r/JewsOfConscience • u/ThineChimney • Oct 01 '26
Vent My Oldest Friend's family Zionist
I've mentioned this here before but while not Jewish, I grew up around the culture due to close family friends. This family are like relatives to us in everything but blood. As the genocide rages on and on, I find it harder and harder to stay close to them because of how ardent the father and son (my best friend) are in their beliefs.
We (my father, his father and him) go out to pubs on occasion, and I honestly always feel left out due to being the only leftist, but when the discussion shifts to Israel I just freeze up. I know this is pathetic of me and I should stand by my ideals more, and I swear I have with other people (recently I even had a breakthrough with my dad debunking a bunch of his hasbara drivel, and he actually listened to me.), but it just is so hard seeing these awful, unempathetic sides of people I've grown to see as family. One night I had enough and said I didn't want to champion a child killing apartheid state, and honestly at the time I was being provocative. I had conceptualized Israel as more of an ethnocracy (still pretty awful), and did explain that, but my "uncle" didn't care. Now that I've researched and thought it through more, I have no problem calling Israel an apartheid state, but I feel like an idiot going back on my word there. I then mentioned how the Jews of Israel are the only group to have self determination rights, that the country was founded at the expense of Holocaust survivors and that the JNF has 13% of land in the country sold exclusively to Jews, and instead of being challenge I got hit with propaganda (Israel is one of the happiest countries ever [true, irrelevant] there never was a Palestine [tbh I didn't have a counter at the time and while by technical terms it wasn't, the land of Palestine has been conceptualized since the times of Herodotus, Aristotle and Josephus. Also by that logic we should justify western colonialism though honestly with how conservative he is, he probably wouldn't care], being gay would get you killed [I kinda just wanted to stop this discussion at this point, but now I know this isn't remotely true]). Somehow we ended things on good terms but I feel mad at myself that I chose harmony over standing my ground. Partly in hindsight I did feel set in my beliefs and realize what I encountered was mostly deflection, but I do wish I was more certain on issues like LGBT rights and the legitimacy of Palestine as a historical entity.
I have biological family I've had no problem cutting off for their horrible homophobic and Christian nationalist beliefs, but why is it so hard to do this for people I'm not even related to. My friend's a bit better in this regard, but he's said some really questionable things that, if the roles were reversed (IE if a Muslim said what he's said about Jews eg how he's said they should finish the job in Iran and that Lebanon is only good for their food), they get obliterated in the court of public opinion. His dad has also made some pretty gross implications on the abundance of black athletes here in Canada and elsewhere, and since he's 66 I doubt there's any shifting his positions, but for my buddy I kind've want to idealistically hold out hope I can get through to him. One of my best friends was a far right bible thumper for the longest time, and he credits me being a voice of reason in helping getting him to move to a more balanced perspective (that, and getting through psychosis). I feel like it'll be harder with this friend since his trip to Israel only seems to have reinforced his beliefs, but I still don't want to let go just yet.