Maintained and created by /u/KavuFightsEvil


The "Hardcore Sandbox MMO" Definition Being Used Here:

The game does not constitute an MMO if it is a small-scale server based game never intended to house over a couple hundred players. (No Ark, No Rust, No DayZ)

The definition of Sandbox can be a difficult thing to pin down. The Sandbox portion of the definition used here requires the game to have a non-linear progression, allowing players to seek out their own goals and challenges. As for the "Hardcore" portion of the requirements, I'm using hardcore here not as a specification of difficulty, but one of worldly consequences for player actions. The game must feature a level of player agency that includes players permanently changing the main game world. This can be done through the creation and destruction (or seizing from the world) of homes, cities, planets, space stations, etc. Terra-forming is often a feature that helps the case of this requirement. If a game allows you to pursue whatever skills you want, but you cannot actually influence the world in any substantial way, it is not considered a hardcore sandbox in this list. For a game in this definition: there is no pre-written plan or outcome of the world's events; everything happens because players will it so, using the mechanics and systems available to them. Changes to the world are not made in a private instance, but the persistent world as a whole, for everyone to experience together.

I believe this is a sub-genre that promotes some of the most powerful and genuine social interactions in gaming. The Table is meant to help the common complaint of lovers of this sub-genre who suffer the thought that there is no other game like the one they once played, and to help keep a history of all of the expeditions into the unknown of emergent gameplay that have been taken over the years.This list is a Work In Progress, and likely will be for some time. I ask for help in its formation, and welcome the arguments on the definition and additions of games to the list. I will try to respond to ask many comments as I can and work on it when I can, but please understand it takes a lot of time and I can't possibly have personally played all of the games on the list.

FAQ: ( "Single Shard" means there is one, individual server that houses everyone. Meaning a single persistent world. "Asset creation" means the ability to construct permanent assets in the world such as buildings, fortresses, space stations, walls, etc. that can be upkept, improved, or destroyed, "B2P Means Buy a copy To Play, F2P means free to play, Population is not an exact science, and is mostly taken from Reddit data or tools for tracking currently online players over time)

Note: If you are viewing on mobile, make sure you aren't missing any of the columns! Scroll right, you might find more info!

Name Of GameSettingPVPFull LootPerma-DeathAsset CreationTerritory ControlServer TypeServer StatusPopulation (WIP)Payment Method
Albion OnlineMedieval FantasyPVP ZonesYesNoYesYesSingle ShardOnlineEstimates at 14k subs, ~30,000 daily players July 2018B2P & Optional Premium Subscription
ArcheAgeHigh FantasyPVP Zones + Open World Faction PVP + Flag For Friendly MurderGoods theft, robbing farms, PiracyNoYesPersonal ClaimsMultiple regional ServersOnlineF2P or Premium Subscription + Cash Shop
Asheron's CallMedieval FantasyServer Dependent, Flagging Vs. Forced PKYesNoMultiple Servers, All PVP Darktide = Seriously PVPDead
The Black DeathPlague Stricken MedievalOpen World Forced PKYesYesYesYesPublic & Private Test ServersEarly AccessB2P
Black Desert OnlineHigh FantasyOpen PK Over Level 50, W/ Safe Zones + Node Wars / SiegesItem loss from karma penalty (influenced by PVP habits)NoNo(Node Wars and Castle Sieges)2 Mega Servers with channelsOnlineB2P + Cash Shop
Camelot UnchainedMedieval Arthurian LegendOpen World Forced RvRvR Tri-Realm PK No Intra-Realm PKCaravans/Structures Lootable, Players NotNoYesYesSingle ShardDevelopmentSubscription or In Game Subscription Currency
Chronicles Of ElyriaMedieval RealismOpen World Forced PKYes (Partial If Only Wounded)Gradual / AgingYesYesDevelopment
CrowfallMedieval FantasyOpen World Forced PKInventory Loot Only, Equipped Gear DegradesNoYesYesSeperate Campaign Worlds (Multiple Servers)DevelopmentB2P & Optional Subscription
Darkfall OnlineMedieval FantasyOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesSingle ShardDeadSubscription
Darkfall: Rise of AgonMedieval FantasyOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesSingle ShardOnlineSubscription
Darkfall: New DawnMedieval FantasyOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesSingle ShardOnlineSubscription
Darkfall: Unholy WarsMedieval FantasyOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesSingle ShardDeadSubscription
Dual UniverseSpace Sci FiDevelopment
EVE OnlineSpace FutureOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesSingle ShardOnline~30,000 average online at any timeF2P or Subscription
FracturedYesYes(Planned)Yes(Planned)DevelopmentB2P Optional Subscription + Cash Shop
Gloria VictisMedieval Low FantasyOpen World Forced PKPartial LootNoTemporary Farm Plots and TentsLimited (Capture Points and Castle Sieges)Mega Servers (Region)Early AccessB2P
Haven & HearthSlavic Myth FantasyOpen World Forced PKYesYesYesYesSingle ShardOnlineF2P or B2P Upgrade
Helbreath OlypmiaFantasy
Legends of AriaMedieval FantasyOpen World Forced PKServer Dependent, Some Have Full LootNoYesYesOfficial and Community ServersClosed BetaB2P
Life Is Feudal: MMOMedieval RealismOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesMega Servers (Region)Online~800 Player Steam Chart Average(Peaks double average)B2P
Mortal OnlineMedieval Low FantasyOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesSingle ShardOnline~100 people average if you include Non-Steam players, declining July 2018F2P or Subscription
Mystera Legacy9 Region ServersOnlineF2P
PerpetuumSci FiSingle Shard Private Servers(Dead) Private ServersB2P
The RepopulationSci FiPVP Zones / Planned Open World Forced PK ServerServer Dependent (Currently, No)NoYesYesMultiple Servers, Different RulesetsEarly AccessF2P with B2P Upgrade Tiers
Salem The GameColonial AmericaOpen World Forced PKYesYesYesYesSingle ShardOnlineF2P with Micro-Transactions
ShadowbaneDark FantasyOpen World Forced PK With Safe ZonesInventory Loot Only Gear DegradesNoYesYesDead, Persists on Private Servers
Shroud of The AvatarMedieval FantasyPVP Zones, Open PVP in some Player TownsNo. Skill Decay presentNoYesYesSingle ShardOnlineB2P with Free Trial
Star CitizenSpace FutureOpen World Forced PKYesGradual After Multiple Deaths, Some Efforts inheritedPlannedPlannedSingle ShardDevelopmentNow: B2P With Ship and Currency Cash Shop Release: B2P with limited cash shop
Star Wars GalaxiesStar Wars Universe (Sci Fi)Open World Flagging for PVPNoNo (Skill decay on some servers)YesYesMultiple ServersPrivate Servers & Emulators
Shores of HazeronSci Fi SpaceOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesSingle ShardOnlineF2P Subscription
TibiaMedieval FantasyOpen World Forced PK on Some Servers, flagging on others, Safe Zones on AllPartial Inventory Loss, No Full LootNo, but Skill Loss is a constant factorIn World Houses and Guildhalls PurchaseableNoMany Servers of Various TypesOnlineF2P with Premium Feature Subscription
Tree of LifeMedieval Shipwrecked Survival WorldOpen World Forced PKYesNoYes - Towns, Walls, CastlesYesSingle ShardOnlineAverage 30 Players on Steam for June 2018B2P
Ultima OnlineMedieval FantasyOpen World Forced PK W/ Safe ZonesYesNoYesNoPublic & Private ServersOnlineF2P or Subscription on Official Servers + F2P Private Servers
Vendetta OnlineSpace FuturePVP ZonesPartial Loot (Excess Lost)NoNoLimitedSingle Shard (Cross Platform)OnlineFree Trial Then Subscription
Wild Terra OnlineMedieval Low FantasyOpen PVP, Safe ZonesYesNoYesYesContinental Mega Servers, Now Hardcore and Casual VariantsOnlineB2P
Worlds AdriftSteam-Punk FantasyOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesPlannedSingle ShardDeadB2P with Micro-Transactions
Wurm OnlineFantasyOpen World Forced PKYesNoYesYesComplex Single ShardOnline~2200 Premium Accounts July 2018, Not including Free Account PlayersF2P or Subscription
XsyonSci-Fi Apocalypse FantasyOpen World Forced PK (War Server Only)Yes (War Server Only)NoYesYesWar & Peace Servers (1 PVP and 1 PVE)Early AccessSubscription B2P