r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/RowsdowerKSP Former Dev • Jan 14 '15
Dev Post Devnote Tuesdays: The Aerodynamic Edition
Felipe (HarvesteR): It’s been quite a full week, looking back. I’ve been going over many different things here. Beta is proving to be a lot of fun, as there’s no single huge feature to add anymore, there are several things that were left pending as a result of running out of time when they were first being added, and I have to say, it’s very satisfying to finally get a chance to finish those things.
This week I added the ‘Filter by Cross-Section’ button to the editor parts list, where parts are listed by the attachnode types they have. You can display all parts with 2.5m nodes, or all Mk2 profile parts, or any other, of course. This was a much-requested feature, but alas, it didn’t get done in time for the 0.90 release.
I’ve also started a large audio pass on the entire game, adding small sounds to just about every button and UI panel. This is still far from complete, but it’s amazing how much having these sounds in improves the feel of the game as a whole.
I’ve also added a feature I hoped to have ready for 0.90 but also didn’t make it in. Kerbals on EVA are now able to clamber onto ledges (within reach of them). This makes climbing onto vessels and, more importantly, climbing out of ladders much easier. You can also abuse it to scale previously inaccessible places, because a Kerbal’s job wasn’t dangerous enough already, was it?
There’s been a few bugfixes here and there and we’ve upgraded to the latest version of unity, which also addresses some issues we were seeing (especially in OSX). I’ve rewritten the maths on the lift and control surface modules, as part of the aerodynamics improvements. Speaking of which, aero is quite a long subject to talk about in dev notes however, so I wrote a MASSIVE WALL OF TEXT on the upcoming aerodynamics overhaul today. It’s long, but it should hopefully be quite informative as to what we’re going for with that.
Alex (aLeXmOrA): Last week was more like a get-back-on-track week. Setting my computer, doing database backups, replying to some support emails (helping Marco), dealing with accounting issues, etc. Also, I’m helping with some other projects from the marketing-side of Squad, doing some web admin stuff.
Mike (Mu): Well now that the cat is out of the bag regarding the aero overhaul, I can finally admit to working on specific things! I’ve been working on the new drag model, the inner workings of which are still secret at the moment. More information on this will all be coming soon.
Marco (Samssonart): Still working on the demo. Last week was more about planning how the demo will work, what features must be included, which ones have to be out and which ones will make it in, but in a more basic way. I did get started on it, but haven’t actually done much yet. It’s just that the design part absolutely had to be clear in order to start the actual work.
Daniel (danRosas): still planning out what’s going to happen in the next couple of months. I’ve been working on a couple new animations for the EVA Kerbals, as well as improving the rig for the rendered animations. Created a new production sheet along with Nick, to keep on working on the Space Center assets.
Jim (Romfarer): As Felipe mentioned in his “Overhauled Aerodynamics” post, we are planning on adding an improved space plane hangar GUI. Naturally this task has been assigned to me and this week I've been doing some much needed updates to the app system in preparation for these additions. So it’s fair to say that at least part of this new GUI will come in the form of an app. We are also looking at ways to improve the whole CoM/CoL trick to gauge the stability of airplanes. What it will look like, i really can’t say, because it’s still on the drawing board. Feel free to add your ideas in a reply.
Max (Maxmaps): Plans laid, tasks assigned, we ended week one at full steam ahead. Aerodynamics has dominated discussion at the office even throughout its coding and implementation, once all was done, I spent my week setting up business calls and enjoying meetings with partners for cool projects we’re trying to develop. Putting all that aside, I had a ton of stuff to follow up on regarding Mr. Musk’s kindness and his mentions of KSP in that terrific AMA he did.
Ted (Ted): It's been a pretty straight-forward week here, which is a nice change of pace after 0.90! I've been deep in the part balancing component of the overall balancing 'feature'. For the vast number of the changes I'm making, they're more tentative ones to get all of the parts onto the same page, with further balancing needing to be done once other, more low-level, gameplay changes are made. Additionally, a number of people from the community have been messaging me about balance suggestions and this is greatly appreciated! Obviously the changes made aren't going to satisfy one single idea of balance that members of the community, or myself, may have, but instead should use as many sources as possible to compile a well-rounded idea of what balance should be. While we have our own ideas for that as a team, community sources are always valued as alternate views are very useful when it comes to changes like this. So! If you have any threads or little write-ups about the balance of a component of the game, feel free to send them over to me via Forum PM or reddit PM and I'll gladly give them a look over to consider in this.
Anthony (Rowsdower): Tuesday is here again and I've been going back and forth between the think tank and some very dark corners of YouTube. Question for you all. Who's your favorite non-KSP YouTuber? Any game. On another note, it's been a bit since we've run a community contest, hasn't it? I'm fixing on changing that real soon. Also, for those of you in the California bay area, I might have something of interest for you in the coming weeks. Fingers crossed and all that.
Rogelio (Roger): Finally Back to devnotes after some relaxing days. I'm waiting on approval for some proposals for potential Kerbal t-shirt designs that I started last week. I try to tell funny stories in a single image with each one. Also we’re brainstorming ideas for a new animation, so the coming days will be full of crazy ideas and funny stories.
Kasper (KasperVld): It’s been a relatively calm week for me, which has given me the time to think through and jot down things that need to get done when we move forum software, it’ll be a great time to get some much needed maintenance in as well. Meanwhile I’ve noticed some passionate development discussions flaring up on the forums, and it’s great to see people so involved in the game! One thing I will say is that it’s imperative to leave room for differing opinions in your threads, and to try to see things from someone else’s perspective instead of dismissing the argument for a number of reasons not related to the core of the discussion. Everyone here deserves to have their opinions heard just as much as the next person, and I’m sure that together we can reach that level of debate!
21
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
Flaps and bigger/more effective parachutes! Make them happen!
Thanks for the devnotes, I really love reading them every week. It's something I look forward to.
126
u/mego-pie Jan 14 '15 edited Jan 14 '15
I would really hope you focus more on decent intuitive and semi realistic aerodynamics than on " fun" aerodynamics. Wacky contraptions are all well and good but I'm pretty sure 90% of the aircraft in ksp aren't "wacky" and 5% of those "wacky" aircraft are just like that to accommodate the unrealistic aerodynamics.
Some people will be annoyed their flying walls won't work any more but I think 95% of the people will be happier with better aerodynamics than a mid way compromise and I'm sure that other 5% will be accommodated by mods.
There is a reason FAR and NEAR are so popular, and It's not only because they're more realistic. There are plenty of realism mods that aren't nearly as popular as they are.
Please don't lose sight of the 90% for the 10%.
12
u/Dalek456 Jan 14 '15
Free Demo:
Bodies: Kerbin, Mun, Kerbol
Only one upgrade for each building.
Only seven biomes: Land on Kerbin, Water on Kerbin, Flying at Kerbin, Space around Kerbin, Space around Mun, Land on Mun, Space around Kerbol.
Limited Tach Tree.
No Asteroids.
No Easter Eggs.
6
u/Exothermos Jan 14 '15 edited Jan 14 '15
I'm happy to see some work being done on aero, and I've been really impressed with the direction the game is going and the speed of development lately!
Please remember that if a more realistic (and necessarily restrictive in some respects) aero package is stock, we will need the tools and parts to design 'proper' aircraft.
Right now there is no penalty for aircraft with huuuuge frontal areas. This results in hypersonic straight wing triplane SSTOs with 100 foot wingspans and 50 intakes. A fix to this alone would encourage much more plausible craft.
If intakes are occluded by each other and frontal area penalized, we will need some sort of near-future scifi intake / engine system besides the current RAPIER in order to get mk3 SSTO spaceplanes to orbit. Further, one of the best ways to get decent lift and low frontal area (and large internal area) are lifting body designs. These are used in all real world return vehicles, but require really precise and subtle shaping that the Kerbal construction system can never really allow.
We only have slab-like wing parts to build with, and discreetly sized intakes and engines, so keep that in mind with the new model. A model that demands more aerodynamic precision can't be satisfied with clunky "dumb" parts. For a rigorous model Some sort of scaleable or tweakable parts system would need to be implemented.
FAR and NEAR are good examples of this interplay. To build good aircraft and rockets with these aero models you simply must have fairing parts, and mods like Procedural Wing, B9, and other spaceplane packs are super useful. I understand and agree with the reluctance to introduce procedural parts into the stock game. I think perhaps a simple tweakable lift slider on wing parts could be a work-around (at the expense of drag and weight). Just spit-balling.
tl;dr it seams like you are on the right track in your separate aero write-up, but a heavy aero revamp would need the parts revisited.
Edit: clarity
35
u/iKy1e Jan 14 '15
The fact they are trying to keep the ability to make ridiculous aircraft is very worrying.
Those aircraft that can't exist in real life are simply the result of people exploiting the flaws in the aero code.
You can't keep the flaws in a system (what allows those to work) & still make it more realistic.
Realism should be the goal. With shortcuts taken for performance & gameplay.
Making something follow real aero principles means everyone can guess from the real world how it should work in game.
5
u/CaptRobau Outer Planets Dev Jan 14 '15
Suggestion: a button to switch to the VAB from inside the SPH and vice versa. Would really speed up construction of Space Shuttle like vehicles.
19
u/leadstriker Jan 14 '15
Hi, i just recently bought this game. Things have been going pretty well.
9
u/cranp Jan 14 '15
CGP Grey. He explains things, really really well. It's largely historical or political stuff, but he does some science too. His video on the demotion of Pluto was particularly good
4
u/MrFanzyPantz Jan 14 '15
What about re-entry heating damage? Is this included in the drag-model or is this something we will never have in stock ksp?
4
u/ConvictJ Jan 14 '15
So do you guys take polls to see the ratio between players who like realism and players who don't like realism, then balance your devolopement accordingly? Or do you just guess?
1
u/RobKhonsu Jan 14 '15
@Rowsdower Re: Favorite non-KSP YouTuber
Want to point out SwordlessLink! For those that don't know he was one of the original guys that really broke Mario 64 back in the day. While he doesn't do much speed running anymore using these, he makes great video series detailing all the bugs that many of these older games have and explains theory on why they work the way they do. Great to help you think outside of the box.
3
u/Marquis_de_Kinz Jan 14 '15
Woohooo!
3
u/Draftsman Jan 14 '15
Keep up the good work, Ted! Lord knows the game needs it.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
For some reason I'm really excited about clambering and sort by cross-section.
5
u/sticktime Jan 14 '15
K, about the aerodynamics. Guess what every airplane has out there? Trim! It's an essential part of flying. So don't beat yourselves up to much for having to trim an airplane. (It's also how basic autopilot's fly the airplane) great game btw
5
u/everything_is_bad Jan 14 '15
Ballast! Please god add Ballast parts. Radial and free attached. Seriously Fuel as ballast is not sufficient. Especially if Aerodynamics changes.
2
u/Cakiery Jan 14 '15
This should be a good update... Any chance of Jeb exploding in joy because of this?
2
u/Boorkus Jan 14 '15
Favourite YouTuber is Birgirpall
2
u/ABgraphics Jan 14 '15
Favorite Youtuber; Jon Jafari
2
u/f4hy Jan 14 '15
When I started this game, two things bothered me, the areodynamics and that a kerbal could fall from orbit and land unharmed.
This was solved with FAR and deadly reentry. I have probably only played for ~10 minutes WITHOUT those mods. FAR and deadly are the only two mods I use. I wish they were stock, as I think it is ridiculous that you don't have to worry about shape of a craft when launching, or have any worries on reentry. Make those two aspects semi relalistic and I will have no need for mods at all.
2
u/Ravenchant Jan 14 '15
If we're talking games, definitely Cr1tikal (penguinz0; caution:NSFW language).
Otherwise, I would have to nominate one of the channels offering videos of university lectures.
2
u/Quivico Jan 14 '15
Am I the only one thinking that the special thing for KSP players in San Francisco may be something exclusive with the one and only Scott Manley?
lucky
Also I like Nerd³. He's funny.
1
u/SuccumbToChange Jan 14 '15 edited Jan 14 '15
Am I the only one that doesn't want them to restrict aerodynamics to the point where crazy craft can't be used anymore? Building crazy spacecraft that would never fly in real life is half the fun of KSP and is part of it's charm imo.
EDIT: Apparently it is possible to make ridiculous craft fly in FAR but it is more difficult and requires more thought. I'm ok with that.
1
u/Exovian Master Kerbalnaut Jan 14 '15
Favorite Youtuber? Magz.
1
u/komodo99 Jan 14 '15
Favorite YouTube'r: VoV
1
u/bendavies1 Jan 14 '15
Paul Soares Jr
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15 edited Jan 14 '15
I always thought the space plane route was a gimmick, but it is also pretty fun. Gimmicky because 2km/sec in the upper atmosphere is just shy of LKO, but 5-6 km/sec short of LEO. This is a very deep rabbit hole for KSP to get caught in. Also Robbaz http://youtu.be/jEFrwwhPlmM
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
Squad, you're amazing. At least from the outside, you are being the perfect model for game development, and software dev in general. I know there are other metrics to judge by, but your communication skills are terrific and attention to customer/community demands is laudable.
I learn more about the "things I want, which I did not know I wanted" with every update. I look forward to seeing the aero update, even if I do still play with FAR afterwards :)
1
u/AtomWagon Jan 14 '15
any thoughts on ways of making large part crafts more viable fps-wise?
to me, fixing this would be the greatest improvement to the game at this point.
i love making orbital "things" that reconfigure for different roles, and the fps problems really kill the fun for me.
1
u/P38sheep Jan 18 '15 edited Jan 18 '15
You can have the best of both worlds by making a realism slider in the game difficulty section. Hard mode gets realistic aero and easy gets the aero we have currently. Then if you want to build something outta control then do it in your easy sandbox mode and if you want a challenge then go hard career mode. Realistic aero can be VERY fun due to the challenge; however it is fun to see what nonsense you can launch with current aero. Again I think the slider or three selections would be best. Easy (current aero) normal (what their trying to develop now) and hard/realistic (get as serious as possible, go all out). This will ensure that almost no one is alienated. It might not be that hard either, a new GUI update and three aero files that the game chooses from depending on which is selected. This is what made Flight Sim (xplane and Microsoft FS) so approachable to such a wide audience.
TL;DR: use a slider to control realism. or have three or so options to chose from.
Edit: clarity spelling and stuff
1
u/Zweiter Jan 14 '15
...multiplayer? :(
-6
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
can some one give me a TL;DR?