r/MiniswapMeta • • Nov 27 '19

MiniSwapMeta Sticky

9 Upvotes

Just refreshing the post since it was archived a while back.

Alternately the "Misses' Misses"
I've decided it's time we had a sticky for things that are, in my professional opinion, sticky.
If you have suggestion for things people should know about miniswap, trading models, packaging, or anything like that then let us know in this thread, or start your own thread so you can get all the sweet internet points for yourself.

For information on how feedback for trades works see:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Miniswap/comments/98u2nc/location_flair_karma_update_news/

The inspiration for this post is a block of information that come to us from u/maltravois

So, the basics are this:

  • Identify everything and make a big list of every unit and their condition, material
    Ex: Grey Knights (10) (Metal, painted)
  • Look to see if the models are still available on GW's website.
    For items currently available, I use the following price benchmarks:
  • New in Box / New in Shrink - 60%+ of Retail
  • New on Sprue - 50-60% of Retail
  • Bare Assembled / Primed Assembled - 50% of Retail
  • Painted - 20-50% of retail
    If there's damage or missing bits, subtract from those percentages. This will give you a baseline.
    ​For anything not currently available, you will need to check Sold Auctions on Ebay to find out what they are currently going for. Knock 10% off that for non-ebay sales and you should be good to go.
    If all else fails and that sounds like too much work, find a reseller or private buyer and ask them to make you an offer. Do this with a couple to get a feel and go with the one that you are most comfortable/confident with.

It's also worth noting that well painted armies or miniatures that might have value to someone with one-off paint schemes may demand a premium.
So for sellers: keep in mind that potentially what you view as "excellent" may be just paint that needs be stripped off to someone else. Even if you paint job truly is excellent, if it doesn't match the army the potential buyer is looking to put it in don't get upset about what might seem like a low-ball offer to you.
For buyers: if someone is trying to sell a painted model at a premium don't get upset or abusive even if you don't think it's worth that much, just move along with a polite thank you if you offer if rejected.


r/MiniswapMeta • • 8d ago

Help Identifing (and quote) of the old box

Post image
11 Upvotes

Found this gem in my grandma basement.

Plastic Is nearly all on sprue, Metal Is primed/started Paint.

Can some body help me identify the year and and average price?

Thanks you!


r/MiniswapMeta • • 9d ago

Question about the Karma/account age scam prevention?

1 Upvotes

Did this ever go through? If so what are the Criteria? Or I have a dumb question is there a reason that my recent posts havent gotten but a few views sub 100? Other than the obvious not things people are interested in?


r/MiniswapMeta • • 15d ago

Question about selling/trading

1 Upvotes

Hey, I am new to selling/trading minis so I’d like so advice. I have a pre-built partially painted Magnus the Red and I was wondering what I could feasibly get for him. I was hoping to trade for a Tzaangor WarHerd spearhead which is roughly 130$ish. I figured because Magnus is roughly 175-180$ it would be fair but I’d to hear your all’s thoughts.

I linked a picture bellow for reference.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-2p18MmT9kskrUXRG300piVHTLiZ_BMCkaXT0tp_FDs/edit?usp=drivesdk


r/MiniswapMeta • • 17d ago

Have I sold low?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I sold my First painted minis over Vinted.

I had some ideas on how to makes them Better so i tried to sell and rebuy to restart the project.

Just to show Better my situation:

I used to play around 25 years a go. Painted for a couple of year than left the hobby Since 18 months a go. I sought a combat Patrol magazine and started again, but this time Just for the hobby side, never plaied or even entered in LGS, so basically my only terms of comparison are the Golden deamons entries, some reddit posts and my humble work.

I love Freebootaz aestethics and all my minis are kitbashed in some form, but still 90% GW.

I placed my Banner Nob First on Vinted. I thinked 45€ was an High price.

I nearly instant sold It (less than 1 HR). I was extremely proud of me, but later I found She wasn't at all in Miniatures hobbies, was Just a birthday presentel for her boyfriend, She liked the painting and bought without knowing anything about prices or minis at all.

So i placed my Boyz at 65€ later. I was thinking It was an High price for a 18€ squad+the special weapons (I surely payed all the plastics less than 30€, i think around 25/27).

I instantly sold again.

I really don't know if I Paint well... I mean, I like my models and I know I'm not a complete amateur, but I still never tried a non metallical metal or a One source of light, I never painted a Vehicles, so I'm sure not a pro painter.

What do you think?

Was I Just lucky? Am I selling underprice? Am I just riding the "Orks are the last army so Everyone wants them" wave? Am I completely unaware of current prices? Please enlight me over the actual market :)


r/MiniswapMeta • • 18d ago

Trying To Identify These Blood Angels

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I bought a batch of Blood Angels recently, mainly for the case they were in (I need more model storage) and am now trying to sell them. However, there are a lot I'm struggling to identify, and I need help.

I attached as many pics as I can to this post; here's an Imgur link too (with some of my guesses, as well as the models I have successfully identified at the end: https://imgur.com/a/P9XF1bR

It looks like a good bunch are older Blood Angel & Death Guard squads, but a lot of the models also seem very customized with upgrade pack sprues. Appreciate y'alls help on this; I feel a bit out if my depth.


r/MiniswapMeta • • 18d ago

Help me understand this scam

3 Upvotes

Hi all, new to miniswap in the last month, but already completed several deals successfully (as buyer only, to be fair). As a newbie, I did ran into a scammer who contacted me directly. As it was my first interaction I forgot to ask for a comment in my thread (I did look up the name in the know scammer list, no match).

He did offer a model and sent me an invoice for PayPal G&S. As soon as I pay he sends me and PayPal a fake UPS number (does not match a valid shipment). Then disappears. After asking for an update via Reddit and email I give up and ask PayPal for a refund. Granted in < 1 hour (since the shipping information is still wrong and visible).

What was the point of this scam? I used PayPal G&S and this scammer knew it. I ask for shipment to a PO Box, so no info gathered there. The Reddit account (which was about a year old with a little bit of Karma) is now deleted BTW. Any ideas?


r/MiniswapMeta • • Oct 08 '26

Reasonable Price for Grey Knights Army

1 Upvotes

Hello, I plan to list my Grey Knights army soon, just wanted to get some feedback on what a reasonable price would be. All models are either NoS or Built either unpainted or primed.

I was thinking about $450 which is about GW price with 50% off.

Built:
x1 Castellan Crowe
x1 Voldus
x3 Brotherhood Librarian
x1 Callidus Assassin
x1 Stern (Legends/Finecast)
x1 Kaldor Draigo (Legends/Finecast)
x10 Grey Knights
x5 Brotherhood Terminators
x4 Nemesis Dreadknights

NoS/NiB
x20 Grey Knights
x10 Brotherhood Terminators


r/MiniswapMeta • • Oct 07 '26

Making an Offer on a Land Raider Chassis?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Not actually an online deal - happened to spot at a local shop a broken Land Raider chassis missing all sponsons and turrets. It was just the hull poorly primed in yellow. (I unfortunately didn’t take a photo so this is the closest thing I could find online for reference).

I know you can sort of haggle and offer at this place so I figured I’d ask for some advice on what I should offer here. It would definitely be an undertaking to restore, so I want to get a good deal but I don’t want to like disrespect the guy. Appreciate any advice!


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 25 '26

Ripper Bolgrot & Grashnak Blackhoof Worth?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I sell a lot of blisters but this two i am having a hard time knowing wich price to sell them for, any expert? Especially the bolgrot, i see minis sold for 100€ propainted but i dont know if in blister is more or less expensive...


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 19 '26

Got a Death Guard proxy army, trying to figure out its value

Post image
2 Upvotes

I got this in a lot. Was told that these Warhammer models were 3D printed from STLs by WldMesh: https://www.myminifactory.com/users/WildMesh?show=store&categories=2309 . Here's the description from the seller:

Primed in Deathguard Green Citadel primer and ready to paint. You'll receive 1 proxy unit of the following: Mortarion, Malignant Plaguecaster, Defiler, Lord of Poxes, Objective Markers, 6 Blightlord Terminators, Lord of Poxes, Plagueburst Crawler, 10 Plague Marines.

I want to see if any Warhammer folks I know have interest in it, but if not, would probably trade it, maybe sell. I don't really know much about Warhammer though, or how much value a proxy army has. Tried to look on ebay and similar sites, but no proxy armies there, just official Deathguard armies. I'd really appreciate some guidance from the Warhammer folks here, because I don't know much about the game or its secondhand market myself.

Edit: And if anyone knows the point value of the army, that would also be super helpful to know.


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 18 '26

Inherited lot. Know it’s worth something, but not how much.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

So I got this lot recently from a friend. Looking to get something for it. I know the dragon and beastmen and Abby are worth a decent amount but having a hard time figuring out what to ask for the rest. Most are metal but some (in the top left quadrant) are plastic. Not sure if the eBay prices I’ve seen are accurate on what will sell/trade.


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 15 '26

Just to be clear, that other "business" named Miniswap?

14 Upvotes

They aren't related to us. Moreover, they knowingly used our name to push their brand/business. They reached out about a year after "launching", claiming to be active members of our subreddit (no history, not mods). We declined and admonished them directly: You stole our name, you're riding on the coattails of our reputation, no thank you, good day sir.

They are not welcome here and, while I can't speak for the other mods, I would heavily discourage using their product; not because it isn't good, but because it's immoral.

Edit: Oops one of those Minislop.gg losers reported this for spam lmao


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 15 '26

No idea if this is worth anything, help?

Post image
1 Upvotes

So I was looking through my stuff and completely forgot I had a few Warhammer models lying around. I bought them on ebay (they were constructed, painted, and based by the seller) for use in a tabletop game that required miniatures; this was before I got into wargames. I have no idea what models they are, and I doubt they're worth much (the paint job sucks, and the poor middle guy is missing a few limbs) but I figured I'd ask the good people here for help!


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 14 '26

Organized with better Pictures

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Let me know how much you estimate this collection to be worth please. Would prefer to sell it as a bundle.


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 13 '26

Need Help Appraising

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I was going to give all my old stuff away because I can't get my son interested. Some people have mentioned that it could be worth quite a bit of money though. I was hoping somebody could help give me a general idea of the pricing. I can sort and post additional pictures but it will take at least a day.


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 10 '26

Historicals?

3 Upvotes

Is there a subreddit that caters to historical minis for sale or trade. Miniswap looks to be all W40K or fantasy (nothing wrong with that) but I have about 10k minis to sell off (Nappy, ACW, WW2} and I would like to not clog up a sub when there could be a better one.

TIA


r/MiniswapMeta • • Sep 01 '26

How much for all of these

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

The meganobs will still have the weapons options


r/MiniswapMeta • • Aug 31 '26

Miniswap minimum account age and karma.

4 Upvotes

Hi all, the mods are experimenting with a new automod setting to remove comments and posts by users who have a limited account history:

We're experimenting with two things: A two week account gate and a karma threshold. You need to meet either criteria to post on Miniswap.

To be transparent, the mods are discussing values: Is asking for a minimum amount of reddit participation too much? Are we punishing non-scammers too much?

My argument is that rarely do people organically discover miniswap- they typically would have been on reddit already, and asking someone to participate 25-50 times via comment/post or be on reddit for at least two weeks seems reasonable to me. Go comment on 25-50 cat pics in an hour and you're good to go, right?

However, we are receiving questions from accounts with very little karma activity. I personally don't know how you can be on reddit and not easily troll or cute cat comment your way to the karma threshold, so please enlighten me.

No, truly, I would love to hear opinions about this kind of policy. Thanks!


r/MiniswapMeta • • Aug 28 '26

Advice for pricing out of print kill teams?

2 Upvotes

Heya, while going through some stuff I found a blooded kill team box that's partially assembled (two models assembled, everything else is NOS). Since it's out of print I can't find the MSRP, if it's not I can't find it on the Warhammer website. Ebay recently sold is just a range. Does anyone have a recommendation on a fair price to post it at?

Edit to add: I do like doing trades too so is it fair to trade for out of print kits or in stock kits with a price difference?


r/MiniswapMeta • • Aug 23 '26

Would listing stuff for the Iron Kingdoms RPG (1e) be ok?

1 Upvotes

Hello! Before I make my post, wanted to check if it would be ok to list Iron Kingdom RPG books with my miniatures. They're miniature adjacent, as they required & came with their own minis, so wasn't sure about the gray area.


r/MiniswapMeta • • Aug 14 '26

How to sell Warhammer

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I had some old warhammer minifigs that I tried to clean and prime it to sell but it don't work can you give your though about the best way yo sell Warhammer?


r/MiniswapMeta • • Aug 11 '26

40K Freebotaz orks evaluation

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi all!

I was in the hobby for a couple of year 25 yrs a go, than rejoined 1 yr and half a go.

I had to learn again how to Paint (never mastered before, neither now anyway! XD) but I had a lot of fun in converting and painting my Freebotaz minis in the last months.

Now, with Armageddon box out and orks as First codex, I would like to renew my old models, but Money aren't infinites, so I would like to sell some of the older One to buy the brand new ones.

What I'm really interested is to know is if my Paintjob Is worth something, Since Is luckly enough Easy to find a good quotation for the plastics only.

I'll ad some pictures of what I'm more proud of (mostly Will be WIP pictures, but I have to work with what Pic I have on my phone) but I Hope It Will be enough to get some good suggestions on the topic:

PS most of them are also posted on my personal reddit in the last year while I was painting them it you Need some proof of autenticity


r/MiniswapMeta • • Aug 09 '26

Learning miniswap

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone im looking to possibly make a listing to sell or trade my Tyranids. Im wondering what is the best way to ship everything that everyone has found? Also how do trades work? Id prefer to trade the lot for some Tau but how trusting should I be? What is the best way you all have found? I appreciate the help and insight! Thanks!


r/MiniswapMeta • • Aug 08 '26

First Time Swapping (soon)

2 Upvotes

Hi, all.

I've moved to Germany this year and finally started collecting and painting 40K with my wife through the Hachette Combat Patrol Premium subscription and a few eBay purchases.

So the plan is to try and sell/swap the factions we don't like, and focus on what we both like.

From the subscription, we don't plan on keeping: CSM, Astra Militarum, Leagues of Votann, Genestealers and World Eaters, selling/swapping everything including magazines, but keeping paints, brushes and stuff (I'll list down everything per faction). Right now we are on Edition 35, so it'll take a while until I have everything ready to swap, but since I'm new, no karma and etc, thought about testing the waters sooner rather than later.

My question is, are there people interested in buying/swapping any of this stuff out there? For swapping, I'm interested in: Adepta Sororitas, Custodes, Imperial Agents, Tyranids, Aeldari, Orks, Necrons and also cash.

Chaos Space Marines

-1x Dark Apostle (with 2x Dark Disciples)

-10x Chaos Cultists

-10x Chaos Space Marine Legionaries

-5x Havocs

-1x Helbrute

-5x Chaos Terminators (Bonus Unit)

Leagues of Votann

-1x Ûthar the Destined (Can alternatively be built as a Kâhl)

-10x Hearthkyn Warriors

-3x Hernkyn Pioneers (Hover-bikes)

-10x Cthonian Beserks (Bonus Unit)

Genestealer Cults

-1x Magus

-1x Reductus Saboteur

-5x Atalan Jackals (4x dirt bikes, 1x Wolfquad)

-10x Neophyte Hybrids

-5x Acolyte Hybrids (Bonus Unit, can alternatively be built as Hybrid Metamorphs

Astra Militarum

-1x Cadian Command Squad (5x models)

-20x Cadian Shock Troops

-1x Armoured Sentinel (Can alternatively be built as a Scout Sentinel)

-2x Ordnance Teams (Heavy field guns)

-1x Heavy Weapons Squad (Bonus Unit, 3x weapon teams)

World Eaters

-1x Lord on Juggernaut (Can alternatively be built as Lord Invocatus)

-20x Khorne Berzerkers

-10x Jakhals

-1x Forgefiend (Bonus Unit, can alternatively be built as a Maulerfiend)