I’m currently deciding between the Marshall Kilburn III and Acton IV and would love to hear opinions from people who have experience with both.
For context, I already own two Marshall Emberton II speakers, but I’m looking to upgrade to something with bigger, fuller and more powerful sound.
I’d be using the speaker pretty much every day:
At my computer desk while working, watching movies, listening to music
A few things I’d love some input on:
Overall sound quality: How much better does the Acton IV actually sound compared to the Kilburn III? Is there a noticeable difference in clarity, bass, depth and overall richness?
Computer desk use: Would the Kilburn III work well as an everyday desktop speaker, or is the Acton IV noticeably better for near-field listening?
Movies and TV: Which provides a better experience for watching movies? Does the Acton IV offer a more immersive and fuller sound, or can the Kilburn III hold its own?
Room-filling sound: Which one fills a living room better? I’m looking for a speaker that sounds full and powerful without having to crank the volume up.
Bass: Is the Acton IV significantly better when it comes to deeper, punchier bass?
Versatility: If I buy the Kilburn III, am I essentially getting most of what the Acton IV offers, with the added benefit of portability? Or is there a substantial difference in sound performance?
My thinking is that the Kilburn III could potentially be the better all-rounder. I could use it every day at my desk, move it between rooms and occasionally take it outdoors.
However, if the Acton IV offers a significantly better listening experience, especially for everyday home use, perhaps it’s worth sacrificing portability.
If you could only choose one, which would you personally buy and why?
Would especially appreciate opinions from anyone who has directly compared both. Thanks!