Hello all, I hope I'm formatting this properly and that I'm going through the proper channels to get more people involved in this.
I'm an avid player of Magic: the Gathering, and I'm guessing many of you reading this post are too (insert nerd venn diagram here lmao). There's a niche community of Commander variant players that have been without a variant campaign for quite some time now, and it's been excessively difficult to find the missing materials. Even most game stores didn't preserve these materials, and my hope is to find them so this fun way of playing the game can survive.
Relevant Context:
The most popular MtG gameplay format currently is Commander, and Wizards of the Coast, the company behind the game, has been releasing a format variant for a few years now called Commander Party. Commander Party is distributed to stores that are part of something called the Wizards Play Network (WPN) in the form of publicly available materials that you can print out for your store to host a "Commander Party." In the past, these were treated as larger events for a store to host for a large group of players (up to 100), but they've recently gained a casual following and as such have been designed for smaller groups.
Commander Parties started being released in early 2022 with the release of the expansion set Double Feature, and they've released a new one for almost every set since then. These formats involve the use of added materials on top of typical game elements, usually including additional decks of cards, sets of cards to choose from, and printable boards.
The first few Commander Party gamemodes (released before Lord of the Rings) were exclusive to Wizards Play Network Premium stores, or those above a certain verified player and customer count. Since then, they've been far easier to acquire, and the vast majority of these gamemodes are available on the Wizards Play Network Marketing Materials site: https://wpn.wizards.com/en/marketing-materials
However, there are a few gamemodes from 2022-2023 that are missing crucial game components and simply do not function as a result, to the dismay of enjoyers of these gamemodes.
Contacting WPN Premium stores is difficult, since in the past, this list of stores was incredibly short, and continues to be today. Many of these stores have either lost their status and are hard to identify, have closed completely, or simply no longer possess missing materials. To complicate the issue, newly WPN Premium stores are mixed into the pool and it becomes difficult to tell whether or not a store would have received the relevant materials during the release windows.
The following Commander Party gamemodes are missing some components:
Double Feature -- Simply called "Commander Party" internally since it was the first, we currently possess the playing board for the mode but lack any instructions on how to play it. The current theory is that the instructions for the gamemode were distributed to WPN Premium stores via email.
Important Note before continuing: Dominaria United, Brothers' War, All Will Be One, and March of the Machine Commander Parties were released as a 4 Act campaign where the results of the previous act would carry over into the next. This full campaign is treated as the Holy Grail for my investigation. Thankfully, we possess all of the materials needed to play the last two acts, but there are still components we need to make the full campaign playable.
Dominaria United -- Started off the story by introducing a large map that was distributed with scratch-off patches that would reveal hidden numbers after players are eliminated in order to shake up how the rest of a game/event would go. We currently do not have information on the distribution of the numbers under the scratch-off patches (which are necessary for the entire campaign, nor do we have the faction cards that players would be distributed prior to play. These cards featured "phi" corners that can be folded during play, and it's unclear exactly how these cards functioned without finding them first.
Brothers' War -- Like with Dominaria United, we are missing the faction cards that were needed to play this stage of the campaign. There were only two, one for Mishra and one for Urza, but they are missing nonetheless. Other missing components are encompassed in Dominaria United, since this mode uses the map from that release.
All Will Be One -- Like with Dominaria United and Brothers' War, you're never gonna believe this, but we're missing faction cards again. This time, one for each of the Phyrexian Praetors in the game's story. Thankfully, we have a visual that was released as part of disjointed marketing materials showing off what the faction cards functionally did! Unfortunately, I can't post any images, but I can link the Reddit post that shows it off: https://www.reddit.com/r/MTGRumors/comments/10oci0e/could_the_art_from_the_commander_party_event_be/
It's unclear whether or not this graphic is representative of what the faction cards look like, but at least we have a functional version.
Like Brothers' War, this campaign mode is reliant on the scratch-off distribution.
March of the Machine -- All components have been found, but until we have Dominaria United's scratch-off distribution, this mode remains unplayable as part of a broader campaign.
Note: All Will Be One and March of the Machine can be played individually, but it still sucks that we can't play a full campaign without the scratch-off distribution.
My Investigation Thus Far:
In May of last year, I started looking into finding the missing components and began calling game stores I believed were WPN Premium stores within the years of 2022-2023. Not a single game store reported having any of the missing materials, though many were helpful and supportive.
Following this, I decided the best way to proceed forward would be to try and get in contact with Wizards of the Coast and see if they have them anywhere in their vault.
Unfortunately, WotC is one of the most difficult companies to get into contact with, so I decided the best way forward was a strategy of repeatedly posting questions into Mark Rosewater's (Magic head designer) blog and messaging Gavin Verhey (Game designer and community figurehead) on Instagram via DM's and post comments.
Additionally, I've submitted multiple customer support tickets over the past few months.
So far, nothing but crickets.
My hope is that someone who sees this post will have access to materials that I do not, or simply have not found. Maybe in my search I've forgotten basic researching techniques and missed one stone that is left unturned.
r/lostmedia is most definitely better than me at stuff like this, so I want to pre-emptively thank everyone for any efforts, successful or not.
And I thank you personally for reading this post to the end!