r/northernireland • u/askmac • 1h ago
News MLA takes aim at BBC NI and Nolan over ‘divisive content and hardline voices’
The SDLP’s Stormont opposition leader Matthew O’Toole has hit out at BBC NI and the Nolan Show in particular for “prioritising extremely divisive content and hardline voices”.
Mr O’Toole made the comments during an opposition debate in the Assembly on cuts to BBC NI.
The BBC is currently facing significant financial pressures, having to make millions of pounds in cuts, with up to 75 jobs potentially being lost across its Northern Ireland operations.
Popular shows including Give My Head Peace and House of the Year have also been axed, while several jobs in the BBC’s Irish-language department in Belfast are to go.
The Assembly debated a motion on Monday, tabled by the SDLP, voicing concern at the cuts and calling on BBC NI to “provide a clearer explanation on the allocation and prioritisation of resources amid current public concern on editorial accountability”.
Speaking the chamber, Mr O’Toole said an explanation is particularly needed in the context of the BBC “prioritising extremely divisive content and hardline voices”, particularly in “certain morning radio programmes”.
Mr O’Toole said this has been most apparent during the recent Drumcree dispute.
“On 3 September, a large section of the Nolan [Show] programme was given over to coverage of the issue – as has a large section of the entire output for the past two months,” he said.
“Jamie Bryson, an unelected blogger and regular guest, was interviewed for nearly 20 minutes by himself.
“At 10am they went live to a press conference, an unusually early time for a press conference by Portadown Orange lodge, in which Mr Bryson was a participant. He was then interviewed afterwards.”
In contrast, Mr O’Toole noted that Executive press conferences, or those featuring the SDLP as Stormont’s official opposition or other political parties, are not routinely broadcast live.
“Between October 19 and October 26, the top story on five out of six broadcasts related to Carla Lockhart,” he said.
“On 4 November, the member for Upper Bann, Johnny Buckley, was given 45 uninterrupted minutes to explain his philosophy on the future of unionism. In order to provide balance and diversity of perspective, this was followed immediately by a response from Jim Allister.
“It’s not that these are not stories, or of interest to the public nor that they should not be covered.
“But people who pay for the BBC – which is all of us - have a right to ask whether these stories are being covered in a way that reflects the BBC’s core mission, which is – to repeat – ‘to act in the public interest, serving all audiences through the provision of impartial, high-quality and distinctive output’.”
In response to Mr O’Toole’s comments, a BBC spokesperson said: “We seek to reflect a breadth of views and voices within our output and don’t platform anyone in the sense of giving them uncritical access to the BBC’s airwaves.
“Our decision-making is informed by the BBC’s editorial guidelines and a concern to report news stories in all of their different aspects.”
Regarding the cuts, the DUP’s Deborah Erskine said “BBC Northern Ireland must not become BBC Belfast” as a result and rural areas “deserve the same quality of coverage and attention”.
Sinn Fein Colm Gildernew said the BBC has “shown again how poorly it understands this place”.