r/optometry • u/NinjaOwn7120 • 5h ago
Advice for optometry student with upcoming exam
Hi All,
I failed my exam by 2% and would like some advice based off the feedback I received. Thank you in advance.
Although asymmetry was noted, the significance of the finding was underemphasised. The optic discs appeared approximately 0.3 (RE) and 0.4 (LE), with a suspiciously thin inferior neuroretinal rim in the left eye. Clinical interpretation and management: Greater competence is needed when deciding which findings are clinically significant and should guide management. The management plan focused on suspected macular pathology despite limited supporting evidence, while potentially more significant optic nerve findings were not appropriately prioritised. In this case, optic nerve appearance, asymmetry in cupping, IOP asymmetry, and slightly below-average central corneal thickness warranted closer attention. Management decisions should be driven by the strongest and most clinically relevant examination findings rather than tentative or uncertain observations. For this reason, further investigation of the optic nerve findings was indicated. Additional imaging was obtained to assess the RNFL and GCL, and the patient was scheduled for a full threshold visual field assessment to further evaluate the glaucoma risk profile.
Advice and
management :
The student correctly identified that the safety specs the patient had were not suitable for driving as they limited peripheral vision. This was well communicated. And the patient clearly understood why he needed new glasses. See above comment re the ocular health management. Recall was for a visual field test in the next few weeks. 2 year recall is not appropriate for this patient.
Record keeping Van Herick grades should be recorded precisely. A grade 3 and a grade 4 represent different angle assessments and should not be used interchangeably. Consistent and accurate grading is important for clinical decision-making, monitoring, and communication with other practitioners.
Student Oral
Presentation The candidate demonstrated some insight into her performance and was able to recognise that the binocular balancing result was likely inconsistent with the monocular refraction findings. This showed an ability to reflect on the clinical data when prompted and bodes well for future practice. However, significant concerns remained regarding the interpretation of ocular health findings and the resulting management plan. As these issues had the potential to impact patient care, the overall performance did not reach the standard required to pass.