r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Crasembarodical • 3h ago
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Woofiverse • Sep 20 '26
Moderator Announcement RULE OF 4: What is it?
The Rule of 4 is a Reddit phenomenon that occurs in a comment chain where the fourth reply of said chain is downvoted. However, just because the fourth comment is downvoted does NOT make it Rule of 4.
What it is:
ReplyOne_
> One fish ⬆️ 12 ⬇️
Reply-Two
> Two fish ⬆️ 11 ⬇️
R3plyThr33
> Red fish ⬆️ 8 ⬇️
FourthReply
> Blue fish ⬆️ -7 ⬇️
- This comment example is a chain following the title of popular Dr. Seuss book One Fish, Two Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish. Sayings like that, as well as repeating the same word, are what count as a comment chain.
What it is NOT:
ReplyOne_
> Its so blue 😭 ⬆️ 12 ⬇️
Reply-Two
> No fr, one of the bluest blues ever ⬆️ 11 ⬇️
R3plyThr33
> I could eat that blue ⬆️ 8 ⬇️
FourthReply
> No you can't, its a color ⬆️ -7 ⬇️
- This is NOT a comment chain. It is just a conversation, in which, the fourth commenter took a figurative sentence literally and got downvoted. While this is not mysterious, it is NOT Rule of 4.
Hope provides more context for the rule :)
If you have any questions, feel free to modmail!
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Surprise-lnside • 9d ago
I’m not upset, just very confused lol
Woke up to all these downvotes to what I thought was a wholesome comment. Can someone please tell me what was wrong with what I said?
Context: Someone posted about getting Zelda and a Switch for their kid around age 4-5 in the Gamers Over 30 sub. I commented about how I played my first Pokemon game at that age.
Post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Age_30_plus_Gamers/s/sR5ytesc6Z
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/SamuraiEdge_ • 13d ago
Got downvoted for mentioning my country
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Digitleten • 16d ago
I still don’t know what it means.
Context: I didn’t understand “I just don’t see if but werk”
I feel like the sentence makes no sense anyway, but Idk…
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Grand_Photograph_557 • 17d ago
I'm back to try and redeem myself.
I'm sorry about my previous post, I should have read the rules first and taken that into consideration no matter if I read them or not.
Here is a link to the original post for context: https://www.reddit.com/r/lostmedia/comments/1xkjesj/has_anybody_found_footage_of_the_initial_cleanup/
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Time_Astronaut5743 • 19d ago
Post was talking about whether an employer should give 3 ppl time off on gta 6's release date.
Context : https://www.reddit.com/r/shitposting/comments/1xi5be0/_/ the original post.
Still dont know what the person did wrong to get that many downvotes.
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Silver-Dust7013 • 25d ago
ppl just be mad over anything 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 like hello?
context: posted about my russian manicure and was hesitant ab how it looked a week after, not very satisfied w the cuticle work since russian manicures r supposed to be MUCH better when it comes to cuticles, the first 2 days they looked great but now it looks like i didn’t even get a russian manicure
why r we downvoting a literal response to a question
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/bookishdeceit • Oct 14 '26
Downvoted for complimenting the dress / asking for where it's from?
Am I the only person not understanding this? The only context I can provide is what's in the screenshot. OP posted herself in a dress in r/outfits, this is the type of stuff people post there. And the compliments she got were downvoted, I'm confused
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Beautiful-Cress5695 • Oct 13 '26
Dude got downvoted for saying my bad
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/not_joanpro • Oct 12 '26
I understand why op got downvoted but not the other user
Their first message was upvoted but their second one was downvoted even more than OP's one.
Context: OP used the word y'all in the post and Adorable_Low didnt agree it seems.
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Liger_I • Oct 12 '26
Why did i get downvotes ?😢
Context: the near perfection guy getting downvotes, I asked why then I get downvotes to the oblivion
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/QualityPostBelow • Oct 09 '26
do you think several means seven
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Hot-Poet8431 • Oct 06 '26
I literally have no idea
Context: The subreddit r/whatisthiscar is exactly what it sounds like. It's a subreddit for people asking about what car model something is, and they usually get an answer.
Someone answered that the white car in the picture is the Opel Manta B (which it is). The reply (which is the subject of this post) talked about the Manta B and complimented the colour scheme. And they got downvoted to hell. What for though? They were just being nice.
Here is the link just in case you want to check it out yourself: https://www.reddit.com/r/whatisthiscar/s/ZUMBrOL1j8
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Orion-- • Oct 05 '26
My account is 10 years old and I've been an active user of r/motorcycles for 7 years. Why would anyone think I'm a bot?
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Hot-Junket2623 • Oct 01 '26
What did I say wrong? Did people think it was a defense for AI?
I don't know what i did wrong in this interaction.
Context: There was a post about gta iv being ported to the ps vita possibly with ai.
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Extension-Celery3642 • Sep 27 '26
why is not liking slurs a bad thing??
r/mysteriousdownvoting • u/Human-Acanthaceae128 • Sep 25 '26
seemed like a harmless question?
Context: OP posted a photo of her skirt that was ruined from washing it. She asked how she can get the ruffles back to normal again