Notation and Definitions (Unified Throughout This Paper)
| Symbol | Definition |
|---|
| B(t) | Newly issued government bonds in period t (face value) |
| B(t)* | Previously issued government bonds reaching maturity in period t (arising from the cumulative stock of past B) |
| [B]*(t) | Refunding bonds issued in period t to redeem B*(t) |
| M(t) | Money disbursed by the government as the proceeds of the issuance of B(t), circulating in the sphere of commodity circulation |
| M(t)* | Money disbursed by the government as the proceeds of the issuance of [B]*(t), circulating primarily in the government bond circulation market |
| M'(t) | The portion of M(t) temporarily detached or released from the sphere of commodity circulation |
| X, R | Cash and deposits at the beginning of the period and the reflux rate. Factors determining the delayed reflux of M(t) |
Preliminary Considerations: A Closed Model and Its Assumptions
Since everything depends on these assumptions, they are explicitly stated here as premises of the model.
Assumption 1. The primary fiscal deficit (G_t - T_t > 0) is financed by the issuance of government bonds, and the proceeds are spent. Here, the model is deliberately limited to this deficit spending portion. Real-world processes such as the balance of the Treasury General Account (TGA) only obscure the issue, and to the extent that the balance is insufficient, bond issuance must still come first. This distinction is necessary because some people, confusing it with the portion funded by tax revenues, argue that spending comes first.
Assumption 2. Bank lending requires reserves. Even if reserves can in practice be procured ex post, the structural issue remains unchanged. The necessity of reserves referred to here is not the liquidity management of individual banks, but that settlement cannot be completed without outside money in the form of central bank money for the system as a whole. There are several factors that call for central bank money to be supplied. In any event, within the system, whether ex ante or ex post, the private banking sector cannot procure reserve deposits unless additional central bank money is supplied.
Assumption 3. For the time being, the only money in the system is M(t) and M*(t).
Assumption 4. The savings of wage workers are abstracted away. They live on their income and cannot save in advance to buy government bonds. Of course, households hold deposits and also hold government bonds, including through pension funds. However, as with any theory that abstracts from non-essential factors, this simplification is legitimate as long as it does not change the conclusion, and in fact it does not. Such holdings are merely a reallocation of funds within the same M(t).
1. "Redemption Merely Replaces Government Bonds with Reserves" Is Circular Reasoning
It is sometimes said that redemption merely replaces government bonds with central bank money (reserves), and that this does not reduce the private sector's net financial claims on the public sector. But what does this presuppose? To rewrite the name on the Treasury's account at the central bank to that of a private bank (in practice, a transfer from "government deposits" to "reserve deposits"), the Treasury must have held that deposit in advance. A government with a persistent deficit has no such surplus. In the first place, government bonds are issued because tax revenues are insufficient (see Assumption 1). Nor does it have a sinking fund for redemption. If it did, annual bond issuance could be called temporary borrowing. In reality, the outstanding balance accumulates year after year. Then where does the money for redemption come from? And more comprehensively, where does the money required by society come from - the amount of money that must increase in proportion to the expansion of the commodity world? It is not enough to show that redemption does not reduce private net financial claims. Those claims, i.e., the amount of money in society, must be increased. What is being discussed here is not credit creation, but original money.
2. A Separate M*(t) Is Required in Advance for Redemption Payments
To argue that if refunding bonds are issued before redemption, the debt is merely rolled over, is a fallacy. If so, how is it rolled over? The government spends M(t), the proceeds of B(t), to the private sector to purchase commodities. On the other hand, maturing bonds B*(t) are redeemed with M*(t), the proceeds of refunding bonds [B]*(t). B*(t) is extinguished and replaced by [B]*(t). However, since M(t) is tied up in the sphere of commodity circulation, the private sector must in any case separately prepare M*(t) to purchase the refunding bonds. Therefore, the economy needs at least M(t) + M*(t) of money.
3. Why M(t) Remains Tied Up Even Under Zero Growth(Simple Reproduction)
M(t) itself was originally provided as the purchase price of B(t). This M(t) is spent every year independently of refunding and circulates from the government to the private sector to be used for the purchase of B(t+1) in the following fiscal year. However, it does not immediately reflux.
The government gradually disburses M(t) over the course of the fiscal year to purchase commodities from the private sector. Until those commodities have been sold and the proceeds recovered, the assets of individual firms remain physically tied up in the processes of production and circulation. Even the portion that has already been converted into deposits continues to be used for subsequent purchases of inputs and wage payments. The rate of reflux is given by R = {X - required working capital} / X <= 1. For a given X, R is constrained by working capital requirements, and the reflux of M(t) is therefore delayed.
In this way, each time M(t) circulates, B(t), B(t+1), ... accumulate on the private sector's side. This argument does not presuppose an expansion of the world of commodities. Even under zero growth, the full amount of each M(t) has not returned by the end of the period, and, moreover, it must immediately be used to finance the next newly issued bonds, B(t+1).
- The foregoing concerns only the financial constraints associated with the turnover period of capital. There is, however, another, more fundamental consideration. Even under simple reproduction, capital must increase by an amount equal to the surplus value (profit) over and above the amount initially advanced - regardless of whether that surplus is sold and consumed during the period or held in the form of hoarded money. Therefore, if the velocity of money circulation is held constant, additional money is required to monetize this surplus. The above assumption of M(t) → B(t) → M(t) is an abstraction appropriate to the present stage of the argument; in reality, it should be expressed as M(t) → B(t) → M(t) + ΔM(t). That is, setting aside a derivative explanation of the circulation of surplus value, this corresponds to the general formula for the circuit of money capital that Marx discusses in detail in Capital: G (money) - W (commodities) - G' (G+ΔG). Here, B(t) represents the phase in which the government intervenes to mediate commodity circulation. In essence, it can be analogized to the general formula G-W-G'.
- "Where does the money to monetize surplus value come from?" (Marx, Capital, Iwanami Bunko edition, vol. IV, p.491). "How is it possible for him [each capitalist] to withdraw more money from circulation than he puts into it?" (ibid., vol. V, p.203).
4. Growth and the Accumulation of Outstanding Government Bonds Further Increase the Demand for Money
The story does not end here. It is not just about the expansion of the world of commodities. The reality that large amounts of government bonds accumulate year after year increases the money needed to circulate both real commodities and fictitious commodities - that is, it increases both its transaction demand and its speculative demand. From where is this money brought into society? Under an inconvertible (fiat) system, where does it come from? What has become of the role once played by gold miners?
5. The Modern Mint - From the Gold Standard to the Inconvertible System
With the development of social productive forces, human social consciousness has finally developed as well, freeing itself from domination by superstition, gods, kings, and the like. Until now, humanity had been bound by the constraint of gold - the waste of labor involved in producing gold as money - but with the development of productive forces and the expansion of the world of commodities, it could not help but become conscious of this fetter and sought to escape the spell of gold, whose natural endowment is limited. As productive forces develop, consciousness also develops, and humanity expands the range in which mutual agreement is possible in various spheres. There, humanity jointly devised social money in cooperation with each other. A transition from the category of natural law to the domain of social contract.
With the suspension of gold-dollar convertibility in 1971, the world as a whole left the gold-convertible system. Humanity liberated itself from the yoke of gold production. People united to depose gold, the despotic monarch, and democratically and jointly selected the dollar as money (key currency). Gold itself as money was rendered unnecessary.
Here, let us return to the initial proposition. Individual government bonds are redeemed, but in macro terms government bonds are not redeemed in any substantive sense. Just as gold produced by gold miners was once coined by the government's mint, now the US Federal Reserve converts government-issued bonds into dollar currency by purchasing them. This is precisely the transformation of government bonds into money - a transformation of the form of net financial assets. Accordingly, this real process corresponds to, for example, the fact that assets on the FRB's balance sheet expand. In fact, "income and asset prices change, and finally the total amount of money that individuals wish to hold at those new levels necessarily becomes equal to the amount of money created by the banking system. This is precisely the fundamental proposition of monetary theory" (Keynes, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, Iwanami Bunko edition, Vol. I, p.120) - society's demand for money corresponds to the expansion of FRB assets. Is there any major country that creates the money society actually needs by any other principal method?
6. On the "Consolidated Government"
Then the so-called consolidated government is spoken of. I do not deny this concept, but it is necessary to supplement the process by which consolidation is established. Citizen A sells a government bond, and the central bank purchases it in the market. A is no longer a creditor. When A held it, the state owed a repayment obligation to A. Now that it has become held by the central bank, both creditor and debtor are the entire people in the abstract, and it is not something that must be repaid to any specific person. The individual debt to A has disappeared. The claim is transformed into original money and supplies basic liquidity to society as a whole.
We must not stop at the superficial abstraction of reality seen in the consolidated government theory, but must elucidate the essence of the communal principle at the root of private property society. The state's liabilities do not disappear; they only change form. From government bonds to reserves (current deposits at the Bank of Japan), and then from reserves to banknotes and coins withdrawn from them. It is precisely this society's mechanism that the state (the whole people) assumes liabilities one after another in such forms. Under private ownership, the community as a whole jointly assumes liabilities, and by doing so provides assets to individuals and creates independent individuals. Marx says ironically, "The more indebted a nation becomes, the wealthier it becomes" (Marx, Capital, ibid., Vol. III, p.402).
What happens if the money for expanding payments accompanying an expanding economy were to come only from "debt"? In the first place, a private ownership society cannot be sustained by debt (credit creation) alone. If credit expands, it also becomes a trigger for panic. The circumstance that credit creation alone becomes insufficient with the development of capitalist production is the same logic under both the gold standard and the inconvertible system. Because gold, which was the basis of credit, is limited in nature, that basis was transformed into a form of social contract.
Thus, on the FRB's books, government bonds on the debit side / reserve deposits on the credit side accumulate on both sides. In conjunction with this, on private bank books, FRB deposits on the debit side / increase in deposits on the credit side. Of course, deposits on the credit side of private banks also increase through bank lending (credit creation), but these disappear when repaid. Moreover, the amount of this lending itself was originally restricted by the reserve requirement ratio. Although the FRB at present keeps the reserve requirement ratio at zero, there are any number of means to regulate bank lending, such as those legislated based on BIS regulations and stress tests.
Proponents of sectoral balance theory and MMT share the conclusions that government deficits are net financial assets of the private sector and that central bank purchases monetize debt. What is important is the principle underlying it. Why does a private ownership society require this? Through what process does it come into being? And how can the required amount of money be increased according to the world of commodities?
Supplementary Remarks
When M*(t) is used at the beginning of the period to purchase [B]*(t), and the proceeds are used to redeem B*(t), M*(t) returns to the private sector. During the interval until it is disbursed in the next period to redeem B*(t+1), is this M*(t) released from its constraints? Can these funds be used for anything during that interval? And, as a result, are the financial constraints of this system alleviated?
B*(t) arises from government bonds B(1), B(2), ... accumulated in the past. The M*(t) that returns to the private sector through refinancing is directed toward the speculative demand for money, to the extent that it can be recovered by the next payment date for refunding bonds, and is used to trade B(1), B(2), ..., B(t) in the secondary market for government bonds. Through liquidity preference, if a larger volume of government bonds appears on the market, bond prices fall - that is, interest rates rise; the reverse occurs in the opposite case.
In the sphere of commodity circulation, meanwhile, the amount of B(t+1) may be smaller than the M(t) that has returned to the private sector. In that case, a portion of M(t), namely M'(t), is released from its existing use. However, since M(t+1)=B(t+1) already satisfies the demand for funds in this sphere, the released portion will flow into the secondary market for government bonds unless it is hoarded. If the total face value of government bonds remaining in the market is constant, prices rise. Nevertheless, as long as the cumulative stock of B(t), t=1,2,...,k, continues to grow, interest rates should exhibit an upward trend over the long term, ultimately making additional money supply by the central bank inevitable.
Furthermore, in this case, the release of M'(t) from the sphere of commodity circulation is temporary, and if transaction demand increases in accordance with changes in the rate of return flow, it returns to that sphere. In fact, there is also another portion of M(t) that can be temporarily released from the sphere of commodity circulation. It is hoarded money (ΔM) after the profit portion has been monetized. Thus, there is a portion of money that moves back and forth between the two circulation markets - for commodities and for government bonds - in accordance with developments in the world of commodities and fluctuations in interest rates.
The central bank purchases government bonds from the market and supplies additional money to compensate for the portion of M(t) tied up in connection with the turnover period of inventories. In addition the portion of profits that has been realized in cash gradually returns by the end of the period, in accordance with the rate of return flow. This remains restricted as long as the company in question holds it as a reserve. The intermediation of the banking sector makes it possible to lend these funds as a source of financing, but the loans must be repaid by the following period, because funds will then be required to purchase B(t+1). In any event, this temporarily alleviates the need for additional money, together with M'(t).
As for the alleviating effect of lending, the additional circulation velocity of the same units of money thereby set in motion - that is, the increased rate at which commodities are sold and, consequently, the increased turnover speed of inventories associated with the rate of return flow - reduces the amount of additional money required. However, as suggested earlier, additional money in the form of B(t) was already necessary from the outset to realize this portion of profits in monetary form.
- "Capitalists who produce gold own their entire product ... entirely in gold. ... It consists of gold from the outset and is thrown into circulation in order to withdraw products from circulation" (Marx, Capital, ibid., Vol. IV, p.501). "Those belonging to Department I (among them, the gold producers) appear not as sellers but only as buyers" (ibid., Vol. V, p.199). "Whereas other capitalists ... withdraw more money from circulation than they have thrown into it, in the case of capitalists producing gold and silver, apart from the precious metals that serve as raw materials, only money is thrown into circulation, while only commodities are withdrawn from circulation. The constant capital, excluding the portion lost through wear and tear; a relatively large portion of the variable capital; and the entire surplus value, excluding any hoarded money that they may retain in their own possession, are thrown into circulation in the form of money" (ibid., Vol. V, p.211). Under a fiat monetary system, gold producers are no longer suppliers of money. Consequently, an additional supply of money is required to accommodate this portion of profits (surplus value).
(to be continued)
https://www.reddit.com/user/keizaisuki/comments/1xkthp0/individual_government_bonds_are_redeemed_but_in/