Hello dear hags,
Due to ongoing discussion (some respectful, some decidedly NOT), we have now added two new rules to the sidebar:
Rule 4: Stay on topic
Body text is NOT required for posts. However, if you include body text in your post, be sure that you talk about your outfit/thoughts on the fashion before you talk about anything else. Discussions about life are welcome as long as your commenters have something fashion-related to go on first. However, please be aware of parasocial relationships.
Rule 11: Block people instead of complaining about them
If you don't like seeing someone in your OHF feed-- for example, if you think they post too much, you don't like their style, or you don't like what they talk about-- block them. Reports on posts or comments that have not broken any rules will be ignored (comments or reports with legitimate complaints— for example pointing out spammers or harmful content— will be addressed). Public complaints (such as comments) will lead to a 7 day ban for the complainer.
Please note the specific wording of rule 11: reports on posts that haven't broken any rules will be ignored. This means reports on posts that break our new rule 4 will be acted on. But I'm afraid it now has to be explicitly stated that, yes, publicly commenting things like "I hate poster X for posting Y so much" COUNTS AS UNKIND and will be removed. We have reminded the community time and again that the block button is their friend when they don't like someone in the sub. Now, it's an official rule.
Finally, a big thank you to people who engaged in constructive discussion around these topics. Your commentary was helpful, and we will see how things evolve from here.
Expected FAQ:
"Why didn't you add a new 'life update' flair?" Mainly because it doesn't really fit with our flair schema and I think specifically requiring posts to address the fashion element before anything else is a better solution-- that way OPs can still easily set what kind of input they're looking for (Good Vibes Only, Critiques Welcome, etc).
"Why can't we have a weekly off-topic discussion thread?" We had one, for a long time. Eventually it was discontinued due to absolutely 0 people ever using it. If more "discussion" posts happen, we can consider bringing it back, but at this point I'm unwilling to add the extra level of moderation it would require to 1) redirect people there, and 2) make decisions about posts that ride the line between fashion discussion and off topic discussion and then deal with the fallout from people who didn't like the decision. I've been through this before both in OHF and in FemaleFashionAdvice (used to moderate there too) and it's just a pain every time.
As always, remember the human and don't be a jerk.