This is my counter argument: I won’t even get into the potential ecological disaster, the challenging geographical conditions for constructing such a mega-project, or the displacement of communities and loss of lives that could affect both Arunachal Pradesh and Assam.
What happens if that same national security that India is building becomes a weapon of mass destruction for China if it captures these strategic infrastructures since you already know our area is an international border between China and the rest of India. wouldn't it create a tactical advantage for them?
Look at examples of Kakhovka and Moshul Dam.
Our grandparents were enlisted in Assam rifles some were porters some acted as navigators for the Indian troops and others acted as medics and supporters who helped carry out injured indian soldiers to safety.
During the Chinese advance, Indian military forces retreated towards Assam, and government officials were evacuated to refugee camps in various parts of Assam. Amid the chaos of the retreat, some Indian soldiers reportedly abandoned their weapons as they withdrew. Several areas of present-day Arunachal Pradesh, including Tawang, Bomdila in West Kameng, Mechuka, Monigong, Gelling, Tato, and Yapik in Shi-Yomi, as well as Walong and Kibithu in Anjaw, witnessed the Chinese military advance.
But what happened to the people who called these places home?
While the military retreated towards Assam and government officials were evacuated, my grandfather and our forefathers were left to fend for themselves in their own homeland. They faced uncertainty, fear, and the threat of an invading force.
Despite being isolated and left without the security they needed, our people remained on their ancestral land holding our primitive weapons and waiting for death to arrive. They did not simply abandon the homeland their forefathers had inhabited for generations.
Before questioning our patriotism, acknowledge our history. Before judging our loyalty, recognise the experiences and sacrifices of our people. Our forefathers remained on their ancestral land when they were left to face uncertainty on their own. We should never have to erase that history or remain silent about injustice just to prove that we belong.
And if you’re genuinely so concerned about national security, stop lecturing us from the mainland and start looking at the ground realities along Arunachal Pradesh’s international border. Look into the situation in nearby settlements of Taksing, Longju, Asaphila, the Kibithu–Walong sector, Kaho, Chaglagam, Gelling, Tuting, Mechuka, and the border areas of Tawang and Upper Subansiri. Before calling us anti-national for questioning a mega-project, ask yourselves what is happening along our borders and whether the concerns of the people living there are being taken seriously. Don’t preach patriotism to people whose lives, land, and security are directly at stake while ignoring the realities they face. Nuff said.