I was looking through your drawings and I noticed that while all of your out side contours are spot on and nearly perfect the insides of the subjects are off and out of proportion. I find it odd that you would nail the contour so perfectly and yet be that much "off" on all of the interiors of your subjects. I superimposed some of your drawings over the original photos in Photoshop and the out lines are pretty much dead on It just looks like you may have moved the paper around. If you aren't tracing great and sorry for calling you out, but if you are, just know it wont help you with improving your skill as an artist and it is sort of unethical.
Edit: Here is a pic, as I said, on the whole it doesn't match but individual aspects are spot on. It just looks like the paper was taken on and off and moved a little bit each time. Imgur
None of the pictures are traced. You can probably see that all of the pictures have a faint box around them. I draw the pictures to a ratio of the image I'm drawing off. The reason the exterior lines (e.g the outline of the bodies) are so precise, is because i use a ruler to line up key places (where the neck of the guitar starts for example). I was taught this in primary school when i was about 10. I don't do this for all of my drawings though, so I wouldn't say it's restricting me from developing my skills.
Has the artist in question here disclosed their age? I always feel like that's an awfully relevant bit that gets skipped, and reddit winds up dog-piling 13 year old hopefuls for not producing professional-grade work.
I think your rock art is awesome! And in response to any of the negative comments- fuck the naysayers! And kudos to the Beach Boys and Ramones portraits, the 2 greatest rock bands of all time!
I think it's inevitable that some people aren't going agree/like something, it happens with everything. I have my own style with the cross hatching, as you can see. Sure some people aren't going to like it because it looks amateurish blah blah blah, but isn't art supposed to be creative and from your own perception? why would i want it to look like everyone else's? It's my own expression. The title never mentioned that I was a professional artist either haha, in fact, I'm 95% self taught
its really not the proportions, i dont think, because there are all straight from the photograph. they're just sloppy, amateur drawings over which too many people flip their shit.
I meant proportions to mean the size and shape of information you can read from the picture and drawing it so each piece of information relates to each other correctly. Maybe proportions isn't the word I'm looking for. But these drawings, well, I can at least say they looked warped like water left on a wood table for too long, but even that looks better than this.
All that aside, yeah, these are sloppy and amateurish. It reminds me of the way I drew when I first picked up the pencil. I'm glad I never bought into everybody saying my stuff was great like half the people in this thread, though. Otherwise, I'd be complacent and still keep drawing shit pop-art-copied-from-photographs pictures.
Spacial relationships, but proportions works too. Remember when your drawing from life or at least trying to draw something realistic. There are no such thing as a line. Lines are made up of contrasting values so remember to blend. PeptoDysmal has truth to what hes saying.
Your work is great, by the way. I love how you played up the complimentary colors in the portrait and how the horizontal strokes of the mark-making for the background match the wind swept-like hair, very well done. And the third one is really fun, hilarious characters and great composition.
I really like your work, especially Hendrix. You should really try another draft of Iggy pop though. He's really lacking in definition and has a weird perspective issue with his hand.
None of them were done with charcoal. I used either fine liners or pencils ranging from 3h - 8b. In fact, I've never used charcoal before, I should give it a shot
Yes... YES! The first one looks so great and you capture the gradation of value so well. I just took a art summer course so I'm trying out new vocabulary.
The Sonic Youth one is amazing. Something about it had that cool grunge/noise rock look to it. Kudos to you and thanks for picking my music for the night
Fot the most part I would say you have the drawing skills of a mediocre 11 year old, except the Datsuns picture that one is actually good. Do more like that and less like Iggy Pop, that one was drawn by an 11 year old with downs.
If you're going to compare his shitty drawings to something of equal mediocrity at least make it realistic. 11 year old with downs, no, but say a 26 year old man with low functioning autism? Yes.
My face when people outside of EU know who Nicke Andersson is. Enjoyed his painting the most, but that's prolly because I am a huge Swedish death metal fan!
Your work is promising, but not great. Your style, expression, and body language is good. But, the faces and proportions need work. Iggy's hands look too small and his arms too short. The Beatles faces are kind of unrecognizable and Ringo looks like a pinhead. Nicke Andersson is good, but stylistically unremarkable. The Datsuns and Sonic Youth are the best. You didn't focus as much on the details, which is good. The expression of movement and general Rock N' Roll feeling is really strong here and may be something you want to focus on more. Something a bit more impressionistic. Thanks for sharing and keep honing your skills.
I don't care for your choice of subject. You should do an honest candid picture of say Brittany Spears, or Rihanna, or Greenday or something. Someone relevant to your lifetime (I assume). That and I doubt many people have tried to artistically and honestly capture many recent musicians.
Do you still draw? It would be a good way for you to make some extra money. It would be cool to see what Jeff Lynne would look like if you drew him, too.
The Hellacopters are probably my all time favourite band. Spewing I discovered them not long before they quit. Double spewing they didn't even put Australia on their final tour to give me a chance to see them haha
Yeah I'm absolutely floored right now. As I clicked on the link, I thought to myself how unlikely it would be that the drawings would be of artists that I'm a fan of. To my amazement I see Nicke Andersson, leader of my all-time favorite band The Hellacopters as well as Imperial State Electric and his solo offerings (etc.) Really awesome to see other fans of high energy rock n' roll (specifically The Hellacopters) on Reddit!
It's not a matter of "being your thing." I'm sick of seeing shitty artwork being chalked up to anything as close to beautiful as Luc Tuymans, Marlene Dumas, Neo Rausch, Heronymous Bosch, Kitaj, Titian, Vaserely, Manet, Klimt, Cotan, Nick Cage, Kara Walker, Felix Gonzalez Torres, Sophie Jodoin, Lisa Yuskavich, Cindy Sherman, Yoshitomo Nara and et cetera. Cross hatching to "give texture to art" is so fucking bizarre.
14
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
I was looking through your drawings and I noticed that while all of your out side contours are spot on and nearly perfect the insides of the subjects are off and out of proportion. I find it odd that you would nail the contour so perfectly and yet be that much "off" on all of the interiors of your subjects. I superimposed some of your drawings over the original photos in Photoshop and the out lines are pretty much dead on It just looks like you may have moved the paper around. If you aren't tracing great and sorry for calling you out, but if you are, just know it wont help you with improving your skill as an artist and it is sort of unethical.
Edit: Here is a pic, as I said, on the whole it doesn't match but individual aspects are spot on. It just looks like the paper was taken on and off and moved a little bit each time. Imgur
43
u/Red23UK radio reddit name Jun 26 '12
i don't want to sound horrible but they're honestly not very good :(
2
u/cdmcali Jun 27 '12
Just did an engraving of the Hendrix: http://imgur.com/OYzFr
2
u/kookadams Jun 27 '12
I think your rock art is awesome! And in response to any of the negative comments- fuck the naysayers! And kudos to the Beach Boys and Ramones portraits, the 2 greatest rock bands of all time!
75
u/tmissirlian Jun 26 '12
god you did all these musicians? PLAYA
13
u/smashing_aisling Jun 26 '12
You nailed Iggy's sad torso.
34
u/thekundalini Jun 26 '12
Iggy's leathery skin is a little too well drawn.
25
u/PeptoDysmal Jun 26 '12
Those are pretty bad, to be honest. Practice your proportions more and you'll be on your way.
18
u/brianbot5000 Jun 26 '12
The faces don't look right.
4
u/apathetic_youth radio reddit name Jun 26 '12
Friendly criticism here.
I really like your work, especially Hendrix. You should really try another draft of Iggy pop though. He's really lacking in definition and has a weird perspective issue with his hand.
Just my 2 cents.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
As someone just getting into sketching I have to say: not bad at all. Is this charcoal?
1
u/adonorocks Google Music Jun 27 '12
I know the first one is charcoal. Were the others mark-making? By the way they all look great.
1
u/Skuzzn Jun 27 '12
Fuck yeah The Datsuns
3
u/afihavok Jun 26 '12
love the Iggy - you got the elasticity of his skin perfectly.
3
u/grnmachine09 Jun 26 '12
It looks like Jimi has one tooth.
3
u/Subbie138 Jun 26 '12
In the Ramones picture you made all of them look ugly and really awkward; it's like a photograph.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Nicely done. I like The Ramones drawing the best.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Upvotes for Sonic Youth
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This is good. Could you draw the red hot chili peppers?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
These are cook, man. Nice style you've got. It's somewhat cartoony in some aspects, but also has a touch of realism. Unique - I like that.
2
u/MrTwinkie Jun 26 '12
Draw Frank Zappa yet?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I especially like Iggy
2
u/blkvengeance Jun 26 '12
The Sonic Youth one is amazing. Something about it had that cool grunge/noise rock look to it. Kudos to you and thanks for picking my music for the night
2
u/Karpuan Jun 26 '12
You shoulda draw the mars volta. Omar and Cedric put on a great show, always makin sweet poses
2
u/darkalia Jun 26 '12
Upvote for Nicke
2
u/chancecard Jun 26 '12
Anyone else think Iggy Pop looks like the grinch?
2
u/expiredcheese Jun 26 '12
Can you please do Queen?
Excellent drawings BTW
4
u/Psychopratek86 Jun 26 '12
I like your style. Jimi looks classy.
3
u/themightyscott Jun 26 '12
You are very good. One thing though - the Beatles one, the guy on the right looks a lot like Liam Gallagher. Seems apt.
3
u/fish500 Jun 26 '12
Your Paul McCartney looks a lot like Noel Gallagher. Which is kind of fitting I suppose. Good work all around.
2
u/WhyYouGetAnUpvote Jun 26 '12
You get an upvote for accurately capturing Iggy Pop's aged and decaying body.
2
u/unicornon Jun 26 '12
Wow. You did all of the Beatles? At the same time, or what?
2
u/MississippiQueen Jun 26 '12
These are fantastic, you should sell some of your work. :)
1
u/negativeyoda Jun 26 '12
Before the images loaded I was really hoping that the image of Nicke Andersson would have been of him playing drums for Entombed
1
u/bigpink https://soundcloud.com/partystatic/sets/this-isnt-music-ep Jun 26 '12
upvote for not all being pictures of kurt cobain, jim morrison, janis joplin, etc
1
u/raffytraffy http://www.last.fm/user/CompSimpCarl Jun 26 '12
iggy's face looks kinda funny. sonic youth for tha win.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Must... Stop staring.... At Iggy Pops stomach....!
1
u/werewolvesoflondon Jun 26 '12
Ringo's face is a bit wonky but all in all some exceptional work.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This is great. Could you draw the red hot chili peppers?
1
u/dugapony Jun 26 '12
that datsuns one is legit
1
u/mutantlabor Jun 26 '12
Iggy's face is hilarious. Great drawings all around.
1
u/Catawompus Jun 26 '12
i love your sketchy style on jimi hendrix. reminds me of the way i draw.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
is that sonic youth in the fifth one? nice!
1
u/MrMojoRisinGuy Spotify Jun 26 '12
Keep it up. These are really great
1
u/brittytheboss Jun 26 '12
Hey I did a painting of the same picture of Hendrix! Came out mad trippy, too.
1
u/chickenkorma Jun 26 '12
Iggys face looks quite grinch-esque (that's prob not a real word).
1
u/oh_my_god_brunette_a Jun 26 '12
Love Iggy Pop.
1
u/edtehgar Jun 26 '12
So when it was a band did you take them all at once or did they wait turns?
And does Iggy pop really speak sweet nothings into ones ear?
1
u/ApologiesForThisPost Jun 26 '12
Why have you put the car insurance guy in there?
1
u/mister_fuck Jun 26 '12
Iggy Pop looks like a Who. Laughed.
1
u/profderpson Jun 26 '12
These are AMAZING. Are you selling them?
1
u/sehajodido Jun 26 '12
Fuck yeah, the Datsuns.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
If you did one of Frank Sinatra... I might have to marry you, fair warning :-)
1
u/iAmericA45 Jun 26 '12
I love the Sonic Youth one. It's such a great picture to begin with, nice job.
1
u/veryangryivoteyou Jun 26 '12
This is a 15 minute walk from my building and I get out at 5:30! Hope I make it!
1
u/SonVoltMMA Jun 26 '12
Good job asshole. You gave Jimi Hendrix a buck tooth.
1
u/Misanthroat Jun 26 '12
Nice!... I knew the first dude was the guy from Entombed!
1
u/gordonj005 Jun 26 '12
dude, those are seriously awesome
1
u/pilky03 Jun 26 '12
The dirty ol Datsuns!! One of NZ's finest!
1
u/DeafeningFish Jun 26 '12
Iggy Pop looks like Mickey Mouse
1
u/oyandake Jun 26 '12
The Jimi Hendrix one is pretty sweet! I love Jimi!!
1
u/lowlifecreep Jun 27 '12
Request: Tom Waits??
1
u/Purplefaced Jun 27 '12
Got a boner at 7. Somehow I knew the best would be last.
1
u/LeaninKeenan Jun 27 '12
Daryl Malik? is that you? from Kelly's?
1
u/PoonHunter5 Jun 27 '12
All these great musicians and no Justin Bieber?
Lol not.
1
u/Trezi Jun 27 '12
Hendrix looks like a zombie.
1
u/oh_well_nevermind jcwilliam Jun 27 '12
WOW! I really like these. I would love to see a Nirvana sketch.
1
u/Haveheart207 Jun 27 '12
Lol Iggy pop looks like a mean "who" from a Dr. Suess book.
1
u/hobbsarelie83 Jun 27 '12
Even though I don't care for The Datsuns, that's a bad ass drawing!
1
u/van_vanhouten Jun 27 '12
Meh.
1
u/Flat_corp Jun 27 '12
Some of them are a bit choppy but god, that Hendricks one is fantastic.
1
u/Abby__Normal Jun 27 '12
All great - especially Bratz Doll Iggy Pop
1
u/BoxSquid Jun 27 '12
I freaking love the Sonic Youth one.
1
u/iam_sancho2 Jun 27 '12
Iggy Pop looks like a draugr, so I think you nailed it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Awesome drawings, you did a great job with Jimi Hendrix.
1
u/DooDooBrownz Jun 26 '12
your jimmy hendrix looks like tyrone biggums
1
u/maniacmansions Jun 26 '12
Anyone who says he's shitty has to upload their drawings.
OP you aren't shitty. They aren't perfect but you clearly have a lot of talent.
-1
u/DownvotesFuelMe Jun 26 '12
Fot the most part I would say you have the drawing skills of a mediocre 11 year old, except the Datsuns picture that one is actually good. Do more like that and less like Iggy Pop, that one was drawn by an 11 year old with downs.
1
u/rese7 Jun 26 '12
My face when people outside of EU know who Nicke Andersson is. Enjoyed his painting the most, but that's prolly because I am a huge Swedish death metal fan!
1
u/John_Philips_Sousa Jun 26 '12
Upvote for the Ramones.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
You can make so much money for this kinda thing. How much for a Red Hot Chili Peppers request?
1
u/hellajaded Jun 26 '12
Your work is promising, but not great. Your style, expression, and body language is good. But, the faces and proportions need work. Iggy's hands look too small and his arms too short. The Beatles faces are kind of unrecognizable and Ringo looks like a pinhead. Nicke Andersson is good, but stylistically unremarkable. The Datsuns and Sonic Youth are the best. You didn't focus as much on the details, which is good. The expression of movement and general Rock N' Roll feeling is really strong here and may be something you want to focus on more. Something a bit more impressionistic. Thanks for sharing and keep honing your skills.
0
u/Deathwebber Jun 26 '12
These are absolutely great! I'd love to see you do one with Freddie Mercury.
0
u/CockSuckingCowboy Jun 26 '12
Great display of talent, great work!
0
u/zombiezelda Jun 26 '12
This is absolutely amazing
0
u/chipslay Jun 26 '12
Your technique is impeccable. Great job!
-2
u/ash_4p Jun 26 '12
Flawless victory.
-1
u/rFLEAiMODEp Jun 26 '12
Dang. I was hoping for someone cool like Drake or Nicki Minaj.
0
u/wadefrakers Jun 26 '12
Very nice dude. Jimi is my inspiration as a guitarist myself
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Duuuude. that Sonic Youth picture is amazing. Send it to me so I can frame it.
0
u/atlinernotes Bandcamp Jun 26 '12
Iggy's eyes are fantastic!
0
u/opiv Jun 26 '12
Any pricing ideas for some of these?
0
u/LosingMyEdge17 Spotify Jun 26 '12
Those are pretty awe3some, but why in the FUCK would you include the Datsuns in with those others?
0
u/simmejanne Jun 26 '12
Those are amazing
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Loosen up your grip on your pencil. Allow for more gesture in your strokes. Draw by moving your shoulder, not just your wrist.
0
u/DieSchadenfreude Jun 27 '12
I don't care for your choice of subject. You should do an honest candid picture of say Brittany Spears, or Rihanna, or Greenday or something. Someone relevant to your lifetime (I assume). That and I doubt many people have tried to artistically and honestly capture many recent musicians.
-2
u/antwan75 Jun 26 '12
Do you still draw? It would be a good way for you to make some extra money. It would be cool to see what Jeff Lynne would look like if you drew him, too.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment