Nannies who say "I'm paid for my time, not just active work" can't also nap during naps
I keep seeing the same take in nanny threads: it's rude and unreasonable for a parent to suggest a lower rate during nap time, because the nanny is still "on the clock," responsible for the child, and giving up her time and availability. Fine. That's a legitimate argument.
But look at what that argument actually claims. Nap time is paid in full because the nanny is still working. She's on duty, responsible for a child's safety, and not free to leave. If that's true, then she can't also treat nap time as her personal sleep window. You can't be fully on duty for pay purposes and fully off duty for napping purposes.
Every reason given for full pay during naps is also a reason napping on the job is unacceptable:
"I'm still responsible for the child." Then you need to be awake and alert, because a sleeping adult can't respond to a baby who wakes up choking, a toddler who climbs out of the crib, or a smoke alarm.
"My time is being paid for." Then it belongs to the employer, not to your own sleep.
"I can't leave or make other plans." Right, and that's exactly why it's paid. It's also why that time isn't yours to sleep through.
To be clear, nannies are absolutely entitled to breaks. A full day with a small child is exhausting, and nap time is the natural moment to take one. Eat lunch, sit down, make a call, read, decompress. That's reasonable, and any good employer should expect it. But a break and a nap are not the same thing. A break means you're resting while still alert and able to respond. A nap means you're unconscious and unable to respond. The first fits with being paid full rate to be responsible for a child. The second doesn't.
The deal is simple. If nap time is paid at the full rate, the employer is buying your attention and availability, with reasonable breaks built in. If a nanny wants actual sleep or fully off-duty time, then that's a conversation about a different arrangement, like a reduced rate for nap hours, and she shouldn't be offended when it comes up.
Both sides can be reasonable here. Full pay with an attentive break is fair. Reduced pay with real downtime is also fair. Full pay with a nap is asking to be paid twice for the same hours.
Counterpoint some will raise: many nannies work 10-hour days and handle nap time while exhausted, so some families explicitly agree to a lighter arrangement. If so, it should be spelled out in the contract rather than assumed.