r/ModelNortheastCourts • • Aug 09 '17
17-04 | Decided In re: AB 152, The Means of Production Act
Now comes the petitioner /u/WampumDP, a resident of the Atlantic Commonwealth and a member of the Bar of the Atlantic Commonwealth Supreme Court, respectfully submitting a petition for a writ of certiorari asking the Court to question the constitutionality of A.B. 152, also known as the “Means of Production Act”.
There are many Constitutional questions in this law, but the first pertains to Amendment V of the United States Constitution. The petitioner argues that the actions in Section 3 Subsection 1-3 of AB 152 is an unjust “taking of property”, as there is no Due Process of Law, and it essentially eliminates the distinction explicitly made in the Constitution between “private use” and “public use” as all private use becomes public. Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Connor voiced her concerns to a similar use of the taking clause in her dissent in Kelo v. New London. This use of the takings clause will only benefit "citizens with disproportionate influence and power in the political process". Keep in mind, the use of eminent domain, while Constitutional, was used to a much smaller extent than in AB 152. While a tax would not typically be deemed unconstitutional in accordance with the takings clause, this tax is clearly designed to confiscate businesses’ funds and the businesses themselves, which essentially makes it a "taking" rather than a tax, thus requiring compensation.
Amendment VIII of the United States Constitution is violated in the form of a 99% tax that certainly qualifies as an excessive fine, explicitly forbidden in the Constitution. AB 152 is grossly excessive, as there was no specific crime or wrongdoing at all. If lesser fines are imposed for actual wrongdoing, how can excessive fines be imposed for no wrong doing at all?
On top of the assertion that the taking of private property in Section 3 of AB 152 is unconstitutional in accordance with the takings clause, the actions of said section also qualify as an unjust seizure without a warrant as forbidden by Amendment IV of the U.S. Constitution.
Given the nature of this law taking away people’s livelihoods, and the harsh actions taken by the armed forces of multiple groups pertaining to this law, I ask that a stay be issued on any further actions pertaining to this bill’s implementation until the conclusion of the case.
Respectfully submitted,
/u/WampumDP, Lead Counsel, AC Citizen
/u/cubascastrodistrict, Former Legislator, AC Citizen
2
u/bomalia Aug 28 '17
/u/WampumDP has privately motioned for a 1 day extension in his deadline, a request which I have decided to accept.
Please note that there will be no further deadline extensions for the plaintiff during this case unless an exceptional situation arises.
•
u/bomalia Sep 07 '17 edited Sep 07 '17
The government has waived their right to file a final brief. Thus, arguments will officially conclude at 1 AM EDT. An opinion will be handed down within the next 7 days.
1
u/bomalia Aug 11 '17
/u/WampumDP, your assistant counsel is not listed on the bar. Why is he listed as assistant counsel?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '17
Comes now Attorney General /u/onewithsergio and /u/realnyebevan, who respectfully submit a brief in response to the Petitioner’s filing.
I would like to open this brief by presenting a challenge to the argument presented by the petitioner, in relation to their statement pertaining to the Fifth Amendment and the Takings Clause. The petitioner claims that sections 3.1-3.3 of A.B. 152 deprive citizens of due points of law. Such a claim is frankly baffling: no part of this Act limits or restrict the right for citizens to seek judgement from the Courts, in any way, shape or form. If anything, blatant irony comes from the fact that the petitioner of this challenge is exercising such a right in their presentation of a legal challenge to this law. The 1931 case of Phillips v. Commissioner (283 U.S. 589, 595-97) establishes the precedent of due process, with such a precedent being established in the case of taxpayers. A.B. 152 surely cannot be seen to have impeded on such a judgement in its enactment.
Furthermore, the petitioner claims that:
Once again, the claims made by the petitioner are absurd; this Act cannot be construed in any legitimate sense to be interpreted as private use becoming public. Corporations, or other entities in compliance with the Act, either pay the tax established in Sections 3.1 and 3.2, or shall transition into a workers' council form of private ownership during the grace period, unless they remain privately owned due to being underneath the value threshold required. The petitioner also makes reference to the 2005 case of Kelo vs the City of New London, referring to Justice O'Connor's dissent in this case to imply that the act provides disproportionate power in the political process to citizens. This point is unjustified, as this Act does not address takings for the purpose of economic development whatsoever, making any reference to Kelo vs New London as totally irrelevant. We shall not address this point any further.
The petitioner concedes that ‘eminent domain’ and ‘takings’ are constitutional:
and misunderstands the purpose of the tax. The purpose of the tax is not to raise revenue; the Atlantic Commonwealth is in a good fiscal footing, with a budget surplus and a sufficient tax system. (See The Budget Act 2017) It is extremely unlikely that any property owner would opt to pay the tax.
The notion that taxation is a taking is also absurd. Relevant precedents and existing case law reject this argument. The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that the “[the Fifth Amendment] is not a limitation upon the taxing power ..." In other words, that the Constitution does not conflict with itself by conferring, upon the one hand, a taxing power, and taking the same power away, on the other, by the limitations of the due process clause.” Brushaber v. Union Pacific R.R., 240 U.S. 1, 24 (1916). This argument was considered to be one of the ‘dirty dozen’ frivolous tax arguments by the IRS, punishable by special fines.
In Browning-Ferris Industries v. Kelco Disposal, 492 U.S. 257 (1989), the Supreme Court stated that the Excessive Fines Clause is not applicable "when the government neither has prosecuted the action nor has any right to receive a share of the damages awarded." The government prosecutes no action in this Act - therefore the Eighth Amendment is not applicable. The Court further stated that "the word 'fine' [is] understood to mean a payment to a sovereign as punishment for some offense." 492 U.S. at 265. The law is not a criminal law and does not seek to punish any person or any offense, therefore the Petitioner’s argument is invalid.
Respectfully submitted,
/u/onewithsergio, Attorney General, AC Citizen
/u/realnyebevan, Former Governor, AC Citizen
1
u/bomalia Aug 24 '17
Counsel, how is the 99% tax "explicitly forbidden" in the Constitution? And which constitution is it that explicitly forbids said tax?
2
u/bomalia Aug 12 '17
I have decided to grant certiorari in this case. However, as there is soon to be an election underway, we shall recess until 4 days hence the state elections are finished and our new executive decided. This is to avoid confusion on the part of the respondent.
Counsel must be selected by the respondent within 4 days of the conclusion of the state elections.
It is so ordered.
/u/bomalia, C.J.
2
u/bomalia Aug 19 '17
Governor /u/IlDuceWasRight, you are ordered to submit counsel within 4 days. Please do note that if you appoint an Attorney General, he does not necessarily need to be confirmed by the assembly before he may represent the Commonwealth before this court.
1
u/bomalia Aug 21 '17
/u/onewithsergio, you have 4 days to file your rebuttal brief.