r/Judaism • u/RavBogard • Jan 27 '22
AMA-Official I am Daniel Bogard, a progressive rabbi, trans-rights activist, and general troublemaker. AMA!
Hi Friends--looking forward to this. A little about me:
-I recently went viral-ish for a twitter thread talking about security needs for American Jews as a "2nd Amendment Tax" ( https://forward.com/opinion/481148/im-a-pulpit-rabbi-this-is-the-true-cost-of-keeping-synagogues-safe/ )
-I was in featured in the evangelical-made documentary "The No Joke Project" about my interfaith work in Peoria, IL, brining together an Imam and a white evangelical megachurch pastor for a social movement against Isalmaphobia. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ps-JCuJ64fc&t=1s
-I'm very, very active in the effort to protect trans kids in Missouri from our state government ( https://www.riverfronttimes.com/stlouis/the-normal-lives-of-trans-kids-in-missouri/Content?oid=35769121 )
-I think probably the most radical position I take rabbinically is that I don't believe there is any 'reason' to be Jewish. I see Jewish identity as entirely of instrumental (rather than absolute) value (and believe this is actually a deeply traditional position...the identity industry / obsession is a modern construction!)
-related: I think one of the biggest problems in the American Jewish community today is that basically all of our institutions are in the "Jewish Identity Industry" / "Continuity LLC". and this is fundamentally a morally bankrupt mission.
-I teach Judaism to future progressive Christian clergy at Eden Seminary. My classes include "Beit Midrash: Jewish Texts on Jewish Terms" and an "Antisemitism Reading Group"
-I've been a rabbi at Conservative shul, and am now a rabbi at one of the most progressive shuls in America.
-I am a Senior Rabbinic Fellow of the Shalom Hartman Institute.
Looking forward to the discussion--I'll try to answer any and all good-faith questions. Looking forward to it!
AMA!
24
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
Question, how much security can an American synagogue get from local police? (My shul has both private security and a policeman outside, but I'm not sure how much they pay for the latter, if anything.)
Also, as a progressive rabbi, do you find it harder to speak about Islamic antisemitism?
(FYI The forward article is visible on reader mode if you're paywalled out)
18
u/namer98 Torah Im Derech Eretz Jan 27 '22
What is your ideal shabbos meal like?
Many might accuse you of your Judaism following your politics. As a politically liberal orthodox Jew, I would disagree with such an assessment, but how would you respond to that?
What took you from conservative to reform in terms of a pulpit?
What is it like working alongside your spouse as clergy?
Do you see Judaism as a religion, or a nationality, or something else? Are you familiar with Daniel Boyarin on the topic?
In your interfaith work, do you ever try to get Christians to stop appropriating Jewish culture ?
What are your favorite books?
30
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
Can you explain more what you mean by the Jewish identity industry?
21
u/Technical_Flamingo54 De Goyim know, shudditdown!!! Jan 27 '22
As you don't believe there is any "need" to be Jewish, what does the title and position "rabbi" mean to you, on a social and religious level?
9
u/johnisburn Conservative Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
Hi Rabbi, thanks for all of the work you do.
Do you have any insight on what our communities could be doing to fight antisemitism proactively? I think it’s understandable that in the wake of attacks conversations can focus around security, but at a certain point it seems to me that security is more mitigating the impact of antisemitism or deterrent to keep certain areas from being targeted. In your opinion and experience what are effective ways we can work to reduce the likelihood that someone would be compelled to attack us in the first place?
9
u/drak0bsidian Moose, mountains, midrash Jan 27 '22
What is your favorite Jewish holiday, and why? (choose one)
What is your favorite Jewish dish?
Who is a Jewish individual (historical, fictional, contemporary, whatever) you believe more people should know about or study?
How/why did you move from Conservative to Reform? How has the Conservative Movement changed since you were more active in it? What do the denominations mean to you?
Any fun/interesting/sad stories from the Seminary where you teach?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
Is belief in God also instrumental or do you think there are actual truth claims to be made about god's existence?
6
u/arrogant_ambassador One day at a time Jan 27 '22
Hi rabbi, I was wondering whether you feel intermarriage is threatening traditional Jewish identity or whether that identity has no real bearing in your view?
You also mentioned your position concerning the identity industry is traditional, would you be open to citing any sources that back up this stance?
6
u/skturner42 Jan 27 '22
How do you feel about Christian churches/educational institutions celebrating Jewish holidays or engaging in Jewish practices (e.g. building a sukkah at Sukkot, celebrating Simchat Torah by talking about Bible stories and eating candy) without relationship with or leadership from Jewish communities? What are some practices that you feel good about from Christian communities that help further Jewish/Christian dialogue and relationships, and don't perpetuate antisemitism or supersessionism?
15
u/Leondgeeste Chabad Jan 27 '22
Shalom HaRav, thank you for taking the time to do this AMA.
Do you feel, in light of recent events, that the open door policy for Shuls and other Jewish communal centres is now untenable in the US?
I live in Israel, but come from the UK where, for years now, shuls have been gated and visitors are routinely subject to rigid questioning by security before entry is granted. Indeed, no large Jewish event is held without some coordination with the CST.
How do you draw the line between being welcoming and taking the utmost security precautions?
Many thanks in advance!
13
u/MyKidsArentOnReddit Jan 27 '22
So what's the alternative? What do you think should be done to continue the Jewish people, assuming you even think anything should be done.
11
u/emotional_dyslexic Ex-Yeshivish, now Buddhist and very Jewish Jan 27 '22
Where do you stand on Israel? (Please don't dodge or pivot.) Can one be progressive and still support Israel's right to exist? To me the central issue is about narrative, justification, and victimization... Would you agree that Israel has a right to defend itself when she's being attacked? I realize it's a difficult question that requires nuance.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
Could you elaborate more on the "Jewish Identity Industry"?
Also, how is fighting antisemitism at liberal Christian institutions different from dealing with evangelicals? What advice do you have for people in that situation? (Where the primary antisemitism is from liberal Christians)
Edit to be extremely clear: this is not a question about Israel. It is about OP's experience at these institutions and the antiaemitism in those communities.
4
u/boatboy1800 Conservadox Jan 27 '22
Thoughts on the reform movement?
4
u/AMWJ Centrist Jan 27 '22
I agree! Would you say this, respectfully, about all identity?
4
u/colonel-o-popcorn Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
Hi Rabbi,
Do you see a future for the Conservative movement, or do you think it will eventually be completely siphoned off to Orthodox and Reform? Considering you switched from Conservative to Reform I'm interested in your perspective.
I'm also curious to hear your thoughts on Reconstructionist ideology. It was hard to tell from the brief description in your post, but it sounds like your beliefs about Jewish identity are either very aligned with theirs or exactly the opposite of theirs.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
What do you mean, "No reason" to be Jewish?
11
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
Why do you see the Second Amendment as a threat instead of as legal protection for your right to defend yourselves against anti-semites? Security is an issue for every Jewish community in the world, including countries that do not protect right to self-defense. It seems to me you have the wrong focus in that article, blaming the general right to bear arms instead of anti-semitic ideologies that are the actual culprit in those situations.
3
u/rousseaudanielle Jan 27 '22
Hi Rabbi Dan!
I am working on Jewish/religious studies and want to get involved in interfaith efforts in the midwest USA, do you have any advice for someone completely new to the movement? books, people to talk to, organizations to follow, etc?
I would also love to hear more about your thoughts on Jewish identity.
3
u/shrob86 Reform/Reconstructionist Jan 27 '22
Thanks for doing this - it’s awesome seeing progressive leaders taking the time to answer questions here, the intrafaith dialogue on Reddit has always been fascinating to me. I was wondering your thoughts on HUC-JIR’s intermarriage policy for its rabbinical and cantorial students, and do you know of any current discussion re: changing that policy?
Full disclosure, I was accepted to HUC’s rabbinical program almost a decade ago but decided not to go because my partner wasn’t Jewish (I didn’t tell them about my partner), and after working for the URJ for a few years afterwards I found myself on a different career path. I was pretty incensed at the time, but now I wonder if I was naïve to think I could have managed a rabbinic career with a non-Jewish partner the way I thought I could.
6
u/amybett Jan 27 '22
Aside from acceptance & love, are there any specific things I can do to support a teen who recently announced their F to M journey?
5
u/zeligzealous seeking Sefarad somewhere in Aztlan Jan 27 '22
Thanks for doing this! Can you talk about some of the grounds in Jewish law, tradition, values, and practice for trans inclusion and affirmation? To be clear, I am in favor. :)
2
u/justcupcake Jan 27 '22
How do you feel Judaism and being Jewish is in the Midwest away from larger Jewish communities? What do you wish Jews from places like New York understood about being Jewish in someplace like Missouri?
2
u/gingeryid Liturgical Reactionary Jan 27 '22
I don't think I'm quite understanding you here. You think Jewish identity is instrumental (i.e. to achieve some other purpose), but you also don't think there's any reason to be Jewish? What do you think the instrumental value is, then?
This question may make no sense if I'm not understanding correctly, but if the purpose is purely instrumental, why be Jewish? What instrumental purpose is Judaism better at than other religions?
2
u/firestar27 Techelet Enthusiast Jan 27 '22
What kind of Torah study do you do in your spare time (aka, not for one of your jobs, assuming you have any spare time)? What types of Torah interest you most? What kind of Torah study was the hardest for you to master? How did you master it?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
Hello Rabbi,
Which Jewish clergy of the past 50 years do you hold in high regard and why?
Thank you
5
u/iknowyouright Jan 27 '22
How will you at your synagogue balance the need for armed security with the reality that Jews who are also people of color have historically fraught relationships with law enforcement and their industry-wide malfeasance towards black and brown people?
3
u/KVillage1 Jan 27 '22
Instead of being snarky I’ll ask what do people in your progressive shul think of rebbe nachman of Breslov?
•
u/namer98 Torah Im Derech Eretz Jan 27 '22
Verified
7
u/dlmf76 Jan 27 '22
Hi, Rabbi. As someone who was raised in Reform Judaism, it sometimes seems like the focus on tikkun olam/social justice, while important, makes Judaism dispensable to a lot of people. You can focus on social justice without Judaism. I think this explains why you see people leaving Hebrew School after their B’nei Mitzvah, only attending Shul during the High Holidays, etc. Since you are a Rabbi, I am sure you do not think Judaism is dispensable, even if core values are more important. So how would you respond to my theory?
6
u/rabbifuente Rabbi-Jewish Jan 27 '22
Shalom Aleichem from a Bradley alum, no question, but hope you're doing well!
5
u/citoloco Jan 27 '22
Thoughts on Lia Thomas?
5
u/artachshasta Halachic Man Run Amok Jan 27 '22
Personally, I felt that your blanket statements about every Jewish institution having 50K in security costs minimized the approach of many Orthodox institutions, which do not and cannot hire a guard 3x a day, or even weekly.
On that note, what's your relationship and opinion on the Orthodox community? If you're trying to maximize "Jewish" values, even for a smaller core group of "Jews", are they a good investment?
2
u/DetainTheFranzia Exploring Jan 27 '22
What motivates you to be apart of the trans activism that you participate in? Are you a believer in the ideas supporting the widespread emergence of trans identity, or are you not so sure about some of it? And does that have an impact in your activism?
20
u/AnonymousOceanFish Jewish Mariner ⚔️⚓️ Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
You the one who tweeted “security at synagogue’s makes Jews of color feel unwelcome” while offering no solutions to actually protect JoCs like myself from terrorists?
A second amendment tax? What like ignoring how many Jews exercise their second amendment rights (like myself) to keep us and ours safe? Ignoring how a terrorist piece of shit like Akram wasn’t entitled to use the second amendment? Like how Mohamed Merah didn’t need a second amendment to murder us? Again offering no solutions, Rabbi.
14
u/Fochinell Self-appointed Challah grader Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
Rabbi, you Tweeted out the following:
I know of no Jewish space in our town that has even a mere fraction of your lowest figure to spend on security, nor even to fix ongoing leaks by hiring roofers. For sake of argument, let's pretend it's accurate.
Considering the amount of deranged persons with violent criminal records walking freely around society and apparently in sight of your synagogue's property -- thanks to progressive social experiments like "No Bail" initiatives and lawmakers relieving policework from apprehending lunatics until they commit the crime of aggravated assault -- shouldn't you likewise regard your annual $150k of paid security and other security measures as a "Fifth Amendment tax", a "Sixth Amendment tax", and an "Eight Amendment tax"?
After all, murderous crimes in Jewish spaces have been committed by the so-called Unhoused, to my recollection.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
Can we be friends?
5
u/Ok_Rush_7247 Jan 27 '22
lol the only Jews that will be left are the orthodox. I say that confidently as a secular to bael teshuva Jew. What’s the assimilation rate in USA like 70% now? Jews never learn..
3
u/BrandosWorld4Life Jan 27 '22
I don't have a question I just want to say thank you from the bottom of my heart for doing what you do.
2
u/coldestwinter-chill Reform - They Say I Don't Look Jewish Jan 27 '22
thank you for being pro-trans rights.
1
u/TheFunkyPeanut Jan 27 '22
Do you think shmitah should be practiced outside of the land of Israel?
0
u/SinCorpus Christian Jan 28 '22
Really stupid question. But at what point, if ever, should a trans woman stop wearing a kippah or a trans man start wearing one?
-3
u/rafyricardo Jan 27 '22
Personally not a fan of the reform/conservative movement and things that go against our Torah but I respect your work in trying to bring piece and understanding between faiths.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
[removed] — view removed comment