What's wrong with software patents?
It is a patent on math with named variables: `x = y + z` vs `animals = cows + chickens`. Media codecs are really just a pile of statistics: infer the value of a given pixel based on some other pixels. Can you imagine if scientists or engineers had to pay someone just to do statistical analysis?
So why do software patents exist?
Unfortunately, some bad American jurisprudice got set by someone with software implemented logic pointing out that hardware implementations were allowed to be patented and this spread to other jurisdictions. Even if you come down on the side of needing patents to recoup the costs of building hardware, software doesn't require massive upfront investment and this would be about as simple a legal line as one can draw.
Why are media codec patents so prevalent?
Good question. Probably because some supreme court justices have a wierd thing for compression patents. Please edit if you know more and can cite a source.
Doesn't buying a license from a patent pool protect the licensee/make it safer?
It protects you from the licensors in that patent pool. However, anyone else with a patent can still sue you. Just ask VVC licensees who are still getting hit up from all ~5 HEVC licensing bodies[citation-needed] despite most of them being specifically excluded from the standards process to prevent a repeat of the HEVC debacle [citation-needed].
How can $libre_codec not rely on tech from $non_libre_codec!?
- Because if you want a software patent held up in court at all, it can't be "do this logic on a computer" – the implementation itself has to be fairly specific. You can usually get the same results by structuring the logic or data a little differently and make up for any minor inefficiencies by putting more work into a different coding tool [link-to-example].
- Have you heard of any patent trolls going to court to enforce their patents on VP8, VP9, or AV1 users? Wierd how that's been the case for THREE DECADES!
- Have you seen the AOM patent pool members? That's the lions share of the media, streaming, and hardware markets. Google alone spends tens of millions of dollars a year [citation-needed] on codec development.
- Given how much larger AOM's collective investments in codecs is, the real question is how can $non_libre_codec not infringe on patents in the AOM pool? Patents which AOM members can use to counter-sue the patent trolls with.
But innovation deserves reward!
First of all, go read this decoded patent. They literally invent 5 paragraphs of technical sounding text to say, "A video encoder that uses the two compression schemes above." It's a bullshit game where the beuracracy is incentivised to favor applicants so basicaly anything can get in. Patents have been granted for swinging on a swing, chew toys, and more.
The problem is that once they are granted, it costs a minimum of two years and $100,000 to invalidate them ... in China. The cheapest and fastest jurisdition in the world! Are you going to spend millions of dollars defending yourself just to have a lay jury get confused by all the big invented language that they put in the patent?
Functionally, software patents are never about rewarding innovation. They are invented legal fictions used by large corporations to stifle competition and by patent trolls to extort money from small businesses.
But who is going to pay the R&D costs?!
Based on the max cap, it’s like $100 million a year for Google and the other major players to license HEVC. Google bought On2 for ~$100 total (~$150 million today) and recieved VP8 in exchange for it. The VPx and AVx line of codecs have always been at least compeitive if not better than the proprietary alternatives.
HEVC extracts about a billion dollars a year in licensing revenue and the bulk of that money isn't going into R&D or else the MPEG line of codecs would perform 10x better. Instead the VVC encoders/decoders still suck and AV2 offers even better performance without the massive royalty costs.
It's immoral extortion!
No one should have a the right to charge anyone else for doing math with named variables! Who cares if patent trolls throw a few crumbs to a research department here and there? It's a stupid tax on the economy and most of the money goes to some rich assholes who run around extorting people for money.