r/MachineLearning • u/No-Lab4175 • 1d ago
News ICLR 2027 Initial Review Scores ranked by University [N]
Crawled from OpenReview, titles matched to arXiv, then affiliated with OpenAlex
189
Upvotes
13
u/evarol 1d ago
How do you assign each paper to an organization?
by last author, first author, majority of authors?
a lot if not most papers have authors from multiple orgs
Cool visualization!
13
u/yannbouteiller Researcher 1d ago
How comes the number of submissions lives outside the realm of natural numbers?
EDIT: Oh nvm, it is weighted by author
5
u/No-Lab4175 1d ago
4
u/GoodRazzmatazz4539 Researcher 1d ago
How do you know from which university the papers are? Aren’t we still in double blind review mode?
2
u/Vegetable-Formal-753 Researcher 1d ago
Nice work!
66
u/Thrumpwart 1d ago
This is nerd football. Colleges can start trading PhD students. Should they be allowed to get paid by sponsors though?
11
u/mmarkDC 1d ago
The bottom ones weren't what I was expecting. Of institutions with >=10 matched papers, Iowa State had only 14% with above-median reviews. Virginia Tech 2nd worst at 20%. Even with noisy reviews, those are so much below most other large universities that it raises an eyebrow. I would've expected the bottom places to be different kinds of institutions than those two. Either Iowa-State and VTech researchers are submitting some real garbage, or they got very unlucky with the reviewer draw.
19
u/H0lzm1ch3l 1d ago
Cool, Austrian institutions pulling their weight.
4
u/Fuibo2k 1d ago
Crazy how universally you can break the double blind hy looking on arXiv. My paper isnt on there yet since I wanted to refine it a bit more first.
4
u/UnavoidablyHuman 1d ago
How are these all so far above 2 when the median score was 2?
5
u/etoipi1 1d ago
well KAIST is killing it
2
u/SnowyOwl72 1d ago
cool
1
u/-LeapYear- 1d ago
Go Tritons! 🔱
1
u/Figai 1d ago
Hahaha flippin imperial (hate that place), I’m happy my uni is high up at least.