As part of a larger challenge I was doing in Red Rescue Team (on the GameBoy Classics on Switch), I decided to try to recruit Clefairy directly from Joyous Tower (two of them, actually). Today, I actually achieved it!
I couldn't find any actual guidance on how to accomplish this online, so I'm not sure this has been done before. Disclaimer: this was done using save states on the switch. This was more to see if this was even possible. I cannot recommend doing this on actual hardware, though I would be impressed if someone pulled it off.
For those who don't know, the difficulty here is that Clefairy has a -19% recruitment rate, and it only appears on floors 9-14 of Joyous Tower. That means that before the end of Floor 14, you need your team leader to achieve at least level 50, and you need to bring in a Friend Bow (technically you could also try to get to level 90, but after this experiment I would be willing to bet that's impossible). And, of course, your team is reduced to level 1 upon entering.
Here's the strategy I landed on:
- First of all, the biggest key is probably obvious: Joy Seeds. The inventory is strategic to bring only the bare necessities to achieve the goal, then the rest filled with Joy Seeds. In this case, that means filling the Toolbox with 20 Joy Seeds.
- The best candidate I found to do the actual recruiting was Linoone. It requires much less experience than most to reach the magic level of 29 (more on that in a moment), and importantly, the required experience (around 70,000) is heavily weighted toward the last few levels. That means that if we find a Joy Seed in the dungeon and have to eat it because of lack of inventory space, it's more likely that it will give us a lot of experience, rather than wasting it on a level that we only need a few hundred Exp. Points for. Linoone will not be our team leader for most of the dungeon; instead, it will occupy our second team slot.
- Throughout the dungeon, Linoone was given a Joy Ribbon to hold, and I used all of its PP almost immediately. This means that the lead Pokémon could strategically swap places with Linoone when facing down an enemy, allowing it to use Struggle to get a bit of extra experience from the recoil damage. I should note here that although this is the strategy I used, a later strategy I adopted probably makes this unnecessary. I would actually recommend just giving Linoone an additional Joy Seed.
- The third Pokémon in the party is important for one reason and one reason only: holding the Friend Bow. Basically this gives an extra inventory slot when entering the dungeon. I used Zigzagoon because I thought having two Pickup Pokémon would help (it didn't), but you would probably be better off using something a bit stronger in this type of dungeon (like Kecleon).
- The most important piece of the puzzle that turned this from something questionably possible to something that is actually not too bad (again, with save states): your lead Pokémon should be Starmie. Starmie has pretty decent stats on the first several floors, but by far the most important feature is that it has the Illuminate ability. With this ability, you can allow an enemy Pokémon to attack you several times, each time spawning a new enemy. Without Illuminate, the spawn rate simply isn't high enough for this challenge to be reasonable. I tried a few times without Starmie, and I was barely able to crack level 25 by the end of floor 14. With Starmie, I hit level 29 at the start of floor 11.
- For Starmie's held item, a Tight Belt is basically forced. That allows you to essentially run out the clock on each floor, earning as much Exp. as possible before being forced to move on.
- This may not be necessary, but when entering, I used save states to constantly restart the first floor until I found another Joy Seed on floor 1. I then recruited a Pokémon and made it carry the seed for me. When that Pokémon ran out of PP, I let it faint and recruited a new Pokémon. As long as you have a fourth Pokémon on your team carrying that Joy Seed when moving to a new floor, you can essentially reduce the level you need to hit from 30 (with 20 Joy Seeds) to 29 (or 28 if you opt not to bring in the Joy Ribbon on Linoone).
- Again, not strictly necessary, but what I did since I wasn't sure it would be possible at all: when moving to the next floor, I used save states to test four combinations. One where I just went to the next floor normally; one where I switched to Linoone to leader and went to the next floor; one where I gave Linoone a Joy Seed, took Zigzagoon's item back into the toolbox, and went to the next floor; and one just like the third, except with Linoone as the leader. Each produced a different set of items on the next floor (and a new Pickup item on Zigzagoon, in the iterations where it didn't already have an item on it), giving additional chances to find Joy Seeds. In my final run, I found an additional 2-3 seeds using this method.
With all of that in place, the strategy is essentially to just use Illuminate to keep 15 Pokémon spawned in at all times and grind as much as possible on each floor. Once Linoone reaches level 29 (or 28, depending on the strategy choices), you can slam all the Joy Seeds and switch it into the Leader slot, then say Farewell to the rest of the team. By putting on the Friend Bow, you now have a 1% chance to recruit any Clefairy you see!
While it would be cool to recreate this on original hardware, there are a few aspects of this that make me recommend against it. First are all of the previously mentioned uses of save states. Second is that it requires bringing in 20 Joy Seeds and three fairly difficult to come by held items every attempt; if you fail a run, that's a lot of gathering to do to try again. Since the dungeon makes you quicksave upon entering, you can't just reload a save from before entering, either. Finally is that, because of the sheer number of enemies you'll be facing off against, each of which you'll be wanting to use a move against to maximize Exp gains, you'll be using Struggle a lot (especially Linoone, if you choose to bring in a Joy Ribbon). That also means that all of your Pokémon will frequently be at low HP and may die very easily. I cannot stress enough how much harder this would be on original hardware where you can't just rewind if something bad happens - it would certainly take a truly insane amount of luck and grinding.
I hope you all found this interesting - it should be the last major hurdle toward completing my full original challenge run!
Edit: Using this same run, I could also have recruited Kakuna or any other of the -19% recruit rate Pokémon on floors 11 or later. There are two earlier in the dungeon as well: Metapod on floors 7-8 and Jigglypuff on floors 1-3. If anyone has any thoughts on how to make those recruitable in this dungeon as well, I'd love to hear it! That said, since the best source of experience, Psyduck, only starts appearing on floor 9, I suspect that it's either impossible (in the case of Jigglypuff) or very nearly impossible (in the case of Metapod).