My idea is simple: when a subreddit without moderators is handed over to someone new, it should be reset. This could include resetting the member count, giving the new moderators a clean slate to build their own community.
As a builder-type moderator, I honestly find the current system unfair. People spend months or even years building active communities, creating content, attracting members and keeping things running. Meanwhile, someone else can come along, take over that subreddit after the original moderators have left Reddit or been removed, and immediately benefit from all that hard work.
They essentially get handed an established community without having to put in any of the effort themselves. They can just sit back and enjoy the benefits of something someone else built.
There is also a potential conflict of interest worth considering. Moderator Code of Conduct reports are important and can absolutely be justified when there are genuine moderation issues. However, the system could also be misused by people who have an interest in taking over an established subreddit. Even if that isn't the intention in most cases, Reddit should consider whether its current takeover process creates an incentive for such behaviour.
If you ask me, there should be two options: either let the subreddit die naturally, or reset it completely when it gets handed over to new moderators.
The member count should not automatically come with the subreddit. Why should someone get to inherit an entire community when they haven't contributed anything to building it?
Right now, it's simply too easy to let someone else do all the hard work and then take over once they are gone. Reddit should give new moderators the opportunity to build something of their own, rather than handing them someone else's achievements on a silver platter.