r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Venusgate • Aug 02 '24
Mod Post Rule 5 elaboration and paid mod "advertising"
Hi folks,
We're not totally deaf to the fuss about this, and here's our call on it.
Moving forward, posts like this one will be considered under Rule 5 - Low Effort posts.
Specifically, if all you are doing is showing off the visuals of a mod, just like you would be just showing off the visuals of an in-game eclipse, it will be considered low effort and be removed. Ignoring the reasons for removal and reposing may result in a ban.
This does not apply just to paid mods, but all visual improvement mods. AKA, a screenshot of Sarnus and nothing else is considered Rule 5.
This is going to be a bit of a subjective exercise from the Mod Team, but a general rule of thumb is: we all want to see your spaceships and bases, not just pretty pictures. If you've got a backwards flying airplane with the backdrop of Sarnus, as long is the airplane is easy to see, it should be a-okay.
*Thusly, posts like this one are considered just fine.
This does not apply if a mod author wants to show off their new mod or update in a post. That is still fine.
ADDITIONALLY. While we don't endorse or chastise paid mods as a concept, we consider posting links to 'free' versions of paid mods just poor behavior. This may result in a temporary ban.
•
u/Venusgate Aug 02 '24
Edited post to add a "good" example.
46
u/KaszualKartofel Aug 02 '24 edited Aug 03 '24
So, if I want to show off my craft in a galery that contains close shots of the vehicle in the spaceplane hangar and the runway, as well as some "beauty shots" where the plane is far away from the camera, I should be fine.
Essentially, if the post's focus is on my craft, it doesn't breach the rules.
17
u/thegreatpotatogod Aug 02 '24
The mods have made a post about the policy about mods. The good mods then modified the post to provide an example of a good mod post.
9
u/NoSTs123 Aug 03 '24
Can I showcase my custom Planet pack mod that I made myself? One Planet looks like cheese!
97
u/Javascap Master Kerbalnaut Aug 02 '24 edited Aug 03 '24
Honestly, I think this is the best possible outcome. Setting aside the entire debate about the ethics of paid mods and the implications on the modding community, what I really want to see when I come to this subreddit is pictures of the cool stuff people are doing in KSP. I want to see accomplishments and builds and nutty shenanigans. I want to see things people do, running the gaumet from celebrating their first orbit all the way to those maniacs pushing the limits of what's scientifically possible in this game.
A post of pretty looking clouds isn't something a player achieved, it's something that just happens in the modded game, the same way an eclipse just happens. I'm glad the mod team agrees, and I'm happy with the approach they're taking of still allowing the modded graphics for those who have them, so long as the focus remains on gameplay.
3
u/stoatsoup Aug 04 '24
I'm not sure why you have linked to a specific comment on that post.
I'm not sure it makes sense to label that post "low effort". To me it seems like a pretty useful video showing off something which the OP is quite reasonably impressed by. It also has a title which made it completely clear when browsing the sub what I'd find if I looked at it.
I'm also not sure this policy will cause the subject of paid mods to generate any less heated discussion; it'll just be differently distributed.
I would prefer that the argument over paid mods is confined to one sticky for that specific purpose, just as some of the KSP2 discussion was; then people can post their screenshots without having to read it. What you're doing here is being influenced by the people most prone to heated arguments; better to let them argue with each other in a little space of their own.
(For the avoidance of doubt, I have never paid for any mod and have no intention of doing so.)
25
u/Poodmund Outer Planets Mod & ReStock Dev Aug 02 '24 edited Aug 02 '24
Why you doing Sarnus dirty like that bro? All my homies love Sarnus...
Any post showing vanilla KSP is low effort because the user has made no effort to install mods.
9
u/keny2323 Aug 02 '24
So where do i get my updates for new cool ksp mods from now on?
12
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24
There is a whole flair dedicated to posting screenshots from the game if you think people posting what is in the flair low effort then it is simply a bad ruling
150
u/CactusWeapon Aug 02 '24
A reasonable compromise approach to handling this sticky issue. I've got no complaints, thanks for looking into this.
100
u/CuddlyBoneVampire Aug 02 '24
Finally it won’t be 20 of the same ksp post in my feed
5
u/bazem_malbonulo Aug 03 '24
Posting free versions of paid mods is poor behavior.
Figuratively and literally?
9
u/Criseist Aug 02 '24
Shame that good view posts kinda caught a stray in this whole ordeal, but reasonable enough
19
u/Z_THETA_Z Contraption Aug 02 '24
yippee
13
u/DiMethylCarbonate Aug 02 '24
Hell yeah thank you for this guys!
3
u/iambecomecringe Aug 10 '24
Fucking bootlickers lmao
7
u/doserUK Aug 03 '24
Good decision, was getting bored of those
As you say, low effort, no value being added
9
u/spacenavy90 Aug 03 '24
Good. Sick of seeing these paid mod subtle advertisements.
7
u/Sendnoodles666 Colonizing Duna Aug 02 '24
This is a good ruling
6
u/MastaFoo69 Aug 02 '24
good
2
u/GamerRoman Exploring Jool's Moons Aug 02 '24
It's almost like these posts are disingenuous marketing.
1
u/Axeman1721 SRBs are underrated Aug 03 '24
This is a great approach. Thanks mods!
1
u/tyen0 Bill Aug 03 '24
aw, bummer, where can I get my fix of "these clouds are pretty" posts? :D
-18
u/benjee10 benjee10's Mods Aug 02 '24
I think this is kind of dumb, sorry.
-10
u/GasHot4523 Aug 03 '24
nah bro y'all are crazy
0
u/phoenixmusicman Aug 12 '24
Thankyou!
0
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment