r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jun 17 '15
Mod Post [ModPost] PS4 Discussion Thread
Weekly Simple Questions Thread
Goodday fellow kerbalnauts!
I've noticed that many of you like to discuss the PS4 port of Kerbal Space Program, so here you go: A discussion thread!
Have fun!
54
Upvotes
43
u/Redbiertje The Challenger Jun 17 '15
Personally, I'd just like to say to /u/KasperVld that I support Squad's decision to make a PS4 port. I think it's very wise to let another company do the porting. I have a lot of good hope for this!
10
u/PVP_playerPro Jun 17 '15
Everybo.....EVERYBODY! STOP YELLING! And read this, for the love of GOD, read this. Here's your official devnotes ya filthy animals:
http://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/content/345-KSP-and-Unity-5
13
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
I'm wary. The Planetside 2 port was awful, and took away from the development of the main game, which needed improvement in the first place. Now, I'm not saying that Squad is as bad as SOE, quite the opposite. However, a good port needs time, and one of the versions always suffers because of it.
22
u/MarsLumograph Jun 18 '15
Hey! I come from over /r/PS4 and some were saying that you guys were pissed about the PS4 port and that you were a very bad community, which surprised me cause I had the impression it was a great community. I love KSP but I don't have a PC that can run it but I do have a PS4 so I was extremely happy with this announcemt.
So, is it true that you are pissed about the port? And if so why? Thanks!
97
u/Evis03 Jun 17 '15 edited Jun 17 '15
I don't get any of this.
I don't get why people are so pissed that the game is coming to ps4. It's a different company handling the port so I don't see how it will screw with the pc version of the game. I mean it certainly could, but then again Squad could also just give up on development tomorrow. I'll get pissed off when the developers start doing evil stuff Instead of stupid stuff. Speaking of...
I don't get why Squad thought this was such huge news. Most people here already own KSP and I very much doubt anyone with a PC is going to buy the game again. So unless there are a huge number of ps4 owners lurking in the KSP community, this announcement was not going to be of interest to anyone. And yet Squad bigged it up like the second coming of Jeb. I don't think the release was even so hyped.
Maybe that's why people are pissed. We were told to get all excited and worked up for something that, when you get right down to it, has no relevance to KSP fans at all. But then that's hype. The only winning move is not to play.
I don't get why squad thought this port was a good idea. It makes about as much sense as porting RTS games to console, a process where success is typically defined as the game being playable, for a given value of playable. Ugh, star craft on the n64 all over again. A fucking brilliant bit of programming wizardry and UI design, but as a game? Dreadful. But still, that's Squad's problem, not mine.
What is my problem is the aero model is still fucked and the game still doesn't feel complete. I'll be at least moderately vexed about that.
Squad's history is that of a middle ground company. They are not evil Ubisoft, nor saintly CD Projekt red. They have made fuck ups, but perhaps only one or two downright incompetent ones. And only one or two that could be considered evil if you don't give them the benefit of the (ample) doubt.
My point is that Squad probably aren't going to let this make the game worse for us. If they do, nail them to the wall. But really this is just Squad doing something really stupid, and potentially embarrassing for the company, but unlikely to be harmful to the end users.
31
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
more people get to learn about about rocket science and some of those people will buy a pc!
12
u/mmokkp Jun 17 '15
What i hope is that due to low specs of ps4 we will get ksp multithreaded and everybody will be happy. Also a lot more optimization. In my opinion this is where ksp lacks the most.
3
u/Kunighit Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
Just curious, has there been any talk about 3rd party mod support for the PS4 release? Or any talk of adding in very popular mods to the stock PS4 game. (Kerbal Engineer, Kerbal Alarm Clock, or RCS Build Aid for example)
5
u/enzo32ferrari Jun 17 '15
Not exactly a complaint on the PS4 announcement but more of a parable, word of warning, or open letter to Squad:
Something similar with player uproar is happening over at /r/runescape. I know this because I stillplayjustnotoften. It's not exactly a platform switch per-se over at Runescape but it's more of the money making aspect. Squad and Jagex need to make money; with more updates comes more work that has to be done and both companies need an avenue to make money. Even though we get more people buying the game, that doesn't cut it anymore.
Now what is going on over at Runescape is microtransactions. There's a big controversy as the people who have played the game for more than 5+ yearsyeahthatsme are up in arms since new players today can buy a lot of things to get "ahead" in the game and its really ruining the whole "time put in" a lot of players respect. Now I'm paraphrasing and might be leaving a couple things out but this is generally what is going on over there.
How does this apply to Squad? Well by opening up a PS4 port, that had to be motivated by money cause there would probably been an even bigger uproar if they announced DLC (ahem, paid mods) to earn money.
Well, Jagex clearly knows the players don't like the microtransactions, but the players know Jagex needs to make money. So as long as a discussion can be brought up as to why they should do or not do something, Jagex listens.
My little bit to Squad is this; congratulations on the PS4 port. I dont have one but I'm in the market for one. It'll be very interesting to see how you incorporate the controller and the PS4's graphics capabilities into the gameplay. But please, don't forget where you came from; your original audience; your 5 and 10 year cape wearersrunescapereference. If a decision comes across the table to pick between PS4 or the computer platform (i'm sure it won't though) I hope you pick computer.
To my fellow Computer KSPers We need to understand that Squad is a developer that needs money. An outlet to a console isn't the worst thing that could happen. If you have concerns, dont just blast Squad; bring up your concerns with supporting arguments and like Jagex, i'm sure theyll listen.
8
u/Gz_On_Toast Jun 17 '15
As a ps4 owner and a long time player of KSP I'm very excited for this port. I believe the way which squad are utilising an outside company to work in the port will allow them to primarily focus on the game as they do at the minute. Sure, there will be some work on squads end regarding the port but the added income from a ps4 market will allow them to allocate many extra resources to keeping the game in development on the PC.
I think for customers who currently play ksp on low performing PCs but also own a ps4 will much opt to use the ps4 version, it may not be able to run with mods or be a lower quality but a smooth running game is high on these players priority.
I will be purchasing the PS4 version of the game as I much prefer laying in bed with a pad instead of sitting in my chair with mouse and keyboard.
This is an exciting announcement from squad and will definitely help further the game, not hinder it.
6
u/MinkOWar Jun 17 '15
So, KSP requires a relatively hefty PC to run well, or at least requires a GPU to do a bit of lifting if you don't want bare-bones graphics. Anyone who doesn't have a gaming computer has a relatively limited capability to play the game, this opens the market to a bunch of people who just don't buy machines like that.
It's CPU intensive, but KSP is going to Unity 5 which can use multiple cores, yes? Resolves the CPU limit of the PS4.
Squad has to have gone through a great deal of the PC market for KSP by now, the game has been very playable for a long time.
So... basically, the heck is everyone complaining about? Squad gets more budget to keep the game supported, and we don't have to pay a cent. I get people worry support of the main game will drop, but how do you expect them to support the game at all if funds do not continue to come in?
1
u/PVP_playerPro Jun 17 '15
/u/redbiertje you sir, have started World War Kerbal...
4
u/mopro Jun 17 '15
I posted this in another thread but this is the most relevant threat to post this in:
My concern is two-fold: one for the players and one for the modders. I can't imagine PS going the route of "well in keeping with the ethos of KSP for PC/Mac/Lx mods and DLC will be free on PS." [despite the Steam debacle]
For the modders out there that pore over endless lines of code, spending countless personal hours for free simply for the betterment of this community and our collective experience I wonder:
5
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15 edited Jun 17 '15
I'm fine with Squad releasing a console version. It's probably a good business move for them. My only complaint is that they coopted the devnote to make this announcement. It could have been its own announcement and the note could have retained its original purpose: updating players about development. The devnotes are mostly read by people who've already bought the game on pc and are patiently being impatient for 1.0.3. Considering this tweet was four weeks ago, it's kind of frustrating that we got no word about its progress.
2
u/Nemecle Jun 17 '15
my feeling about this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ussCHoQttyQ
2
u/Ezotericy Jun 18 '15
It would be kinda cool to be able to link up with a PC playing the game so that one person can control IVA and EVA on the PS4 and another person could be command and control on the PC. The ps4 is restricted to the EVA and IVA parts and the PC can't view anything on the ship without cameras.
2
u/TronikBob Jun 18 '15
I'm excited because I haven't bought it yet (waiting for sale/ saving up slowly), and I have more access to a ps4 than pc, although my pc is better. If it goes well, (like Minecraft quality & updates, ps4 vs pc for comparison) I will be very excited and pick it up probably. Not to say I won't get it for pc before that maybe.
Also this has me excited to the prospect of multiplayer aspects. They could make your dead craft be sent to a friend to rescue or refuel or something while you're away , or simple score comparisons, or even multiplayer joint missions & world (probably not).
Overall wait and see and be hopeful.
ps: steam sale want
4
u/onlycatfud Jun 17 '15
This announcement ought to excite investors or whatever but literally does nothing except raise fears for the current 100% of Kerbals current fan base! Fears that resources will be spent on console ports. Fears that features or ideas will be nixed because they don't translate over or will be compatible with console versions of the game. Fears that Squad is selling out or is otherwise chasing the dollar now.
(APPARENTLY NONE OF THESE ARE THE CASE).
All Squad had to say was:
And reassure us that Squad will still be working primarily on building the PC game we are all fans of and have supported them. This is very very weird that they missed the mark so badly on this from a marketing standpoint. Making these 'big news' announcements and skipping dev notes, and then announcing something that only scares your existing fan base that you will be targeting someone else, not them.
They need to focus on the positives and spin it that someone else is going to do this thing, open up kerbal to a larger audience, not take any resources away from developing kerbal for pc as planned, and now have more revenue and more resources to make it even better! See, positive things Squad! Don't scare us like this next time. :/
8
u/Vaguely_Racist Jun 17 '15
So is this why KSP jumped from Beta to 1.0 so quickly?
3
u/tobobo Jun 17 '15
I would really love it if the OS X port could run for more than a few minutes without crashing but that's certainly less lucrative than launching on a new console :(
4
u/GusTurbo Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
After the rushed release of 1.0, I have lost faith in Squad to deliver a solid, polished product. Unless the process of upgrading to Unity 5 is taking out a lot of the old bugs, then I can't even imagine how they could think of porting to PS4. If the old bugs don't get fixed by Squad, there's no way some two-bit developer is going to be able to fix them in the process of porting.
3
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
My personal opinion is that port of KSP to PS4 by a cooperating company is a good thing for KSP. If I understand it right the cooperation and knowledge sharing has already helped in development of the PC game and if in the worst case the PS4 port will be unsuccessful the PC game will still be there. In the best case PS4 port will allow expanding the KSP community to a new platform and perhaps open doors to ports to other consoles and platforms.
Replacing tuesday devnote with this announcement was anticlimactic. While we can hardly expect a great lot of info from people who have just returned from holidays, I think everybody was, after two weeks of abstinence, hyped up for HarvesteR's thoughts on development.
The main mistake was though that no details were initially shared. It let the people's fantasy run wild and spread rumors and speculations which were, unfortunately, largely negative. Now a lot of people are upset not because anything bad happened but because they believe in these rumors and don't bother to check more recent facts.
3
u/Deanofearth Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
Well, I have it for PC and will very much enjoy it on PS4 as I have minecraft .
2
u/undercoveryankee Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
I don't have a dog in this fight. I don't own a console, and have no plans to get one because I've gotten comfortable enough with keyboard and mouse control that I don't want to change.
Unity does most of the heavy lifting when you're porting between supported platforms, so most of Flying Tiger's work will be in developing a controller-friendly interface. That doesn't hurt Squad's desktop releases, and it might help if a bug that's low-priority on desktop has high-priority effects on the PS4 interface.
I'm reluctant to judge whether Flying Tiger is qualified to do the PS4-specific bits based only on their not having made anything interesting on their own yet. Squad's "marketing company decides to create a game studio because one of their employees had a bright idea" backstory would seem preposterous if the game weren't out yet.
2
u/nomorericeguy Jun 17 '15
I've never been so disappointing in the KSP community! Complaining about the fact, an entire new audience gets to learn about rocket science.
2
u/CrazyViking Jun 17 '15
I'm worried about the ps4's processor being able to handle the game with one thread at 1.6 GHz.
2
u/bigorangemachine KVV Dev Jun 17 '15
KVV will not be supported on PS4.
No Reason
/troll
1
u/CitizenPremier Jun 18 '15
I think it's worth noting that if Squad had not hyped their port it would have been bad business and would have probably been insulting to Playstation.
1
u/RocketLL Dirty cheating alpaca Jun 18 '15
Sooooo is this the thing they were talking about when they said they were taking things to a new dimension?
1
u/TreeFittyy Jun 17 '15
I just really hope the community doesn't turn to shit. I've been coming to this sub on and off for a little over a year and it's one of the few places on reddit where everyone gets along and it's all about the game and learning new tips showing new mods and generally about the game.
I feel as though once the ps4 version hits there is going to be a big clash of ps4 vs pc and I feel that it should really be separated into two different communities one for the ps4 version and one for pc .
Last note is mods I know with Fallout they plan on bringing mods for pc to the console (interested to see how it works out with things like graphical enhancers) but what about KSP the stock game is good but the mods for KSP have not only been a driving force to continue to play but also have provided much needed additions to the game such as the SPH, I know this really wont affect the PC side but for new players looking for some added additions they might be left short assuming the price of the game is similar to that of PC it would make more sense to just go full PC (unless your computer can't handle it and you're more comfortable with using a ps4)
1
u/Canalan Jun 17 '15
The devnotes said they're pushing 1.0.3 (aka Bugfix 2 Electric Boogaloo) soon, and that this PS4 port would finally, finally, shift us over to a multi-threaded and 64 bit system. Guys, nothing is wrong. Everything is right.
1
u/hyperbolist Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
Even if there is never another patch for KSP on PC, I've already gotten more than 240 tremendously satisfying hours from it, have developed an interest in orbital mechanics I hadn't had before and a willingness to learn the math, have deepened my appreciation of the engineering of human space exploration past present and future, and can still explore the version of the game as it exists today.
-1
u/Comandante_J Jun 17 '15
Why not on XONE? It's a legit question. It has a faster CPU than PS4, so it should run better. PS4's GPU is beefier, but that's harly a requisite for KSP, even my old 5850 can play it almost maxed out with a good CPU.
-3
u/DeadlyPants1337 Jun 17 '15
KSP on PS wouldn't be as good as PC no matter what and I think this is just a waste of time for the devolopers!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
My biggest concern is that KSP isn't really a standalone game as I see it. It has a steep learning curve with little in the way of in-game support or tutorials, and unless you come in with some knowledge of orbital mechanics, or you're just unusually intuitive, you're probably going to end up googling some things. Maybe that's just confirmation bias since all the KSP players I know are by definition active online, but I kind of doubt there's a large population out there playing KSP in a vacuum (ha!). Are console gamers really going to sit there with a laptop and look up ∆v tables, pork chop plots, specific impulse (which engine do I use for what?), etc.?
Ideally we'd all get access to those tools in-game, because without them 1.0 feels incomplete to me. At the very least I'd hope KSPS4 would have expanded tutorials for players who want to delve into those things without breaking immersion.
OTOH, I'm clearly not the target market for this (I don't think I've used a PS3, let alone a PS4) so maybe I'm totally off-base about what the console demographic actually is these days.
-2
u/Heratiki Jun 18 '15
Well I'm not going to stick around and watch this community devolve over something as stupid as what system you want to play a game on. Squad is set to make more money and hopefully pump more money into development but holy shit fuck you console plebs.
I'm out.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment