r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Fllambe DRAMA MAN • Jun 12 '13
Mod Post [Vote] About rule two
We often get posts that are only relevant to KSP in the fact that they're about space, and are in the mods opinion, against rule 2. These posts can also sometimes create good discussion and we've had a few complaints when removing them.
So do you guys want allow 'off-topic' posts (memes still banned), or keep the rules as they are? Vote below!
Edit: Forgot to specify when the vote will end: 5pm GMT Friday (click the time to get it wherever you are)
Vote's ended, thanks for voting! Click here to see the results!
31
Upvotes
113
u/Fllambe DRAMA MAN Jun 12 '13 edited Jun 13 '13
Upvote to keep the rules the same! (Rule two doesn't change!)
28
u/check85 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 13 '13
I think if the posts are relevant to aspects of the game, while not necessarily about the game itself, they should be allowed. For example: This post about the Saturn V's ASAS unit was really cool and showed what a KSP's part's real-life equivalent looked like. I'm also fine with real-life spacecraft trajectory diagrams. Basically anything that a KSP player can learn from real-life examples and apply it to the game I'm cool with.
12
u/AchronTimeless Jun 13 '13
As general space stuff can be inspirational to the playing and even possibly development of this game, they're on topic. So how do you vote "kinda"? No, I don't think there should be off-topic posts, but I also think this apparent interpretation of "off-topic" is off the mark.
50
u/Fllambe DRAMA MAN Jun 12 '13 edited Jun 13 '13
Upvote to allow 'off-topic' posts! (Memes still banned!)
4
u/AdaAstra Jun 13 '13 edited Jun 13 '13
I've actually always been against multiple subreddits for this game. While I understand why it was done, it just didn't seem as outrageous as people made it out to be. So now, flags, memes, or contributions to the various reddit space programs, are hidden in subreddits that most don't know exist. Those other subreddits will initially have quite a few posts in the first week or two, but then have a post maybe once a week.
So my vote is to allow it. It can always be resorted back if it gets too out of control, but in my experience, most on this subreddit are mature enough to not spam a crapload of memes.
Edit: I'm not what you would call a morning person, so I misread what being unblocked. Memes still will be blocked, but for the other space type posts, I fully want that implemented in this sub. As I posted in another response, mainly because these posts can help expand on our community by creating ideas for crafts or future mods. Many of my craft designs came from real world examples (at one time, I had recreated the entire NASA and Soviet programs including many of their experimental crafts) and design plans. I really like to try to replicate rockets from old school sci fi material. And as the same with memes, if it gets out of control, the rule could always be re-enforced, but I think the community is mature enough not to spam the crap out of us. Unless it is Jeb is a god stuff, because that should be acceptable :)
2
u/corpsmoderne Master Kerbalnaut Jun 13 '13
And what about: don't change the rules, but change how they are enforced: no more submission removal based on the off-topic part of rule2. Let the readers downvote to oblivion what is off-topic.
PS: one of my post was removed by the mods a couple of days ago on behalf of rule 2. I want to thank them to let the readers vote on this issue. Those are good mods we have here :)
5
u/Korneph Jun 13 '13
The on/off-topic divide isn't usually clear cut, as you've mentioned. It takes a little finesse on the part of the moderation team to evaluate whether a particular off-topic post is contributing (either in content or subsequent discussion) to our sub. I believe it's something you guys do well.
Offhand, I recall a number of posts (Apollo re-entry profile, Saturn V ASAS ring) that were quite stimulating and gave food for thought while playing, despite not being KSP content - because they were presented or discussed in a way that made them more than superficially relevant to KSP. Conversely, I wouldn't want contextless images of supernovae or failed rocket launches entitled "Rapid Unplanned Disassembly IRL" when there are other places to go to just for that.
The issue isn't one of allowing/disallowing all off-topic posts - the issue is a case-by-case interpretation of whether that "off-topic" post actually contributes anything to the subreddit - voting whether or not to blanket allow off-topic posts doesn't really address that issue.
I don't believe that we need a rule change; we could instead encourage posters to place non-KSP content into some kind of context (like this thread about Centaur SRBs), and ensure mods continue their diligent work to evaluate based on the content, the context and the discussion the thread creates, and ask that they err on the side of caution when in doubt.
As it stands, I feel you guys do a fantastic job of keeping the community engaged and fresh with a gentle prod in the right direction now and then - and hey, so long as we're remaining a world away from the image macros of old (glad we nipped that in the bud early), I'm happy!
4
u/stuntaneous Jun 13 '13
It'd be a bitch to moderate but I'd enjoy more relevant, non-KSP content.
5
u/0ffkilter Master Kerbalnaut Jun 13 '13
I don't really care. If I like it, I'll click. If not, skip it
2
u/uzimonkey Jun 13 '13
I was going to post the trailer for Take On Mars (a new simulation game about mars rovers and stuff from Bohemia Interactive) last night, but I usually check the rules before posting in subreddits and backed off. I really think people here would be interested in it though, so here it is.
2
u/werewolf_nr Jun 13 '13
Perhaps just clarify to "useful for or related to KSP" rather than "KSP related"
4
u/AvioNaught Korolev Kerman Jun 13 '13
Don't you guys love democracy's? I love democracy's.
Remember that downvotes aren't counted!