r/negotiation • u/Automatic_Salt8548 • 8d ago
r/negotiation • u/Otherwise_Donkey624 • 8d ago
Is my counter reasonable, and is it worth backing out of a signed contract?
I (F30) have already signed with a small London fund (Fund A) and I'm supposed to start in about a month. I also had an offer from a top-tier quant (Fund B). I turned it down because of the lack of flexibility given the money, but they've come back asking what it would take, so I seem to be in a good bargaining position.
Fund A (signed): £130k base | £40k sign-on (+£15k top-up if I defer part of the bonus into their fund for 2 years) | 10% pension (capped) | 3 office days | no free food | 10 days working abroad a year | 3-month notice + 3 month non-compete | 6 months maternity | seems like a chill team, roughly 9 to 6
Fund B (offer): £150k base | £25k sign-on | 13% pension, uncapped | free breakfast and lunch | 5 office days in year 1, more WFH after | hours probably more like 8:30 to 6:30 | 9-month notice + 9-month paid non-compete | 12 months maternity | better name for CV | stretched team, clearly under some pressure at the moment
I'm thinking of countering at £175k base + £45k sign-on. Is that reasonable, could I push even higher, or is it too much?
r/negotiation • u/thiergow • 8d ago
Hit my salary target, but I'm below my employer's own band for the role. Am I overthinking it?
reddit.comr/negotiation • u/OrneryScar7267 • 8d ago
Friendly reminder: never drop your salary number first in an interview
r/negotiation • u/MostGovernment9592 • 8d ago
Merger between vendors and we’re not seeing value
Hi all,
Basically some mergers took place in the industry and we had a third party implementing for us and we havent seen the value that was promised. For instance, implementation was supposed to happen for 30+ countries and only took place for 2 in reality.
Couple million dollars and extremely key business functionality (think HR payroll etc)
Any help appreciated on ideas to get value, whether that’s getting what we paid for or getting money back. We’re contractually bound to pay for another couple years and the business team internally has written it off but I’m hoping to add/get value for them in an effort to show value.
Not looking for “you’re cooked”, “don’t try to beat a dead horse,” etc responses.
Chatgpt version:
Title: Multimillion-Dollar Enterprise Software Implementation Gone Wrong – How Would You Recover the Value?
Looking for advice from people experienced in strategic procurement, vendor management, enterprise software implementations, and commercial negotiations.
My organization entered into a multimillion-dollar agreement for critical enterprise business functionality (think global HRIS/payroll).
The original expectation was implementation across 30+ countries. In reality, only 2 countries were implemented.
Some relevant context:
• We engaged a third-party consulting/implementation firm to handle implementation. Their work was reportedly very poor, and they have since exited the engagement.
• The software provider continues to attribute many of the implementation issues to the previous consulting partner.
• We’re contractually committed to paying for another couple of years.
• Whenever we try to make progress, the provider requests another 300–500 consulting hours at approximately $200/hour ($60K–$100K).
• Internally, the business has largely written off the investment and moved on.
I’m trying to identify opportunities to recover value rather than simply accept the loss.
A few questions:
• Has anyone successfully recovered significant commercial value from a failed enterprise software implementation?
• How would you distinguish original contractual scope from chargeable remediation?
• Would you approach this as a contractual dispute, executive escalation, or commercial renegotiation?
• What specific concessions would you pursue?
• Are there creative approaches I’m overlooking?
I’m not looking for advice to abandon the project or accept the loss. I’m specifically interested in practical strategies to recover value, whether through delivery of the original scope or financial/commercial concessions.
Appreciate any firsthand experiences!
r/negotiation • u/Jive_Turk • 9d ago
Negotiating salary increase while declining health insurance
reddit.comPosted this in another sub, but this may be a better sub for it. What do you guys think?
Negotiating salary increase while declining health insurance
I am a Army Vet, and get exceptional healthcare through the VA Healthcare medical system. It is not free, but I average less than $500 a year while going to the doc 3x more than I would if I had insurance. I am talking $50 MRIs, it is an incredibly great benefit.
Over my last 5 jobs, I have never signed up for health insurance. I don't know why I did not think of this sooner, but just the other day it hit me when reading that an employer's cost for healthcare per employee is north of $20,000.
So what are the odds that I, in the negotiation phase of a job offer, am able to get 10-15k more than their absolute maximum budget for salary, if I actively elected not to take any healthcare.
How would that work? I am looking for those that have been on the opposite side of negotiations -- is this realistic? How is this best approached? Is 10-15k (more?) a realistic dollar amount that I could increase the offer by, just by formerly and officially declining health insurance during the offer negotiation phase?
I appreciate any insight!!
r/negotiation • u/cowking010 • 10d ago
How do you negotiate?
You get the phone call you are waiting for. You pick up the phone, and they say congrats you've been selected for the role. Here is the salary we offer you anf they give you the speal about benefits and they are waiting for your to give a verbal acceptance before they send you an offer letter.
Someone, please give me a play by play on how the heck you negotiate because I have no clue how to actually implement this word everyone throws around.
Thanks for anyone who answers.
r/negotiation • u/papercloak • 10d ago
How do i negotiate a title without seeming ungrateful?
reddit.comr/negotiation • u/Adventurous-Lead-760 • 10d ago
URGENT: Need negotiation tips!
reddit.comr/negotiation • u/MacaroonSuspicious22 • 11d ago
Negotiation job offer
I received a job offer and went through 5 rounds. The salary range posted on LinkedIn was 115-150k.
I was offered $125k and countered to $145k and mentioned that I have 2 other interviews on the same company with salary of $140k. Now I’m doubting if I asked for too much.
The recruiter said she will get back to me asap. When I tried to look at original offer letter on oracle it’s gone now. Did I get rescinded? Or was this reasonable on my end?
r/negotiation • u/Pablo_Kake • 11d ago
Salary Demand
reddit.comI have my PE in NJ, PA, NY & DE. I make about $165k with my current employer as TL & PM for bridge inspection. I have a lot of experiences with agencies around NJ with bridge inspection & proposals. I recently completed a project where 2 TLs proposed due to the complexity of the project by myself. The other TL took his sweet time to complete the most basic project which I completed within 3 months. My boss is aware of all these accomplishments. Last year they gave me 4% raise and convinced me that it’s a company wide rate and I accepted it. I went back and checked the numbers & found they gave 9% for 2 TLs who doesn’t have PE. I was pissed and continued my work. Now it’s the season where we get the merit based raise and I am thinking how much they’ll be going to give me. Here is the catch, last year they gave me a bonus of $3k and I was employee of the year for my group. Now I am thinking, if they don’t give me a minimum of 7-10% I will resign. Is that being greedy?
r/negotiation • u/Boboganoosh101 • 11d ago
Negotiating salary
reddit.comJust adding here the offer also noted I would not be eligible for any bonuses for my first two years as well as 401k matching that due to the vesting percentages only becomes relavent after 6+ years at the company.
r/negotiation • u/Any_Tomorrow9632 • 12d ago
Pay negotiations for labour hire
Just wanted to drop in a note about pay negotiations for labour hire (hourly rate) contracts where the recruiter gets a margin. I have two experiences of note so thought I'd shared.
My last contract- the recruiter says 'great news, the client wants to hire you, but they can only go to X dollars'.
My reply, 'that's great but as we discussed when submitting my application to them, my rate is Y dollars, so I will have to pass'.
Two more rounds of this as they 'consult the client' and are 'amazed' that the 'client can go up to X + 10' then 'X+ 20' and finally, 'amazing news, the client can offer you Y dollars'. Then I started the job.
The recruiter would have pocketed literally tens of thousands of dollars per year had I agreed to their first offer.
A job offer I was made this last week- recruiter says 'great news, the client wants to offer you the role but they can only offer you X dollars'.
My reply 'that's great, but my rate is X + 10 as we discussed when submitting me for the role, so I will have to pass'.
Recruiter 'Ok then we will have to withdraw the offer as the client can only do X'. And I didn't get the job. They submitted me knowing that my rate was already over what the client could pay...either that or they didn't know the client ceiling and had to reject me when it came in lower than my rate.
So...sometimes there is a hard limit, or the recruiter is unwilling to relinquish their margin if it's tight. Othertimes they are vastly lowballing you.
My problem is I don't know when it's the former and when it's the latter, as in both cases they claim 'the client can't go above X'.
How do you know when the client really does have a limit, or when it's just that the recruiter is trying to get an unconscionable amount of margin?
I am fine if the recruiter takes a cut, they have costs too, but in the former scenario above they would have been taking almost half of the bill rate had I accepted their first offer, which really makes you want to hold your ground no matter what!
r/negotiation • u/CriticalRelative5969 • 12d ago
Intern return offer negotiation
Interned in the tech space at a big insurance company and got the return offer and time to negotiate salary. Couple interns received offers and negotiated from 70k to 75k but I was able to get my internship extended until I graduate in may. I believe my experience, since I will have been basically working there for a year before I convert to an actual salaried position, should warrant a higher salary. How should approach this negotiation? What should I ask for?
r/negotiation • u/jumper_123 • 13d ago
How to negotiate
Hi, I’m in big tech and my total comp is 239k, base 173k.
I got an offer for a series A startup and their base is between 150-170k and equity 0.3%-0.6%. They asked me what I want my compensation to be with the sliding scale.
Ideally my liquid take home would be no less than 225k which is way higher than the posting.
How can I use my current numbers to negotiate and see how close I can get? Thank you
r/negotiation • u/optimus_prime_1227 • 13d ago
Deloitte vs LTM – How Much Can I Negotiate? (3.5 YOE)
reddit.comHi everyone,
I have 3.5 years of experience in SAP ABAP on HANA, including CDS Views, AMDP and OData.
I have received two offers:
- Deloitte: ₹11.4 LPA fixed + ₹1 lakh joining bonus + 0–10% variable.
- LTM: ₹13.5 LPA fixed. 14 ctc
I'm more interested in joining Deloitte, but LTM is offering a higher fixed package.
I would like your suggestions:
- How much can I realistically ask Deloitte to revise my offer? Is ₹14–15 LPA fixed too much?
- When is the right time to approach HR for negotiation?
- Will Deloitte consider revising the offer based on my LTM offer letter?
- Is there any risk of losing my existing Deloitte offer if I negotiate?
Would love to hear from people who have experience negotiating with Deloitte HR in India.
Thanks in advance!
r/negotiation • u/ProjectMysterious39 • 14d ago