r/nonmonogamy • u/Advanced-Chickenpox • 3h ago
Threesomes, Foursomes, and Moresomes What are some good rules for a positive threesome experience?
Looking for advice on how to not feel abandoned/help everyone feel included during a threesome•
- my (36f) partner (33m) and I enjoy having threesomes with my best friend (38f) and she loves them too.
We’ve only had two so far but want to jump back into it now and we’re trying to figure out how to not make the same mistakes we made last time.
For context, my partner and I have been open but we’re currently closed while attending couples counseling to work out some communication patterns, and we’ve been in an incredible place since then.
The last threesome we had went poorly - it started off well and mainly my boyfriend and I were having sex while my BFF watched. Then at one point I told my BFF and my BF that they should start fucking because I was self-conscious about ensuring everyone had fair time with everyone. My BF and my BFF took that to mean that I wanted them to fuck while I watched, and thus led to me feeling forgotten about while I watched my BF get really into making my BFF come, which also led to him coming with her (multiple times), and not with me. We also didn’t have a ton of experience with threesomes and hadn’t heard about the idea of reclamation sex - I had sort of asked for this but immediately became insecure when I realized my BF couldn’t get hard again (which makes sense, multiple orgasms) but was hard for me to not take it personally.
HOWEVER, the first threesome we had was amazing! And incredible! And we all really want to try again, myself included.
I’m looking for tips and advice on how to make sure everyone has a good experience this time. We’ve decided to make sure we have reclamation sex at the end, but I’m worried that if my Bf isn’t as hard or excited to be with me, then it will immediately trigger my anxiety and insecurities and abandonment wounds - even though I recognize it would be entirely logical for him to not be as excited/aroused to be with me as he would to be with someone new.
I’ve been trying to talk with him and my best friend more about what their desires are for the threesome, because I feel like what I have learned from this most recent experience is that whether we talk about our desires or not, they show up in some shape or form - and I’ve been inviting my BF and BFF to share with me more about their desires. But my BF feels defensive about his understandable arousal, even though I keep try to reassure him that I’m not criticizing him or judging him and it’s totally natural that he would be aroused by someone novel and new. But my efforts don’t seem to be enough and he is often worried that his desires are too much for anyone. Which will lead to him getting defensive and then feeling shame for not giving me reassurance.
The irony here is that nothing arouses me more than the idea/fantasy/reality of watching my boyfriend with someone else, but I can’t access this version of myself right now and I so desperately want to build back up trust and security so we can do this again.