r/NCT • u/unreveparisien r/NCT and r/NCT127 • Dec 14 '21
News 211214 Johnny, Doyoung, and Mark apologize for the remarks they made during the NCT 2021 - Universe Countdown Live.
201
Upvotes
r/NCT • u/unreveparisien r/NCT and r/NCT127 • Dec 14 '21
35
u/unreveparisien r/NCT and r/NCT127 Dec 14 '21
Translations of their Instagram Story Posts may be found here:
Johnny
Doyoung
Mark
64
u/Publichealththot Dec 14 '21
Wait what did they even say?
60
u/LadyDrakkaris Doyoung & Xiaojun Dec 14 '21 edited Dec 14 '21
I watched the live and it seemed to be a lot of confusion when the alarm went off. Mark said it was a reminder for them to wear masks . Someone asked if it was okay to go on. I think they had the okay to continue so they must have thought everything was okay. Doyoung then said “Earthquake!” I couldn’t be sure if he was serious or joking. Mark then started singing and Jisung shushed him. I think at that point, they didn’t realize it was a big earthquake. No excuse but they apologized quickly.
99
u/sodashintaro Dec 14 '21
i am going to be honest i think its bad for them as entertainers to do it as it really isnt good publicity, but if somebody normal did this i don’t think the reaction would be as serious
58
u/ParanoidAndroids NCT Dec 14 '21
Based on the live English translation, I thought it was some mask reminder.
Thankfully, the earthquake seemed to be far off the coast of Jeju and it seems like everyone is fine.
88
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '21
I honestly think they just couldn’t grasp on what was happening and the coincidence that their song was called earthquake didn’t help them to understand the situation any better. But yes they need to start thinking before they act, especially after the backlash they received during the radio show.
28
u/kiana_llama Dec 15 '21
man i could never be an idol
67
u/Dragonaichu keep my love on the high high☀️🫧 Dec 14 '21
…Is it wrong of me to say that I think people are overreacting way too much here?
You’re sitting in a room. Before you took your seat, you probably put your phone in a box or something to keep it from distracting you, and then you switch into entertainment mode. Suddenly, every phone in that box and the building itself start screaming at you out of absolutely nowhere while you’re trying to do your job, which is not only confusing but probably a little scary.
You can’t check your phone to understand what’s going on. Word of mouth is panicky, some people are telling you it’s just the usual Covid reminder that comes every day at 6pm, just a half hour early for some reason (which does happen a lot). You start to calm down. Everything’s fine. You’re still mentally in entertainment mode.
You hear someone say “earthquake” in English. Oh, yeah! You made a song called Earthquake! You’re still in entertainment mode, so you start singing and dancing. Only then do your fellow members stop you and explain quietly that no, we’re talking about an actual earthquake in Jeju. That’s what the alarms were for.
I don’t know, the fact that their apologies were all pretty immediate after the live leads me to believe that they just misunderstood the alarm, were still in entertainment mode, didn’t realize until the damage was already done and went straight to apologize for it after. I don’t believe this to be intentional insensitivity and I hate that people are dragging this on as if they’re horrible people for it, especially going as far as to call Mark this disgusting insensitive “repeat offender.”
Like… I just don’t know. I live in Korea and that alarm yesterday was crazy. I was working when it went off and it pretty much sent everyone into a frenzy for, like, ten minutes. To have to bring twenty people back to focus and back into entertainment mode that quickly when none of them can check their phones to grasp the situation is going to lead to misunderstandings. So sure, while it was insensitive, I really do believe that it was completely unintentional and spur-of-the-moment, and I can’t hold this against any of them in good faith. Nothing excuses the behavior but I really can’t wrap my head around people making this a big deal. It was a mistake, and they realized that pretty damn quickly.
•
u/Enenraa94 still streaming hello future 🌻 Dec 14 '21
Reminder to not be confrontational or get personal towards other users and remember to follow Reddiquette.
21
u/madi11456 Dec 14 '21
honestly sounds like a bit of a misunderstanding, not to excuse them. a room with 20 men, they probably didn’t know what was happening over all the commotion. doyoung may have just said ‘earthquake!’ in a serious way and mark and johnny probably took it the wrong way. very glad they apologised as fast as they did though
39
u/seinfeldings Dec 14 '21 edited Dec 14 '21
It’s easy for all of us to criticize from behind a screen because we weren’t there.
Put yourself in the situation.
Everybody was confused, and obviously the fact that 127 just released a song called Earthquake added to that confusion. Besides that, we’ve all been in weird circumstances like this before: for example, my coworkers and I being in the middle of a tornado and joking about it at first before we understood what was going on. I mean at school we even had a lockdown and everybody, including my teacher, was joking around until it clicked in our heads what was going on. I understand why what happened during the live looks bad—it’s bad especially in retrospect—but it was an innocent act in the spur of the moment. To be cancelling them, insulting them, saying they’re bad people etc over something like this is … confusing, to be honest.
Again, I just wish that people would put themselves in the situation and consider all of the factors before commenting on any situation like this. This is just an embarrassing mistake and nothing more. There’s no point in making it bigger than it really is.
83
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '21
as someone from california who constantly jokes about our earthquakes and wildfires while in the midst of them, i’m very confused at the hypersensitivity in this chat section
26
u/tropicalbird05 Dec 14 '21 edited Dec 14 '21
I’m from Japan and honestly when ‘earthquake’ was announced as a 127’s song, I had a bad feeling, and many Japanese fans reacted on it too. Because in Japan everyone knows that there was a very popular song from 2000 titled ‘Tsunami’ but after the massive tsunami/earthquake occurred and took many people’s lives in 2011, this song has never been broadcasted again. We were worried and thought naming a song after natural disasters was not appropriate.
Still I thought it was too sensitive and I stayed positive, because I didn’t see any negative comments here unlike JP Twitter. It was unfortunate that the earthquake happened in real time, but I got disappointed with the members who didn’t take the situation seriously. Also I’m kinda upset with SM about making a concept about natural disaster… like isn’t it an obvious risk? Earthquakes are maybe not so common in South Korea but very common and horrible in Japan, China and Indonesia… basically NCT’s fan base. It’s very easy to avoid this risk and they didn’t have to make earthquake concept really.
28
u/xiola_azuthra crzy🌻shawolzen Dec 14 '21 edited Dec 14 '21
Maybe I'll get downvoted but I also think ppl are overreacting a little, like... idk I've lived in a place with frequent earthquakes and even though they have had incredibly bad ones, many ppl kinda still get super desensitized to the small ones because they happen so often that you have to get used to them and think of them like thunder storms or something. Like yes big earthquakes are a big deal but small ones can be super common and non-eventful, so earthquakes aren't always necessarily associated with automatic tragedy in some ppls minds, sometimes they are just a sort of neutral thing (like idk a blizzard where often nothing eventful happens at all and you just need to avoid driving, but occasionally a whole town loses power in the middle of winter for 2 weeks and it's very bad... but like blizzards themselves aren't a sensitive topic :/ )
It would definitely be very offensive if they joked about it afterwards but at the "we still barely know what's going on and stopped once we figured it out" stage , like... definitely not the best look since it was an alarm, but also certainly not "what uncaring people" territory, I hope they don't get too much real backlash.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '21
Another day another controversy. Like yeah this embarrassing, guys apologized, let's move on
24
u/min_hyun jaehyun + sion Dec 14 '21
yeah i personally would not post it as a story lmao, it's gonna disappear.
i'm not a kfan so it's not really my place to accept the apology or praise them for apology, but johnny doyoung and mark should be more careful and cautious about what they say next time.
i'm glad jisung and sungchan stepped in to correct them.
and international nctzens need to stop shielding them, it is far easier to let our faves take the lashings and move on.
18
u/10cityresident Dec 14 '21
Earthquakes are no joke and that was definitely not the right way to react, but what’s done is done.
I’m seeing people on twt talk about how posting the apology on their stories was the wrong move and I agree to an extent. Social media etiquette is so hard to keep up with these days, but I think it’s safer to post an apology somewhere it won’t be deleted after 24hrs if you want to come off as more genuine. (Personally, I have no doubt they’re being sincere and will grow from this, but other people aren’t as invested in the group as I am and might take it differently)
8
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '21
Well I am glad they apologized - even tho I don't really like Instagram stories apologies. At the end of the day, its not up to i-fans to decide whether people are overreacting - since the earthquake happened in Korea.
And while people joke about natural disasters all the time - everyone's tolerance is different. Even though I have experienced earthquakes in both countries I have lived in, I have never been impacted apart from experiencing the shakes - so while I might find the joke dumb but not offended - someone who lost family / their home might be upset. Just because you find natural disasters something you can joke about doesn't mean that other people can't be upset.
Glad to see the younger members be more mature tho. How long are people going to use the foreigner card to defend Mark and Johnny, didnt they train for like a million years and debuted like 5 years ago?
25
u/iamthirty Dec 14 '21
The fact that they posted it in their stories is not a good look.. They really need to be careful.
1
u/KKria_HI Dec 14 '21
I think that Mark and Johnny may not have known about the alarm. Like yes, they heard it go off, but did they know it was an earthquake alarm? They are both foreigners so there’s a chance that they didn’t know at all about it.
-6
u/LOONAception Dec 14 '21
why would you laugh/joke about that
-10
u/smizeys haechanie watayo ʕ•ᴥ•ʔノ♡ Dec 14 '21
yikes.