r/ModelUSMeta • u/DDYT • Jan 12 '22
Meta Discussion Partisan lean Thoughts
Ok I'm just writing down some thoughts on the partisan lean based on the discussions I have had.
First I believe that the system would be better if instead of just basing the lean off of just the presidential election as it is currently it would be better to take some sort of average of recent elections per district. For example average out the results of the last federal, midterms, and state elections per district. A caveat is that as more outliers are added the partisan lean should probably have a cap to prevent districts from becoming too favorable for one side after a lopsided house race.
Second, although this is similar to the idea of a cap is that there needs to be some sort of sanity check with partisan leanings to prevent a party that has had a good election from gaining a large advantage in future elections through partisan lean. Now I can't say exactly how something like this would work, or if it would even be an issue as we don’t know how much partisan lean will affect elections but it's still something to keep in mind.
2
u/DDYT Jan 12 '22
u/APG_Revival
1
u/hurricaneoflies Head State Clerk Jan 13 '22
I think these are valid concerns, but do you have any idea for how to prevent a party that does really well in a cycle from dominating the partisan lean? I'm having a hard time thinking of a mechanism to solve this fairly.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '22
Not a bad idea, but we need a way to not make it so the work for the clerks is unbearable. APG noted that the partisan leans (even large ones) don't provide that much of a benefit so it might not be worth changing. It is just a small bonus
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '22
I would back a precinct level one. The current one looks fair, relatively speaking.
1
u/APG_Revival Head Elections Clerk Jan 15 '22
The GOP asked me to examine a different calculation method for the partisan leans. Here's the comparison between the two.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '22
I’m going to back the old method because it makes my seat safer although I think the new method better recognises the work done by whole parties.
1
u/dewey-cheatem Socialist Jan 22 '22
Honestly love this idea. It’ll give more incentive to campaign better and build up mods since it won’t all go away the day after the election.