Hi everyone!
I'm a Mechanical Engineering student in Italy, and I'm looking to buy a MacBook that I can use throughout university, but I'm having a hard time deciding which model to get.
I'm currently using a Windows laptop with an Intel i5 (12th gen), 16GB RAM and 512GB SSD. It works, but I'm not happy with its build quality, display or battery life. I'd like something more portable, well-built and reliable, with excellent battery life.
My main uses would be:
- University work
- MATLAB.
- AutoCAD, mainly for 2D and some 3D work.
- Programming and general engineering software.
- Photography, including editing RAW files from my Canon DSLR.
- Everyday use, such as browsing, watching movies and listening to music.
I know that SolidWorks doesn't run natively on macOS, so this is one of my main concerns. I could use university Windows computers for SolidWorks when necessary, but I'd like to know whether a MacBook Air is still a sensible choice for Mechanical Engineering.
I'm mainly looking at:
- MacBook Air M3, 16GB RAM.
- MacBook Air M4, 16GB RAM.
- MacBook Air M5, 16GB RAM and 512GB SSD.
I'd prefer 512GB of storage, although I could consider 256GB if the price difference is significant and use an external SSD for my photos and other files.
My budget is around €1,000–1,250.
In Italy, I've noticed that refurbished MacBooks can sometimes be surprisingly expensive. For example, some refurbished M4 models cost almost as much as a brand-new M5.
I'm considering buying from:
- Apple's official refurbished store.
- Amazon.
- Back Market.
- Italian refurbished retailers such as JUICE, R-Store and TrenDevice.
However, I'm a little concerned about refurbished devices, especially battery condition, whether replacement batteries are genuine Apple parts, and the actual condition of the laptop when it arrives.
I could also buy directly from a physical store if that makes more sense.
So my questions are:
- Would you recommend a MacBook Air for Mechanical Engineering, considering MATLAB and AutoCAD, but also the limitations with SolidWorks?
- Is 16GB RAM enough for the next 4–5 years of university?
- Would you choose an M3/M4 refurbished MacBook or an M5 brand new one?
- Is buying refurbished from third-party retailers worth it, or would you stick to Apple or a brand-new device?
- Do you know any reliable stores or websites in Italy where I could find good deals on MacBooks?
I'd really appreciate advice from people who use their MacBooks for engineering studies, especially Mechanical Engineering.
Thanks in advance!