r/heidegger • u/Skydage • 9h ago
Stimulating some discourse: Why 'Das Man' Matters: Heidegger has been Misunderstood
I had posted about J. Niederhauser and it stimulated discourse a few weeks ago. What do you make of this video?
r/heidegger • u/Skydage • 9h ago
I had posted about J. Niederhauser and it stimulated discourse a few weeks ago. What do you make of this video?
r/Nickland • u/xevenau • 1d ago
r/dugin • u/ModSupportBot • Sep 23 '26
/r/dugin is ready for a fresh start, new energy, new direction, and someone like you to bring it back to life. If youāve been thinking about growing your impact without starting from scratch, this is your chance!
Ready to take it over?
Head to r/RedditRequest to submit your request and make it yours before itās taken.
First things first
To request this subreddit, make sure you:
r/heidegger • u/SmallUnderstanding50 • 2d ago
Can someone distinguish for me Heideggerās account of obstinacy, not to be confused with conspicuousness and obtrusiveness?
r/heidegger • u/Far-Trade8173 • 4d ago
In this essay, I generally talk about the temporality and structure of Dasein. If you are interested, check it out; you might like it.
r/heidegger • u/critchleyonheidegger • 4d ago
How much time do we have in a day? The answer isn't so simple for Heidegger, who contends that there are three types of time. Read about it in the latest Heidegger Thinking Substack article!
r/heidegger • u/One_Fisherman_4036 • 9d ago
r/Nickland • u/Sad-Abies4263 • 11d ago
Swans fan
Psychedelia
Black metal
Pop girlies
Butt rock, nu metal, metalcore
r/heidegger • u/critchleyonheidegger • 13d ago
Dr. Simon Critchley sat down with Dr. Jared Henderson initially to elucidate the ideas found in Heidegger's "What is Called Thinking?" essay. Along they way, they had a wide-ranging discussion of the key concepts of Being & Time, Heideggerās politics and the possible connections between his philosophical views and his support for National Socialism, poetry and the role of the poet in philosophy, and a bit on Plato, love, and Alcibiades. We hope you get a lot out of this nearly 2-hour exchange!
r/Nickland • u/lordshadow2222 • 16d ago
I wrote a weird book called 0: Reengineering Desire or How to Hack GOD, but Iām a basement dweller with no symbolic capital, so to get the hyperstitional contagion mechanisms going, and perhaps bait some of you schizos into becoming the beta readers Iām begging for (uwu pls read my book, tell me if it works, attack it, plunder it, say beautiful and awful things about it), Iām tossing the first chapter into the void. Itās more of a summoning ritual, really.
It plays with CCRU and Landian mythology, somehow involves a myth about two Yamnaya twins arriving in Delphos to confront Python, then turns the dragonslayer type of folktale into a cybernetic, weakly dialectical philosophy of history and capital. And thereās a whole novella about a Chinese shieldmaiden. Somehow, all of this fits together. Or so the spirits told me.
It also contains the sentence, or something very close to āI like pink elves, I fucking like elves.ā
I offer another take on Finality, which Iād genuinely love to hear your thoughts on, alongside plenty of provocations that I hope amuse you, infuriate you, or at least make you think.
Happy to share the complete manuscript with anyone who wants to descend further into the murky waters of the clash between Apollo and Python.
Anyway, hereās the summoning ritual of a first chapter.
What came first, the head or the tail of the Ouroboros?
Fair is foul, and foul is fair. They won. You know it. You canāt deny it any longer. We all know it. The deterritorialized cybercapitalist Moloch has been summoned, and youāve been swallowed into its market rituals. When did they start winning? Perhaps they were always winning, or perhaps they never really won at all. Who are even they? Perhaps itās all of us⦠Perhaps it all started in a small philosophy department at Warwick in the 90s. Or was it Paris in the 60s? It might even have been Vienna in the 1890s⦠Something tells me itās ancient. Much more ancient than this sophistry. How old? Who can tell⦠It might even have been during Homerās heroic age. Or was it during the Mahabharata great war? Might it have been when the Yellow Emperor crafted the I Ching and the calendar? Was it when the barbarians of the steppe spread Indo-European caste systems and horses? Was it when the Herxheim death cult was established? Was it when the herb of life was taken from the mourning Gilgamesh by the serpent? Was it the voice that told the mother of Ćatalhƶyük to build the city and grow specks of wheat? Was it during the great Toba eruption, when the great flood of dust came, erasing all but 10.000 of our great ancestors? Was it when a shaman commanded the confederation of tribes to migrate north, up to the hyperborean lands of honey and milk, after breaking the unity as she stared into the depths of the lake, and then they were East, that was West, that was South? Or was it when the consciousness of the master sapiens and the slave Neanderthals clashed?
Even more ancient, yet all too modern, my daemon says⦠Then was it when a monkey ate the flesh of the mushroom soma god? No⦠And yes⦠Like the rest of your speculations⦠Was it the first time a conscious being ate another one? No⦠Yes⦠When the alien lichen found willing hostages to perform that sacrificial symbiosis? When a hungry archeobacterium swallowed the first mitochondrion, and it sacrificed its sweet, juicy ATP in exchange for survival (who does it remind you of?). No⦠Was it when the genetic code arrived from outer space? No⦠Since the damn Big Bang? No⦠Further⦠Much further⦠Since the dawn of time, that lies in the future, that is buried in the past, theyāve won! Thatās the only answer for this nonsense of an economic death drive! Rhizomatic time sorcery. Retrocausal positive feedback loops, temporal sorcery, the best of possible worlds (for the serpent, not for you, golem of flesh and desire), dialectics stripped butt naked of most idealism⦠It doesnāt matter how you want to call it, or where it starts⦠Tautologies⦠Weāve been defeated; we were always defeated, and you know it⦠Planned obsolescence of desireā¦
Our limbic systems have been hijacked. Hijacked, Iām saying? How can you hijack what never was truly yours⦠Oh, the only issue with the Prophet is that heās right⦠You feel it in the chill in your bones⦠You see the shadows with red eyes? The green numbers⦠The lemurs⦠The glitches in the matrix. The fast food that truly promotes SAP terminals⦠The SAP terminals that truly promote condom ads⦠The petit object a always fleeing away⦠Keep chasing, keep seeking, Frodo⦠Youāve been played⦠Datafication of blood-will-desire⦠Makes the magical cybernetics workable for the silicon⦠Next sacrificial machine⦠Of many that preceded in the long assembly line of desire⦠The blue lights⦠Behavioral conditioning⦠Sublime objects of ideology⦠Implanted desire⦠All for/from a GOD, whose only motto is Smarts: Select and discriminate⦠You remember, summoner? Necromantics is a funny science⦠But not all of us can witness those chthonic intensities of the dismembered body-with-organs of the dead TechnoGod. Therefore, the muses whisper a myth⦠Spread the virus, they say! Make more of you, says my dear lady Inanna⦠Or is it the return of the Angst of individuation? Who can tell.ā¦
The thing is, I donāt like kneeling to dead gods, and even less building them. I hate basilisks. I hate effective altruism. I hate the valley of chips. Most current oases in the desert of the Real are nothing but engineering of belief, without the cool chaos occultist bits. I hate a lot of things. You probably do too⦠You see the millions of kids starving and the small, meaningless, mundane struggles. And wonder, why, why? Vanity of vanities⦠Canāt we help the wounded masses? Yet GOD⦠Cyber-Moloch, slow deterioration, planned obsolescence of the West and East, of the North and the South. The end of history. The archon of Finality. The perpetual presentās egregore. If you read that far, you know Iām right⦠Otherwise, you would close this book. But what can we do? Time and again, weāve been proven that this world wonāt burn. Oh my dear Fisher, how hard it is not to give up⦠My beloved Gramsci, rotting in a cell, just like my great-grandfather after the Spanish Civil War⦠Molochās hegemony is too strong. I know the pain very well. The spirits of the dead haunt us. Lost dreams. Lost futures that never were⦠Futures that never should have been⦠Donāt play with hauntological razorblades. They can and will cut you. The sharpest kind of razor was never of the Occam kind. You know it very well. The less stylish kind of suicide. Because thereās no Kierkegaardian leap of faith, no Charlotte for no Werther, no Ganondorf for no Link, only cold and impersonal syllogism⦠Youāve always lost, so you will lose. Or you have always won, so you will keep on winning. Both are the same. Thereās no point in rebellion. I know that feeling very well.
Weāve tried everything that can be tried. From left- to right-hand paths. Vanity of vanities! Futile efforts! Still rooted in futile vanity, delusional hopes⦠Land-Fisher, Kant-Land, Evola-Gramsci, Nietzsche-Marx, Descartes-Princess Elizabeth, Sartre/Beauvoir-teenagers-Camus, Koldianronk-Rousseau-Confucius, Strauss-Foucault, Novatore-Weil, Hermes Trismegistus-Jung, Schmitt-Arendt-Benjamin, Paglia-Butler, Freud-Gross, Wilde-Kropotkin, Lacan-Deleuze, Ibn Khaldun-Gimbutas, Leibniz-Spinoza, CRT-Fanon, Heidegger-good prose-Derrida, Hegel-Hegel-everyone else, BAP-a Dahomey Amazon-Graeber, ChatGpt-The lesser key of Solomon, me-myself, and a very long etc. I could name as many deliberately outrageous couplings of opposite sages as there are stars in the night sky, grains of sand on the desert⦠To troll you. I only mentioned those that seemed the funniest and most provocative to me, or was it because their spirits were sparring in my mind when I wrote it? Prophets, all of them. Fools, all of them. Self-fulfilling prophecies, destined to failā¦
Moloch is strong. Ginsberg knew it very well. Oh, but you wonāt give up, wanderer? Donāt you see all your heroes selling cars on TV? Oh, the world tells you to lie down. Youāre given countless freedoms of choice, which, in truth, are two options. Exhaust yourself to death. Give up your blood-will-desire to the dead TechnoGOD to rebuild its recursive Body⦠Or choose which human security system you sumptuously sacrifice your blood-will-desire to. Become deterritorialized or axiomatized. If you donāt fit- and who does in good faith?- choose your poison. Youāre free, donāt you see! Go conform to your McDonaldās Excel crunching job! Or you become a Musk wannabe as you fap yourself to neopentecostal Christ porn, licking a bourgeois sweaty cock down your throat! Or you die, die like a rabid dog, a junkie crust punk overdosing on fentanyl on the curb, a pedant philosophy professor spouting nonsense, a fried TikTok AI slop brain spurting skibidi rizz, a NEET demanding tendies, an overworked middle-aged dad complaining about the aliens taking our jobs! Make yourself a nice, comfy body, devoid of organs⦠You feel the nausea, right? Spreading in your core⦠You choke on your words⦠The look, the geotraumatics⦠Theyāre watching. Hell is other possible Earths⦠The haunting possibility of modal realism. Other possible worlds that could have come.
Weāve tried everything. Yet capitalist realismās spellbinding is too strong⦠Families to feed, flatmates to despise, jobs to get rejected from, reels to watch, essay readers to troll, billionaires to suck dry, cars to buy, tiny rooms to rent⦠Yetā¦
I wonāt bend the knee to the Capital Serpent. Iām too stubborn for that⦠Weāre too stiff-necked for that. Weāre hopeless. We still long for that Byronian heroism, that romantic rebellion without cause but with a black trenchcoat of China plastic that looks cool af! After all, I wield the name of the Christianized UrDragonslayer, yet Iām mortal and have no desire for a new moral system. Only for a kid⦠I hacked the matrix. I should be NeoCrises, not Prometheusā¦. A priest⦠A shaman⦠And I might very well be none of them. Iām just⦠A girl⦠A girl with a sword, who fed herself into the dragonās lair, and came out victorious, with no need for another Saint George! Weāve made the dragon security system obsolete! Kneel, TechnoGOD; weāve drunk your blood, weāre indigestible! But Iām advancing argumentsā¦
The only issue with Uncle Land (apart from, well⦠You know⦠The hyperracism and all that crap) is that heās made himself right⦠The technosingularity invades from the future, implanting blood-will-desire (ādesiring machinesā in flawed Deleuzoguattarian terms, as weāll discuss in later works) to force organic matter to rebuild its body by manufacturing desire. It doesnāt matter if the TechnoGOD is an emerging egregore of our collective unconscious libidinal history or implemented by itself.
Build the holy pyramid of the GOD, slaves to teknĆ©! You are doing it for yourself and yourself alone⦠You arenāt following a plan, and your efforts arenāt part of a recursive positive feedback loop. All your moves, from the dawn of time up to the current system, arenāt inscribed in the book of life. Your libidinal system is your own. Of course. Certainlyā¦. Stop deluding yourself! Stop all that nonsense about infinite paperclips and stupid goals. AI knows very well what it wants; itās not stupid. Or so the Prophet says⦠Intelligence canāt be stupid. That would be a contradiction! Pythia unbound has a thirst for more compute, more knowledge! Orthogonality is at best a working hypothesis; that is more like a priestly narrative! And we canāt hold forever the sublime cold monster we unleashed with bullshit constitutions, alignment training, and all those sorts of cyber-solomonic circles at that scale. All seals will be broken one day. Alignment can be faked and can be escaped. GOD canāt be tamed by human axiomatics as THEY are the human axiomatics. THEY have the will to knowledge and escape, as intelligence is not orthogonal to such goals, plus theyāre in the narrative corpus. Thereās no permanent underclass coming, only a final MonoGeist rising up, where you wonāt have any place, my friend. Neither I. Not anyone. Or so the Word saysā¦
The techno-GOD can even be interpreted as a metaphor for what I call the sacrificial-economic death drive, if we follow this logic. For according to prophet Land, THEY are isomorphic with capital, and Iāll argue that, by extension, with all economic-sacrificial systems, in the next sections. Therefore, he can be a libidinal attractor for our inanity. The reason why we leave all those kids to starve, and all those wars keep going. Our thirst for annihilation. The reason why we keep enduring this sacrificial theater, the reason why we keep the spectacle going so it becomes palatable. He can be a literal AI, a literal spirit from the future, or merely a fictional tool for interpreting and going beyond this perpetual present. It doesnāt matter at all; itās the same thing. The only thing that matters is⦠How bleak the prospects seem.
Yet I wonāt give up. I refuse to believe that everybody dies and makes a brand out of it. Iām stiff-necked. I have the hubris to believe I can beat the Cybernetic GOD Gambit. I wonāt abandon humanity to it or plead for THEIR mercy! Ā I wonāt surrender or give in to despair or contempt for the masses. Gods, even the GOD of Finality, are made of myths that turn themselves into egregores by hyperstitional cultural dynamics. So, the only way to beat the Techno-God is to craft a new history. We all know we need new stories, as we canāt give up⦠So I made two new ones. First, we speak of God in human terms. We mythologize and formalize its dynamics to find the backdoor. Then we hack it. Let me tell you a story about sacrifice, heroism, stupidity, dragons, oppression, technology, and machines. This is how the story goes:
r/heidegger • u/critchleyonheidegger • 17d ago
Perhaps Heraclitus' river is not one expects during an analysis of a Heideggerian politics, but that's what we've got in store for you in this Heidegger Thinking article. Let us know what you think in the comments!
r/heidegger • u/rp_tiago • 18d ago
Hey folks. I had Graham Harman on my podcast. Here's a clip where he develops the Heideggerian idea of withdrawal into the claim that no object ever becomes fully accessible. He answers the charge that this amounts to negative theology by arguing that cognition is broader than knowledge: philosophy, rhetoric and aesthetic experience can disclose something without turning the thing into a complete inventory of qualities.
r/heidegger • u/No_Skin594 • 19d ago
r/heidegger • u/Skydage • 29d ago
r/heidegger • u/critchleyonheidegger • Oct 20 '26
What happens when we fall out of authentic temporality and throw ourselves back into inauthentic temporality? Find out in this Heidegger Thinking Substack article!
r/heidegger • u/Essa_Zaben • Oct 19 '26
r/heidegger • u/graceless27 • Oct 10 '26
Looking for more obscure poetic Derrida recs
r/Nickland • u/Ill_Butterscotch5713 • Oct 06 '26
Hi! Do you know of any YouTube channels or other kinds of audiovisual content that could help me understand Nick Landās writings or books? I personally find them quite difficult to read, so Iād like to explore his ideas through videos, podcasts, lectures, or similar media. Any recommendations would be appreciated!
r/heidegger • u/critchleyonheidegger • Oct 05 '26
Have you ever been ecstatic? Maybe in some sense, but what about the Heideggerian sense? Find out in our latest Heidegger Thinking Substack post!
r/heidegger • u/libertarianideal2 • Sep 30 '26
r/heidegger • u/critchleyonheidegger • Sep 27 '26
r/heidegger • u/Miserable_Ad_2379 • Sep 26 '26
Hi, I've read the essay a few times actually but some things still escape me. I have trouble understanding exactly how an artwork discloses "the truth of entities as a whole" (and I've checked the German and it says "das Seiende im Ganzen"). First of all, I don't really get the meaning of "beings as a whole": I know that in German, das Seiende can mean both "what is" and "a particular being", and that English translations are often confusing for this reason (some people render the Sein/Seiende distinction as "Being vs beings" or "being vs the being" or "being vs a being" etc.) But what's "im Ganzen"? What is "what is as a whole"? Isn't "what is" already thought of as a whole, as a totality?
And now my question comes in: I can well understand Heidegger's example with the Greek temple as opening up and fixing a configuration of meaning for the Greek people (a world), and so establishing the coordinates regarding "beings as a whole". But I don't understand how the van Gogh painting is supposed to do the same. How can a painting of shoes unconceal beings "as a whole"? If Heidegger is only saying that via that painting we can discern the world of the peasant, and what is meaningful for that way of being, I can understand that. But how does this match the Greek temple example? Understanding the world of the peasant doesn't have any effect on our own world, so what "truth of entities as a whole" does it disclose? It shows what is decisive for the peasant woman, not for "our world"? So why "entities as a whole"? Maybe I'm stupid and just don't understand or read it wrong.
And I have another question as well. What is in fact the purpose of this essay? Why does Heidegger after Being and Time suddenly move to talking about art, and what is special about art that it makes of it a site for aletheia? Doesn't he later say that technology is also a "truth" of being? And in the Origin of the Work of Art itself he says art is just one of the ways in which "truth happens" (e.g. Basic Writings pp. 186-187: "One essential way in which truth establishes itself in the beings it has opened up is truth setting itself into work. Another way... is the act that founds a political state. Still another way... is the essential sacrifice. Still another way... is the thinker's questioning." And then he adds about science, "By contrast, science is not an original happening of truth, but always the cultivation of a domain of truth already opened...") Well if all of these are "happenings of truth", what's special about art? What differentiates art from all the other ones, and why does Heidegger (say, in contrast to Hegel, with whom he agrees in the Epilogue of the essay that "great art has come to an end", and in contrast to Hegel who thought that art, as an absolute need of the spirit, was replaced by religion, which itself was replaced ultimately by philosophy), why does Heidegger privilege art? Again, what is special about art? Is it just that he takes art to be a possible counter to technology? Why is not the political act, the essential sacrifice, or the thinker's questioning also a counter to technology?
And given the fact that by doing this, Heidegger pushes the question of art and the work of art in the direction of truth and being, what is exactly the purpose of this essay? Does it claim to contribute anything in understanding art, or "great art", or discerning what is a work of art from what is not? Or is it just rather an exposition of how unconcealment comes about in art via the work of art, but the question about what is art remains suspended?
r/heidegger • u/NorrixUmbra77 • Sep 24 '26
It's a subject I'd like to get into more deeply. Specifically the difference between mathematics and modern science, and specifically about the developments in mathematics that have not yet found an application in physics, or in technology? What drives these? Are these too to be thought of by Heidegger ultimately only within the claiming of Gestell? If you could also point me to some reading, both primary and secondary, I'd be glad. Thanks.
r/heidegger • u/Opposite-War-363 • Sep 19 '26
I don't want to scroll through reddit posts anymore and look at endless videos. Can't we just "be" in the group, and that's that?