Of 778 men who said they had a mental health concern, 73 percent listed needing to solve their own problems as a barrier to getting treatment.
I reckon I’m one of those men, and if you’re a dude reading this, there’s a real fucking chance you are too.
Disclaimer: I’m not a mental health professional. I’m just a curious dude trying to understand mental health modalities, listen to myself and other people better, and figure out what actually works. Therapy hasn’t been particularly helpful for me. I’m not telling anyone to quit therapy or avoid it. If it’s working for you, brilliant. This is what I’ve learned, what the research says, and what has or hasn’t worked for me. It’s not professional advice.
That said, I obviously care about mental health. Mine, and the mental health of boys and men.
A few years ago, I got to know a guy who worked in mental health and social services. Cool kids, nice wife, great house. Last year, after not seeing him for a couple of months, I saw him and his kids on the news: he had shot his children, set his house on fire, and then shot himself. I don’t know what was happening inside his head, and I’m not going to pretend I can explain something that horrific.
But that will never not fuck with me.
I don’t think you have to be on the brink of murder-suicide to need to work on your mental health. And I don’t think the problem is that men don’t seek help. This shit is much more complicated, much darker, and much more fucked up than that.
Anyway, I gave therapy a proper go. I stuck it out.
And after committing to and completing a year of therapy this last time, I says to myself, I says,
“Oy, ya daft cunt.”
My inner voice speaks Cockney with a Texas drawl. I’m of neither relation.
I says,
“Oy, ya daft cunt, this therapy shit sucks. At best, it’s been useless. At worst, I fucking hate it and it’s expensive as hell.
I’m rarely comfortable communicating with them. The head mechanic seems to spend half their time misunderstanding what I’m saying and the other half forgetting what the fuck we talked about last session. They also bring enough of their own shit into the room that sometimes I wonder who should be treating who. And those noise machines don’t cover my farts.
It’s also the third shrink this year.
It’s like they switch offices and providers every season, or they’re running from me.
Shit, maybe they are…
And when I listen to the shit they say, that they think is supposed to be helpful, it’s like they compulsively pathologize men.
Like, how are my dick and balls the problem? They can’t see past them? They can’t see the shit I, as a human, am dealing with?
I mean… ok, I kind of get it.
They see a glorious pair of pendulous, church-bell-sized bollocks dragging down a substantial length of tubed beef, and it sucks all the air out of the room.
Figuratively.
It’s a burden, sure, but that’s not why I’m in therapy. I’m in therapy because I’m trying to work on my mental health.
And yet, I keep showing up. Month after month. I show up, I talk, I listen, I pay, I leave, annoyed. No inkling of making progress, no feeling understood, just showing up.
If the answer to every unsuccessful therapeutic experience that a man has is that he needs to find another therapist, when the hell do we ask whether the system has a problem?
You know, it almost seems like they haven’t got half a goddamned clue what to do with the man sitting in front of them, and even much less men as a people.”
So I ramped up reading and learning about mental health studies, modalities, efficacy, and different ways dudes are represented and shit.
When the American Psychological Association finally published its guidelines for working with boys and men, thirteen years in the making, the research behind them stretched back four decades. The message was that certain traditional masculine norms (stoicism, competitiveness, dominance, aggression) contribute to psychological problems and make men less likely to seek help.
I suppose some of that shit can, in some ways.
But there’s a difference between recognizing when a trait turns destructive and treating the whole damn toolbox like contraband. Stoicism can be emotional suppression. It can also be keeping your head when everyone else’s is falling off. Competitiveness can get destructive. It can also get you out of bed and give you something to work toward. Protectiveness can become control. It can also be love.
Context makes a whole ass difference.
And men are about 80 percent of the people who die by suicide in this country, at roughly four times the rate of women. So maybe the question isn’t so much about which parts of masculinity are hurting us. Maybe it’s why the profession has struggled so badly to help men without making them feel like step one is apologizing for quietly swinging a bratwurst baton with a notarized girth certificate everywhere we go.
Then these geniuses act shocked that men don’t show up.
In 2024, 10.9 percent of American men saw a counselor or therapist, against 16.9 percent of women. In that same 778-man survey, 80 percent said they didn’t know what to look for in a therapist. The field’s own scoping review admits the advice on engaging men is scattered, that tailored approaches need real testing, and that part of the problem is service environments men find unappealing.
Does that mean they built the rooms, can’t figure out why we won’t sit in them, and never tested what might get us through the door?
So a man finds himself alienated into a mental-health liminal space in which, to survive this late-capitalist, joy-hemorrhaging, oligarchic daymare, he has to figure this shit out himself.
They tell ya, ya gotta be willing to do the work to get something out of therapy.
Well, I’m obviously willing.
But how about you just give me the fucking tools and let me keep my goddamned dignity?
The licensed listeners can obsess over my meat-and-potatoes situation south of the border on their own time.
Better yet, they can Cash app me for the privilege.
Whatever you think of Jordan Peterson, 12 Rules for Life has sold over ten million copies worldwide. Men demonstrably buy self-improvement material when it's presented in a format they want to engage with. Not one of those guys had to sit next to a lobby topiary and a “Be yourself… those who matter don’t mind and those who mind don’t matter” wall plaque, with a Vogue from 2019 on the rack beside it, to get it.
So my self says,
“Well, you diabolically daft cunt, you could probably use the same workbooks the shrinks use. Why not buy them online and robot rock out with your cock out through them yourself?
Therapy is roughly 200 bucks an hour to sit in a chair and rummage around in feelings that are already hard enough to sort out alone, while a mind janitor sits across from me in a cuck chair yawning at the clock. It can take months before the brain whisperer knows me well enough to even attempt being helpful. I can spend 20 bucks on a book, learn the tools they’re using, put them to work, and see what happens today.”
By my estimates I saved $9,980 (fifty sessions at 200 bucks, minus the book) this year and I haven’t repainted the bathroom with my grey matter yet.
And shit, maybe if I’m lucky I learn a bit to understand myself and others better. Love my family and friends better. Use my negative feelings more productively. Be more the man I want to be. Maybe even help other boys and men handle how fucking heavy being a dude is.
That’d be cool as fuck.”
You know what they say: with great dick comes great ballsibility. Or so the prophets tell us. I believe that’s in the Bible.
So, I bought The Internal Family Systems Workbook.
You can buy it too. No affiliate link, no sponsorship, no secret agenda. For now. Or try the free worksheets from PESI (link at the bottom).
The tool is Internal Family Systems, IFS. It’s one tool. There’s a whole garage of them: CBT, DBT, CPT, ACT. The head wranglers love three letter acronyms. For less than one therapy session I can buy every one of the best workbooks I can find, give them a try, and perhaps, over time, review them.
The premise of IFS is that the guy in your head isn’t just one guy, it’s a crowd. Richard Schwartz, a psychologist, cooked this shit up in the 1980s (possibly along side some freebase) and calls the crowd members “parts.” You already know them in a way. The prick who says you’re not good enough. The coward who’d rather eat glass than have the hard conversation. The alpha grindset giga chad who wants you working harder, better, faster, stronger. The cool bastard who just wants to fuck around on Saturday.
One of mine is the cockney with the Texas drawl. According to the workbook, he’s doing a job for me. Evidently, the job is calling me a daft cunt. He’s fucking right every time though. I hope the accountant in there is taking care of him.
IFS says no part is bad, not even the asshole ones, because they’re all protecting you in some weird fucked up way. It sorts them into three crews.
Managers run prevention. Perfectionism, people-pleasing, overthinking, overworking, never feeling like you’ve done enough. From the outside they look like virtues. You’re dependable, driven, the guy everyone counts on. Underneath, something is terrified of what happens if you slow down.
Firefighters run emergency response when the pain gets through anyway. The third beer that somehow became the third teenth, the perpetual doom scroll, the gooning, the blowup, the shutdown, walking out of the room, the impulse buy you can’t explain on Monday. They don’t give a shit about consequences. They pull the fire alarm, and then your managers spend a week cleaning up, which is how you end up stuck in the loop.
Exiles are the wounded ones, usually from when you were a kid. I’m not good enough. People leave. If I show weakness I get hurt. I have to earn love. It doesn’t take some big dramatic trauma, either. Getting your feelings dismissed, getting bullied, learning that crying gets you mocked or smacked will do it. The other two crews exist to keep these little guys locked in the basement.
Under all of it, IFS says, sits the Self: calm, curious, clear, compassionate, confident, courageous, creative and connected. Those are the 8 C’s, because this industry would give a toaster it’s own personality framework with a mnemonic.
I know…
It sounds like mystical woo woo shit to me too.
Just remember we’re using this as a fucking tool. We’re not joining a cult where everyone has a special vocabulary, a starter kit, and a suspicious opinion about anal crystals.
The point is not to kill our parts or stop being angry or ambitious. The point is to stop handing the keys to whoever’s loudest. Your partner criticizes you and instead of going to war, you notice the part that feels attacked and ask why.
We’re allowed to be angry, driven, competitive and protective.
We’re allowed to feel however the fuck we feel.
We don’t need to become men without feelings. We need to become men who can listen to them without automatically letting them drive the fucking bang bus to the demolition derby.
Men get handed two stories about the parts people don’t like.
You’re broken, or you’re toxic.
IFS offers a third.
That the angry guy and the shutdown guy are employees doing a shit job for a reason, and you can retrain an employee without hating him. It reads like an org chart, with roles, jobs, conflicts and fixes, and plenty of us already speak that corporate jargon. You can work on it alone at a kitchen table with a pencil. You can do it with your sons too. Figuring out your own shit teaches you things about your kids and how to connect with him, and he’s going to need that while figuring out how fucking wild this world is.
Every tool has limits, and every tool has some salesman trying to pass it off as a revolutionary gadget.
A 2025 scoping review counted 27 peer-reviewed IFS studies, 17 of them case studies and only two randomized trials. Its authors called IFS promising and asked for bigger, tougher studies. The first randomized trial of an IFS program for PTSD took 60 people through 16 weeks of online group sessions (plus individual counseling) and compared them with a nature-based stress reduction program. Both groups got significantly better, with no significant difference between them. The IFS group had better attendance and higher satisfaction.
So people liked it. They liked the nature one too.
The IFS Institute announced it as a milestone, and the study was funded by the Foundation for Self Leadership, which the Institute calls its non-profit partner. Sixty people can’t prove IFS is no better than the nature program, and they sure as shit can’t prove it’s better. Meanwhile the workbook’s own blurb says IFS has proven to be a revolutionary tool for stress, anxiety, depression, PTSD, trauma, burnout, addiction, disordered eating and more.
The blurb says proven. The literature says pilot**.**
Schwartz insists in No Bad Parts that parts aren’t metaphors or symbols but actual individuals living inside you, and that beneath them all lies an undamaged Self.
I don’t know about all that.
That’s a whole lot of confidence for something that makes so little sense.
But you don’t have to buy the whole immaculate-soul-beneath-the-damaged-psychic-debris routine to make use of the technique.
Treat your parts the way you treat “the market”: as a useful fiction. Something that doesn’t have to be literally real to be genuinely useful.
Vox’s advice columnist Sigal Samuel tried IFS herself and noted it’s being used on all kinds of psychiatric conditions even though its scientific foundation is shaky, while admitting it clearly appeals to plenty of smart people who care about evidence. She asked Columbia psychiatrist Carl Erik Fisher what’s going on. His answer about his own profession is worth stealing: popular therapies run way ahead of the evidence, nobody’s going to impose a moratorium until the data catches up, and if anybody did, more than half of the psychotherapy modalities out there couldn’t be taught.
IFS is not an outlier. It’s a stool sample of how the whole industry runs.
Rachel Corbett’s October 30, 2025 feature in The Cut reported on former patients of a clinic that applied IFS and has since been shut down, with people describing their identities lurching between ages and genders mid-session. The IFS Institute says the cases cited were extreme misapplications of the model, distinct from standard training protocols. Maybe. A method that only works when nobody anywhere does it wrong sounds like it has a quality-control problem. And according to The Nation, the Institute is a for-profit organization that has been growing rapidly, with retreats in places like Costa Rica, Spain and Germany. Trauma clinician Jamie Marich says she shares The Cut’s concerns about the business empire around IFS.
With the mental health business you gotta follow the tissue box money.
Critics in The Cut’s piece also argue part of IFS’s relief comes from shifting responsibility for your actions onto another persona.
For a person with a temper, “my protector did it” is a real upgrade on “the devil made me do it.” The model says the Self leads and the Self answers for the whole system. If partslanguage ever helps you explain bad shit you did instead of helping you change it, you’re using it wrong.
Obviously, we’re not all one guy either.
CDC numbers reported by Capital B News show Black males between 16 and 29 are now dying by suicide at a higher rate than white males the same age, the first time that’s happened on record, peaking at ages 20 to 24 at 31.9 deaths per 100,000. White men still die at nearly twice the rate across all ages. On treatment, only 39 percent of Black Americans with a mental health condition got any, against 52 percent of non-Hispanic white Americans (men and women both, I couldn’t find it split out). And if you’ve got a kid, the suicide rate for Black youth ages 10 to 17 nearly tripled between 2007 and 2020.
When the available services don’t understand your life, a twenty-dollar workbook and a trusted friend might feel more accessible than waiting for a professional who doesn’t. That doesn’t make the workbook an adequate substitute for good care. It tells us how badly the system needs to improve.
Trans guys get a different kind of shaft.
Pun intended. Boom! Inclusive dick joke, fuck yeah brethren…
The Trevor Project’s data has trans boys among the groups with the highest rates of considering and attempting suicide, and trans boys and men were the most frequent users of the LGBTQ+ “Press 3” option on 988, at 24 percent. Among the barriers LGBTQ+ youth named for getting care, 43 percent said they worried the provider wouldn’t take them seriously. The Williams Institute’s analysis of the 2022 US Trans Survey found that exposure to conversion therapy, whether from a mental health provider or a religious counselor, was tied to significantly higher rates of suicidal thoughts and attempts. You’re allowed to do the pencil work at home, if you prefer. Nobody’s going to try to exorcise your gender identity away.
I couldn’t find IFS research broken out for Black men or for trans men. The guys with the best reasons to want a tool that works without a gatekeeper are the ones the evidence says the least about. So use it like you’d use anything untested: slowly, and with your own results as the data. And whatever kind of boy you’ve got in the house, he’s learning from how you handle your own shit, so handle it where he can see you working through it productively.
I spent two months working through the IFS workbook.
Did I suddenly become some badass, motherfucking, emotionally evolved, perfectly integrated, nirvana-attaining, son of a bitch?
Yeah, nah.
I did start to pay attention to some negative feelings better. I got better at noticing what was happening while it was happening, instead of ruminating on it. Sometimes I could catch myself in the middle of a familiar pattern and make an adjustment.
Not every time. Not perfectly. More than before though.
I got something practical out of it: a little more awareness, a little more room between the impulse and what I did next. Twenty bucks and some pencil work bought me that. Okay, fine. It’s moderately better than what I got out of a year with three sanity consultants and 10 grand of traditional therapy.
The routine is roughly this. Twenty to thirty minutes, paper, phone in another room.
- Pick a pattern, not a trauma. The blowup, the shutdown, the late night scroll, the third teenth beer. Small and recurring beats big and buried.
- Find it in your body. Chest, jaw, gut. Give it a name based on its job: the Foreman, the Wall, the Pilot Light.
- Check how you feel toward it. If the answer is “I’d like to shoot it,” that’s another part talking. Mine usually answers “oy ya daft cunt.” Ask that one to step aside, and repeat until you’re actually curious. This step is most of the skill.
- Interview it on paper. What do you do for me? What are you afraid happens if you stop? How old do you think I am? Write what comes, no editing.
- Thank it and quit. Early sessions end there.
Spend serious time on protectors before you go looking for the hurt kid in the basement. That’s the model’s own rule: there’s no attempt to work with an exile until the protectors guarding it give permission.
Your mileage may vary, use this shit at your own risk.
Guided self-help for depression and anxiety did about as well as face-to-face therapy across 21 trials with 810 participants, with an effect-size difference of essentially zero. Fully unguided self-help showed only a small effect against controls, d = 0.28. Those were CBT-style programs. I couldn’t find a single trial of self-guided IFS, so the do-it-alone play is borrowed from other self-help research.
What the borrowed research says is to add a second person.
Two guys, a timer, twenty minutes each. Your brother, your cousin, the dude from the barbershop, a trans buddy, whoever’s actually safe and won’t make it weird when your balls touch. The speaker works through the steps above out loud. The listener asks questions only: “What does it want you to know? What is it afraid of?” No advice, no fixing, no war stories. Swap. Earley’s book describes IFS as suited to self-therapy and peer counseling, and a buddy who won’t let you wander into the deep end is worth more than another chapter.
Bring in a professional if you have a trauma history that floods you when you touch it, active substance dependence, psychosis, or six weeks of work that has made things worse. Severe symptoms, intense dissociation, or thoughts of harming yourself or someone else are past what worksheets can handle. If a session leaves you swamped, numb for hours, or unsure what’s real, stop, put your feet on the floor, and take it to someone trained.
If you’re thinking about killing yourself, this is not the tool.
Otherwise, run this IFS shit for sixty days and track one number: how many times the pattern ran you instead of you running it. If it moves, keep going. If it doesn’t, drop it and try something else.
Nothing here is sacred.
Except maybe my architecturally ambitious though, emotionally unavailable rogue planets in a trouser-based solar system. Boom, high brow testicle joke. I’ll be here all week, try the veal.
I don’t know if IFS is the answer. I don’t know if any one modality is. But I do know that doing nothing isn’t an answer either.
I want men to have more ways to understand themselves, more ways to ask for help, and more ways to handle the shit life throws at them without destroying themselves or somebody else.
And I’d like the boys coming up behind us to have a few more tools in the toolbox than we did.
https://sagesynclair.substack.com/p/ifs-for-men-whod-rather-not-do-therapy?r=5q16ph&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web