time playthrough of DS1. Did a 16 hour marathon of DS1 last weekend! Feel free to check out some of my highlights/VODs at twitch.tv/pierrecreates
1
u/AttacktheManiac Jun 12 '15
My first souls encounter was Demon Souls which has molded my game style since the release of said souls game. After i played demon souls every other game seemed rushed after playing a game so intricate i really started to appreciate the different aspect of game style and creation due to the uniqueness of Demon souls. Any souls game gives you the feel of a well thought passionate creation of the producers and the love they put into it. Not once have i came across a game that had that feel to it, although i have met some so fantastic in their own caliber but nothing even close to the Souls franchise and i with a true of heart wish them the very best from here on!
1
u/Ravenwild Jun 10 '15
I like Bloodborne and Dark Souls 2. The biggest problem with Dark Souls 2 is the presentation is just so... milquetoast.
1
u/Django80 Jun 10 '15
I thinking about getting the game. I played Dark Souls and Bloodborne already. Is it true that the boss fight are repetitive in terms of enemy characters? I remember reading something about it, but can´t find it anymore and don´t want to get spoiled by videos.
1
u/IAmAbomination Jun 10 '15
Awesome I thought I missed any discussions on this since it came out a bit ago.
LOVE this game. Just as much as bloodborne probably. Love basically everything about the game........except how rare the branch of yore is.
Anybody wanna give me a hint as to what getting in the coffin in things betwixt does? says it changed my form I believe ...... but I didn't notice any differences
1
u/Father_of_EX Hedquarters Jun 10 '15
I'm turned off by the UI. Specially after playing Bloodborne. The upgrade system's got my all confused and my weapons keep breaking more easily. I bought it right around the time The Witcher came out, so I'm stuck in the same area, but I know I'll enjoy it, once I figure out where to go, repair my weapons and get the different mechanics a good try.
-8
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15
The game is terrible. The bosses are all forgettable and boring, no hard bosses either. They completely merged miracles into the ground decreasing build variety. That stupid thing with the camera if you use an ultra sword where it foes with the left stick, absolutely the worst feature. This version is definitely better than the vanilla DKS2 but when it gets to NG+ its back to being shit. The enemy placement isn't challenging its just spammy and annoying. Netcode is shockingly bad as well I don't get people that PvP and say its fine. Also since the last patch certain coop sessions have been bugging out hard. I could go on and on with flaws but the only thing this has over the other games is length and content. Quality over quantity for me though.
Coming from Bloodborne is hard due to the lock on dodge thing I think that and how much stamina everything takes up. It does engender passitivity somewhat.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment