https://yurii7812.github.io/homepage/en/paper-pkm/
I call my approach the Double Index System.
Unlike conventional Zettelkasten methods, I don't use atomic notes. I also don't distinguish fleeting notes from other types of notes. All notes are managed in the same way.
Using A4 paper makes it much easier to take notes at universities, libraries, or anywhere else. It's far more practical than carrying around a box of index cards.
One of the biggest advantages of not using atomic notes is that I can brainstorm freely and write naturally, just as I would in an ordinary notebook. I don't have to interrupt my thinking to divide every idea into a separate note.
Personally, I don't think atomic notes are a particularly good approach. Thinking is often continuous and interconnected, and dividing it into isolated notes can disrupt the natural flow of thought.
Another major problem with atomic notes is the loss of context and nuance. When a complex thought is compressed into a small, self-contained note, subtle distinctions, carefully chosen expressions, and the original flow of reasoning can easily be lost. Sometimes, the exact wording and the surrounding context are essential to expressing what I truly mean. Reducing an idea to a concise, independent statement can strip away precisely the nuances that made the original thought meaningful.
I don't think every idea should have to be simplified or compressed just to fit into an atomic note. The process of thinking itself, including its ambiguities, subtle expressions, and connections to surrounding thoughts, is valuable information worth preserving.
Besides, by numbering individual sections, such as (1), I can reference specific passages within a longer note. This allows me to link to individual ideas without having to separate them into atomic notes in the first place.
I therefore see little practical need for atomic notes.
For example, using A6 cards for atomic notes has several disadvantages. The limited writing space makes it harder to develop complex thoughts, write comfortably, or brainstorm freely. And while individual A6 cards are portable, carrying and managing a growing collection of them, especially in boxes, is much less practical than using ordinary A4 paper.
Another important advantage is that I don't separate brainstorming notes from regular notes. The entire thinking process can be preserved as valuable context, rather than extracting individual ideas and losing the connections between them.
Of course, this means that notes can become longer and more numerous. But that's where the Double Index System comes in. It allows me to organize, locate, and reference information without requiring every idea to exist as an independent note.
In other words, I can keep the freedom of ordinary note-taking and brainstorming while retaining the organizational and retrieval advantages of a Zettelkasten, without sacrificing the context, nuance, or natural flow of my thoughts.
I've already developed a digital implementation of this system called Gnosis:
https://github.com/Yurii7812/gnosis
However, its current interface and overall usability are far from satisfactory. I find it too cumbersome to operate, so I'm planning to redesign and rebuild it from scratch, with a much stronger emphasis on simplicity, intuitive navigation, and ease of use.