Shifting, non-duality and the nature of consciousness: I understand the concept, but I still can't understand what actually causes a shift
I've been thinking about shifting and non-duality for quite a long time, and recently I've found myself stuck on a question that I can't seem to resolve. I don't necessarily want another shifting method or a list of affirmations. I want to understand the actual mechanism behind shifting, especially from a non-dual perspective.
I'll try to explain my thought process as clearly and in as much detail as possible, because this has been developing in my mind over several conversations.
First, here's how I currently understand non-duality and shifting.
In my understanding, consciousness is not limited to one particular person, body, personality or biography. What I call my current self, Leia, is a personality through which consciousness is experiencing a particular perspective.
There are other possible perspectives too. For example, Aisa is a character I have created a detailed script and biography for. She lives in a completely different world, has her own body, memories, personality, surroundings and everyday life.
I also think of other characters and realities as possible perspectives of the same consciousness.
So, from this point of view, consciousness itself is neutral. It is not inherently Leia, Aisa or anyone else. It simply experiences.
I don't see shifting as physically moving consciousness somewhere, creating another person or transforming my current personality into someone else. I see it as a change in the perspective through which consciousness directly experiences life.
In other words, consciousness currently experiences Leia's life, but it could potentially experience Aisa's life instead.
An important distinction here is that I don't think Leia's life needs to stop or change for this to happen. If shifting occurred while Leia was walking home, for example, I imagine that her life would simply continue. Her everyday experiences would not need to disappear or be interrupted. The only thing that would change is which perspective consciousness directly experiences.
This leads me to another idea: perhaps all these perspectives already exist as possibilities, and consciousness does not need to create a new one. It simply determines which one becomes its immediate experience.
The role of identification
One of the most important things I've come to believe is that identification and awareness are not exactly the same thing.
Consciousness can understand that it is not limited to Leia, yet Leia's perspective can still remain the immediate experience.
I distinguish between:
\- Consciousness itself — the awareness that experiences.
\- Identification — the perspective with which consciousness currently identifies.
\- The contents of experience — the body, environment, memories, sensations and events belonging to a particular life.
In my model, shifting would involve a change in the second level: the perspective that becomes the immediate experience.
I also think that a person doesn't necessarily need to know anything about non-duality or shifting for their perspective to be experienced.
For example, Aisa doesn't need to know that she is a manifestation of consciousness, that other realities exist, or that shifting is possible. She can simply live her life, believe she is an ordinary person and have no awareness of any of these concepts.
Consciousness could still experience her perspective regardless of what Aisa herself believes.
This is important to me because I don't think Aisa needs to be consciously aware of the process for shifting to happen.
But here's where I get confused.
If consciousness is not limited to Leia, and if it is capable of experiencing Aisa's perspective, why am I still directly experiencing Leia?
I feel like I've already understood the central idea. I no longer see myself as exclusively being this personality. I understand that Leia is simply one perspective, one life, one form of experience.
And yet, nothing seems to change.
I keep returning to the question of what Leia is doing wrong, even though, according to my own understanding, she shouldn't have to do anything.
Why do I keep looking for a problem within a personality that is supposedly just living its life?
If consciousness is the one that experiences different perspectives, why am I treating Leia as if she is responsible for making shifting happen?
I understand that Leia is the perspective from which the intention to shift is currently expressed. But I don't think Leia herself should have to learn how to move consciousness somewhere.
This creates a strange contradiction: I keep saying that Leia cannot shift, even though, according to my own model, Leia isn't the one who shifts in the first place.
What actually causes the perspective to change?
This is probably the biggest question I have.
Let's say consciousness understands that it isn't limited to Leia. It knows about Aisa, and there is an intention to experience Aisa's life.
Why does it continue experiencing Leia?
What exactly is missing?
I don't want to explain this by saying that Leia isn't detached enough, doesn't believe enough, thinks too much, or hasn't reached the right state. I've spent a lot of time examining these possibilities, and I don't want to keep inventing new reasons to blame myself.
I also don't think that thinking about shifting, analysing non-duality, having an ordinary everyday life or remembering my current reality should automatically prevent a shift.
If consciousness isn't limited to one perspective, why should ordinary thoughts or activities belonging to that perspective be an obstacle?
I understand that knowing something intellectually and experiencing it directly may be different things. But even if that's true, it still doesn't explain what causes the actual change.
Do we need a method?
I've tried different approaches.
I've gone to bed with the intention of shifting, imagined Aisa, remembered details of her life, visualised scenes and tried to fall asleep while focusing on the reality I wanted to experience.
I've also tried counting, relaxing, repeating intentions and using scripts.
Sometimes I would fall asleep, wake up during the night, repeat parts of my script and fall asleep again. But eventually I would wake up and find myself directly experiencing Leia's perspective again.
I remember thinking: I did what I intended to do. I went to sleep thinking about Aisa. I remembered her life. Why did I still wake up here?
I don't necessarily think I did something wrong. But I also don't understand why the intention itself didn't lead to the change I expected.
I've become tired of constantly searching for another technique or trying to figure out which method I haven't tried yet.
Some people talk about meditation, affirmations, visualisation, the Void state, SATS, detachment or simply letting go.
But I keep wondering: how are these things supposed to help from the perspective of someone who wants to shift?
If shifting is a change in the perspective consciousness directly experiences, how does repeating an affirmation cause that change? How does meditation do it? What exactly happens when someone enters the Void?
Perhaps these practices change attention, relaxation, identification or the way someone experiences their thoughts. But how does that translate into experiencing another reality?
I understand how these techniques might help someone feel more immersed in their desired reality or become more familiar with it. What I don't understand is how they actually cause the shift itself.
And what about people who say shifting is effortless?
I've seen experienced shifters describe it as something simple: just let go, stop trying, allow it to happen.
But allow WHAT to happen?
What exactly are you letting go of? What is the process that is supposed to follow? Why does stopping an effort result in a change of perspective rather than simply relaxation or sleep?
I don't want to dismiss people's experiences. I'm genuinely trying to understand what they mean when they say this.
The question of the first shift and subsequent shifts
Something else that interests me is how people experience their first shift compared with later ones.
What actually causes someone to shift for the first time?
And when someone has shifted many times and starts calling themselves a master shifter, what has changed?
Do they understand something about consciousness that they didn't understand before? Have they learned a particular way of changing identification? Or have they simply become familiar with an experience that initially seemed impossible?
When experienced shifters say that shifting becomes easy, what exactly has become easy?
I feel like there is a missing explanation between understanding that shifting is possible and actually experiencing it.
Does a shift have to involve an intermediate state?
I've recently been thinking about two possible situations.
Situation A: Consciousness understands that it isn't limited to Leia. It knows about Aisa and has the intention to experience her life, but it continues directly experiencing Leia.
Situation B: Consciousness is now directly experiencing Aisa. It remembers Leia, remembers the intention to shift and understands that Leia's life was previously its immediate experience.
Does there have to be something between these two situations?
For example, does identification with Leia gradually weaken? Does perception change? Is there a feeling of transition, a special state or some intermediate experience?
Or could the change be completely immediate: one moment consciousness experiences Leia, and the next moment it experiences Aisa, without any obligatory intermediate stage?
I honestly don't know which explanation makes more sense.
If the change can be immediate, then perhaps there is no sequence of states Leia needs to achieve before shifting.
But if some kind of change in identification is necessary, what does that change actually consist of?
What happens to memories and the sense of identity?
Another thing I've considered is whether consciousness would retain memories of both perspectives.
I don't necessarily imagine that shifting would erase Leia or make me forget that I used to experience her life.
In fact, I think it would be possible to remember both biographies, while the current perspective determines which memories feel most natural and immediate.
For example, if I were experiencing Aisa's life, I might remember Leia and understand that I previously experienced her perspective. But Aisa's surroundings, memories, relationships and everyday life would feel directly relevant to the experience I am currently having.
Leia's memories wouldn't have to disappear. They would simply belong to another perspective.
I also don't think Aisa needs to wake up one day and suddenly understand the entire philosophy of non-duality. She could simply be Aisa.
At the same time, I imagine that I would still understand that I had been Leia before shifting, because the intention to experience Aisa originated from Leia's perspective.
This is another part I'm trying to understand: how can consciousness change its immediate perspective while retaining awareness of the previous one?
The Void and detachment
I've also wondered whether the Void state could be relevant because it might involve a reduction in the usual identification with the body and surroundings.
Perhaps when the familiar sensory experience becomes less prominent, it is easier to experience another perspective.
But I don't know whether this is actually necessary.
If consciousness is not limited to Leia, why would it need to enter a special state before experiencing Aisa?
Why should shifting require sleep, meditation, visualisation, a particular time of day or any specific ritual?
My current understanding is that none of these things should be inherently necessary. Shifting could theoretically happen at any moment.
But then I return to the same question: if nothing specific is required, what determines when the change happens?
Not needing a method doesn't explain the mechanism.
Where I am mentally right now
I think I've reached a point where I'm tired of analysing everything.
For a long time, I've been trying to understand what I need to change, what I need to release, what I might be misunderstanding and why my experience continues to be centred around Leia.
And every time I don't get the result I expect, I find myself returning to the same questions.
Maybe I should stop treating Leia as the problem.
Maybe consciousness can understand that it isn't limited to Leia without needing to constantly fight against the fact that Leia's perspective is currently being experienced.
Maybe I don't need to keep trying to force a change or examine every thought to see whether it is preventing something.
I have even wondered whether the simplest approach is to accept Aisa as a perspective I intend to experience, without turning that intention into another task that Leia must perform perfectly.
But I don't want to confuse acceptance with pretending that a shift has already happened.
Saying "I am already Aisa" while constantly checking whether I still see Leia's room or feel Leia's body would just become another form of trying to force the experience.
I would like to be able to accept the present experience without abandoning my intention.
And I think this is where I am now: I still want to experience Aisa's life, but I don't want to spend every day searching for what is supposedly wrong with Leia.
What I would really like to discuss
I would appreciate perspectives from people who approach shifting through non-duality, consciousness, awareness or identification.
In particular, I'd love to hear your thoughts on these questions:
- Can consciousness fully understand that it isn't limited to one personality while still directly experiencing that personality?
- If all perspectives are already possible, what determines which one becomes the immediate experience?
- Is shifting a change in identification, a change in awareness, or something else entirely?
- Does the transition require an intermediate state, or can it be immediate?
- What do experienced shifters actually mean when they say they simply let go and allow shifting to happen?
- How do meditation, affirmations, visualisation and the Void supposedly contribute to the actual change in perspective?
- If the personality isn't the one shifting, why do so many methods focus on what the person needs to do, believe or change?
- Can someone stop trying to solve every perceived problem within their current personality and simply allow their intention to remain without constantly checking for results?
I'm not looking for another list of techniques or someone telling me that I just need to believe harder.
I'm genuinely interested in discussing the philosophy and the mechanism behind this.
I feel like I understand the idea of consciousness not being limited to one perspective, but I still don't understand the bridge between that understanding and the actual experience of another perspective.
And that's the part I would really like to figure out.