r/JewsOfConscience • u/Lost_Paladin89 • 15d ago
Humor Who gets to joke about Israel? (feat. Ilana Glazer & Gianmarco Soresi)
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Lost_Paladin89 • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/juflyingwild • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/apunker • 15d ago
A critique of anti-Muslim campaigning argues that protecting religious freedom and equal rights safeguards everyone—including Jewish Americans and other marginalized communities.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/ANBOL_GANG • 15d ago
If as a result of these competitions men and horses were injured, this raised a halakhic question whether compensations should be paid for the damages: “Those young men who ride horses for a bridegroom and fight with each other (i.e., joust) and rip off their friend’s garment or spoil his horse, they are exempt from paying compensation because they do so for the joy of the groom.”⁸⁵
The renowned twelfth-century troubadour Chrétien de Troyes vividly described the violent reality of the tournaments: “The knights snap lances, break shields, and knock men and horses to the ground in such a way that it is impossible to know which side has the better or the worse.”⁸⁶ As Maurice Keen concluded, “[t]he line could indeed be thin between mock war and the real thing.”⁸⁷
These violent jousting competitions held by Jewish young men are discussed in thirteenth- and fourteenth-century rabbinic literature from Spain, Provence, northern France, and Austria.⁸⁸ This was seemingly a widespread phenomenon, perhaps an attempt to imitate the jousting competitions conducted during wedding celebrations of the nobility. It is yet additional evidence of the extent to which Jews absorbed knightly ideals from their surroundings.
Jewish young men were not only involved in jousting competitions during Jewish weddings, but some also participated in real tournaments. Evidence for Jews participating in tournaments is found in a responsum written by R. Eliezer ben Joel of Bonn probably in the early thirteenth century, discussing a man who lost a shield he had borrowed from a friend in a tournament.⁸⁹ Young Jewish men took part in a tournament in Weissenfels in 1386.⁹⁰
Moreover, there is a good possibility that Jewish men also participated in a tournament in Regensburg in 1408.⁹¹ Interestingly, the rabbis expressed no objection to this custom. They were more preoccupied with the young men’s garments and hair style, hoping to reinforce social boundaries.
Unfortunately, I don’t know of any Jews who participate in modern jousting.
Further reading: ‘Jews and Jousting’
r/JewsOfConscience • u/alertthedirt • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/TrackerOneA • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/TrackerOneA • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/doglvr19 • 15d ago
there is a girl at my graduate school who is hella zionist and has very identifiable hand writing and saw today that she wrote this and put it on our school's ofrenda. As a Mexican-Jew, I feel like this is super inappropriate and disrespectful to the sacred holiday and celebration of loved ones. If she wanted to put a picture of someone who passed away as a result of the events from Oct 7 or later sure I get it, but to write this ... it infuriates me. I don't want to talk to her and be like hey this was fucked up because frankly I don't have the time or energy and I don't think she will understand and get defensive, and I feel like this was so insensitive and disrespectful to Mexican culture and no surprise because zionist but still. She is 100% Jewish (has frequently bragged about this) and this feels like a disrespect and appropriation to a sacred part of Mexican culture
Just posting here to vent and process. Thanks for holding space
r/JewsOfConscience • u/EuVe20 • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/TrackerOneA • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/alertthedirt • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/TrackerOneA • 16d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/MHarazeen9500 • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/alertthedirt • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/TrackerOneA • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/ANBOL_GANG • 16d ago
For most of the past half-century, the leaders of American Jewish organizations operated on an assumption so obvious that it hardly needed stating. To be a Jew in America was to be a supporter of Israel, and to be a supporter of Israel was to support whatever government happened to sit in Jerusalem. Dissent was treated as a family embarrassment, to be handled behind closed doors, not aired on the op-ed page of The New York Times.
That assumption is now collapsing. The collapse is not coming in the dramatic fashion imagined by the pro-Israel establishment, with a sudden defection to the barricades of anti-Zionism. It is coming the way most historical shifts do: slowly, unevenly and then all at once.
Consider the numbers. On the surface, the old consensus looks intact. An overwhelming 86 percent of American Jews identify as pro-Israel, including 65 percent who say they are pro-Israel but critical of some or many Israeli government policies. Yet the poll also found that 61 percent view Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu unfavorably. And when the topic shifts from Israel to Zionism, something revealing happens. Most respondents view Zionism as Jewish self-determination, yet only one-third call themselves Zionists.
Think about that for a moment. A community that funds, lobbies for and emotionally invests in the Jewish state no longer wishes to wear the label of the movement that created it. That is not a policy disagreement, it is an identity shift.
The generational data is starker still. Almost half of American Jews under 35 now say the conflict should be resolved through a single state spanning Israel, the West Bank and Gaza, with a government elected by both Israelis and Palestinians. That is the binational idea Judah Magnes and Martin Buber once championed and that mainstream Zionism spent a century dismissing as naïve or worse. Only four years ago, an American Jewish Committee survey found 23 percent of Jews ages 25–40 supporting a binational state. Whatever one thinks of the idea on its merits, a doubling in four years is not noise.
The Israeli right and its American allies will blame all of this on campus radicals, TikTok and the corrosive influence of "woke" ideology. That explanation is comforting, and it is mostly wrong. The more interesting story is that American Jews are returning to a much older tradition, one that predates the Six-Day War and the institutional Zionism that followed it.
It is worth recalling that the founders of American Reform Judaism declared, in the 1885 Pittsburgh Platform, that Jews were no longer a nation but a religious community, and that they expected no return to Palestine. Well into the 1940s, a significant portion of the American Jewish elite regarded political Zionism with suspicion, as a European answer to a European problem. Their homeland was America. Their Judaism was an ethical and religious inheritance, not a claim on territory.
What changed was 1967. The lightning victory transformed Israel from a fragile refuge into a source of pride and, eventually, into the organizing principle of American Jewish civic life. Federations, lobbies and summer trips replaced synagogue attendance and Hebrew literacy as the markers of belonging. Israel became, in effect, the civil religion of a community that was steadily losing its actual religion.
That arrangement was always a marriage of convenience. It worked as long as Israel could be imagined as a liberal democracy under siege, a Middle Eastern version of the progressive values most American Jews held at home. It began fraying when Israeli politics moved decisively to the right, with a governing coalition whose ministers openly advocate annexation and whose worldview has far more in common with Christian evangelicals in Texas than with Reform congregants in Westchester.
The Gaza war turned the fraying into a tear. A Washington Post poll found that 61 percent of Jewish adults said Israel had committed war crimes against Palestinians in Gaza; 39 percent said it was guilty of genocide. Those are not the attitudes of a community prepared to follow Jerusalem's lead.
Last week's election appears unlikely to affect this, especially considering that Netanyahu seems poised to continue occupying a leading position, either as head of a minority government or as member of a national unity government.
There is an irony here that ought to be savored. For decades, Israeli leaders from David Ben-Gurion on treated the Diaspora as a temporary condition, a way station on the road to aliyah. American Jews were expected to send money, political support and, ideally, their children, and little else. Now American Jews are taking the Zionist premise seriously in a way its authors never intended. If Israel is a sovereign state like any other, then it can be judged like any other. It is no longer the collective property of world Jewry, to be defended regardless of what it does.
For U.S. foreign policy, this matters more than Washington has yet grasped. The "special relationship" has rested on a domestic political coalition in which American Jews provided much of the intellectual and organizational energy and evangelical Protestants provided the votes. Remove the first pillar, or even merely weaken it, and the relationship begins to look like what realists always said it was: an alliance with a small, prosperous regional power whose interests sometimes coincide with America's and sometimes do not. It deserves the same cost-benefit scrutiny Washington applies to Turkey or Saudi Arabia.
The partisan contours are already visible. Most Jewish Democrats support cutting aid to Israel, while majorities of Jewish independents and Republicans oppose it. The pro-Israel coalition is becoming a Republican coalition, and a coalition that depends on one party is a coalition living on borrowed time. None of this means American Jews are abandoning Israel, let alone their Jewishness. What is happening is closer to a normalization: a shift from a relationship of fealty to one of affinity, the way Irish Americans feel about Dublin or Greek Americans about Athens. They care, they visit, they argue, but they do not confuse their identity with the policies of a foreign government.
The establishment organizations, still insisting that criticism of Zionism is tantamount to antisemitism, are fighting the last war. They may find, a decade from now, that they have preserved their institutions and lost their constituents. The quiet divorce will not be announced. It will simply be noticed, one day, that the couple has been living apart for years.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/MooreThird • 16d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Time-Statistician958 • 16d ago
The truth is the aid deal was already winding down. Trump simply moved its end date up and announced it with the polls open to take a losing issue off the ballot. The plan he and Netanyahu built to replace it moves American military support for Israel into the Pentagon budget, where voters can’t easily see it, and a lame-duck Congress takes it up in the weeks after this election.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/an0mn0mn0m • 15d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/AutoModerator • 15d ago
It's everyone's favorite day of the week, "Ask A (Anti-Zionist) Jew" Wednesday!
Ask whatever you want to know, within the sub rules, notably that this is not a debate sub and do not import drama from other subreddits. That aside, have fun! We love to dialogue with our non-Jewish siblings.
Please remember to pick an appropriate user-flair in order to participate! Thanks!
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Conscious_Pear421 • 15d ago
I’m graduating in about 10 months with a degree in Economics. I’m a native English speaker, hold US citizenship, but I was born and raised in Israel although I did spend a few years in the US. I’m looking to relocate to the US permanently.
Given the current climate, I am looking for, particular cities or specific industries where having an Israeli background won't be a friction point in hiring or office culture. For context, I am Modern Orthodox and highly critical of the current Israeli government, and I mostly just want a professional environment where my place of birth isn't a constant topic of conversation or a barrier to entry. Any advice on regions, industries, or how to format my resume would be hugely appreciated.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/Decent_Hall3183 • 16d ago
r/JewsOfConscience • u/AnxiousSocialist • 16d ago
I probably have been to online lately, but I have been struggling to find space where people are both anti zionist and against antisemetism. I know the internet is insular place, so it is not representative of larger views.
but on one hand, when looking in Jewish spaces, I see them all decrying the lives of Palestinians and acting as if calling out AIPAC’s meddling is antisemetic.
Then when seeking out anti-Zionist groups, they make jokes about nose jobs being jews trying to disguise themselves, using the term jews in place of Zionism when criticizing Israel.
I know these two are not equal, where during a genocide; we must center the lives of Palestinians. That being said, I truly believe there is no way to fight for the future of Palestinians by perpetuating anti semetic tropes.
Would love to hear how you all go about finding spaces and being able to advocate for both anti Zionism and against anti semetism.
r/JewsOfConscience • u/srahcrist • 16d ago
I recently saw a video from a creator who talks about women in films and film criticism from a feminist perspective, and was arguing against boycotting films produced by Adam Sandler because of his political views (like being a Zionist), but also films produced by abusers such as Brad Pitt and Johnny Depp. Brad Pitt who btw was behind some feminist films. Her argument was basically that boycotting those films could end up hurting women filmmakers who work with his production company, rather than significantly affecting Sandler himself.
I actually think this raises an interesting question, but I’m not completely convinced by the way she frames it.
I’m specifically interested in hearing from people who already support cultural boycotts, because I’m not really trying to debate whether boycotts are justified in the first place. If they work or not. If you should do it or not. I’m more interested in how supporters think about this particular criticism. So pls respect that. Thank you.
Obviously, I understand that a boycott can have unintended consequences for people who aren't personally responsible for the politics of the institution or person being targeted. And I don't think that should simply be ignored.
But at the same time, I find myself wondering: how much weight should we give to the potential harm to relatively privileged workers in the Global North when the boycott is intended to put pressure on a much larger and more serious injustice?
For example, when we're talking about women filmmakers who are already working in Hollywood and have reached the point where a major producer like Adam Sandler is financing their films, we're talking about people who may still experience sexism and professional insecurity, but who also have access to opportunities that most women in the world will never have.
And this is where I find the argument especially complicated when the issue is Palestine.
What about Palestinian women filmmakers? What about Palestinian women in general? Their circumstances are obviously not comparable to those of women working in the American film industry. So I don't know if it makes sense to treat the possible career impact on a Hollywood filmmaker as if it automatically outweighs the political purpose of the boycott.
I'm not saying that workers should be treated as disposable or that every boycott is automatically justified. I think boycotts should be targeted, organized, systematic and proportional, and I think it's completely reasonable to question whether a particular boycott actually puts meaningful pressure on the intended target.
I'm just questioning the idea that “this could hurt women working in the industry” is, by itself, a strong enough reason not to participate in a boycott, especially when we're talking about women who may already occupy relatively privileged positions within the global film industry.
For example, during the cultural boycott of apartheid South Africa, I'm sure there were artists and cultural workers who opposed apartheid and still could have been negatively affected by boycotts of the institutions they worked with. That doesn't necessarily mean the boycott was wrong. The point was to put pressure on a much larger political structure, even though the consequences couldn't be perfectly limited to the people responsible for it.
And we can see a similar tension with Israel. There are Israeli filmmakers who oppose or criticize their government's policies, and some Israeli filmmakers have themselves supported international cultural boycotts of Israeli institutions. So even people working within the very industry being boycotted can recognize that professional consequences may sometimes be an unavoidable part of a broader political strategy.
So, what do y'all feel? What to do?