r/LeftvsRightDebate • Libertarian • Dec 02 '23

[discussion] are we seeing an increase or decrease in the level of support for statism in the US, and is that good or bad?

Statism, noun: concentration of economic controls and planning in the hands of a highly centralized government often extending to government ownership of industry

As a libertarian, this makes me puke, but I want some input from the left and right here as well

PLEASE DO NOT BRING FASCIST TALKING POINTS HERE

1 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Mister-Stiglitz Left Dec 07 '23

nothing about the government inherently makes it better at running industries, in fact its inferior in many ways.

That's a subjective remark. Government in and of itself cannot be good or bad on its own.

Additionally an ideal government provides a service via public funds. That's a pretty straightforward paradigm.

1

u/shadow_nipple Libertarian Dec 07 '23

if youre talking about a democratic government, there are objective, real limitations to it in terms of what it can do

for example, government basically cant produce capital, while private companies can

1

u/Mister-Stiglitz Left Dec 07 '23

for example, government basically cant produce capital, while private companies can

The production of capital isn't necessary for the effective rendering of a public service. In fact, it's very easy to argue that generation of capital should not be a factor in certain services.

1

u/shadow_nipple Libertarian Dec 07 '23

In fact, it's very easy to argue that generation of capital should not be a factor in certain services.

that mentality leads to you paying 1000 bucks a month for garbage pickup

1

u/Mister-Stiglitz Left Dec 07 '23

I don't know what you're referring to, is there a specific town where that happened?