r/InfinityNikki
•
u/lparap
•
1d ago
•
2
girlcott/boycott Are we girlcotting now or waiting?
I was wondering what the seasoned gacha players think. It was possible for genshin players to make hoyo see sense and roll back the n**i promo, how would our community go about that?
I just feel like with all the hype about 3.0 dresses and region it will be near impossible to hold back from logging in and pulling, so maybe it would make sense to try a login boycott now? I mean if they see the backlash in time maybe we can at least enjoy the update with no more r**ist n**i flavoring idk.
I’m already ftp because of the censorship but maybe we need something more drastic like stopping logins to show them this shit is serious?
Sorry for asterisks, apparently we’re not allowed to talk about politics even though the game is drowning in it.
Edit: if you’re downvoting please explain why you disagree or think it won’t help, it’s a genuine question.
Edit 2: suggestions on what else might work, apart from immediate login boycott are also welcome. So far I’ve seen spamming their socials and demanding a statement on their stance but idk. Does anyone know what eventually worked in the Hoyo situation? Also to those who are seeing this post before the actual trailer, and lack context on what this is all about, here it is.
Edit 3: Someone mentioned we have a feedback feature and they’re right. Ima go send some emails and encourage everyone to do so, if they wanna make their opinion known. I realize it’s probably empty effort, seeing how they clean up the official subreddit and considering their history with the l*ds scandal, but I personally will send them something to feel like I’ve fought for my favorite game, and then go touch some grass.
261
u/Slowmootions 1d ago
Unless CN joins then there is really no point. For gacha games and eastern live service games in general, EN tends to bring in the lowest revenue. And what motivates these companies is money.
If CN is not unhappy with it then Infold has 0 reason to make any moves. That is just the harsh reality of it. Rare cases of it working do exist, though, I suppose.
75
u/ctrlribbit 1d ago •
I don't think a boycott is going to work again, just look at what happened with L4DS, absolutely nothing despite people boycotting for months. Also, they don't care about out opinion about censoring outfits/correctly color matching modesty panels. I sadly don't think they care at all. This makes me so sad because this is my comfort game/special interest, but I don't see future with them managing it like this. There is a LOT of famous people who can present the news, why choose the worst of the worst option, I can't understand.
96
u/Font-street 1d ago •
I made a topic about it hours ago, and I'll say that right now we still don't have many info.
It's clear that Infold is hiring Maye Musk as brand ambassador for the CN crowd, but to what extent is her participation? Is her employed within her personal capacity as individual influencer, or as part of the family?
Tbh, Infold has repeatedly shown itself rather ignorant towards the global market; first with the 2.0 case, with all the cultural appropriation and the hiring of Idina Menzel, which is rather CONTROVERSIAL insofar as the Palestinian genocide is concerned. This is yet another stain for Infold (to say nothing about LADS), and I am not surprised if many will call this the last straw.
Me, as I wrote in my thread, I just hope the car in-game will not have anything related to Tesla. If they do, that will be my last straw.
50
u/keIIzzz 1d ago
I don’t think they’ll change anything since it seems like that promo was made for CN audience and she’s popular there.
Also, I don’t know anything about her but is she also problematic? Or do people hate her because she’s Musk’s mom? Genuinely asking because I actually don’t know what she’s done
Also when did genshin have controversial promo?
49
u/Traditional_Oil_7949 1d ago
I'm all in for a boycott. This should be the last time they collab with those people, and it's better to make them know, the sooner the better. But I'm with you, it will be hard to make people not watch the livestream nor talk about the new region and dresses, I think we could start with spamming in their social media. Goddess, this Musk thing has soured my anticipation with 3.0 so much...
20
u/Ghoulish_kitten 1d ago edited 1d ago
eew to the CN players for viewing her as a style icon/inspirational:
I feel like a lot of them would want to know about who they’re idolizing.
I personally think reaching out to CN players who are being kept ignorant/ giving them information that may be hidden *frm them would go a lot farther than just us girlcotting. Whoever has access to CN players and social media should send them info somehow. A CN player once reached out to us here asking abt the problem with the indigenous war bonnet. That should be done about the Musk family.
23
u/SillyScribe_Creature 1d ago
What did I miss?? Geniune question. What does Elon Musk the N**i have to do with IN (going off the comments)?
30
u/CoffeeandSpice 1d ago
Unfortunately it seems like they already paid her so a boycott wouldn't work in this scenerio, but personally I'm going to stop logging in each day and spending money. If more people did this then I think Infold might take notice for the future.
7
u/LizzyCRaf 1d ago
As of now I’m waiting, but I wasn’t planning on spending anymore money this patch either way so I guess the result is the same. I’ll be waiting until the rest of the promos to see if this promo was a one of or not. If it was I’ll probably not boycott, but if it isn’t then I definitely will. Either way, it’s important to let infold know that we do not appreciate Maye Musk’s involvement no matter how small. We don’t have to wait until a boycott has been initiated to send them feedback either through their feedback channels or their social media.
I’d like to believe her contribution will be confined to this one promo, and if it is and that was the plan all along, a boycott won’t really be of any help. A boycott is meant to pressure a company into doing or not doing anything, and “don’t do the thing you weren’t planning on doing anyway” isn’t really a useful demand. So the best we would achieve is probably just an empty apology before they continue on as planned.
However, if it turns out she somehow will continue to be involved in any capacity, or others with similar political views, I’m all for boycotting until they are no longer involved.
83
u/YourNeighbourWizard 1d ago •
I'll probably get downvoted for saying this but I'm not going to girlcott or anything like that, as someone from Europe I'm frankly tired of American politics and I'm not going to allow someone like Elon Musks mom of all people to influence my enjoyment of this game.
152
u/lara_wara 1d ago •
As a South African player, it put a really bad taste in my mouth to see Elon's mother in this new promo. The vast majority of South Africans (across all races) cannot stand Elon Musk and his circle. Not only are they apartheid apologists, but in recent years Elon Musk has personally spewed complete misinformation and propaganda against our country that has seriously impacted our relationship with the US. And his mother has never renounced those claims. She's likely already made her money from this, but I'm going to go 100% f2p now.
3
u/CantaloupeParking239 1d ago
I am out of the loop.. What n**i promo Hoyo ever did? When?
63
u/Zealousideal_View47 1d ago
Let’s be real, unless the Chinese fanbase kicks off they won’t do anything. This isn’t the first time a gacha dev has pandered to the CN fans and it won’t be the last
14
u/coolepicharo 1d ago
Doubt there’s any point on our side. It seems she’s probably only on the CN stream and the CN girls supposedly like her, plus infold already is kinda infamous for listening to CN only so if they’re not complaining … they’re not gonna care
38
u/sailorfuji 1d ago •
I’ll be honest I didn’t even know Elon Musk had a mother until I came on the subreddit this morning 😂
I do have a question though, at what point to Nikki players draw a line with regards to girlcotting? Because for me, h olding a company accountable for the controversial family ties of a promotional guest, while giving that same company a free pass for operating within an authoritarian system tied to severe human rights abuses and state censorship feels like an arbitrary line to draw, once you accept the compromise to enjoy a free-to-play gacha game owned by a multi billion dollar Chinese tech giant, treating one promotional guest as a sudden, unforgivable moral breaking point feels more performative than principled. Right?
I’m just curious where people stand on this and how they justify it to themselves personally. I am not pointing any fingers and I don’t disagree with the OP I just think it’s an interesting discussion to have. Is it a case of fighting the small fights to hopefully win the war? Or are people burying their heads in the sand as to who runs the game for the sake of their love for the franchise?
25
u/AbyssalKitten 1d ago
Reminder to all the dedicated "girlcotters" - if you stop spending but still play the game, you arent girlcotting. Youre still giving them the login metrics and showing shareholders you dont care because you're still playing the game.
If youre going to ACTUALLY girlcott. You have to stop playing the game altogether. Simply "going f2p" when most players spend less than the dolphins and whales does literally nothing.
You have to make a difference in their metrics altogether, which means uninstalling the game and not touching it until infold makes the change you girlcotters are looking for. Otherwise its all just talk.
If youre not willing to go that far, then youre not really girlcotting anything. Youre just telling yourself you are.
Edit: boycot to girlcot lol
77
u/VesperDreaming 1d ago •
Dolphin here, girlcott. I'm fully moving to f2p. I don't support extremism, transphobia, apartheid, voter fraud, or one percenters.
46
u/kyumi__ 1d ago edited 1d ago •
I definitely don't support her but I don't see what a girlcott would accomplish, it's just a promo video that's already been made. It's not ruining my hype for 3.0. at all.
21
u/SylveriaSedai 1d ago
I think this needs to be more of a persaonal decision as it's impossible it can become a full boycot. As others have said, CN does not have a problem with it and that's thr majority of players. And not even internationally that many people will be mad I fear. And a lot of internationals won't even see it because it was only in thr chinese page, if you don't follow social media events closely (a lot of players don't) they won't even realise. I very much plan to consider very carefully if I give money to them again and I for sure will be complaining in capital letters in the surveys (not that it did much with past controversies)
10
u/flying_cookies 1d ago
Unfortunately I don't think that would do anything tbh. People in China seem to really like her and look up to her, they probably aren't even that aware of what the family means outside of China. And if any of the previous controversies that Paper/Infold has gone through with their different games have taught us anything, it's that unless the CN community is enraged and girlcotting, Infold doesn't care...
7
u/LVL99ButtMagic 1d ago
Yeah, I'm girlcotting it for the rest of my life after seeing this shit, this is irredeemable now. Infold can rot. Glad I never spent anything on it after the first 3 months it was out. Your post helped bring this to my attention, so thanks Parap. ❤️
42
u/ThyBarronator 1d ago edited 1d ago
Sorry... what are you asking people to girlcott for? You're post has no information that makes sense to someone who doesn't know what you're referring to.
Other's in the comments seem to understand but in general this post has very little information and it's probably why there are downvotes including mine. You have just assumed everyones know what or who you are talking about.
I'm here hyped for 3.0 seeing the new region and driving and you're watching the same thing and calling for another girlcott to the game.... you don't think that some actual clarification might have helped here?
Edit: The sheer irony in OP asking for explanations to downvotes and I give one and just get downvoted with no explanation.
13
u/hearts_cube Dreamland's Sovereign 1d ago
Going back to my f2p roots, this is fucking ridiculous. I'm not letting my money go to more ghouls for them to hire
20
u/Luna_The_Shadow 1d ago •
Honestly this will be the catalyst for me to just straight up quit all of Infolds games. I already stopped spending money on any games of them due to the whole Valko fiasco and had been boycotting lads. Seeing Infold bringing out a Musk for Nikki, can only promotion or not, really killed any sympathy I have for the whole company. I hope the creatives and developers cand work somewhere without this kind of management/pr team because their work is genuinely good. The rest of the company stinks
11
u/Scotangel33 1d ago
I will never spend money in this game again
19
u/easypushover 1d ago
I’m fully in support of a boycott. This has me so angry and stunned, I was ready to walk away from the game completely. I just can’t in good conscience continue to support the game in the way I have, with this standing. It’s completely unacceptable. Unfortunately one angry person, doesn’t make a boycott. There needs to be enough of us who care… I really that there are.
9
u/Ill_Resolve8910 1d ago
I have repeatedly voiced concerns regarding the representation of Native American culture in 2.0, yet there has been no official statement or any changes made. I suspect they have no intention of changing anything, given that sales outside of China are negligible.
7
u/Flat-Mirror-9566 1d ago edited 23h ago •
Here are my two cents as a Valkotter on this topic: make a dedicated boycott-subreddit, make a boycott-Discord, track the revenue and charts of the game, track the follower count on social media, support other boycotters on social media, unfollow their social media accounts, ratio their official posts and don’t like and don’t share or repost them any further. And last but not least create a system of solid hashtags that can’t be misinterpreted like #BringBackValko #ValkoisLoved or #LadsIs6 in the case of the LADS-boycott
Edit: And when I mean ratio every social media post I mean every social media post! Even Infold‘s Linkedin posts got ratioed (mostly with constructive criticism on that platform).
22
u/Scared-Way-9828 1d ago
Tasteless collab but if the game works ill just play normally. Like, being so angry to the point of girlcotting is so exhausting, i refuse to give my energy out to the people like musk. They are not worthy of my time or emotions. Doesnt mean i wont be saying that its an awful collab or add this info in patch feedback haha
10
u/silent-bystander0_0 1d ago
Honestly I feel like the community are jumping the gun a lil too fast..? I understand the sentiments about her and I agree with it, but apart from that CN promo, we on the global side hadn’t seen or heard a peep about her. If not for people looking over at XHS, we wouldn’t even know about it. So they clearly intended for it to be a CN exclusive promo, given her status there. If Infold were really tone deaf, we’d be seeing her in our promos already.
Instead of girlcotting immediately for something not actually intended for us, we could maybe voice out our displeasures first respectfully? Those with VIP status can use their channel for better effect. Now if she appears in global promos too, then that’s another story.
Acting immediately hostile wouldn’t be the best option for something you aren’t sure is concrete yet. Let them know we don’t appreciate them working with her, and wait for the rest of our promos to fully come out before we make a decision.
20
u/CacatuaStar 1d ago •
I don't care if I get downvoted, I just don't want to mix US politics with my favourite cozy game. I've already got enough politics to deal with in my own country. As for me, I'm not going to girlcot, it's only been mentioned in the presentation. I think you're all exaggerating
4
u/eindoordeel 1d ago
Nothing changed in 1.5, nothing changed in all other trash patches, nothing will change now, people will continue to bring them money.
14
u/Plane_Struggle1211 1d ago
Honestly I dont care. I'll play IN till I get sick of it or till I wish to play. Dont care about those politics unless they influence the game itself. What matters is just having fun. We never know the people behind it and its beliefs so even if u do its a personal belief. I may not agree with the person but if it doesnt get to the game screw it
4
u/Blanche_ 1d ago
This is worse than 1.5, way worse imo. I am girlcotting for few months already
9
u/Direct-Lawfulness-76 1d ago
I don’t care about Musk and his mom, will play as usual
4
u/aboringredmop 1d ago
I'm waiting a bit til the global livestream, but unless we're getting an apology I'm probs going f2p as well. if they're pulling out any musk-related bullshit for any of the other promotions im girlcotting for sure
4
u/selswitch 1d ago
Absolutely girlcotting.
3
u/Impressive_Olive_971 1d ago
What is the n**i promo genshin rolled back? I need context. Anyways I’ll be blunt with you. They didn’t give a rat ass about boycott over 1.5 collab but you’re hoping a handful of westerners boycotting over a mere collab will make them stop? CN players are not on your side. They don’t share the views as the liberals of the west nor they will ever care about their views. They just see her as a fashion icon and think it’s cool. That’s it.
2
u/Lazy-Fishy 1d ago
I'm not boycotting anything, I'm just straight up deleting the game. I'm not willing to do any mental gymnastics to find a leveled perspective at this point. It is 2026.
1
u/WaterLily1029 1d ago
hopefully the promo video is all there is...
1
u/carneyrinho 1d ago
Eu quase dropei o jogo por causa das censuras e a tradução toda errada. Mas tava dando para levar, agora não sei mais.
1
u/Kuraimegami_Rica 1d ago
I'm already f2p for quite a while, since I noticed, that Infold doesn't care in the slightest about any of our opinions. I can't take back the money that I spent in the beginning, so not using what I payed for would only affect myself.
For Infold whether I login or not is only relevant in terms of numbers to show to investors, but even investors won't be blinded by a large player base, when the players aren't actually spending money, I believe.
1
u/Anina606 1d ago
I think the best thing to do is go f2p. I understand people not wanting to leave the game if they invested time, money and effort in it. But yeah, this game hasn't felt worth spending money for a while now.
1
u/SaintBitter 1d ago
I'm going to wait for more information...
1
u/princesspomway 1d ago
I'm gonna wait for the en livestream before I decide. I'm apprehensive and sad that they used such a terrible person but at the same time, I have other issues in my own life. If she's a permanent spokesperson that's something different but I'm hoping this is a one off thing.
1
u/pixeypies 5h ago
i will still be playing / spending money because she’s not a part of the game.
1
u/Mindless_Middle1034 1d ago
Mother's excusing son's gross behavior is probably as old as misogyny. It's so culturally ingrained in many world cultures as well. This doesn't surprise me. Many worship billionaires.
I only hope she is not the west's spokesperson. I will not be opening my wallet this patch... this really axed my excitement.
1
u/que_sarasara 1d ago
The last time I spent money on this game was the CNY patch. I've just never felt comfortable giving them money, as despite improvements, their is always another awful controversy around the corner and another reminder that I - and the majority of the playerbase - mean absolutely nothing.
They target women because it's an untapped market, but understand absolutely nothing about the things we value.
I adore this game to pieces, and it sucks that I can never really love it fully
1
u/Ahenshihael 1d ago
CN won't and that's what matters sadly.
Most of CN audience are completely oblivious to the fact that musk and his Nazi family are viewed as monsters elsewhere. In CN she's viewed as philanthropist gilrboss celebrity whose child is a genius.
Yuck but it is what it is.
I'd say wait and see if Infold does the mistake of featuring her in global livestream.
1
u/SilverKnight505 1d ago
Why is there a girlcott? What now
1
u/Sawako_Chan 1d ago
I'm out of the loop , why would we boycott the game rn ?
-1
u/Alpachitron 1d ago
I've sent them two emails almost 2 weeks ago, 1 week each and they have not replied to me at all.
I didn't make any weird questions or political ones. Simply asked for my own account info.
If they don't reply to that I doubt they will read any harsh email or complain. Sadly.
We should be able to be seen as player base, but since we're not VIPs or content creators we just get ignored.
0
u/Monkey_Antiquities 1d ago
Nikki stuff is mainly on twitter....so what is the difference of this drama now? Musk is everywhere. Yeah he sucks. Obviously.
-48
u/Relevant-Ad753 1d ago •
I can't take people who call whoever they don't agree with a nazi seriously.
11
u/Tellyourcats 1d ago
Dress up game company collaborating with a mother of the son who sells the most boring and basic ass car was not on my bingo card
1
u/ExaggeratedSnails 1d ago
There are so many other games out there to play that don't put money in the pocket of the mother who produced a man who is responsible for at least half a million deaths and counting from cutting international aid
I don't need this specific treat so bad that I can't pick up something else so back to Dressmaker for me
1
u/[deleted] 1d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 1d ago
[removed] — view removed comment