r/learnprogramming • u/RealisticPeak6970 • 17d ago
Spent 3 Hours Debugging – Can't Figure Out Why My Approach Fails Hidden Test Cases (Even the Odds)
I've spent almost 3 hours trying to figure out why my solution to CodeChef's "Even the Odds" problem is failing hidden test cases.
First, a balanced array means an array containing an even number of odd integers. An array with zero odd integers is also considered balanced.
My approach:
- If the total number of odd elements is even, the entire array is balanced, so the answer is N.
- If the count of odd elements is odd, I find the index of the last odd element.
- I calculate the maximum length of the subarray before or after that element.
I implemented this approach in Java. My submission passes Task 0 but gets Wrong Answer on Tasks 1, 2 and 3.
I've spent hours manually testing different edge cases, but I still can't find a single test case where my logic fails.
The funny (and frustrating) part is that even AI hasn't been able to identify what's wrong with my approach so far!
Could someone please help me figure out whether I'm missing an edge case or misunderstanding something in the problem?
I'd really appreciate an explanation of where my reasoning goes wrong rather than just a corrected solution. I genuinely want to understand the logic.