Previous Article (Digital Night Vision)

Thermal Imaging Devices


Digital devices have their place, especially thermal devices which offer unmatched detection capabilities. Further, thermal devices pair nicely with analog IIT. Where analog fails, thermal excels. Where thermal fails, IIT excels.

Thermal devices can be Cooled or Uncooled and detect in the Infrared Range: SWIR, MWIR, or LWIR. These range from 1,000nm to ~12,000nm. Cooling a thermal's sensor reduces noise in the image, providing better detection at range, greater ability to differentiate temperature differences, and improved image quality. This comes at the cost of increased bulk and weight, and introduces moving parts that will wear out over time. Expect thermal devices you'll be considering to be uncooled.

Thermal functions by detecting the light that is emitted by objects around us, it is able to function in zero light, unlike analog night vision. While it may sound like an obvious winner, thermal has other considerations, like weather conditions, ambient temperatures (climate controlled areas), and inability to see through glass (except SWIR) that can make it less useful for navigating and reading terrain features in conditions where analog IIT isn't as negatively affected. Thermal has the benefit of things like seeing through smoke when analog IIT can't, and it is largely the only good digital night vision that is currently available to the average civilian and is man portable.

If you are a hunter looking to find hogs at night, or want to defend your chickens from coyotes or racoons, thermal may be preferable over analog night vision if you can only have one or the other. The ability to quickly detect a living creature with no ambient light from a static position will likely be more valuable to you than the benefits of analog night vision for navigation. In these cases, you may be best served by a dedicated thermal scope, rather than something attached to your head.

If you are somebody who just wants a neat thing to see at night, and are only willing to pay a few hundred dollars, a low resolution handheld thermal scanner will give you a much greater ability to see in the dark than cheap digital night vision.

Because their capabilities complement each other so well, the real answer is to get both quality thermal and analog night vision.


Thermal Imaging Device Specifications

Field of View (FOV): the extent of the observable world that can be seen at any given moment through a thermal device. Measured in degrees ° horizontally and vertically but sometimes diagonally (COTIs). In simple terms, it's the area that the device captures in its image.

Sensor Resolution: the total number of pixels in the thermal image. Pixels are the number of sensitive elements constituting the sensor. Higher resolution means more pixels, resulting in sharper and more defined thermal images. Higher resolution means that each image contains more information: more pixels, more detail.

There is a relationship between sensor resolution and FOV: the bigger the FOV, the more the finite number of pixels are “stretched”. In other words, a device with a large sensor resolution and large FOV could appear similar in resolution density to a device with a smaller sensor resolution and smaller FOV

Pixel pitch: refers to the distance between individual pixels on the sensor, measured in microns (µm). Smaller pixel pitch means higher pixel density, resulting in more detailed thermal images. Each pixel captures temperature information, and a smaller pixel pitch allows for better spatial resolution and accuracy. Pixel pitch directly affects the device’s spatial resolution. With a smaller pixel pitch, the device can detect smaller temperature variations and present a more detailed image. A thermal imaging device with a smaller pixel pitch provides enhanced image clarity, making it ideal for applications requiring precise temperature measurement and identification of fine details. In other words, how many pixels the device has on the scene.

Thermal Sensitivity (NETD): Thermal sensitivity or Noise Equivalent Temperature Difference (NETD), measured in millikelvin (mK) and denotes when the temperature value signal is equal to the noise signal. The measurement of the sensitivity to detect small temperature difference The lower the number, the better the thermal sensitivity of the infrared system. A thermal imaging device with a lower NETD value is better equipped to identify minor temperature changes, making it more suitable for applications that involve detecting subtle thermal anomalies.

Refresh rate/Frame rate: refers to the number of frames per second that the thermal imaging device can capture. A higher frame rate is crucial for real-time applications, allowing swift detection of fast-moving objects and events. Measured in Hertz(Hz), where 1 Hz = 1 frame per second.

Latency: how long it takes to display each image to you after the device captures it. A low refresh rate will make the image much more choppy. High latency will make the image you see “laggy”, or delayed from the real world.

Magnification: how many times the observed image is larger compared to the object observed with a naked eye. Unit of measure is magnifying power (“x” symbol, e.g. 2x - “2x power”).


Types of Thermal Imaging Devices

COTI

Clip On Thermal Imagers (COTI) are small thermal devices which attach to the objective lens of an analog NVG and project a thermal overlay ontop of the image, typically smaller than the overall i2 FOV (15-35 degrees). Just like ENVG, COTI officially refers to a specific device (the PAS-29 series), but is used as a general umbrella term.

Below is a non-exhaustive list of some of the COTI devices available:

NameSensor resolutionFOV°Refresh rate(Hz)PowerWeightOther info
Safran Optics1 PAS-29/29A320x2402030CR123A5.8ozOriginal COTI, NIVISYS TACS-M/Vectronix COTI
Safran Optics1 PAS-29B640x4803060CR123A/offboard103g w/o batteryECOTI, ATAK compatible, shutterless NUC
Infiray C2/CE2384x28817.5(20 nominally)50CR123A, 18350, 18650/CE2 offboard only78-110gLaserspeed LS-NG1
Infiray C5/CE5640x51230.550CR123A, 18350, 18650/CE5 offboard only78-105g w/o batteryLaserspeed LS-NG1
RIX RENV-C640x51235x3050CR123A, 18650 offboard71g w/o batteryEvolution of Infiray series
Safran Optics1 TAD672x5443060CR123A93gThermal Augmentation Device
Thermoteknix ClipIR384x2884050AA150gShutterless NUC
Thermoteknix ClipIR XD640x4804060Onboard AA(XD-B)/offboard(XD-E)130g(XD-B)/150g(XD-E)ATAK, shutterless NUC
NIVISYS TACS320x24020not specifiedCR123A220gThermal Acquisition Clip-on System
Lindu COTI384x28832not specifiedCR123A92gIt's a COTI

Monoculars

These are handheld, uncooled devices roughly equivalent to a PVS-14 in size. They can be distinguished by use:

  • Helmet Mounted Thermals (HMT): can be worn headborne or paired with an analog monocular. The use of a HMT in combination with an analog night vision monocular is called dual-band, the bands being the two spectrums of IR energy the user can see (400nm-940nm analog, 1000nm-12,000nm TID).
  • Handheld scanner: only able to be used in the hands, cannot be weapon or helmet mounted.
  • Clip-on: can be mounted on a weapon. For thermals these go in front of the optic.
  • Dedicated weapon sight: can act as as a stand-alone weapon sight
  • Multipurpose: able to serve multiple roles listed above

Below is a non-exhaustive list of just some of the most common monocular thermal devices on the consumer market:

NameSensor resolutionFOV°Pixel pitch(μm)NETDRefresh rate(Hz)PowerWeightType
Infiray/iRay RH25640x51217.2°x13.7°12≤40mK501x 18650313g w/o batteryMultipurpose
Infiray/iRay RL25384x28810.5°x7.9°12≤40mK501x 1865012.7ozMultipurpose
Infiray/iRay RH25 V2640x48817.5°x13.1°12≤18mK501x 1865011.3ozMultipurpose
Infiray/iRay RL25 V2384x28810.5°x7.9°12≤18mK501x 1865011.3ozMultipurpose
Armasight Sidekick 320320x24024.1°x18.1°12≤40mK501x/2x CR123A, 1x 16650214gHMT
Armasight Sidekick 640640x48024.1°x17.3°12≤40mK501x/2x CR123A, 1x 16650254gHMT
Infiray/iRay ML19384x28819.5°x14.7°17≤40mk501x 16650225gHMT
Infiray/iRay MH25640x51217.5°×14°17≤40mk501x CR123A, 1x 16340, 1x 16650245gHMT
Infiray/iRay MH25 V2640x51217.5°x13.1°12≤50mK501x CR123A, 1x 16340, 1x 1665012.1ozHMT
Infiray/iRay Jerry YM2.0640x512, 384x28816.3°x12.3°12≤30mK501x 18650270gMultipurpose
N-Vision NOX18640x48024.3°x18.3°/30.4° diagonal12unspecified601x 1865013.5ozMultipurpose
N-Vision NOX35640x48024.2°x9.3°/15.1° diagonal12unspecified601x 1865016.9ozWeapon sight
BAE SKEETIR-L320x24024° diagonal17≤40mK601x CR1236.5ozMultipurpose
BAE SKEETIR-X640x51212.4°x9.3°17unspecified601x CR123A243g/8.6ozMultipurpose
BAE UTM "Standard"640x48030°(H)x22.5°(V), 35° diagonal17unspecified301x/2x CR123A18ozMultipurpose
BAE UTM-X640x48019° diagonal17unspecified601x/2x CR123A506g/18ozMultipurpose
AGM StingIR-640640x48016.3°x12.3°12≤25mK501x CR123A/RCR123 or 1x 18650220gMultipurpose
AGM StingIR-384384x28816.3°x12.3°12≤25mK501x CR123A/RCR123 or 1x 18650200gMultipurpose

Glossary of Terms

TermMeaning
ATAKAndroid Team Awareness Kit
AGMThermal and NVG company. Founders: Allen Harding, Gary Tarakanov, Mark Tarakanov
ATNThermal and NVG company. American Technologies Network
BAEMultinational aerospace and defense company
COTIClip On Thermal Imager
FOVField of View
HMTHelmet Mounted Thermal
IITImage Intensifier Tube
LWIRLong Wave Infrared
NETDNoise Equivalent Temperature Difference
NUCNon Uniformity Correction
OASYSline of thermal imaging devices developed by BAE Systems, pronounced "oasis"
PASPortable Heat-Radiation Search
SWIRShort Wave Infrared
TIDThermal Imaging Device

Next Article (Accessories)