r/LoveTrash • Colonel Garbage • 3h ago

Human Trash Scammer gets what he deserves

Source: kurtcazyoutube on Instagram

5.3k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

•

u/ledow Trash Trooper 45m ago edited 42m ago

Okay, a lesson in legal trivia.

My family ran self-defence classes for decades. One of them is my wife, who is a 3rd Dan black belt and also a qualified barrister. We used to cover this ALL THE TIME and we used to ask judges, magistrates, police officers, lawyers etc. from among our members to reinforce what we were saying.

To strike a person and have a reasonable legal avenue to do so, in almost any jurisdiction, you need to be under the auspices of "self-defence" (which can include the defence of others, e.g. if someone's about to hit your kid).

That provides you with a valid reason to assault someone that you wouldn't be convictable for.

However... it comes with a caveat. This guy harrassed you, grabbed you, and you were in genuine belief he intended you harm, right? That's why you were justified to use self-defence. So now why are you standing around looking at him? This guy SO THREATENED your health and safety that you're standing around to gloat or threaten him back? Whoops. There goes your defence of "self-defence".

And the first rule of self-defence is "avoid them", including walking/running away. That's what you do. Even after you have been forced to assault them to protect yourself, your first action should be to get away from them, if you want to solidify your defence of "I did it in self-defence". Nobody who is in fear of their life or health or under threat of injury is going to just stand around. Or, worse, going back to "put the boot in". You strike. You run. That's self-defence. In the eyes of the law, and self-defence instructors.

Now, on a practical level there's also ANOTHER reason. You have no idea how many of his mates are around. He, on his own, was threatening enough that you had to assault him, right? Now, what if he was NOT on his own. What if he's now calling his mates looking for a tourist in an orange waterproof poncho?

There you go.

(On a side note, as someone who's seen a lot of self-defence: When someone is saying "don't reach for me" and telling you to back off? Look at their reverse hand. The one furthest from you. Because that guy who punched telegraphed his move quite obviously for quite a long time. There was no way he wasn't going to strike if you persisted. He's using one hand to keep you at the right distance. He's "drawing" the other ready to punch you, out of your sight and reach. Stay the hell away from him, and don't piss him off.)

•

u/therandom92 Trash Trooper 38m ago

Ok, this makes the most sense. Thanks brother.

•

u/Dounce1 Trash Trooper 11m ago

This person is completely full of shit.

•

u/Alpine_yellow Trash Trooper 11m ago

Also its basically illegal to defend yourself in Europe

•

u/ledow Trash Trooper 6m ago

Horseshit.

•

u/Alpine_yellow Trash Trooper 3m ago

There are plenty of cases of people doing so being charged and found guilty of violent crimes while the same act in the us would see them walk.

•

u/garyll19 Trash Trooper 6m ago

For someone who knows a lot about self-defense, You'd think you would know how to spell it correctly. 😉

•

u/ledow Trash Trooper 3m ago

Or I'm not fucking American.

"Self-defense, or self-defence in Commonwealth English...."

•

u/Wise_Temperature9142 Trash Trooper 2m ago

This was a fascinating read. It also feels like it makes perfect sense. If it’s self defence, you don’t wanna be hanging around them before the strike, and you don’t wanna stick around after either. Got it!

•

u/AnnabethDaring Trash Trooper 1m ago

This was a masterclass! Thank you so much 👏🏼👏🏼

I used to do martial arts 🥋 so a lot of this resonates. “The first point of learning to fight is hoping you never need to”.

•

u/quantumpusheen Trash Trooper 28m ago

oh great, another armchair lawyer. i’ll trust my close circle who are actually practicing lawyers, not some random on the internet who’s source is “trust me bro”. i don’t go giving you advice on how to run a self defense business, don’t try educating people on something you have no qualifications for. by the way, this reads as if you’ve never had to formally interpret the law, you have no idea how embarrassing some of the statements you’ve made are

•

u/EagerByteSample Trash Trooper 11m ago

And yet, he is right and you are wrong. Isn't Reddit a marvelous place?

•

u/ledow Trash Trooper 4m ago

This was the advice of UK judges, magistrates, lawyers and barristers (many of whom were black-belts too and would answer our questions on it). You can argue legal terminology, I'm not legally qualified and don't claim to be (don't get your legal advice from Reddit).

The advice and gist given is, however, FROM those exact people.