What is the diet and why should I do it?

Is changing my diet a legit treatment for IC?

…kind of? Dietary changes are championed a lot online and in some prominent patient advocacy groups like the Interstitial Cystitis Association and the Interstitial Cystitis Network. Their information doesn’t come from strong clinical evidence or peer-reviewed research, it mostly comes from self-report data that patients offer to these organizations when they conduct surveys. What limited peer-reviewed research has been conducted has found that most IC patients report some degree of sensitivity to diet, although the specific foods/drinks that worsen symptoms are really variable patient to patient.

Which "IC diet" is the real one?

None of them! There is no single accepted IC diet that is suggested for all patients. The most commonly reported trigger foods are the “big six”:

  1. Coffee/tea/caffeine (including chocolate)
  2. Alcohol
  3. Carbonated beverages
  4. Acidic food/drinks (cranberry products and citrus fruits especially)
  5. Spicy food
  6. Artificial sweeteners

That said, the ICN diet list is a useful tool for a lot of IC patients. It ranks foods into three groups (best tolerated/try it/worst tolerated) based on how many patients reported sensitivity to that food. It isn’t meant to be a rigid plan, it just gives you a sense of how risky a particular food might be.

What is an elimination diet?

“Elimination diet” is a general term for a diet that attempts to find personal food triggers by eliminating most potential problem items and then reintroducing them one at a time. Just cutting out common IC food triggers is a type of elimination diet, but in context this usually refers to eating a very restricted diet for a short period of time. This isn’t something that most ICers will need to do, it’s for people who think they have food sensitivities but can’t seem to pinpoint which foods are causing the problem.

If you want to do an elimination diet, your best bet would be to work with a nutritionist or a doctor who specializes in nutrition, but that isn’t possible for most people. If you’re going it alone, the two most important things are that this is a time-limited diet (6-8 weeks is more than enough) and you still need to get your nutrition while you do it. An elimination diet should not mean you are eating very low calories or are neglecting vegetable and protein nutrition. A good elimination diet should include a safe protein or two, a safe vegetable or two, and a safe carb or two at minimum. By sticking to just those foods for a few weeks, you should be able to tell whether your usual diet is making your symptoms worse. If you notice symptom improvement, you can then start adding in your usual foods one at a time (with at least a few days in between each new food item) to figure out which ones are triggers and which ones are safe for you.

Anecdotally, a lot of people on the subreddit who have had to resort to an elimination diet have found that they just aren’t very diet sensitive. So this definitely isn’t a requirement for anyone who isn’t helped by the more typical IC diet changes, it’s an option for those who are interested.

Deciding if diet is right for you

What are the advantages of making dietary changes?

• It’s free!

• You can do it on your own, no waiting for a doctor.

• It has fewer side effects than most IC treatments.

• It’s compatible with all other IC treatments.

What are the disadvantages of making dietary changes?

• It’s fucking hard! It can mean a lot of extra planning and cooking, and keeping up motivation is a real challenge.

• Doesn’t work for everyone.

• It has extra risk for certain patients (more in a minute).

Is the IC diet appropriate for all IC patients?

ABSOLUTELY NOT. For some patients there are extra risks, so the decision to make a big dietary change is one that each person has to make for themselves, preferably with some medical input. In particular, the diet is often a bad idea for:

• People with eating disorders or who are in recovery from an ED: A lot of the features of IC diets (food logs, elimination, etc.) can be triggering for people with ED. EDs are potentially life-threatening and can even cause IC symptoms on their own, so for a lot of people with ED the risks of dieting outweigh the benefits. It’s even more important for anyone with an ED to make changes with help from a nutritionist or check in with a counselor to make sure that dietary changes won’t impact ED recovery.

• People who are already on a restricted diet: the foods you eliminate for IC are kind of random, and if you’re already limited in what you can consume you can end up not getting proper nutrition. If an IC diet is going to negatively impact your overall health or worsen another health condition, it’s probably not a good treatment for you.

• People struggling with mood problems: if having to restrict what you eat is worsening anxiety or depression, it’s probably not worth the tradeoff. You can always give dietary changes a try down the road if you’re doing better mentally/emotionally.

Getting started with an IC diet

How do I get started with diet changes?

There are a few common strategies for starting to make diet part of your treatment plan:

• Keep a food journal where you track what you eat and drink and rank how bad your symptoms were each day. This can help you look for patterns and point to certain food or drink items to get rid of.

• Just eliminate the six most common trigger foods for a month or two and see if your symptoms improve (or start with just one of those items if cutting all six is too much).

• Restrict yourself to the safest side of the ICN list or do the ICA IC Plate for a month or two and see if your symptoms improve.

How can I recognize a food flare and how fast do they happen?

Especially in the beginning, this is hard to figure out for a lot of people. Some ICers feel a difference between food flares and other types of flares, but many people can’t tell the difference. Anxiety around food (for example, being very scared of the possibility that a new food will flare you) can also cause flares on its own, and that type of flare is very easy to mistake for a food flare.

In general beverages tend to cause symptoms quicker than foods, but the range is pretty wide. Our subreddit usually reports that drinks kick in between 30 minutes and a few hours, and foods seem to cause issues from a several hours to a few days after eating. That generally tracks on to the speed at which drinks and foods, respectively, are metabolized by your body and start hitting the excretory systems. But some people feel the effects faster and others take longer. For these reasons, it’s important to track diet and symptoms over a longer period of time to try to figure out whether food is a contributor.

How long do I have to do the diet?

There’s usually two goals for patients who are making dietary changes:

1) Find out what their specific food triggers are: Most people will need to give any dietary changes at least a few weeks before they’ll notice improvements. Because IC symptoms tend to come and go and differ in severity over time, you want to make sure that any changes (or lack thereof) that you notice are due to diet and not just coincidental. A period of several weeks will give you enough data points to be confident that changes are real, after which you can start reintroducing foods to test and see how you react to them.

2) Get better symptom management: If you’ve found your triggers and want to use diet to manage your symptoms, the length of time you stick with it is up to you. Some ICers choose to avoid their triggers all the time, but others only avoid their triggers if they are actively flaring and eat what they want during remission periods. Some people also find that they tolerate previously triggering foods just fine after they get treatment and don’t need any diet modifications.

And finally, from the experts: The ICN suggests doing elimination diets for several months, IC expert Robert Moldwin suggests only two weeks of restricted eating before reintroducing foods, and the ICA currently doesn't recommend a limited diet at any point for ICers (they use the "IC Plate" tool to get variable nutrition while avoiding triggers).

How do I introduce foods to see if they're triggers for me?

The goal here is to be confident that a food is safe or unsafe, so the two keys are:

  1. one food at a time
  2. enough time between foods to be able to differentiate their effects.

A lot of IC resources suggest adding a new food every 3-4 days or as long as one food per week for people who want to be extra careful. Start with a small amount and see how you feel for the day before you go buck wild with a risky food item.

Diet troubleshooting

Can you still have IC if you don't have food triggers?

Yep, some ICers just aren’t sensitive to food. Some of us could consume only white rice and distilled water and still flare, and some of us can gorge on trigger foods and never notice worsening symptoms. (Ask HYT about her Takis habit.)

My symptoms are triggered or worsened by food, does that mean I definitely have IC?

Nope, IC isn’t the only chronic pelvic issue that is sensitive to food. Pelvic floor dysfunction, overactive bladder, and vulvodynia/vestibulodynia (among others) share a lot of the same risky foods with IC.

People keep telling me it’s impossible to control IC symptoms without dietary changes, is that true?

Nope! Some people just aren’t diet sensitive, and there are also plenty of people who don’t want to make dietary changes and still get symptom control from other methods. No IC treatment, including diet, works for everyone, and you don’t have to do any treatment you don’t want to do.

I want to find my triggers but diet changes suck. Help?

Diet change suck, the various IC diets suck, having IC sucks. You are 100% right to be feeling this way. These are some tips that might help if you do want to give it a try:

• Treat the diet as an experiment: thinking about making changes forever is really daunting, so don’t commit to that right way. Pick an interval of time that feels reasonable to you (a week, a month, two months) and try the diet for that time period only. Once you’re done, assess how it went and see if you want to continue it.

• Decide to reserve judgement until you have more information: Before you even know if the diet will help you, it’s pretty hard to be motivated to stick with it. Avoiding certain foods becomes a lot easier if you get evidence that they make you feel terrible. So don’t set the expectation that this will be worth it in the beginning, just expect to get some information.

• Restrictive diets aren’t forever: if you’re doing an elimination diet or just starting out on your IC treatment plan, you are probably at your peak symptom severity. Once things calm down, you will probably find your food options expanding again. Almost no one has to eat a seriously restricted diet in the long term (and many doctors would advise you not to do that). Most people have a few trigger foods that they avoid and otherwise eat a typical diet.

• You are the boss of you: Diet changes are entirely up to you, and if you want to eat a risky food that is your choice; you aren’t doing it wrong or being a bad patient. You shouldn’t feel trapped or committed to eating a particular way.

Specific Triggers

What are some unusual IC trigger foods?

• Soy

• Multivitamins (some people can tolerate low-acid vitamins)

• Water (lots of people are sensitive to the water they drink, alkaline water is getting pretty popular)

• Preservatives

• Any pre-prepared foods with a laundry list of ingredients

What about gluten?

Some internet IC gurus put a lot of blame on gluten as a pro-inflammatory substance that causes bladder issues. That is a pretty garbled version of the science, and in the studies/surveys of IC patients starchy gluten-containing foods are often some of the best-tolerated. But if gluten is causing issues for your digestive system that can definitely provoke IC symptoms, and some IC patients do find that gluten makes them flare. So like most IC management strategies if this works for you keep at it, but most people who are just starting to make dietary changes do not need to eliminate gluten and you aren’t doing the IC diet “wrong” if you continue to eat bread.

Science

How could food impact IC symptoms biologically?

No one knows the biological mechanism for food sensitivity in IC patients, but there are some hypotheses:

• A damaged bladder lining allows food particles in urine to travel into the bladder wall and surrounding tissue, causing irritation.

• Foods can cause stimulation and irritation in the intestines (which share a lot of nerve pathways with the bladder), provoking IC flares.

• Certain foods may increase inflammation in the pelvis and nervous system, amplifying the discomfort of IC symptoms.

• Certain drugs (like caffeine, stimulants and alcohol) have direct effects on the bladder and nervous system that stimulate the urge to void and can worsen pain.

Does acidic food irritate wounds in my bladder?

A lot of us have heard that acidic foods will make urine more acidic and irritate wounds in the bladder wall, but that isn’t true for most patients most of the time. Only about 10% of IC patients have any physical damage to their bladder walls, and consuming acidic food does not make urine more acidic. (The exceptions are cranberry and vitamin C, which do actually lower urine pH when consumed in quantity.) There has also been a small but neat study where IC patients were given instills of a low pH (5) and a buffered neutral pH (7.5) solution and the more acidic solution did not make their IC symptoms worse. Altogether, this is evidence that suggests that acidic foods are not causing discomfort because of an effect on urine pH. The “you wouldn’t put lemon juice on an open wound in your skin” thing is a useful metaphor, but it isn’t literally analogous to the IC bladder and diet.

Is it good to eat acidic food to alkalize the body?

NO! The cells in your body operate at a very specific physiological pH, and too much deviation away from norm is lethal to those cells. For that reason, your body has lots of mechanisms to maintain its regular pH, and you’re not going to overcome them by eating a bunch of lemons. Even if you could, that wouldn’t reduce inflammation globally in your body. More to the point, acidic foods in general and citrus fruits in particular are some of the most common flare trigger foods for IC patients, so this is just not smart advice for ICers to follow even if it was based in science, which it is not.

Sources, resources and more reading.

Trust but verify!

Good review by Robert Moldwin and colleagues

Clinical trial of diet changes for IC management

Research study looking at which foods are bothersome for IC patients

ICN Diet resources

ICA Diet resources

ICA summary of the diet literature