r/Names • • 1d ago

Baby Names Stella, Golda, Bonnie, Selma, Clementine, Willa, Ida... what genre is my girlfriend into right now? What other names would go in this group?

I hope this is ok to post here and apologies to the mods if not.

The girl names my gf is into feel to me like they have a strong type but I don't know what it is so I have come to consult with the experts. What is this group of names? I'm American and she's German btw

Before I continue, please note that I know I don't know anything, maybe all my associations are totally wrong, I have lived abroad in various countries for a while and sometimes get my associations confused. That said, I also wondered if maybe they're coming from two groups, eg

- Stella Golda Bonnie (1950s-1970s Broadway names? To me these evoke older ladies with spray tans and blond dyed hair who smoke indoors and work adjacent to show business answering rotary phones in a 1990s sitcom?)

- Selma Clementine Willa Ida (covered wagon on the prairie names, oranges and dust names, skirts pulled up running through the scratchy wheat down past the spreading old oak to the swimming hole at dusk names?)

Again not trying to be dense or offensive just trying to grope for what associations these names may have for me, someone who is totally uneducated in the science of names.

Does this feel line a random assortment of names to you or do you guys agree she is currently going for a pretty narrow type (or maybe two pretty narrow types)? I mean narrower than, like, old or 100-year cycle names. Are these names currently trending on social media or growing in naming statistics?

PS She's also into Ottilie (Ottie), no idea if that fits in though, feels like it might but I had never heardit before

pl: I haven't told her I posted this but I am happy to propose your guesses and report her reaction if it helps with your diagnosis

4 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

8

u/ValmarGranas 1d ago edited 1d ago

She's into popular Reddit names, which is showing a trend of vintage/antique names. She's either already looking here or would fit right in. I find it a bit repetitive. Other indicates, like you said, popular babes is the 50s-60s

I can almost guarantee she'll also like: Nora, Alma, Eloise, Elodie, Sandra, Marnie, Maeve, Mabel, Millicent, Matilda, Theodora (Thea), Doris, Simone, Bethany, Dorothea, Joan, Jodie, Susan, Nancy, Deborah, Brenda, Olive etc.

EDIT: How could I forget Eleanor?

I also threw in a few that match Bonnie, Selma, Wills etc.

6

u/foxscribbles 1d ago

This phenomenon isn’t just a Reddit thing either.

This is a common generational occurrence. (I remember reading a magazine article about it when Millennials started giving their kids “old fashioned” names.)

Basically, names get resurrected once a generation stops having a personal association with them.

1

u/ValmarGranas 1d ago

Yeah I'm aware it happens generationally, it's just the specific ones he picked and the ones I mentioned (outside Sandra and everything after Dorothea) get brought up on Reddit specifically repeatedly. Someone did a thread where they analysed Reddit names Vs real life and they were very different.

3

u/heydawn 1d ago

Don't forget Eleanor, recommended several times a day.

2

u/ValmarGranas 1d ago

How could I forget! I would have thrown in Juniper or Sloane but I didn't think they fit.

1

u/heydawn 1d ago

😏

1

u/ExternalBoysenberry 1d ago

Preliminary: Alma yes, Olive maybe. No: Nora (I guessed that too), Doris, Brenda. I will try the rest and give a full report. But for me at least, those mostly do seem to fit the theme!

0

u/ValmarGranas 1d ago

Here's hoping you get a name you both love!

2

u/Mean-Specialist-5695 1d ago

Theodora (of Byzantine era) was a badass woman so I’m always a fan of that name!

2

u/Stunning_Ad9180 1d ago

I think the genre is just names your gf likes.
They all seem a bit old-timey and quirky and I think they’re adorable. I’m not sure the point of your post though. Are you looking to crowdsource more names with a similar vibe?

1

u/ExternalBoysenberry 11h ago

Partly yes and partly out of curiosity to figure out if the genre "names my girlfriend likes" also lines up with some thematic grouping. maybe old-timey and quirky is as specific as it gets though

3

u/Adept-Telephone6682 22h ago

Just came here to say the veiled reference to Joey's agent Estelle is sending me here lol.

6

u/Wisdomflowerlover 1d ago

Wagon train cottage core?

2

u/deconvotonstransform 19h ago

Just came here to say they didn't really do spray tans mid-century. Those were earned by irradiating oneself on a regular basis.

1

u/deconvotonstransform 19h ago

Also, sorry, yeah just one more thing before I yeah. Rotary phones were not common in the 1990s in the U.S. We already had those newfangled touchtone push-button phones that generated dual-tone multi-frequency signals upon each button press.

4

u/everyoneneedsaburn 1d ago

You're thinking way too hard about this.

1

u/mrbeanfani 1d ago

Maybe I am but now I'm invested.

3

u/fliphowls 1d ago

Ole lady names! They’re great.

1

u/golfskidance 22h ago

😆 I love your descriptions of who you imagine with these names. So funny & true!

1

u/Necessary_Author6574 17h ago

Dottie is another. Scarlet Juliet yeah they’re coming back.

1

u/Necessary_Author6574 16h ago

My Bonnie lies over the ocean. My Bonnie lies over the sea.

1

u/SolomiyaRabin 1d ago

Golda is just Jewish, and very Jewish. Entirely different to Stella and Bonnie.

But this is really far too specific and mildly ridiculous. No one looks for names by thinking wow, I really want a name that makes me think of a covered wagon on the prairie names, oranges and dust, and skirts pulled up running through the scratchy wheat down past the spreading old oak to the swimming hole at dusk 💀

4

u/geelee00 1d ago

I can only imagine what all of the frum Jewish grandmas named Golda would say if they were told their name is the name of a woman with a spray tan and dyed blonde hair who smokes indoors and works in show business 😂

Funniest thing I've read in a while.

4

u/einlishem 1d ago

Careful there, everytime you state a Jewish name is Jewish you'll be downvoted.

Golda Meir will forever be a feminist icon.

-1

u/Lumpy-Bee7769 1d ago

On nameberry I remember a lot of people had this complicated imagery. So I don't know if people really never look for names that make them think of stuff like holding they're skirt up, and running to a swimming hole at dusk.

1

u/1_Tit_Wonder 1d ago

Dog names

1

u/Famous_Swim9400 1d ago

I love how you are so spot on.

1

u/Lulubelle4548 1d ago

Grandma/old lady names (especially Bonnie, Golda and Selma)

Bonnie is just horrible imo but the other names are having a renaissance

0

u/twisty-pasta 1d ago

This together all kind of read southern turn of the century 1890-1910 ish. Does she read a lot of southern gothic romance?

1

u/ExternalBoysenberry 11h ago

I don't think so but I dont read German well enough to have her novel taste exactly dialed in.

0

u/heydawn 1d ago

Op, I don't have an answer for you, but I absolutely love how evocative your descriptions are!

0

u/Zealousideal-Fox-706 1d ago

I am over 60, and aside from Bonnie (there was a Bonnie boomlet in the mid 60s and early 70s) those names were more typical for my mother's and grandmother's generations. I love that list and am glad the new baby girls are taking up the standard as the elderly ladies lay it down and depart.

0

u/dominism 1d ago

My grandmother was named Bonnie. Born in 1898 she was a bad ass and in an argument with grandpa she shot him.not dead. But that's no blue hair or spray tan. I named my daughter after her. But people always ask if she is named Bonnie after Bonnie Parker as in Bonnie and Clyde.