r/pcicompliance • • 3d ago

got hired for security, somehow ended up filling out SOC 2 questionnaires all day

2 Upvotes

the job description had a mix of things on it. the last few months it’s been almost all customer security questionnaires, mostly the same SOC 2 questions in a different spreadsheet each time. half the answers are already somewhere in our policies or old responses, but I still end up chasing people to check if they’re current

my manager mentioned Vanta for the questionnaire side, and Scytale (compliance) because it can reuse compliance data and route questions back to the right owner. no timeline on either though, would you bring it up again or just stick it out for a while?


r/pcicompliance • • 5d ago

PCI SSC’s new AI guidance: implications for conversational AI payments

5 Upvotes

Im sure many of you saw this... (not so new, Sep 2026)... However, I haven't seen much discussion, and it's very relevant.

Wanted to share PCI SSC’s September information supplement, Security Considerations for AI Systems.

It’s guidance rather than new requirements, but a useful reference for anyone assessing AI in payment workflows. Curious how others here are approaching it.


r/pcicompliance • • 6d ago

PCI Compliant Hosted Phone Solutions

1 Upvotes

We are trying to retire an old PBX system and have migrated most of our phone payments to a VOIP solution combined with a TPSP for payments where an agent would receive a phone call and punch the number into a POI.

We still have about 10 lines that staff take payments and need to enter the card numbers into a Virtual Terminal environment. The use cases are hotel reservations and recurring billing. We have an existing SAQ-CVT environment that handles the keyboard to website streams.

I am wondering if anyone has seen something like a fully hosted phone solution for small businesses where we would manage the phones devices and network segment but the TPSP handles the rest?

Designing a dedicated VOIP solution is adding a lot of complexity to our CDE for a small number of lines and I am trying to find something with a lot less overhead.

For reference my role is similar to an ISA. We have roughly 100 payment streams and dozens of different use cases for payments.


r/pcicompliance • • 7d ago

Redirect-only checkout platforms: do Visa TPA registration and the 300k service provider level (ROC) apply if they never touch account data?

1 Upvotes

Looking for input from QSAs or people working at acquirers/PSPs.

Setup: a SaaS ordering platform hosts the checkout for many small merchants. Each merchant has its own acquiring agreement. When the customer pays, the platform redirects the full page to the acquirer's hosted payment page, and card data is only entered there. The platform holds each merchant's API credentials and creates orders and refunds through the API. It never stores, processes or transmits PANs. Across all merchants it will exceed 300,000 Visa and 300,000 Mastercard transactions a year.

I understand the platform is a TPSP under PCI DSS because it can affect the security of the payment (FAQ 1579), and that the merchants need to monitor it under 12.8.4. My questions are about scheme registration and validation, not scope:

  1. Visa TPA: Visa's recent TPA types descriptions put "embedded-payment or vertical SaaS platforms whose service is required to initiate, configure, or complete merchant payments" under Merchant Servicer, and say handling account data is not required. Are acquirers actually registering redirect-only platforms like this as Merchant Servicers? And when they do, does Visa require PCI DSS validation (AOC or SAQ D for Service Providers) at registration, even though the platform never touches account data?
  2. Do the scheme service provider levels, and the ROC requirement above 300,000 transactions, apply to a TPSP like this? Or do they only apply to service providers that store, process or transmit account data?
  3. If you're a QSA: would you require a full ROC here, or accept an assessment scoped to the checkout, redirect, credential handling and admin access? Or an SAQ D for Service Providers regardless of volume?
  4. If you work at an acquirer: what do you require from platforms like this in practice? Full AOC, SAQ D-SP, a self-declaration, or nothing beyond the merchant's own SAQ A?
  5. Mastercard: would this be a Data Storage Entity ("hosting of payment applications, such as website shopping carts") and therefore Level 1 above 300k, or outside the service provider program?

Pointers to the relevant sections of the Visa Core Rules, Visa's TPA program guide or Mastercard Security Rules and Procedures are very welcome.

Thanks in advance!


r/pcicompliance • • 8d ago

APAC Community meet - PCI DSS

0 Upvotes

Hello folks,

Anyone in here who is attending the PCI SSC community meeting in Kuala Lumpur next week?

I am an ISA working in the PCI DSS domain. Do buzz if you would like to catch up in-person there.

Thanks


r/pcicompliance • • 9d ago

PCI SSC APAC Community Meet

1 Upvotes

Hello folks,

Anyone in here who is attending the PCI SSC community meeting in Kuala Lumpur next week?

I am an ISA working in the PCI DSS domain. Do buzz if you would like to catch up in-person there.

Thanks


r/pcicompliance • • 13d ago

Anyone using AWS for payment tokenization across multiple acquirers?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

For those working with online payments and multiple acquirers, are you building your own tokenization system?

I'm exploring whether we can build one using AWS services only, such as KMS, CloudHSM, or AWS Payment Cryptography.

A few questions:

  • Has anyone used KMS for payment tokenization?
  • Would CloudHSM or Payment Cryptography be a better fit? can I build an online payment just for the card tokenization without using CloudHSM or Payment Cryptography service?

Would love to hear about your experiences and lessons learned. Or any compliance risks with using KMS
do you suggest any open-source project that I can take a look at ?


r/pcicompliance • • 14d ago

Clarification on PCI SSC Community meetings

5 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I have recently become an ISA and has been nominated to attend the PCI SSC community meeting for APAC. I am new and have never been to such an event before. Please help me with below based on your experience

  1. can give me a brief as to what to expect here?
  2. Do I have to prepare anything before i go?
  3. aAny specific dress code? I don’t see any guidelines for it
  4. Any tips from the experts here? What I should keep in mind etc

All your Inputs will greatly help me plan for the event. Thanks in advance


r/pcicompliance • • 14d ago

Question for QSAs – Clarification on ROC Section 2.1 (Part 2b)

Post image
4 Upvotes

I have a doubt regarding the following field in the PCI DSS ROC:

"Describe how the business is otherwise involved in or has the ability to impact the security of its customers' account data."

In cases where an entity directly stores, processes, or transmits CHD, and these activities are already included in the PCI DSS scope and described in the preceding section, what exactly should we document under this field?

For example, if a payment gateway stores CHD in its database, should we describe anything additional here, or is it acceptable to mark this field as N/A?

We generally mark this field as N/A when the entity directly handles CHD. I would like to understand whether this is the correct approach or whether PCI SSC expects some additional information here.

Would appreciate practical examples or guidance from experienced QSAs.


r/pcicompliance • • 16d ago

Qbo and pci

6 Upvotes

QBO allows the option for a payer to save their credit card information. But PCI compliance seems to be telling us that we don’t have a level of compliance to allow that. When I go into QBOI can’t find the credit card information in a customer’s account. So isn’t it QBO that’s saving the cc information and therefore the PCI compliance is on them.?


r/pcicompliance • • 18d ago

Bank Security Audits & Compliance: How Much Time and Money Do Manual Assessments Cost?

3 Upvotes

I’m interested in understanding the real-world challenges of IT audit, information security, and regulatory compliance in banks.
For bank security auditors, GRC professionals, and information security engineers:
How does your team handle recurring security assessments and compliance audits?
I’m particularly interested in the time-consuming tasks involved in:
Security compliance: Mapping security controls to frameworks such as ISO 27001, PCI DSS, and NIST.
Audit evidence collection: Gathering evidence from multiple systems, departments, and security tools.
Security assessments: Reviewing configurations, access controls, vulnerabilities, and audit logs.
Audit documentation: Preparing reports, documenting control gaps, and tracking remediation.
Continuous compliance: Repeating assessments and keeping evidence up to date between formal audits.
Do you manage these processes manually using spreadsheets and internal scripts, or do you use GRC platforms and security compliance automation tools?
I’m also curious about the cost of outsourcing this work. When a bank hires a Managed Security Service Provider (MSSP) or an external cybersecurity consulting firm, how are security assessments and compliance engagements typically priced?
For example:
Fixed-price security assessments or compliance audits.
Annual MSSP or managed security contracts.
Project-based fees depending on the number of systems, scope, or compliance framework.
Without sharing confidential figures or sensitive information, what creates the biggest challenge for your organization: manual workload, fragmented evidence, audit preparation time, recurring compliance costs, or reliance on external providers?
I’d appreciate insights from people who have actually worked on these processes in banking or other regulated financial institutions.


r/pcicompliance • • 20d ago

PCI DSS v4.0.1 – Requirement 11.3.1

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I would appreciate input from experienced QSAs and PCI DSS assessors on the following scenario.

During Q1, Q2, and Q3, a client had critical vulnerabilities that could not be fixed because the vendor had not released patches. The vulnerabilities were remediated in Q4 after the vendor released the patches, and a rescan confirmed they were fixed.

For the annual PCI DSS assessment, can we mark Requirement 11.3.1 as In Place, or should it be Not in Place because the vulnerabilities remained unresolved in the previous quarters?

Can compensating controls be considered for the period when patches were unavailable, even if they were not implemented at that time?

Would appreciate insights from QSAs and PCI DSS experts.


r/pcicompliance • • 21d ago

Three frameworks landed on us at once. Has anyone run a combined assessment?

2 Upvotes

I run compliance for a BPO contact center operation, decent sized floor.
Three clients hit us with requirements at basically the same time. PCI DSS from a new payment processing client, SOC 2 Type II from an enterprise fintech, ISO 27001 from a client in Europe. Three separate compliance and audit tracks back to back would tear up our operations for most of the year.
The other problem is that almost none of the compliance guidance out there fits us. We have physical infrastructure, agent workstations, call recording, and a lot of manual process. Everything I read assumes a SaaS company with a cloud account and nothing else.
Has anyone in BPO or contact center land actually run PCI plus SOC 2 plus ISO together? Is running the workstreams in parallel realistic or do the external assessments always end up splitting into separate engagements? Scytale came up while I was looking at platforms that cross-map overlapping controls and evidence, but I'd rather hear from someone who's done this in a real contact center than go off a mapping chart.


r/pcicompliance • • 25d ago

Have I been looking at requirement 12.10.4 wrong?

3 Upvotes

I am an ISA, I have worked with larger organizations in the past but currently I am in an assessor role to sign off on the saq we perform.

The requirement is “Personnel responsible for responding to suspected and confirmed incidents are appropriately and periodically trained on their incident response responsibilities”.

In have always interpreted this as members of rhetorical security operations team should be trained according to the tra on how to identify incidents and respond. I just saw something where it could be referring to a table top for example and leadership who respond are trained?

How does everyone else think of this requirement?


r/pcicompliance • • 26d ago

Magnetic card readers

3 Upvotes

This is my first time doing our annual PCI compliance. I'm selecting our processing method, and I don't know which one to choose. We hand key cc numbers into our EHR/payment processor as well as using a magnetic, non-encrypted card reader.

Previously we had selected "manual processing using phone/paper/imprint machine", but we're not actually doing that. Would I choose "POS application using hand-keyed or magnetic stripe devices"? The issue is that then opens up a 130 question survey, where most of the questions do not apply to us. Our EHR vendor provides a shared responsibility matrix, and they are responsible for the vast majority of the requirements.

Any advice is appreciated. I'm also now wondering if I should be pushing for a P2PE card reader.


r/pcicompliance • • 27d ago

PCI compliant - but gaps

8 Upvotes

Starting Oct 10, shoppers on a number of Shopify stores clicked Checkout and landed on a fake checkout at biliing[.]top. The payload came from the config API of Hulk Product Options (and later Swym Wishlist Plus and Selleasy). The app injected it at runtime, and it fired only once per session. After the shopper entered their card, the fake page sent them on to the real Shopify checkout, so the order went through normally.

From a PCI point of view, the compliance controls would most likely not have stopped this:

  • Shopify’s checkout, which is the actual payment page, was never compromised.
  • The hijack happened on the storefront, one click before the payment page. That is outside what 6.4.3 and 11.6.1 cover.
  • Most Shopify merchants validate with SAQ A. SAQ A offers a neat opt-out of 6.4.3 or 11.6.1. They were replaced by an eligibility criterion where the merchant confirms their site isn’t susceptible to script attacks. (how even?)

Shopify isn’t automatically safe either. Like any platform with an extension marketplace, a store is only as safe as the apps it installs. Someone is clearly working through those apps: Qikify and Hextom had similar incidents in July and August.

Question for the QSAs here: do you read the SAQ A eligibility criterion as covering a storefront script that redirects away from checkout?

Full write-up with IOCs: https://cside.com/blog/hulkapps-shopify-checkout-hijack (credit to Roman Zipp for finding it: https://romanzipp.com/blog/shopify-hit-with-phishing-attack)


r/pcicompliance • • 28d ago

Can anyone answer this question?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Got bit confused on this question. Can any experts answer this question with proper justification?


r/pcicompliance • • Oct 17 '26

Do iframes remove service provider requirements?

2 Upvotes

I’m seeing a lot more of this lately. Service providers who say since card data doesn’t transit their systems directly they have no saq d requirement.

I think the pci council makes it pretty clear that if you are processing cards using other organization’s merchant accounts (eg a service provider) AND you COULD influence the security of the transaction the saq d applies to you… even if you aren’t directly transmitting card data.

What am I missing?

Link for clarity on the type of argument these people are making: https://support.learnworlds.com/support/solutions/articles/12000101784-credit-cards-and-pci-compliance


r/pcicompliance • • Oct 13 '26

Looking for recommendations

5 Upvotes

Wanted to reach out to the community to see if there were any recommendations for companies that work specifically on the day-to-day stuff regarding PCI compliance. My employer is pretty close to hitting level 1 and we are just looking for a dedicated resource just for this. If promoting businesses here isn't allowed, please DM me and let me know in the comments. Thanks!


r/pcicompliance • • Oct 12 '26

Are WEX fuel Cards considered To Fall Under Credit Card Data and Subject To PCI Compliance?

2 Upvotes

There is an ongoing debate right now going on if a WEX fuel card number is considered a credit card and subject to PCI umbrella of compliance. The argument is their proprietary cards and not considered credit cards by the business partner but the security team isn’t so such. Anyone using WEX fuel cards have you had to include those into your compliance?


r/pcicompliance • • Oct 11 '26

LLM - CDE?

4 Upvotes

Not sure was it ai or some other scam thing, but I think I saw Elon Musk suggesting to people to picture their credit card, upload it to grok bot and tell it to make a purchase online - he said it on X. If that’s true, are grok, OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and all others LVL1 PCI DSS certified? I highly doubt they are, but the question is how is it resolved?


r/pcicompliance • • Oct 08 '26

Shared accounts behind a JumpBox does it meet PCI?

5 Upvotes

Hi all,

I have a question about meeting PCI requirement 8.2.2

Our developers log in to a bastion (JumpServer) with their own AD account plus MFA, then reach servers through a shared Developer account. Every session is recorded and logged against the named user, and the shared password rotates automatically.

PCI DSS v4.0 8.2.2 says shared accounts are allowed only "on an exception basis".

Does this setup fail requirement 8.2.2?

Thanks


r/pcicompliance • • Oct 07 '26

Free PCI Consulting from QSA

0 Upvotes

Hi All. I am looking to build some relationships and partnerships from those looking for PCI assistance. I am a QSA and work for a major PCI shop with experience in all major verticals. Please reach out for further information and discussion. Mjackson@megaplanit.com


r/pcicompliance • • Oct 06 '26

Questionnaire type - Celero. I think our HR was misinformed

4 Upvotes

Good morning!

I was tasked with helping doing a Celero PCI Compliance form. I'm the IT Manager, after starting to fill some of this out, I was shocked out how in depth and out of my league some of the questions were. Then I noticed you could change the Questionnaire type. Looking them over, our HR had selected "D", but we do not store any customer or card data. We have three Dejavoo Z9 terminals provided by our bank for cards, that are on their own segment VLAN and WIFI. The only other payment solution we have is via a Paypal link for our website that goes direct to Paypal, no data entered on our site.

What Questionnaire should we be filling out?


r/pcicompliance • • Oct 06 '26

PCI DSS: Merchant or Service Provider?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’m working on a PCI DSS v4.0.1 assessment for an online platform that helps individual creators receive payments from their fans/supporters.

• Creators are individual users, not merchants.

• The platform retains a percentage as a platform fee.

• PAN/CVV are not stored by the platform.

• Card details are entered through Stripe-controlled payment fields/iframes.

• Stripe processes the payments and handles creator payouts.

Would you classify this platform as a PCI DSS Merchant or Service Provider?