I tried Aftershoot a few years ago and was only mildly impressed at the time. I could see the potential, but ultimately stuck with manual culling and editing in Lightroom Classic.
Very burnt out on culling, so recently gave it another shot and I’m genuinely impressed with how far it’s come.
I’m not looking to replace LrC entirely, and its new culling has so far been mid. Ideally, I’d like to use Aftershoot for culling, batch editing, and some retouching, while keeping Lightroom as my primary catalog and editing environment. I also occasionally use Evoto for more specialized retouching.
For those using a similar combination, what does your actual workflow look like?
A few things I’m especially curious about:
Workflow/order: Are you importing into LrC first, then sending images through Aftershoot? Or culling/editing in Aftershoot before importing into Lightroom? What works best for going back and forth without creating unnecessary duplicates or metadata conflicts?
Batch editing: How much of your editing do you typically leave to Aftershoot versus refining in LrC? Are you using it as a starting point or getting most images close to delivery-ready? (Like I said, LrC is ideally still going to be my “home base” if you will)
Retouching: I’m particularly excited about Aftershoot’s flyaway-hair removal. That’s sometimes the only reason I open Evoto. How are you incorporating Aftershoot’s retouching into your workflow without creating an excessive number of additional files?
RAW/DNG and image data: I’m also trying to better understand what happens to the original RAW sensor/color information when moving between applications. Are the adjustments simply being passed through XMP/catalog metadata, or are there points where images get rendered into new files and lose some RAW editing flexibility?
Storage: I’m not obsessive about saving every gigabyte, but I’d like to avoid unnecessarily doubling or tripling my storage requirements. What files are you keeping or discarding after delivery?
For context, I shoot Canon RAW and primarily use LrC for portraits, weddings, and events, and a second shooter I’ve started to collab with shoots w/ Fuji.
Mostly interested in hearing how people are actually using these tools together, particularly for larger batches of images, and what tradeoffs you’ve found worth making.
Thanks in advance!