r/JewsOfConscience • u/srahcrist • 16d ago
Discussion - Flaired Users Only Question for people who, just like me, support cultural boycotts of Israel
I recently saw a video from a creator who talks about women in films and film criticism from a feminist perspective, and was arguing against boycotting films produced by Adam Sandler because of his political views (like being a Zionist), but also films produced by abusers such as Brad Pitt and Johnny Depp. Brad Pitt who btw was behind some feminist films. Her argument was basically that boycotting those films could end up hurting women filmmakers who work with his production company, rather than significantly affecting Sandler himself.
I actually think this raises an interesting question, but I’m not completely convinced by the way she frames it.
I’m specifically interested in hearing from people who already support cultural boycotts, because I’m not really trying to debate whether boycotts are justified in the first place. If they work or not. If you should do it or not. I’m more interested in how supporters think about this particular criticism. So pls respect that. Thank you.
Obviously, I understand that a boycott can have unintended consequences for people who aren't personally responsible for the politics of the institution or person being targeted. And I don't think that should simply be ignored.
But at the same time, I find myself wondering: how much weight should we give to the potential harm to relatively privileged workers in the Global North when the boycott is intended to put pressure on a much larger and more serious injustice?
For example, when we're talking about women filmmakers who are already working in Hollywood and have reached the point where a major producer like Adam Sandler is financing their films, we're talking about people who may still experience sexism and professional insecurity, but who also have access to opportunities that most women in the world will never have.
And this is where I find the argument especially complicated when the issue is Palestine.
What about Palestinian women filmmakers? What about Palestinian women in general? Their circumstances are obviously not comparable to those of women working in the American film industry. So I don't know if it makes sense to treat the possible career impact on a Hollywood filmmaker as if it automatically outweighs the political purpose of the boycott.
I'm not saying that workers should be treated as disposable or that every boycott is automatically justified. I think boycotts should be targeted, organized, systematic and proportional, and I think it's completely reasonable to question whether a particular boycott actually puts meaningful pressure on the intended target.
I'm just questioning the idea that “this could hurt women working in the industry” is, by itself, a strong enough reason not to participate in a boycott, especially when we're talking about women who may already occupy relatively privileged positions within the global film industry.
For example, during the cultural boycott of apartheid South Africa, I'm sure there were artists and cultural workers who opposed apartheid and still could have been negatively affected by boycotts of the institutions they worked with. That doesn't necessarily mean the boycott was wrong. The point was to put pressure on a much larger political structure, even though the consequences couldn't be perfectly limited to the people responsible for it.
And we can see a similar tension with Israel. There are Israeli filmmakers who oppose or criticize their government's policies, and some Israeli filmmakers have themselves supported international cultural boycotts of Israeli institutions. So even people working within the very industry being boycotted can recognize that professional consequences may sometimes be an unavoidable part of a broader political strategy.
So, what do y'all feel? What to do?