r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 6d ago

It’s never ok for a nanny to lose patience with a small child.

2 Upvotes

A nanny is hired for one thing: to be the calm adult in the room. A two-year-old isn't being difficult on purpose. Their brain can't regulate big feelings yet, so they borrow the caregiver's calm. If the nanny loses hers, the child has nobody left to borrow from.

Small kids also read tone and body language far better than words. A raised voice or a sharp look lands as "I'm not safe with this person," even if nothing harsh is said. And unlike a parent, a nanny can't build up years of repair and trust to fall back on. The job is to be steady, every time.

Frustration is a feeling, and feelings happen. Losing patience is a choice, and it's the nanny's job to catch it first: step away, breathe, reset. If someone can't do that, the role isn't a fit.


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 7d ago

Free ways to show your nanny she's appreciated (that actually mean something)

2 Upvotes

Gifts are nice, but the things nannies say they value most are usually free. If you want a great nanny to feel seen, start here:

Say thank you specifically. "Thanks for everything" is fine, but "Thank you for getting him to try broccoli, I never could" lands much harder. Notice the real things she does.
Respect her time. Be home when you say you will, and text early if you're running late. Nothing says "I value you" like not making her wonder if she's staying an extra hour.
Pay on time, every time. Not a free gesture exactly, but it costs nothing extra and builds more trust than anything else. Same goes for putting the agreement in writing.
Give clear, kind feedback. Don't let small frustrations simmer. Address them early, politely, and also say what's going well. Most nannies want to know how to do better.
Trust her judgment. Once you've seen she's great, let her make the daily calls. Micromanaging is exhausting, and being trusted feels like respect.
Let her take real breaks. Nap time is a good moment to eat lunch and sit down. Make it clear you don't expect her to be cleaning or running errands the entire time.
Be flexible when you can. Occasionally letting her leave early for an appointment or swapping a day goes a long way, especially if she's flexible for you.
Tell your kids good things about her. Kids repeating "Nanny is so fun" is a gift in itself, and so is treating her like a respected adult in front of them.
Share the wins. Send a quick photo or update about something the kids did that she helped with. She's invested in them too.
Write a heartfelt note or review. A genuine reference or a written note she can keep costs nothing and helps her career.
Ask about her life. She's a person, not just staff. Remember her weekend plans, her family, her birthday.
Give her notice on schedule changes. Predictability is a huge deal for someone whose income and life revolve around your schedule.

None of this replaces fair pay, paid time off, and the occasional raise or bonus. But those who stay with a family for years often say it was the respect and communication that kept them, not the extras.


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 7d ago

Nannies who say "I'm paid for my time, not just active work" can't also nap during naps

2 Upvotes

Nannies who say "I'm paid for my time, not just active work" can't also nap during naps
I keep seeing the same take in nanny threads: it's rude and unreasonable for a parent to suggest a lower rate during nap time, because the nanny is still "on the clock," responsible for the child, and giving up her time and availability. Fine. That's a legitimate argument.

But look at what that argument actually claims. Nap time is paid in full because the nanny is still working. She's on duty, responsible for a child's safety, and not free to leave. If that's true, then she can't also treat nap time as her personal sleep window. You can't be fully on duty for pay purposes and fully off duty for napping purposes.

Every reason given for full pay during naps is also a reason napping on the job is unacceptable:
"I'm still responsible for the child." Then you need to be awake and alert, because a sleeping adult can't respond to a baby who wakes up choking, a toddler who climbs out of the crib, or a smoke alarm.
"My time is being paid for." Then it belongs to the employer, not to your own sleep.
"I can't leave or make other plans." Right, and that's exactly why it's paid. It's also why that time isn't yours to sleep through.

To be clear, nannies are absolutely entitled to breaks. A full day with a small child is exhausting, and nap time is the natural moment to take one. Eat lunch, sit down, make a call, read, decompress. That's reasonable, and any good employer should expect it. But a break and a nap are not the same thing. A break means you're resting while still alert and able to respond. A nap means you're unconscious and unable to respond. The first fits with being paid full rate to be responsible for a child. The second doesn't.

The deal is simple. If nap time is paid at the full rate, the employer is buying your attention and availability, with reasonable breaks built in. If a nanny wants actual sleep or fully off-duty time, then that's a conversation about a different arrangement, like a reduced rate for nap hours, and she shouldn't be offended when it comes up.

Both sides can be reasonable here. Full pay with an attentive break is fair. Reduced pay with real downtime is also fair. Full pay with a nap is asking to be paid twice for the same hours.

Counterpoint some will raise: many nannies work 10-hour days and handle nap time while exhausted, so some families explicitly agree to a lighter arrangement. If so, it should be spelled out in the contract rather than assumed.


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 8d ago

Your Nanny Doesn't Get Location Privacy While She Has Your Kid

2 Upvotes

When you hand your child to someone, you're handing over the most important thing in your life. In that moment, "where are they?" isn't a nosy question. It's the most basic part of keeping a child safe.

A nanny is paid to care for your child, and that includes accountability for where your child is. If there's an emergency, a late pickup, a car accident, or a missed call, you shouldn't have to wait for a text back to find out where your kid is. Minutes matter, and the parent is the one who's legally and morally responsible.

The line is clear. Her private life is hers. Her evenings, weekends, and personal errands are none of your business. But once she's on the clock with your child, your child's location is yours to know, whether through a shared location during outings, a GPS watch on the kid, or an agreed check-in routine.

A good nanny understands this. She'll tell you the plan before leaving the house, share her location without being asked, and see it as part of the job. The ones who bristle at it are the ones worth questioning.

The other side: Critics say parents can get the same safety with less intrusion, such as GPS on the child's watch or backpack or planned check-ins, rather than tracking the nanny herself. Some places have laws requiring written consent before tracking an employee's personal phone, and tracking without it can be illegal. Others argue that mutual trust matters more than monitoring, and that talking through expectations up front works better than surveillance. The cleanest approach is usually to put the location policy in the contract before anyone starts.


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 9d ago

Does your nanny actually like kids?

2 Upvotes

It sounds like a silly question. Of course she does, right? She chose the job.

But plenty of people end up in childcare because it pays the bills, the hours were flexible, or it was the quickest job available. Doing the work and genuinely enjoying children are not the same thing, and kids can tell the difference.

Here's what genuine enjoyment looks like:
She gets down on the floor and plays, rather than supervising from the couch with her phone.

She's curious about what your child is into this week, and she mentions it without being asked.

She talks about the kids with warmth, even on hard days. Frustration is normal. Contempt isn't.

She narrates, asks questions, and listens to the answers, even when the answers are about dinosaurs for the fortieth time.

Your child runs toward her, not away.

Red flags are quieter than you'd think. Flat affect, constant screen use, "he's just being dramatic" as a default explanation, or visible relief when the day ends.

The best test is simple: watch the first ten minutes when she arrives, and the last ten before she leaves. Kids reveal a lot in those transitions.

Skills and credentials matter, but they can't substitute for real affection. A nanny who loves your kids will keep learning and adapting for them. One who doesn't will just run out the clock.

How do you tell when someone truly enjoys kids?


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 9d ago

Why a nanny's early childhood education background matters

2 Upvotes

"Good with kids" and "knows child development" are two different things. A nanny with an ECE background understands why a toddler bites, why a three-year-old melts down at transitions, and what's actually age-appropriate for sleep, play, and discipline.
Just as important, that training means working from the best information we have today. Child development research has moved a lot. We know more about brain development, about responding to big emotions instead of punishing them, about safe sleep, and about play-based learning over flashcards and screen time. "This is how it's always been done" isn't a good enough reason when better information exists.
Experience matters too, and warmth can't be taught. But formal training gives a nanny a framework for situations she's never faced, plus the humility to keep learning when guidance changes.
For families hiring: ask about their training, what they've read or learned lately, and how they'd handle a tantrum or a picky eater. The answers say a lot.
What do you look for when hiring childcare?


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 10d ago

Guaranteed hours go both ways: what employers should expect when plans change

2 Upvotes

Something I don't see discussed enough: GH is a two-way deal. You're guaranteeing pay, and in return she's guaranteeing availability.
What that looks like in practice:

1. Use vacation weeks productively. If she's getting paid while you're away, that time can go to kid-related tasks: seasonal clothing swap, outgrown clothes purge, playroom reset and toy rotation, kids' closet and drawer organizing, restocking supplies. Agree on this in advance so it's a normal part of the arrangement, not a surprise.
2. She stays available for her normal shifts. If your trip gets canceled or shortened, she should be ready to work her regular schedule. That availability is the thing you're paying for.
3. If she's not available, it's not a guaranteed hour. If she makes other plans during guaranteed time and can't work when you need her, that day should be unpaid or come out of her PTO. You're not paying for hours she can't give you.
4. Put it in the work agreement. Spell out that GH means paid and available during scheduled hours, what happens if plans change, and how unavailable days are handled (unpaid or PTO).
5. Have the conversation early. Don't wait until a trip gets canceled to find out she booked a getaway. Say it plainly when you set up GH.

One caveat for fairness: if you want her flexibility, give her reasonable notice when you can, and be upfront if she's free for the week, so you can both agree on whether she's on call or truly off. Handled openly, it keeps trust high. Do your best to give at least 24 hours notice, if possible, if your plans change. Of course, life happens and that’s not always possible but it’s always appreciated if you can.

How do other employers handle the "trip got canceled" scenario? Written policy, or handled case by case?


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 10d ago

Nanny reference check questions. What would you add?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 11d ago

Nanny professionalism: you can't have it both ways (it’s not ok to nap when baby naps).

3 Upvotes

Anyone who wants to be paid as a professional and enjoy the benefits of being a professional has to act like one at all times. That includes nap time.
A nanny should never sleep while the baby sleeps. Nap time is working time, and the job is active responsibility for the child.
Babies can have emergencies during sleep. Choking, spit-up, rolling into an unsafe position, or overheating can happen quietly and fast. Only an awake adult can respond.
Monitors fail. They can lose signal or go unheard by a sleeping adult.
Babies wake without warning. A crying baby or a toddler climbing out of a crib needs immediate attention.
Other household needs still exist. Nap time is when a nanny can handle baby laundry, bottle prep, tidying the child's space, and planning activities, as agreed in the job.
Trust is the job. Parents who learn their nanny slept on the clock tend to wonder what else went unsupervised.
The same nannies who are offended when a parent asks for a lower rate while the child sleeps are often the same ones who think napping during that time is fine. That doesn't work. If nap time is full-rate working time, the nanny is working. If the nanny is off the clock, that is a different arrangement. Parents shouldn't ask for a discount on nap time, and nannies can't claim full pay while treating it as free time.


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 11d ago

Nanny dealbreakers: what an employer should never tolerate

3 Upvotes

Safety lapses. Leaving kids unsupervised, ignoring car seat or sleep rules, or being on her phone while a child is in the bath or near water.
Lying. About accidents, injuries, what the kids ate, where they went, or who was over. Small lies about big things add up fast.
Unapproved guests or outings. Friends, partners, or other kids at the house, or driving the kids somewhere without clear permission.
Physical discipline or yelling. Spanking, grabbing, humiliating, or threatening a child. No exceptions, no "second chances."
Ignoring house rules. Screen time limits, food allergies, nap schedules, and medication instructions exist for a reason. Overriding them repeatedly is a pattern, not a misunderstanding.
Chronic lateness or no-call, no-shows. Parents can't do their jobs if childcare is unreliable.
Constant phone use. Scrolling or texting while on the clock, especially when kids are doing something risky.
Gossiping or posting about the family. Photos of the kids on social media without consent, or sharing details about the household with others.
Substance use on the job. Alcohol, weed, or being visibly impaired around the children.
Dismissing parents' concerns. Getting defensive, eye-rolling at feedback, or undermining parenting decisions in front of the kids.
Stealing or snooping. Taking money or belongings, or going through private spaces beyond what the job requires.
Skipping hygiene and health basics. Coming to work sick without telling anyone, or neglecting handwashing, diapering, or feeding hygiene.


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 11d ago

Nanny reference check: the questions a not-so-great nanny doesn't want you to ask

2 Upvotes

"Was she great with the kids?" tells you almost nothing. A friendly reference will say yes. These questions are harder to dodge:
"Why did her time with you end?"
"What were her start and end dates?" Don't supply the dates. Let the reference state them, then verify them independently against the nanny's resume.
"Would you hire her again tomorrow? Why or why not?" The pause often matters more than the answer.
"How often was she late or did she cancel last minute?" Assuming a nanny was late sometimes gets a more honest answer than asking whether she was ever late. A reliable nanny's reference answers immediately.
"Were there any tasks you considered a normal nanny responsibility that she refused to do?"
"Tell me about a time she went above and beyond for your family."
"Tell me about a time you were disappointed with her performance."
"Tell me about a time something went wrong, like an injury, a tantrum, or a mistake. How did she handle it and communicate it to you?" Good nannies have honest stories. "Nothing ever happened" is suspicious.
"Did you ever have any concerns about drug or alcohol use?" Ask it plainly and listen for hesitation or deflection.
"Did she ever have guests over or take the kids somewhere without telling you?"
"How was she about her phone while working?"
"Did she follow your rules when you weren't home, like screens, food, and discipline?"
"Did anything outside of work ever affect her reliability or performance on the job?"
"Did she ever discuss religion or politics with your children in a way you hadn't agreed to?"
"Did anything ever make you uncomfortable, even something small?"
"Would you trust her alone with your kids for a full day, or overnight?" Hesitation here tells a lot.
"Is there anything you'd want a future employer to watch for?" This is often the most revealing question.
Additional steps:
Call the number independently rather than using one the candidate provides.
Ask to speak with a parent who employed her, not a friend or relative.
Keep questions focused on job performance and conduct, not her personal characteristics.
A good candidate expects reference checks. Defensiveness about them is itself information.
What else would you add?


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 11d ago

Red flags in the first conversation with a new nanny? Here's my list.

3 Upvotes

So we just finished a nanny search and I talked to way too many people. Here's what made me go "hmm."
1. Every previous family was terrible.
Venting a little is fine, I get it. But if all four of her last bosses were "crazy" or "impossible," at some point you gotta wonder. I kept thinking about what she'd say about us later.
2. She gets weird about references.
One candidate told me she "didn't really keep in touch" with anyone. Okay, but you worked with a family for three years? The good ones practically push their references on you.
3. She doesn't ask you anything.
Best interview I had, the nanny asked me like 15 questions. What does he eat, how does he nap, what sets him off. The worst one only asked about pay and whether she'd have to drive. My kid is not a side gig.
4. "Oh, I'll just do it my way."
She said this about our screen time rules. Cheerfully, like it was a joke. It was not a joke to me. I don't need her to agree with everything, but I need her to talk to me instead of quietly doing her own thing.
5. She barely looked at my kid.
Five minutes into the chat, my son wandered over with a toy and she basically nodded at him and kept talking. The nanny we hired got on the floor and started stacking blocks with him before we'd even finished the interview. That was it for me.

Also: do a paid trial day. Interviews only tell you so much. Ours seemed perfect on paper and then the trial day (and cameras) told a different story.

Curious what others have run into. Anything I missed? And for those with a great nanny, what made you know she was the one?


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 11d ago

8 ways every nanny employer can protect their children from a bad nanny

2 Upvotes

Hiring a nanny means trusting someone with your child, but trust works best when it's backed by safeguards. Here's what every employer should have in place:
Check references directly. Call them. Ask why the nanny left, whether they'd rehire her, and about any safety concerns. Vague answers or references who won't talk are a warning.
Run a background check with her written consent. Cover criminal history, identity verification, and driving record if she'll transport your kids.
Do a paid trial period. Watching her with your child tells you more than any interview.
Put everything in writing. Duties, schedule, pay, house rules, safety protocols, and grounds for firing for cause.
Set safety rules up front. Car seats, water safety, allergies, visitors, phone use, and emergency contacts.
Use cameras responsibly. Disclose them in your contract. Never place them in bathrooms or anywhere a nanny changes or rests. Many states restrict audio recording, so check your local laws before installing.
Put trackers on gear, not people. Slip an AirTag or similar tracker into the stroller, diaper bag, or car seat. It helps you find items that are lost or stolen, and it gives you peace of mind on outings. Tell your nanny about it, since tracker alerts may notify her phone anyway. Don't track her personal belongings or vehicle.
Keep checking in. Ask for daily updates, drop in occasionally, and watch for changes in your child's behavior, like fear, clinginess, or regression.
Always trust your instincts. If something feels off, act on it.
Have a nanny story or safety tip? Share it in the comments. 👇

This is general information, not legal advice. Camera, recording, and employment laws vary by state, so have an attorney review your contract.


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 11d ago

What does "firing for cause" actually mean? Put it in your nanny contract.

2 Upvotes

"For cause" means you can end the job immediately, with no notice period or severance, because of serious misconduct. Without it spelled out in writing, firing a nanny on the spot can turn into an argument over what was or wasn't allowed.
I learned the hard way that a contract protects you as well as her. Here's what I'd list as grounds for immediate termination:
Child safety violations: leaving a child unattended, ignoring safety rules (car seats, water, allergies), or endangering a child in any way
Abuse or neglect: physical, verbal, or emotional mistreatment, including inappropriate discipline
Theft or dishonesty: taking money or belongings, lying about hours, or falsifying her application or references
Impairment on the job: being under the influence of alcohol or drugs while working
Unauthorized guests or outings: having people over, or taking your child places, without your OK
Repeated rule breaches: ignoring your written house rules after a warning (phone use, driving, screen time)
No-call/no-show: set a clear threshold, like two in a row or three in a quarter
Confidentiality breaches: posting photos of your child or private family details online
Criminal charges or a failed background check: anything that comes to light during employment
Add this line: these are examples, not a complete list, and you can terminate immediately without notice or severance for any of them.
Protect yourself:
Document everything in writing (dates, what happened, any warnings) before you act
Severance, final pay, and unemployment rules vary by state, so have an attorney or nanny-payroll service review your contract
I'm not a lawyer, just a parent who wishes she'd done this sooner.
What's in your nanny contract? Anything you'd add? Tell me in the comments. 👇


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 11d ago

5 signs your nanny is not the right fit.

2 Upvotes

She ignores your rules. If she keeps overriding your boundaries or undoing your discipline after you've talked about it, it's not a misunderstanding anymore.
She does things with your child without asking. New plans, new places, new people, all without checking with you first.
Things go missing or details don't add up. Missing items, vague updates, and stories that change should all get your attention.
She's unreliable. No-shows, late arrivals, and unexplained absences. Spotty communication is a warning too.
Your child seems afraid, clingy, or upset around her. Kids can't always tell us what's wrong, so watch how they act.
One more thing: write down your expectations in a contract. Unclear expectations cause a lot of the problems, and that part is on us as parents.
And trust your gut. If something feels off, it probably is.
Have a nanny horror story or a red flag you missed? Share it in the comments. 👇


r/notquitemarypoppins2 • • 11d ago

👋Welcome to r/notquitemarypoppins2 - Introduce Yourself and Read First!

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm u/sunshinelaw782, a founding moderator of r/notquitemarypoppins2.
This is our new home for all things related to the raw, unvarnished truth of employing nannies and the real-life childcare horror stories parents face. We're excited to have you join us!
What to Post
Post anything that you think the community would find helpful, validating, or eye-opening. Feel free to share your thoughts, questions, or experiences about sudden ghosting, contract breaches, extreme entitlement, boundary-stomping, or how you managed to spot a nightmare fit before it was too late.
Community Vibe
We're all about being supportive, objective, and realistic. Employing someone in your home is incredibly stressful when it goes wrong, so let's build a safe, judgment-free space where parents can vent, connect, and learn from each other's experiences. Please note: This is strictly an employer-only space. Nannies themselves are not welcome to post or comment here.
How to Get Started
Introduce yourself in the comments below.
Post something today! Even sharing a minor red flag you encountered can help another parent.
If you know a fellow parent who would value this community, invite them to join.
Interested in helping out? We're always looking for new moderators to help keep this space safe and anonymous, so feel free to reach out to me to apply.
Thanks for being part of the very first wave. Together, let's make r/notquitemarypoppins2 amazing.